HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | future10se's commentslogin

It wouldn't be able to access your account-related information (passwords in keychain, apple ID, etc.)

Still pretty bad, though. Too much valuable information in "regular" files. If possible, I always wipe devices before bringing them in for service. (Good reminder to have some kind of regular backup plan.)


And I still don't understand why they need it. Just boot from a USB drive if you need to verify if everything works. (Or even drop another internal drive in while it's opened up.)

Sure they can, admins can just grant themselves access to other folders

Regular admins cannot compromise the secure enclave. I'm pretty sure to unlock the keychain the first time, you need to authenticate through the secure enclave.

(Of course, Apple could roll out a rogue macOS/sepOS, but they could do that at any time.)


Well, this was pre-secure enclave, an MBP 15" from 2011? Would have still used it today probably if they wouldn't have replaced that GPU with a new and again defective GPU. I had just replaced the hdd with an ssd, added 8 GB of RAM and bought a new battery when it failed the second time. Never bought another MacBook after that. (Actually after failing I desoldered the GPU via 1 connection and it ran perfectly fine for a couple of days on the iGPU... But a software update bricked it!)

But you know, my Daughter still takes my OG Moto G with her when needed (from 2013, just got a message on it that next year they'll turn of 2G and it can't be on a network anymore). So perhaps I'm not your typical tech user ;)


Any machine old enough to need a GPU replacement wouldn't have had a secure enclave.

That being said - each user's keychain is encrypted using their account password. You can't read another user's keychain without knowing their password.


You might've missed this recent story where the FBI was able to identify an alleged teenage member of the Scattered Spider hacking group using the Microsoft GDID, and made an arrest:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48815196

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48920338


Thanks! I did miss it


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: