HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | fbrchps's commentslogin

This isn't about voicemails, this is about "voice recording sent via iMessage/RCS".

Those don't (currently) get automatic transcriptions, and I don't know of a single medical office/business that would fallback to sending one via a phone call system.


Oh! Thanks, the waveforms should have clued me in. To the site author: Apple calls these “Audio Messages” — you might match their terminology for clarity. Although Google calls them variously both “Voice notes” and “voice messages” (particular semantic collision with prior art for the latter). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Voice_Message_Exchange_(VMX)

But these do have transcription after iOS 17 in 2023: “Audio messages are automatically transcribed in the language chosen in the sender’s Settings.” It works sometimes I’m told (presumably “requires download of speech models” applies to the sender’s device).

And Android has it as well: Google Messages > [profile picture] > Messages settings > Voice message transcription > “Show transcripts of voice messages”.


These are not exclusive to Apple or Google, almost any messenger nowadays (think WhatsApp, Viber, Discord, Signal, Telegram... to count a few) has these and pretty much none of them do transcription (TG does but charges you for it, the audacity). "Voice message" is a pretty standard term used by those messengers, and the site makes no reference to the Apple/Google services whatsoever either, so I'm not sure why the info on what Apple calls them is relevant?

And, while anecdotal, personally I don't know anyone who still uses standard mobile-OS-bundled "texting" (iMessage/RCS), unless it's a text from a business or a government, and those are text texts, so these two settings aren't really useful. Real people are all on those third-party services. I do know the States are different in this regard and iMessage enjoys some popularity there, but I do not know how much.


WhatsApp does transcription, but you have to tap "Transcribe" on each message, and the accuracy is poor.

Accuracy has been fine for me in WA. And far better than listening to someone's stumbling, rambling nonsense filled with um's, okay's, and yeah's.

> But traditional technologies lack cognitive processes: they do not perceive, evaluate, or solve problems

Neither do LLMs, which are "billions of dice" -word-guessers, still to this day.


Applied, I had looked at Amplify before, but haven't gotten any movement. Interested in the space!


Please email me so I know which role / what name to have a hiring manager look for! (firstname)@harnly.net.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: