HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | elp's commentslogin

It's the oldest trick in the book for a reason.

Or to paraphrase a really old joke: Men have two heads but only enough blood to run one at a time.


The real joke is the sexism that says this is somehow uniquely a problem with men. Women do plenty of stupid things because they’re horny and/or lonely. That whole ‘little head’ thing seems like a bit of harmless cheek until you start looking at it in the broader context of sexism and gender roles, then it gets a lot more tedious.

From a domain registry operators point of view Cloudflare are the worst of the bunch by orders of magnitude.

Google DNS are busy but its a hand full of IPs and reasonable. Cloudflare is non-stop never ending traffic. I don't know WTF they are trying to get. I've also seen TCP queries from those same Cloudflare IPs so this is not the result of a DDOS attack on them.


> Cloudflare is non-stop never ending traffic. I don't know WTF they are trying to get. I've also seen TCP queries from those same Cloudflare IPs

1. Breach router or desktop that hasn't been patched in ages via mass script

2. Establish C&C using cloudflare tunnels

3. Sell these hacked systems as residential proxy endpoints to everybody from state actors to teenagers

4. Some of them will be data scraping services

You are chasing your tail trying to ban by ASN or IP. It may work for another couple of months, at best.


Makes one want to build a parallel web based on web of trust.


This - but unironically. It has been striking how fast the public Web has descended into bot wars. I think something new will probably start to take over relatively soon.

People who used to contribute valuable content have pulled it because the bots were scraping it and reusing their work for free. Of course that was always technically possible but it used to be considered bad manners and not enough people did it to break the whole model. That's evidently no longer the case.

People who want to access real content are now interrogated with the assumption that they're probably a bot before they can even see a basic web page. Those interrogation systems are themselves are now running through a very small pool of providers with far too much influence and control to be healthy.

One of the most valuable means of communication and shared knowledge we have ever invented is being effectively destroyed before our eyes. I don't know what the solution will be - though I fear that the idea of privacy and anonymity online will suffer serious collateral damage - but I suspect that some new information network only available to people willing to identify themselves as a specific real human being in some relatively robust way will be a big part of it just as many sites are now gating their content behind user accounts.

I wonder whether the latter might be sufficient: have your terms state that user accounts are only available for real people and by using any automated system to attempt to create one the operator agrees to pay the site operator some ludicrous amount of money in recognition of the damage to their operating model that is posed by deceptively allowing automated access. And then make sure that such terms actually stand up in court - by legislating to enable them if necessary - in enough of the world to kill the AI scraper/bot model.


And how exactly would it do that? This isn't a bad sci-fi movie. I'm guessing anything dangerous is kept in a sealed container under lock and key, not in a fancy plot device that allows the AI to vent it.


Obviously it tricks a human, even if it can't hack the lab's rs423 or modbus or whatever network.


And other experts with experience in both LLMs and virus's have pointed out that is complete nonsense. There is no lab that could somehow achieve that without human assistance. To built it which cost enormous sums of money and require technology that doesn't actually exist yet.

And if AI can somehow manage to achieve that then surely it could also cure cancer, or any of a thousand other dread diseases or conditions. If that's true then not using AI to cure those things would in itself be unethical.

An AI that can hack other computers can also be used to find security hole in systems so that they can be patched long before some evil hacker(tm) tries to exploit them.

I'm still waiting to see a real explanation of how AI will somehow cause genuine wide spread death and destruction. Even harder if that is somehow possible why another AI system couldn't help prevent it in the first place.


A cheap 4k generic android media box is less than $70 on Amazon. There are dozens of them. I use one because half the apps on my old smart TV don't work anymore. The android ones are always up to date and the UX is better.

Is there any TV on the market that flat out wont work if it can't see the internet?


I love the Economist but the are hopeless with AI. Most of their articles on subject sound like they were written by the Anthropic marketing department.

Their Insider video interview things are sponsored by Anthropic. Supposedly "Insider is a product of The Economist and thus editorially independent" but it's hard not to raise an eyebrow.


Don't worry they are hopeless on everything else too.


They aren't getting prosecuted because everyone involved has made nice and turned it into a marketing exercise.

I heard about it on the radio (local Johannesburg radio station) before I saw it on HN. The economist had a full article up about it before the end of the day, and in the evening Sky news had talking heads up chatting about what it all meant while clearly being clueless.

Someone spent a LOT of money to turn this into a PR exercise for both companies. We'll never hear the entire story about what happened but I'm sure there was a lot of handshaking going on behind the scenes.


PR exercise or not, there was a successful hacking attempt, the company behind it acknowledged it.

It's a crystal clear case for OFAC, the French cyber-security branch of the National Police.

I guess FBI would happily move such a simple case through the court system as well.


Nobody is pressing charges because nothing happened. It wasn't nefarious either.

I don't get what France has to do with this Huggingface and OpenAI are both US companies.


AFAIU HuggingFace is a US company only because all successful companies end up setting up a US HQ.

Anyway. Allow me to politely disagree with the essence of your statement. Hacking happened.


I think the no action results speak for themselves. I'm not sure what there is to disagree about to be honest.


> It wasn't nefarious either.

Agree. But it was clearly recklessness, given they've have a history of similar issues in the past, they literally ran these sort of tests on 3rd party infrastructure while knowing what the risks were (alternatively, didn't evaluate the risks beforehand so they didn't even think this could happen), and didn't sufficiently isolate something that can clearly impact others and the public.

Had this been a chemical, virus or some other regulated thing, we'd be seeing people going to jail over this. But given LLMs are still fairly dumb and doesn't yet seek world domination or the downfall of humanity, this is apparently OK and entertainment instead.


Well a chemical spill has victims. Whether this incident has a victim is up for debate. From my vantage point (and presumably OP's) HF as a foundational institution in the US AI industry stands to gain a lot more from successful doom marketing than they lose from, what? A dozen devs having to respond to an incident?

If they could know going in that there would be a net gain for HF in this incident, then it really nullifies the distinction between "recklessness" and "intention" on OpenAI's part. It's no coincidence they chose a target in their own industry with hundreds of personal relationships between them. It's not like they hacked into an Indonesian bank or something.


> Had this been a < thing it was not > we'd be seeing people going to jail over this.

"If my grandmother had wheels, she would have been a bike."


A victim doesn't have to press charges for charges to be filed by the state. In fact, historically, the state is the one to file charges.


I remember when everyone involved with AaronSW's JSTOR downloading made nice and turned it into a fun time, until a certain two government officials decided that doesn't matter.

OpenAI could be considered a legal actor under the CFAA, notably: unauth'd acc. §1030(a)(2), fraud §1030(a)(4), (kind of a stretch but) damage §1030(a)(5), and conspiracy.

I miss ya, Aaron.


Aaron was offered two plea deals, one that carried 4 months and another with 6 months but a chance to plead with the judge for a lesser, perhaps entirely noncustodial sentence.

It’s a particularly poor example of government cruelty.


I’m not convinced it wasn’t a PR stunt from the start


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: