Are there any companies outside of the "AI shovels" business that make more money because of AI? Every time I ask someone why they went so hard on adopting AI, I hear the same story about the fear of losing the market share or becoming less competitive. Honest question, who is benefitting from all of this? The revenues at majority of companies seem flat at best. There is a growing concern about professionals getting deskilled, the job satisfaction is not improving, wages are stagnant. Mind-boggling that we are actively engaged and often push for this experiment that hurts our own profession. Cheering for our own demise.
Not keen on outing myself by providing evidence, but I think we do generate more revenue by using AI. We launched new products with a small team and also optimized our outcome-pricing based product using AI several times. We also reduced costs by self-hosting more software.
But we're a tiny baby startup, so things like "spin up a new product with 1 engineer and get to $1m in revenue on it" or "reduce our IaaS bill by 300k/yr" is a meaningful contribution for us.
We're also building new AI-enabled software that was not possible before.
The big breakout hits have been AI Infra, but that makes sense from a technological perspective, Cisco made a lot of money well before Google did, but Cisco is not where the money concentrated in the end.
We don't really know what the equivalent of Google as an application business will be in the AI era, but there's a pretty big chance it's not actual Google. But Google still has to do it's best to hold on.
I use AI compatibility as a metric when evaluating new software to add to my stack. If an AI agent isn’t able to do most of what you can do in the app by opening it, I prefer to look for other options.
Does not apply to everything though. E.G: I don’t care about AI support for my non work chats/email, since I’d rather not give it access.
This seems really really easy to do even if your org isn't using AI at all. You certainly don't need to be "AI Native" to implement an MCP server for your webapp.
Engineering’s job has always been to deal with hard technical challenges and apply new technologies.
Writing code was never the point. Predictably creating specific outcomes was. Wrangling AI in a way that multiplies productivity is the new job.
I won’t lie, it kind of sucks to be young right now, learn about punch cards and assembly in school, and then graduate into a market that’s moved on to Fortran. Sorry, I meant high level languages and AI. To say otherwise might imply the industry has seen a similar shift in the past where engineers made the exact same complaints practically verbatim.
Regardless, the reality is that college teaches very little about 90% of real engineering work anyway, and we still need to hire smart people for this new type of work.
I am seeing the same. The skillsets degrading rather rapidly, people not able to maintain focus and becoming less sharp in general. The brain rot associated with short form videos is affecting our industry via LLMs. It doesn't give me any joy to see it happening, especially to people I care about.
I don't know why I haven't been able to see the similarity between short form content and LLMs in our industry until reading your comment, but that is apt. That's the impression I'm getting. I stay away from "agentic code generation" as much as possible, just like I avoid short form content mills like the plague. That said, LLMs have been a huge boon for me as a research assistant. Being able to look up very niche problems, and have responses be tailored to me, is awesome. My brain stays sharp and I still enjoy the fun of putting the pieces together myself much faster than before.
I don't personally like LLMs for research assistance (yet?) because i can't get over the hallucinating or rather, waste too much time validating that it's not currently overcast when they tell me the sky is in fact blue.
But, especially as code gets flung over the wall faster and with less care, I do think they are getting to be pretty great at reviewing code for specific things that a linter can't easily catch and for looking for security, implementation, and architectural flaws before I have to look for them. A couple examples of what i mean: 'does the code use knex.raw with a template literal?', 'does the code do n+1 db lookups instead of something better?' 'do all the added/modified tests follow the test case template defined here?'
do we know how much are they paying on average? I just got Gemini Plus that seems sufficient for my family's ordinary usage and it's $37 per year (3 bucks / month). I just don't see the AI companies making any serious money with this type of pricing.
Hmm, sometimes I feel like living in a different universe. Since LLMs can solve any technical challenge (like most of you claim here) and help folks explore new fields and revive all sorts of projects, wouldn't be all seeing effect of that everywhere? Wouldn't the bar for software quality go up (and go up significantly)? Wouldn't we see new innovative apps that people are delighted to use and more than happy to pay money for? Yet when I recently challenged some friends of mine to name just ONE major app / service that became materially better (I'd argue even better at all) or a new/innovative widely adopted by masses outside of pure AI world (Claudes and GPTs), they couldn't name any. Meanwhile, I am looking around and see that banking, insurance, search, social media, cloud computing are getting more bloated, unstable, mediocre and in general of lower quality. Where is all the cool software everybody is talking about? Where are the features from your backlogs that you were finally able to burn through? I am just not seeing it in the real world. Something doesn't add up here.
No LLM can help companies that didn't care about software quality in the first place. If they did, they wouldn't have fired QA testers. And now that they've been gone for a decade while revenues have soared, why would they bother using LLMs for QA testing when they could execute on the stakeholder's vision instead!
You'd expect to see the majority of benefit to independent devs who previously _couldn't afford_ QA or a full team, and now can. But since the target audience for this stuff is niche, you're less likely to hear about it unless you're plugged into the subcommunities (see e.g. how LLMs have helped with game preservation, retrogaming).
We have a Landlock (formerly Bubblewrap) Linux sandbox due to an LLM. It sat unfixed on our roadmap for almost a decade. I and at least one other maintainer (as well as several LLMs) reviewed every line of code.
Homebrew has never been better performant, secure, tested, linted and typed. I understand the LLM dubiousness (I used to share it myself) but we’re the type of project where it’s very easy to get agents to do sensible end-to-end testing and review a nice language (Ruby). Just us on our outputs, not just our inputs.
One of our former maintainers was in high school when working on Homebrew. I’m sure many people would have found that worrying. His code was great, though (I reviewed most of it) and he made the project better. Same ultimately with LLMs. Your mileage may vary.