I recently got very pessimistic about this when I realized that in order for the agent to make meaningful changes, it frequently needs to read all your config files / dotfiles.. even if this is a sandboxed project, it feels pretty bad this config is instantly stored in the cloud out of your grasp. My OpenCode one day was like "and now I'm signing into your local mysql instance with your (plaintext) pw that I picked up last week to make some schema updates... " and I was like, ok we're done here.
I'm now avoiding any cloud-agents until further notice.
Once we get to that point, and I know he's fulfilling orders reliably, maybe I'll write up a blog post somewhere and share it here. I'm still somewhat guarded, but he's been quite transparent about his situation so far. I asked him to travel to the local shop and take a picture of the sewing machine he'd need to buy, and he did. He told me how much a flat would cost him, and I looked up listing in his city, and it was dead-on. It's not often you have the opportunity to potentially change the course of someone's life for a few hundred dollars, but maybe I've been given one. Maybe I'm gullible, but if it works out for him I'd be happy.
Very cool... but... if education in the region is not affordable for many, and a minority of students begin to get subsidized, is it not in a way helping to support an unsustainable situation? The system now has less pressure to adapt to poorer students because it is getting paid into.
I think efforts like this are probably very rewarding and draw good attention, but ultimately the change needs to happen more systemically.
Education is the basis for all change. Without education, change is impossible. The students who get support for their school are in no way worse off than others who don't get help, even if their studies don't help them get a good job.
Practically I believe the individual outcome will be of two kinds: a student will use their schooling to help their village, start a business and bring a small amount of improvement. Or they will leave the area and find work elsewhere. Neither is unsustainable. The worst outcome would be if everyone leaves and the village dies out. Could that happen? Maybe. But I think it is unlikely. Or at least, I think that education is unlikely going to be a major factor, because even without education people from villages move to cities to seek their fortune.
And while this is pure speculation, I'd like to believe that people with education are more likely to stay because thanks to ubiquitous internet they have more opportunities to use that education to their advantage even from their remote location.
Systematic change will happen when more people with better education move into the ranks of government or business where they can affect such change.
Btw: when I talk about education I don't just mean STEM. I also mean ethics or moral education to teach people that contributing to society is important. Sponsoring students does not achieve that on its own, but it's something others are working on, and these students tend to be grateful for the help they get that they also get the message in a way and are motivated to pay it forward.
Interesting point. What do you envision a systemic effort looking like in this case?
In my mind there are serious barriers to systemic change in a place like a rural village in Tanzania. In many ways the place is systemically stuck in a state of stagnation due largely to outside forces that the people there cannot control.
My thought is that by providing education to the kids, you can give them the ability to assess and change their environment in a way that they otherwise couldn't. I think that will lead to positive change.
That’s EA entering the chat, arguing that all currently available ways of helping are ineffective and until there is an effective way to help is found, they are absolved from helping.
And since they are one day planning to help, they must maximize wealth in the interim. Obviously this wealth maximization can take unorthodox paths because ends justify the means.
a TUI using react seems like something they would be particularly bad at; visual feedback (esp the very specific feedback we rely on during dev, with Inspector) is kinda the Moravecs Paradox hurdle for these things.
Idk much about virology tools but I would imagine it's a very text-friendly environment, and it can probably find plenty of documentation on how to use the tools.
I recently had Claude write my entire particle system for a virtual world I'm working on, in 3d. It did fine without ever "seeing" anything.
There's still a lot of intervening steps between a virus being synthesized in real life and programming one, but I would bet the programming part is within reach.
I'm now avoiding any cloud-agents until further notice.
reply