HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | fblp's commentslogin

I was redirected to https://ipo.anthropic.com/au/ for the Australian offering

The economics of this are absurd, and Anthropic hasn't been without their controversy; but I use Claude everyday, and they've made tremendous impact on society. I wish them the best for their IPO.

They’ve had a tremendous impact on software development, which is not exactly society.

For society more broadly, what I’ve seen is a bunch of white collar workers under threat (real or perceived) of losing their livelihood, and a huge uptick in the amount of interference I’m having to run as my family members get taken in by a wave of increasingly sophisticated scams and phishing attacks.


The only impact I see on my family and friends is a proliferation of daft pictures and realistic-looking nonsense.

At work I see an increase in people spending (wasting?) time trying to make it work reliably for their inputs.


> they've made tremendous impact on society

How?

I can see Google did for fostering an environment that lead to the creation of the Transformer and LLMs. I can see OpenAI for pushing on LLM development and making it into a product that the whole world can use.

What did Anthropic introduce that Google or OpenAI (or any other lab) wouldn't have gotten to iteratively eventually?


he didn't say the impact was good. Could be talking about anything.

They’re cultists who want their golem to control the world. I wish nothing but the worst for them—they have done enough harm already.

Social media had a huge impact on society. AI in comparison has had very little impact, with a couple of exceptions. I'm sure it will have a impact at some point in the future though.

Social media is AI right now. Almost all of it.

It is still entirely possible to curate your social media timeline to be 95% humans.

Or maybe the chatbots are adapting.

The only "tremendous impact on society" I have seen is that people generally outsource thinking completely and get dumber.

You are expecting them to reach this conclusion without asking claude? Their critical thinking is gone.

> they've made tremendous impact on society

Such as?

I can think of a bunch of stuff they released, but none that have impacted the world. I can think of some partly positive impact, which is that my bar for bullshit has to go up because words are cheap now, and so is ""graphics"".

Some other fun impacts they've made is irreversible environmental damage, beautifully detailed in their IPO. Fossil fuel reliance and and water scarcity in the big '26 is probably the most "fuck you" move you could've done, and zero sustainability plans. at least Cloudflare tries to pretend theyre sustainable (and frankly they do invest in green energy).


Anthropic has enable things like workplace surveillance and the ability to categorize school children as enemy combatants. Both of which are what imperialist nations love.

This is a thread about stocks and finance. We are not supposed to discuss what companies do to the real world here.

They have not made significant impact on society. You're in a bubble.

I don't think they have a proven history of abandoning projects yet. Why would they when the tools they build (agents) can dramatically reduce the costs of maintaining and improving projects?

They don't have a history. Period.

And I'd argue they sort of abandoned MCP. Claude's support for it is poor.


Yep, just need Claude Mail (Cmail, anyone?) and Cluade Docs and you have a strong competitor to Google Workspaces. I'd consider using Cmail to start getting out of googles ad ecosystem.

and… into anthropic’s instead??

Would also love to hear more about your project!

Disagree.

A large portion of billionaire wealth isn't reinvested in productive assets. It comes from holding onto assets like corporate shares and land that grows in value based on the asset's ability to extract profit or rent. Or from distorted (speculative) demand for that asset that is completely detached from its productive output.

Someone like Bernard Arnault is worth around $160B (wealth from luxury brands like Louis Vuitton, Dior, and Tiffany). That paper valuation exceeds the total national wealth of many entire countries: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_total_pri...


How does it keep growing if it isn't invested in productive assets?

Yes he is valuable because he makes a product people want. That is how life works. If you want him to be poor, convince people to buy something other than luxury brands.


I actually think it's impressive that they have a prototype. It's less of a leap to think it could end up getting shipped. Whereas other competitors in the industry like Ferrari (Jony Ive collaboration) are launching cars with renders.


Its not a prototype of a car.

Its Airtank and all of this tech wouldn't fit the car.

It jumped for 1-2 seconds and needs 6 hours to be ready again.

It did not had a driver.

It probalby/for sure was striped of evertying unnecessary to even make it to these 1-2seconds


Correction: The writer chose not to engage a lawsuit after receiving advice it was likely to be dismissed given 30 years had passed.


This is a helpful industry article with clear recommendations. Many critiques on competition or consumer issues don't have such precision on their recommendations. I'd donate to them if I was in the US.


These visa policies have already encouraged large tech companies etc to expand their Indian offices. It erodes the US tax base and means talent stay in their home country, which means more innovation happens outside the US. More start-ups are been founded in these countries because more talent is now there.

Trump first term was make Mexico and Vietnam Great Again as companies moved their manufacturing there. This term its make India Great Again as companies retain and train their tech talent there.


They will and after a cyberleek incident they'll rethink that plan.


I've never worked at a company that gave offshore teams the same responsibilities as onshore employees. When shit gets real, and someone's head needs to be on the chopping block, it's always a same-shore employee. But reduced responsibility also means reduced impact. Let's see if that changes, and I'd love to see it happen, but I'm not holding my breath.


Who cares where this so called innovation happens? Won't it be cheaper for all of us if the salaries are in much lower cost of living places? Why would a US citizen give a shit?


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: