I mean main media outlets know that the public really has turned on billionaires so this is some meat to feed the readers (great ad rev). Someone from the administration leaking the information to a reporter for sure wouldn't be surprising without knowing how much it would blow up. Also many other viable theories too.
Stock trading isn't gambling. It's just owning assets that can change in value. Options trading is much closer to gambling, and I would say the biggest difference between it and Kalshi and similar gambling companies is that it's much more rigorously (if nowhere near perfectly) regulated.
Both have risk associated with them yes, one has oversight from the goverment and the other is a game / world event.
With stocks if I try to do insider trading I run the risk of Jail time. Or if I try to do a Pump and Dump scheme, I go to jail. If I am an person and I "place a bet on polymarket/kalshi" and then go and influence that outcome. It may not be illegal. Since these markets commodify literally any event, its impossible to control the items themselves. So the markets need to be controlled.
But oversight from the government could change tomorrow. The definition of something shouldn't hinge on what the government thinks it is. The government's definition should be based in something meaningful.
I could hedge it at the blackjack table too -- that doesn't make a blackjack hand a financial asset. I'm talking about whether the instrument itself is backed by something of inherent value.
You could buy a stock expecting asset appreciation, but the stock itself is a certificate of ownership in a business. Even a derivative of this, like options trading, is a contract to buy or sell or deliver said certificate of ownership in a business. Ultimately it is backed by something of tangible value.
"Predictions markets" are all of the mechanics of trading, but without any underlying value. It is literally gambling wearing Groucho glasses. The bet is simply for the sake of the bet.
It's heartening to see a large group of people working (mostly) for free on a passion project. Makes me optimistic about the resilience of intrinsic human drive.
You could make an analogy to getting a flu vaccine. There's a small up-front cost, but you're making a bet that it will prevent or reduce the severity of a larger issue down the road. There's no guarantee that the larger issue would ever occur, but "getting the vaccine" makes it less likely to occur, and less costly if it does occur. Skipping the "vaccine" is a reasonable choice if the business is willing to incur substantial damages in the case of a large event in the future. To put hard numbers to it, you could always show numbers like "X% of our customers are likely to leave if we leak all their data to hackers", and base it on documented examples from recent history.
I feel like I haven't yet figured out the line to draw between disliking something because it's AI-generated and disliking something because it's lazy.
This line:
> Checked by a guardrail test, not just claimed.
Is such a meaningless statement to include in the marketing page, it immediately makes me feel like the entire effort was lazy because it seems like they didn't proofread their own page. I almost would rather they just have a page describing what they were trying to accomplish and the prompt they used to get there, and skip the ceremony of the generated library.
reply