HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | feoren's commentslogin

> retargeted to focus on gun owners, “hate speech”, and right wing groups

This sounds like retargeting the surveillance apparatus away from people who are opposed to fascism, genocide, and secret police killing people in the street, to focus on the groups that actually commit 90% of political terrorism in this country. Unfortunately, it will never happen, because liberals have never, in their entire history, had the guts to go after citizens for political reasons, even when those citizens have actually committed crimes. This is why almost everyone who openly fomented insurrection against the United States is still walking around and even running for (and sometimes winning) office. Right-wing groups love to pretend that they're being targeted and victimized -- mostly because it gives them an excuse to overtly victimize other groups -- but they never actually are. You sometimes see right-wingers claim that they'll be sent to prison if liberals are elected; it's a damning self-incrimination, but nothing ever actually comes of it. Microseconds after it was clear that this latest "blue wave" was actually happening, Hakeem Jeffries was already making speeches about how, don't worry you guys, we're not ever actually going to hold anyone accountable for any crimes.

Palantir is not just going to suddenly give up on instituting their fascist dystopian dream just because some liberals won some elections. There will be no "pivoting to a D administration." Their politics isn't going to change at all -- it doesn't need to.


> liberals have never, in their entire history, had the guts to go after citizens for political reasons

You make it sound like this would be a good thing. It’s a bad thing when anyone does it!

And besides, you’re wrong — liberals were in charge in Philadelphia during the 1985 MOVE bombing, and they authorized it. LBJ expanded COINTELPRO and authorized Operation CHAOS. Obama’s government coordinated national disruption of Occupy groups. I’m sure there are more examples.


The argument I was responding to was: Palantir is just going to pivot to using it surveillance against conservative groups instead of liberal groups. My point was: no, liberals never do this, even when it would be justified. They are accused of it so often you might think they do it, but they don't.

> You make it sound like this would be a good thing. It’s a bad thing when anyone does it!

Whether it's a good thing to go after citizens or not depends on whether the citizens have committed actual crimes. "Political crime" is a big umbrella of things you can get away with if you are conservative, but not if you are liberal. Want to kill people in the streets? Just do it in the name of conservatism. Join ICE, or shoot some liberals at a protest. Conservatives will hail you as a hero, and liberals will never have the guts to prosecute you.

Conservatives go after citizens for political reasons, regardless of whether they have actually done anything wrong or not. Liberals actively avoid prosecutions that appear political, even if the citizen has killed people or fomented insurrection against the government. This has been true since Reconstruction.

> MOVE bombing, COINTELPRO, disrupting Occupy groups

Liberal groups were the main targets in all of your examples. The argument that center-leftists also sometimes politically target groups that are more liberal than them is not the counterexample that you think it is.


> Liberal groups were the main targets in all of your examples.

Liberal groups were not the targets here, left groups were. Liberals only punch left not because they lack fortitude, but because they aren’t actually opposed to the right except in presentation, some superficial social policies, and in who should get the lion’s share of the loot.

“Obamacare” was a rebadged “Romneycare” backed by the Heritage Foundation, Clinton’s NAFTA had conservative backing, etc.

When you start to understand that our political system is not actually the “liberal versus conservative” BS peddled in the media, this is the beginning of understanding.


It sounds like we're not really disagreeing on anything. Palantir is not going to pivot to liberal politics; they don't want to, they don't need to. Conservatives are basically never targeted for their politics, and liberals are targeted by everyone to the right of them. Belonging to the Democratic party does not mean one is necessarily liberal. It's true that "liberal versus conservative" is not the major axis of competition in our current political system, and doesn't align perfectly with Democrat vs. Republican.

Perhaps the only part where we disagree is that you seem to be implying that one must lack understanding to frame the fight as "liberal versus conservative". I frame it that way because that's the fight we should be having: human rights and effective governance vs. cruelty, corruption, and entrenched power. We can and should play a pragmatic game of politics for small wins, but it's not ignorance to simultaneously keep up the broader fight for liberalism regardless of whether our political system currently "works that way" or not.

> Liberal groups were not the targets here, left groups were

You are making a distinction between "liberal" and "left" that I've never seen anyone else make before. These are synonyms in almost everyone else's brain. What distinction are you drawing here?


Have you really never come across this distinction? The term “liberalism” has a complicated history, but in the current-day US it typically refers to the more centrist spectrum that spans from social liberalism to neoliberalism. Leftism, on the other hand, typically refers to groups like the now defunct SDS, the DSA, Marxist-Leninists (rare in America except on the internet), syndicalists and the more radical unions (like the IWW), libertarian socialists, and left-anarchists.

Typically conservatives refer to “liberals” as the “left” and to the “left” as “communists”. Despite most of the right also following a form of liberalism (neoliberalism), at least economically. There is no group in the US that both has significant power and opposes neoliberal economics, although this may be starting to change, with contenders arising on both the left and the right.

Outside the US, most people are more specific about the term and are able to distinguish social democracy from liberalism from socialism, for example.


The ancient Chinese invented WiFi. They used the light from signal fires to send messages between towers on the Great Wall. WiFi uses radio waves to send signals, which are also light. Therefore WiFi was invented 1800 years ago by the Chinese.

Not much more of an exaggeration than the often-repeated claim that WiFi was invented by a certain actress-inventor.

It's not terrifying because it's unknown. It's terrifying because a tiny number of obscenely rich psychopaths are trying to take sole control of it so they can enshrine themselves as living gods and make 99% of humans so obsolete that they die sick and cold in the streets. That's their overt goal, and almost all evidence we have from history and current politics suggests that they will be wildly successful at this. None of this is for you, it's all for them. All of it. That's why it's terrifying.


> Perhaps they could allow mass immigration to fix it but that would destroy the culture.

This is the racist part. The majority is always worried about how awful everything would be if they were to become the minority. Usually it's because they treat minorities like shit, and they'll worried that they'll suddenly be treated that way too.

Why would that possibly destroy their culture? Are the cultures of all minorities always destroyed? Why would that be? Is it because of racist assholes?

It's an incredibly weak argument when you think about it. The South Korean culture doesn't have to go anywhere: there will be the same number of Korean pop stars and artists and chefs as there was before, it's just that there will also be others coexisting with them in the same country. Somehow this is a huge threat? They're worried about their culture being "watered down" by lesser cultures? These are racism-adjacent fears, similar to their pure blood being mixed with the lesser races. If you're worried that the South Korean youth will get so much exposure to other cultures that they somehow drop or forget the Korean culture, that just feels like weird gatekeeping and more "mixed blood" concerns to me.

Is there a limit on how much culture can exist? If so, it's surely based on population. We're not talking about the South Korean population declining more due to immigration; it's already declining. If their culture is in danger, it's surely due to that, rather than some sneaky danger of all those dirty immigrants. How is it not based in racism? We're just talking about more culture overall.

Not to mention the fact that most culture spreads over communication channels, not physical bodies. Those terrifying 8 billion non-Koreans who are threatening to destroy Korea's culture are already influencing Korea's culture. Would it really make that big of a difference if they were physically within its borders?


i think racist is a projection.

example: I'm a new Zealander.

i don't want Americans immigrating in large quantities to New Zealand, because they have cultural values that change the nature of the society, in ways that i don't want it to change.

And i don't consider American a 'race', but more an agglomeration pf people with some general preferences, shared experience and even material characteristics ($$$) that will have negative impacts.

Now, if i could filter, as a voter, to 'allow in Americans that share my values and that would minimize change on axes that matter to me', i would accept immigration of Americans.

but, as a voter, i cannot do that. So instead i vote to keep immigration restrictive. that does not mean I consider Americans inferior, not that i hold that they are meaningfully different from me in any way except culture.

it's not racism. but instead a generalization that we are forced to apply as individuals.

does that change your perspective on this?


Mathematicians always define their terms exactly, in order to begin their discussion. Philosophers never define their terms exactly, because then they would have nothing to discuss.


Deontic - `Relating to or expressing moral duty or obligation`

Deontology - `normative ethical theory that the morality of an action should be based on whether that action itself is right or wrong`


That's the is-ought fallacy. We know humans can survive on many different levels of oxygen saturation, and it's clear that very high oxygen content is sometimes helpful. We are not "adapted for ice caps", and they are clearly not a requirement for our survival. Sure, ice caps help maintain Earth in a climate that is favorable to us, but think about all the many different climates that humans have existed in for thousands of generations. There's no real reason to assume ice caps are necessary for a favorable climate. Not to mention the fact that ice caps seem pretty common in the universe.

Similarly, the ozone layer is not a requirement, the requirement is that we have some protection against harmful radiation. I don't know how many different possible ways there are to produce a world with minimal UV light, but I'm sure it's more than 1. And besides: are you seriously suggesting that Earth is clearly optimally habitable regarding UV light, when a large percentage of all humans have to take active measures to protect their skin from frying every time they go outside for more than 30 minutes? It's actually very easy to imagine worlds where it's much more pleasant to be outside.

Why would you even think humans require tectonics, vulcanism, and erosion? This is the most obvious is-ought fallacy. Humans cannot live on a planet unless it has earthquakes and giant death-gas-spewing lava mountains? What?

Abundant fresh water I'll give you. This is something that all our evidence suggests Earth is definitely S-tier at, and rare in our neighborhood of the universe.


Sure, if you want empty, soulless writing, akin to TikTok mind-rot and engagement bait. Get your reader's emotions up so they hate-read it. A/B test your blog for which sentences, jokes, and moral stances get the most engagement. Sell your soul to the lowest common denominator. To fight the AI slop, you must become the AI slop.

Or write something that actually provides value to your reader, communicate that value effectively, and trust your reader to recognize that value. Which would you rather read: writing that was optimized for psychologically capturing your eyeballs, or writing that was optimized for providing you something of value?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vtIzMaLkCaM


Thanks for the reply.

I really didn't mean to encourage emotional manipulation, soulless optimization, listicles, etc., although I agree that a lot of writing online falls in that bucket, and it's even likely that the advice I uncritically quoted was aimed at that bucket.

I obviously should have thought more carefully and written more clearly.

But I don't think that "Write each sentence to give the reader a reason to keep reading" and "Actually provide value to the reader" have to be mutually exclusive. Instead, I think of it as (like you said) communicating the value effectively: dispense with the throat-clearing, meandering intros, irrelevant personal details, weak thesis statements, etc., and write tight, well-crafted prose that respects the time and honestly maintains the interest of those who'd benefit from the value you can provide. (I certainly don't claim to be an expert here! Appreciate the video link.)


> if you start very publicly shipping a cryptographically secure hash, you better keep it cryptographically secure

So if my API happens to return text strings that always happen to have an even number of characters, I better make sure that all future versions of it also always return an even number of characters, just in case some moron decided to bank their application's functionality on that? No. If you decide to write a fragile application tethered to some incidental property of some upstream software, your application deserves to break.


> No. If you decide to write a fragile application tethered to some incidental property of some upstream software, your application deserves to break.

Just because you never made any promise regarding one aspect of your API doesn't mean that you're absolved from responsibility when you choose to change it. If you know for a fact that many users rely on it and you choose to break it, you need a good reason. That kind of balancing act is part of your job. If you don't respect your users, perhaps development wasn't the right career choice.

As developers we're of course constantly tempted to rename things that we named poorly, or change a schema that is no longer optimal. But we must always take a step back and think about the downstream impact.


> I better make sure that all future versions of it also always return an even number of characters, just in case some moron decided to bank their application's functionality on that?

Oh yes, this does happen. There's even a name for that: ossification (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Protocol_ossification). You can't change your API/protocol, because "some moron" started depending on implementation details.

It's easy to say "your application deserves to break" from an ivory tower, but it's often not easy or viable to fix it (for instance, it might have different owners, it might no longer be maintained, it might be more expensive to change, etc). And the change which broke that application was not in it; the blame naturally goes to what was changed last.


Hey, I'm just the messenger here, if you don't like it, take it up with Hyrum ;)

But seriously: If you can afford to break your user's applications if they "deserve to be broken", sure. Many API maintainers can't, or at least don't want to.

In the latter case (which is honestly the norm rather than the exception, at least for public APIs), yes, you should better think about all implicit API contracts your API shape might be projecting. That guideline has served me very well through my career, at least.


> He does correct for the efficiency of both electric cars, and heat pumps in later chapters.

There's something really important to understand when evaluating non-fiction books: nobody reads the later chapters, and the authors generally know this. They can present tremendously one-sided information in the first few chapters, giving the spin that they want, and then in later chapters give a more balanced approach to shield themselves from criticism. Almost everyone who reads the book will read only the spin, but any criticism levied against the author will be met with "but I specifically say, in the later chapters ...". It's a slimy technique that you start to see everywhere once you're aware of it.


Although in this case, iirc the argument that using renewables in isolation would be challenging came in an even later chapter


> There's something really important to understand when evaluating non-fiction books: nobody reads the later chapters

Asserted without evidence, and I very much doubt that it's true. I suspect it varies dramatically by subject matter, intended audience, book length, data density, and more. I have no evidence for any of that. Do you?


There was some statistics on capital in the 21st century by Picketty (maybe from Kindle readers?) that most owners of the books only read the first 10 pages or so. Am on mobile but should be easy to find.

Not necessarily saying this generalises to all non fiction books though


I don't care how hard it was to live in Abyssinia. This is absolutely the worst time to try to make a life in the United States since WWII ended 80 years ago, and there's every reason to believe it is going to continue to get worse for a long time. I have no idea why you are dismissive of people saying this is a difficult time.


The standard of living/real GDP per capita or per hour of work is about as high as it's ever been.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: