HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | erkt's commentslogin

Uhhh the US cannot force compliance? How many missiles do you think it would require to take ASML out of competition?

Without ASML the US wouldn't be able to source the best semiconductors ever produced, sure it can force compliance by destroying it all but it'd be creating a much larger issue for itself than other means available to force compliance (like sanctions).

Either way, forcing compliance through destruction or sanctions, has a diplomatic and political cost, if that's what the USA chooses to do it will be spending the little political capital it has left with its closest allies.


NL couldn't sanction ASML from the US without causing a serious financial loss, perhaps the end of ASML and its acquisition by a Chinese company. Like most politics it's a multiway standoff.

I meant the US could sanction NL entities if they don't bend the knee, it's a way for the US to force compliance not the other way around.

It's why I mentioned the USA would spend the very little left political capital they have with allies if that was done, would work in immediate terms but hurt the USA itself in the longer term since it'd accelerate decoupling.


The US would seem to be the losing one if it bans itself from receiving GPUs. It would never do that.

Is your expectation here that this issue would lead directly to a military conflict? Not my expectation in anyway, it seems like it just lead to more stupid trade wars from the Trump administration.

A blockade or siege is a militaric tactic and sanctions are basically the dynamic pricing variant of them. Sanctions are applied as an answer to a militaric threat all the time and are intended to change the outcome of a war. Wars are won with logistic and economy ultimately and this is a measure intended to alter the logistic and economic capability of a another country.

Sanctions are not military, there economic. Its well within a person's, company's, or state's rights to decide who they want to do business with and what terms they're willing to agree to.

That's all this is, regardless of whether we agree with the terms themselves.


The USA make sure that the sanctions they create are not only enforced by them. If that were the case, I would agree with you, but as the USA wants to be the world police, I don't.

The USA similarly doesn't have jurisdiction over those other countries either. The US can try to leverage everyone, since WWII its been pretty effective at it, but thats still very different from jurisdiction.

I think that's a reasonable expectation. The US does it regularly, but usually in south america, not europe. Doing it in europe would be something new, but they've done a lot of new things.

How brutal do you think the consequences would be for the US if they attacked a NATO country?

I'd recommend saving what few missiles remain from failing to get control of Hormuz back from Iran. As a bonus that'd save some dignity too.

AI truck drivers won’t even replace the trucker in the cab of a Coca-Cola truck, let alone a wide load.


Currently no good use for it other than as a Biochar. Come up with a solution and save billions for the tourism industry.


Yup, every time this issue comes up the first question is can it be used for anything? Turns out, the answer so far has been a resounding “no”. It’s a super interesting problem from a purely analytical perspective as you run into roadblocks any time you think of a potential use case


Are they still in competition? Or are they a government sanctioned monopoly? I’m not sure that will be competitive. There are no market forces to do so but pride.


You are severely misusing the term monopoly.

There is demand for AI that is not US or China controlled. Mistral is serving that demand.


That demand is enshrined in law and being forced through coercion. It is the definition of a government dictated monopoly.


Nobody is preventing other Europeans from setting up AI companies


Just the lack of capital, lack of electricity, lack of datacenters, lack of gpus. Of course to navigate all that you have to fight endless regulations in the EU.

No one prevented other people from running their own AT&T phone company in the US. Except the lack of capital, and endless regulations with running telephone polls across the US.

Google even tried more recently to run their own fiber optics and gave up in the end because of entrenched regulations making it impossible to challenge the modern monopolies internet providers have.


Lack of capital, datacentres and GPUs being the barrier to competition in European AI giants is the exact opposite of a "government sanctioned monopoly"...


"The definition of a government dictated monopoly".

This is a joke right?


A lot of national defense stuff is a de facto "government sanctioned monopoly" and this is certainly the same flavor. Market forces are different if the industry is perceived to be vital to continued sovereignty.


Being the only(?) competitive European model probably makes them a de-facto monopoly for doing sensitive European stuff.


That's rich coming from a country who's top AI contender just announced 80B in yearly losses. Looks a lot like a subsidised duopoly to me.


72B of the 80B was paper losses due to stock exercises and not related to cash flow.


Who's subsidizing it?

Also what about SpaceX, Meta and Google? They are clearly still in the game. They are all ahead of Mistral.


Which government? Sanctioned how? What stops other European companies from competing with Mistral? Is the situation better in the US?


french are pretty proud man. pro-euro europeans too!


I mean, the model architecture is basically that of GLM 5.3 with slightly more parameters and slightly more active parameters, so it should probably be able to beat GLM 5.3 enough post-training.


Actually, with Trump in the Office, "AI/Data Sovereignty" is quite a strong market forces. From Europe point-of-view, any US company is a potential risk (hello Starlink)

;-)


There is one word too many in that last line. The US is no longer a 'potential' risk.


It's well known that every Mistral employee is a fonctionnaire. No.


With the proper facilities, isn’t it already economical to transmute mercury to gold via neutron bombardment?


If I am reading this correctly, then mercury-198 will receive a neutron, decay to mercury-197, then emit an electron to become gold-197.

Mercury has seven stable isotopes ranging from 195 to 204, so purifying to 198 is challenging (this isotope is 10% of the metal's occurrence). Would this require centrifuges as uranium does?

The decay chains of the other isotopes would be different.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Synthesis_of_precious_metals#G...

"...the production cost is estimated to be a trillion times the market price of gold."

The above reaction is at the end of the section.


You wouldn't enrich the 198 isotope, you'd just bombard natural mercury and chemically separate out the gold afterwards.

> "...the production cost is estimated to be a trillion times the market price of gold."

Wikipedia just pulled this one out of its butt. The value of a neutron in a nuclear reactor is the opportunity cost of it not hitting a uranium atom to produce fission. 1 mole of neutrons can produce about $100,000 worth of wholesale electricity assuming 40% efficiency. 1 mole of neutrons could alternatively produce 1 mole of gold, which is worth about $26,500. So it's roughly 4 times the market price of gold.

Of course there would be the cost of building and running the reactor and the associated chemical processes to collect the gold, but these cost are probably similar orders of magnitude to mines and refineries. Certainly not 12 orders of magnitude more.

While it's not economical to make gold this way, it is economical to make certain medical isotopes this way.


>> "...the production cost is estimated to be a trillion times the market price of gold."

> Wikipedia just pulled this one out of its butt.

It is worth checking before accusing someone of making something up...

This appears to come from https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/fact-or-fiction-l..., which states that the author of a 1980 experiment says "It would cost more than one quadrillion dollars per ounce to produce gold by this experiment." That appears (from skimming sources) to come from a running cost of $5000/hr to produce a few hundred atoms of gold per hour. Modern methods are probably more efficient, but the number didn't come from nowhere.

Addendum: And per https://home.cern/alice-detects-conversion-lead-gold-lhc, the LHC can turn lead into gold at a rate of 89000 nuclei per second, which is ridiculously far from economically reasonable. The LHC cost $9 billion and uses a lot of power, so I'd say not "similar orders of magnitude to mines and refineries" used for gold.


> "It would cost more than one quadrillion dollars per ounce to produce gold by this experiment."

"This experiment" being a radically different method than the one under discussion. Wikipedia pulled something useless from someplace irrelevant, which is exactly what should be described as "pulled out of their butt."

The LHC is also neither a nuclear reactor, nor a gold making machine. You can make gold with it the way you can use a space shuttle to deliver newspapers. That it is possible is an interesting tidbit of trivia which you might include in an encyclopedia article, it is not however evidence supporting the claim that newspaper deliveries cost millions of dollars.


No it really isn't. People have transmuted a few hundred milligrams of mercury into gold in the lab with multi-million dollar machines, but that doesn't make it economically viable in the slightest.


Is plagiarism actually illegal? This is primarily an ethical, academic or professional violation.


Were we discussing legality?


Maybe they should be treated like the festival goers?


The IDF has killed not just a higher number but also a higher percentage of civilians, and a much higher percentage of children, than the October 7 attacks[0]. Even if collective punishment was considered not cruel but moral by the larger community, Israel has far surpassed it.

[0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Casualties_of_the_Gaza_war


They would be better off if they were.


The words you are looking for are combatants. How does bulldozing a combatants home have any affect on a tunnel? Because it destroys the entrance to the tunnel. There are no innocents in Gaza.


“ There are no innocents in Gaza.” funny, this is exactly what people said to defend what Hamas did on October 7th.

The babies and young children in Gaza are as innocent as they are everywhere else in the world. If you can’t see that, you should reexamine the lens you use to look at the world, it’s distorting things massively.


> There are no innocents in Gaza.

This is true. Their crime is not having been born a Jew. According to the Torah, the Talmud and the Talakha, shkotzim and shiksim like us must be slaughtered as is the right and the duty of the Chosen Ones to honor G-d.


I’m not sure your point? They are not civilians when they are covering up tunnels in their homes for Hamas to use.


Look at Google map of Gaza city, Rafah, Khan-Younes, Al Qarara, ... pretty much all building have been destroyed. You want to try to argue that every one of them was somehow hiding a tunnel ?


Is having tunnels in their own territory a problem?


Then maybe the civilians should kill their Hamas neighbors, instead of cheering them in the streets and supporting the actions of Oct 7th…


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: