No it’s definitely not that simple. Code are read more often than written, no one works in a vacuum, especially not in open source. Also, when in Rome...
If a project's owner feels that strongly about not using generics, that's a choice. No dependencies using generics, no generics allowed in PRs etc. Perfectly doable.
How many sloc are required for this?
var max = mycollection.Max();
Probably 5-10 if you’re missing higher order functions. And the risk of bugs will be 10x.