HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | eska's commentslogin

First paragraph: G-buffers, screen space reflections. These are considered outdated for years now in computer graphics and modern games have moved away from them.

WebGPU, which is the main API Three.js runs on, does not expose ray tracing at this time. Trying to emulate raytracing via compute shaders is possible but it is too slow to be usable on the majority of the devices. I am trying to make a solution that works on the majority of devices, see:

https://ben3d.ca/blog/how-aaa-games-light-indoor-scenes

https://ben3d.ca/blog/aaa-quality-on-a-web-budget


Your AI slop is considering games from 2016, i.e. techniques from 2014 as modern.

The complement of deferred rendering is not ray tracing. Since you don’t put effort into your posts I will stop here.


half of engines are still regular gbuffer deferred, and screen space reflections are basically in every engine still, because a non RT path is required even in 2026 because its just too slow for a lot of people still.

but as a "goal" maybe regular deferred isnt the best target


They also do upscaling, temporal interpolation, AI shenanigans, etc. All signs of previous techniques breaking at the seems. New approaches go back from deferred to forward+, hybrid, etc to deal with higher resolution, frame rate, memory bandwidth, complexer materials and higher dynamic light count.

BTW ray tracing and g buffers are orthogonal to each other. I see some comments thinking they contradict each other.


Are you from 2040? G-buffers and deferred shading are still very popular.

You can make a blockbuster game with outdated graphics engines, yes. It doesn’t follow that your graphics technology is modern because your game is doing well in the present.

Loki Entertainment, run by Sam Lantinga, author of SDL! Which I would argue did a lot for cross platform compatibility as well. We almost got world of warcraft for linux because of him (I added that to his wikipedia page).

Something else to look into is DDS for P2P with broadcasting in the local network.

Curious, do you have any standards particular to agtech? In manufacturing I also just went with mqtt+sparkplug and buttblasted the entire competition struggling with opc-ua.

no, no real standards that I know of, we support a relatively flexible way on how to push tags to fit a customers standard. I know the MQTT Ignition gateway had a bunch of bugs with sparkplugb initially that got fixed, which is odd as they came up with the standard. It's not super common in agtech except for water districts which operate large pumping systems and tend to use things like Ignition. We don't have too many people who integrate using it. Not surprised you beat out the opc crowd!

It’s strange to see AAA gamedevs in this comment section claim to know better and criticize him while the western AAA gamedev industry is getting absolutely eviscerated, outsold by indies, multiple huge titles in development hell getting canceled weeks after release and losing record amounts of money. And still most arguments are about his character or him supposedly not knowing what it’s like at your big evil corp. You guys just won’t get it, and indies and asian devs are taking your lunch money.

Reminds me of the “Silicon Valley” drama intro. Was fun to rewatch the show and see which companies were dominant at the time (it was updated throughout the seasons).

The Terry A Davis (TempleOS author suffering from mental illness) hit me out of left field. RIP that guy

I do realise that scrapers are also using residential IP ranges via SDK pitched to app developers that add backdoors to utilise the connection for "other things"

Can anyone corroborate this?


The residential proxy SDKs for Smart TVs have been discussed at length at least. [1]

[1]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48635954


Thanks for the link. That’s atrocious


In the long term, the only way for them to fight this is streaming video games. But even then AI can be used to recreate gameplay from video material..

> But even then AI can be used to recreate gameplay from video material..

Sorry what? Is there an example of AI recreating a nontrivial, modern game from just video material?


Low complexity, but to test fable 5.2 I gave it this instagram reel of a Kikis delivery service inspired seedance video: https://www.instagram.com/reel/DXKjMSIkv97/?mdxt=OHBwaW5yamV...

And told it to make a game, and it made: https://petalwake.non.io

Vid is here if you prefer that: https://x.com/pwnies/status/2119987174884143348?s=46&t=bwJTI...


Yes, it can create a new game based on the style of a video, that's not really what anyone cares about though?

The claim is that AI can recreate GTA6 from a GTA6 stream, not create an off-model GTA6 clone from video footage.


It's getting there. Most games are sitting on top of engines that do almost all the heavy lifting, so the AI just has to reverse engineer the assets, gameplay and levels from footage. It can even run the game alongside the clone to see what sort of differences it finds.

> Most games are sitting on top of engines that do almost all the heavy lifting

What? Yes, most game use engines, but all of them customize gameplay systems, graphics/shaders, UI, etc dramatically. That's like saying that most programs are easy to reverse engineer because Windows/Linux are doing almost all of the heavy lifting.

> so the AI just has to reverse engineer the assets, gameplay and levels from footage.

The word "just" is doing an incredible amount of lifting here, you're basically appealing to "AI is magic and will eventually be able to do everything". If that's your argument I can't dispute it I guess, but the fact is that at the current time there has not been an example of AI reverse engineering a modern video game from gameplay footage alone.


Google's Genie and Dreamer models have 'reverse engineered' Minecraft and other games, but to a low fidelity so far.

https://deepmind.google/models/genie/


I suppose this gets into world models a bit, but I honestly don't know this is a reasonable question. Do you really care to know it was already done or do you care to know if it could reasonably be done if it were the best available way? GP seems to be talking about the latter but you seem to be talking about the former.

aren't there games that forbid streaming them

And that's one of the problems of creeping copyright maximalism that will lead people to be fed up.

How do these licenses gatekeep streaming when the only right granted by copyright is control over who can copy?

Don't forget the justification for copyright in the US is "To promote the Progress of Science and useful Arts". I don't see how blocking streaming fits under that justification.


Yes, they always require special licenses. GTA 6 won't stream to PCs on day one for example.

Nintendo in particular leans way too hard on old intellectual property.

The first step to their continued survival is admitting that they lost. They put up a good fight, but betting the farm on nostalgia was already pissing in the wind 20 years ago. AI is a hurricane in comparison.


Do you think Nintendo, Disney, and other IP holders, are going to roll over? Just like RIAA did when MP3s were being traded? They are bigger now than ever and the rest of us are stuck with laws that threaten fair use, eliminate first sale rights, and threaten people who just want to fix the stuff they bought.

The bear will only be poked so much before it decides to get up. If the fight seems existential, it’s not the content owners who are going to end up losing.


I'm excited because the tighter their grip, the more quickly people will realize that intellectual property is obsolete.

Intellectual property is a violation of nature anyway, so good riddance when that time arrives.


And OpenAI and Anthropic get to pick up all the pieces and control the lifetimes of work and billions of dollars spent to create it?

I’m all for copyright reform, but handing it to two companies puts us in a significantly worse position, imho.


So what? If it wasn't those two corporations it would be other giga-cap corporations. IP has been subverted by large companies with full time staffed lawyers to make sure they always win. The only way to beat them is to be another huge company with teams of lawyers.

If you think individuals have any of these rights anymore, then your're living in some alternate reality.


GameCube/GBA era was the last time they made great games with any consistency. Every single series had a significantly worse game for Wii/DS, yet the Wii sold way better and all the IGN reviews were great. 10/10 for Skyward Sword.

I'm sorry, I disgaree firmly, there's tons of great first party games on both the Wii and the DS.

That's alright. Smash Bros, Zelda, Mario Sunshine/Galaxy, Mario Kart, Mario Party, Paper Mario, those are the big ones where I was disappointed in the Wii sequels. And the motion controls were overall a downgrade, which it seems even Nintendo admitted. Do you prefer the Wii ones, or are you just saying they were still great?

There are also people who say Nintendo lost their way with the GameCube and that the N64 was the real deal. Well, I can see that with Zelda at least. I was a kid at the time and went back to play Ocarina.


I'm saying mario galaxy is generally just as well regarded as sunshine and 64, I grew up on sunshine, its obviously my favourite but galaxy takes the second place over 64 for sure. we also had metroid prime 3. MKDS was the best portable mario kart at the time, MK Wii was also a great game even if it didn't have the same kinds of advanced techs (which casual gamers don't even care or know about), paper mario is almost impossible to compare since it changed so much from ttyd but also an quality game. none of those to me signal the loss in quality like we saw with all the "new super mario/luigi" rehashing that we saw during the wii u and 3ds era.

Agree and disagree. The OoT remake that just came out is basically all-in on banking on nostalgia, and it's sold out basically everywhere, so obviously what they're doing works even today. Them taking stuff down like this though is just obviously out of line, for much the same reason. If your stuff is flying off the shelves and selling out the world over, it should not matter to you that some people are ripping stuff for free on the internet somewhere. You made your money already, what more do you want?

Nintendo fans are a special breed. Thinking AI will disrupt them by cloning games from videos is like thinking Six Flags is a threat to Disneyland.

It might be an anecdote, but the Gary Bowser decision got me to stop buying Nintendo, even though platformers are my favorite genre. My third video game was Super Mario World and I have every home Nintendo console from the SNES to the Switch and handheld from the Game Boy Color to the 3DS. It didn't hurt that my Steam Deck is also pretty good for games. I like having an open platform and it actually delivered on what I wanted with the OpenPandora.

I stopped buying Nintendo when it became their official policy to brick your device if they don't like what you did with it.

https://www.ign.com/articles/nintendo-revises-user-agreement...


Oh wow. I haven't thought about my openPandora preorder in a long time.

I'll also add that the indie scene on Steam is amazing. We're consistently getting great games at prices that are a fraction of any Nintendo game. Frankly, I don't miss Nintendo.


OpenPandora? Isn't it super old?

"Clones".

Oh, sweet summer child... either native or emulated, but 100% the same game.


I wonder whether that results in better accessibility for disabled people in the end because agents can control UIs for them.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: