HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | eddyg's commentslogin

It’s important to share his follow-up⁽¹⁾ too, since it provides important context:

> The CFO agent wrote an instruction for itself that said "Update Exec team" and when it went to run this task it saw that I also had a Slack channel called "Exec team" and it got confused and posted it into that work channel.

⁽¹⁾ https://x.com/shanemac/status/2108209486154301893


I wouldn’t be too sure.⁽¹⁾

“there’s little evidence that AI labs are pelicanmaxxing. Or at least they’re not doing it in a plainly obvious manner. Pelicans aren’t drawn any better than other animals. Bicycles aren’t drawn any better than other vehicles. And no lab draws the combination better than its pelicans and bicycles already predict.”

⁽¹⁾ https://dylancastillo.co/posts/pelicanmaxxing.html


Because retail models now dominate the price-performance frontier by a huge margin. An open-weight model wins at just 3% of price points (down from 41% just a few months ago).

https://village.dev/blog/closed-ai-models-now-dominate-the-p...


That chart is comparing the cost of buying tokens, not the cost of generating your own. The system I specced out can generate 5.2M tokens per day.

That's $104/day of opus 5.5 tokens, or $265/day of fable 5.1 tokens.

If you were able to saturate usage of this system, you could pay it off in 3 days of fable time or 6 days of opus 5.5.

But ok those are more intelligent. Let's go with something that scores similar - sonnet 4.6. 5.2M tokens is $78/day and the system is paid off in 8 days.


> That's $104/day of opus 5.5 tokens, or $265/day of fable 5.1 tokens.

But you’re not generating Opus or Fable tokens.

And people buying subscription plans aren’t paying API rates.

I have a Claude subscription and I have hardware to run Qwen3.8-Flash-Next a full order of magnitude faster than the theoretical system you specced above.

In no way would I ever consider my local Qwen3.8-Flash-Next setup comparable to even a $20/month Claude subscription. It’s just not.

I do try to use it for bounded tasks from time to time, but using it for actual complicated work generates so many problems later that it’s not worth it.

Often I can have Opus produce a better result in 1/10th the tokens. The Qwen model often gets things wrong that require 10X as many tokens to debug or fix later. You cannot make comparisons like you’re trying to do.


Your analysis is correct if you’re maxing out the $20 Claude subscription and using the best models to do things that need high quality results.

In my opinion, what we actually have to compare against is the $20 subscription compared to what using Claude or ChatGPT is like with the free plan.

If I use Claude free it cuts me off from using it for hours after a very small number of questions being asked, and it can’t be hooked up to a coding system at all (no Claude code CLI or VSCode extension).

So when I dropped a $500 GPU into my gaming server in my closet, I’m breaking even compared to the $20/month Claude subscription in 2 years (and my GPU already appreciated in value since I bought it).

I can send as many queries as I want in any way I want, including custom applications that would have normally been billed at API token rates.

On top of that, all my data is kept private to my server.

(I’m not counting electricity because my server was already on serving all my self-hosted apps, so a significant amount of electricity is only being added to the load when I’m actively asking questions)


> In my opinion what we actually have to compare against is that $20 subscription compared to what using Claude is like when it’s nearly free.

No, we’re not going to compare $500 GPUs to free tiers.

The contorted logic in these threads makes my head hurt.

> So when I dropped a $500 GPU into my gaming server in my closet, I’m breaking even compared to the $20/month Claude subscription in 2 years (and my GPU already appreciated in value since I bought it).

But the $500 gaming GPU in your closet isn’t providing Claude level intelligence or performance. Not trying to brag, but my LLM hardware is an order of magnitude more expensive than that and I hold no illusions that it’s comparable to what I get from Claude.

If you want to compare against something, compare against Qwen tokens purchased through a provider. Compare like for like.

The $20/month Claude sub is on a different level of performance entirely. There is no direct comparison on quality or speed until you’re spending A LOT more on hardware, and even then the closed models still win.


Let me clarify and I hope this helps you understand where I'm coming from.

The free Claude subscription is an insufficient level of service because what I'm looking for is the ability to send as many queries as my heart desires, and to be able to use it with a coding agent. Therefore, I must spend some kind of money. The cheapest flat price plan I can buy from Claude is $20.

That's why I'm comparing against $20 a month. Of course, maybe for this sparse use case it would be better to use API billing instead of a $20 plan, although maybe that means I'm thinking about billing variability.

I am not comparing it to the level of intelligence that Claude offers. I'm comparing spending $500 one time to spending at least $20/month forever. Yes, it's smarter than the model I'm running, but if I'm not paying that money Claude ends my usage mid-conversation and tells me to come back in 5 hours.

The model I'm currently running is Qwen 3.8 Flash Next using Strata (https://github.com/Niko1221/Strata), the VM has 64GB of system RAM assigned (which was previously sitting unused, with deep apologies to Ram Altman). It's definitely not a bad model, and gets the job done for me.

I would generally agree with you that I'm never going to break even against buying tokens from better open weight models on the open market, or maybe even just buying Sonnet 5.5 tokens, but I'm also gaining the data sovereignty aspect, which is worth a non-zero amount of money.

On top of that, the GPU is an asset with resale value, so I'm not losing the money permanently. It has appreciated in value by $150 since I purchased it, and will probably be worth no less than $200-300 in the next 5 years in the worst case.


> to do things that need high quality results

Are there situation where you don't want high quality results?

It's taken until very recently for me to trust AI to actually do what I want it to do for hobby projects. I still have to scrupulously code review everything that isn't greenfield or an http rest endpoint.


When I don’t want to pay money every month.

I also figure the open models I can run on this same hardware will only improve.

I’m not really struggling against poor quality results, I’m struggling against free tiers that don’t give me enough usage plus my unwillingness to pay a continual subscription fee.


You’re comparing API rates, but your original question was about subscriptions.

Also, if I wanted to generate Sonnet 4.6-quality tokens, maybe your suggested setup is the better approach (though I still highly doubt it), but I don’t. I want Opus 5.5 / Fable 5.1 level of quality, because the ROI in terms of human-in-the-loop time saved and how much better and faster I can build is worth WAY more than $200 / month to me. That’s basically a rounding error for my business.


… For now, until the machine you keep feeding eats your business.

Anyway, if it’s worth more than $200/month definitely don’t spend $600 and expect it’ll replace that. But $2400 ($200/month for one year) gets you much closer to sota than $600 - and whatever the line that stops being a rounding error for your business gets you closer still.

How much is it worth to own your livelihood? To me outsourcing to anthropic or openai for $200/month means you’re handing them the ability to kill your business at any moment without even noticing. That’s worth more to me than 30% points of intelligence.


I’m getting like $8k per month in API rate value from each $200/month subscription.

You clearly have an ideological issue with these companies, but I don’t share your views or your values. They could cut me off tomorrow but it wouldn’t kill my business. Worst case, I’d have to figure out how to make do with what you’re already choosing to do today.


I absolutely do have an ideological viewpoint. I hope i haven’t come across as trying to hide that.

One of my beliefs, call it ideology if you like, is that api cost is much more representative of real cost of this stuff. Good luck switch to local models the same week everyone else decides to switch because subscription prices went up 5x… it’s going to cost more than $600.

Anyway, like it or not, you are giving $200/month to fund another ideology. One that looks to me like a leopards-eating-faces type of ideology.


There's nothing wrong with having an ideology or having a set of values that the big AI labs are bad for the world and you don't want to support them, etc.

But in this case it seems like it's led your reasoning astray into this perspective where a small open weight model you can run on cheap hardware is just as good as the value you get from paying $200 to Anthropic. The reality is that it's not even close, at least for some people's use cases.

I really doubt I'll ever need to use local models, even in a scenario where the big labs stop doing subscriptions (unlikely), I could just pay API rates for the open weight models through OpenRouter, or just pay for API rates for Sonnet 5.5 or GPT 6.1 Sol, and adjust my workflows a bit. Still worth it.

I don't know, there are a LOT of things I worry about with AI, but what I'm going to do when the big labs drop subscriptions isn't even in my top 10. Probably not my top 20. Just a non-factor.


> on cheap hardware is just as good as the value you get from paying $200 to Anthropic

Not just as good. I’ve never said just as good. what i will stand by is good enough. What you can get for $600 is good enough to be useful for building software. Since paying anthropic/openai money to continue their sociopathic mission is a hard no-go for me, i’m just very glad there’s another option that passes “good enough* bar.


>They could cut me off tomorrow but it wouldn’t kill my business. Worst case, I’d have to figure out how to make do with what you’re already choosing to do today.

That's just the issue of your access to AI in the worst case.

The actually impactful part of the worst case would be what happens to your ability to have a job, put food on the table, or even afford to live in a house.


I have only so much control over any of that.

>That’s basically a rounding error for my business.

As long as you have a business. AI will "Sherlock" many and commodify all.


Perhaps, but there’s nothing you or I can do about one end of that. I can only control how I respond.

I mean, every person who pays them money helps them continue to do this to us. Part of responding is choosing who to give your money to.

Do you want to be using Sonnet 4.6 day-to-day though across all of your work?

Doesn't matter if it's free, you'll spend 3x the time correcting its mistakes.


For what I do, that works. In exchange I get privacy, i get to not fund the big labs eating the world, I get to not worry about hitting plan limits, and I don't have to worry about them killing my account if I ask about the wrong thing.

As much as I might agree with your points, is it reasonable to think that the majority of people or even say 25% of people will feel similarly enough to endure a meaningful drop in quality and intelligence in pursuit of those things you mentioned?

I think most people unfortunately don't care about any of those things, or at least they don't care enough as we are about to see by the trillion dollar IPOs of these AI megalabs.


> 25% of people will feel similarly enough to endure a meaningful drop in quality and intelligence in pursuit of those things you mentioned?

Anthropic continues to serve haiku - which suggests people have a use for less-than sota models.

A bugatti is undoubtedly a higher performance car than a honda civic. Yet if you're commuting to work in rush hour traffic, both cars will get you there in the same amount of time - and one is going to cost you a lot less.

The pitch of the frontier labs is that you need a bugatti for everything. I don't buy that.


Also, I'd think the analogy is more akin to a pickup truck compared to a bicycle.

The bicycle will still get you there.

It will just take much longer depending on how far you have to go, and there are some things that, no matter how hard you try, the bike will simply not be able to do that a truck can, such as haul heavy loads from one place to another.

You don't need to drive the pickup truck around everywhere. Certainly you can just take your bike if you're traveling a reasonable distance and you don't need to bring a bunch of stuff with you.

But it sure is nice to have a truck sometimes.


I use haiku and open weight models as well. It doesn't mean they're the only models I rely on, far from it.

In fact, it's usually my use of more capable models that I've instructed to delegate low-level work to these less capable models that is resulting in my haiku et al usage.


Are you considering intelligence per token?

1 qwen output token != 1 opus output token.


Which is exactly why I compared sonnet 4.6 at the end there. They have similar intelligence scores.

Qwen3.8-Flash-Next is closer to Haiku than Sonnet in my experience.

Yes I know what the benchmarks say. It does not reflect my experience.

You’re also comparing benchmarks for the full model, but then telling people to run IQ3_S. I found the IQ3_S model to be a substantial step down from 4-6 bit quants.


Fair criticisms. If it's comparable with haiku, that's $13/day or 47 days til break-even (again, assuming I have my system generating tokens 24/7 - which I do not).

> You’re also comparing benchmarks for the full model

I wish there were more concrete ways to judge the difference. I've spent a bunch of time using 3 and 4 bit versions of qwen 27b, and my conclusion was that the lower qaunt made more mistakes - but that both systems were able to recover from those mistakes in a coding context. I'm not sure if that holds across the board, but that's the best answer I have so far.

It's also unclear if anthropic always serves you f16 versions of their models. My friends who use claude a lot complain about intelligence that varies from day to day - but that's entirely anecdotal.


> If it's comparable with haiku, that's $13/day or 47 days til break-even

With a $20/month subscription you can basically run Haiku nonstop and never have to worry about limits.

Your comparisons continue to make little sense.

> It's also unclear if anthropic always serves you f16 versions of their models. My friends who use claude a lot complain about intelligence that varies from day to day - but that's entirely anecdotal.

This myth has been debunked over and over. There are numerous sites that run benchmarks against the providers repeatedly and the results are always within the same margin of error.


Compare it to deepseek flash or glm. Those are far more capable and far cheaper. Or compare it to a hosted version of the same model. The math becomes much harder to justify when you compare apples to apples.

If all you do is generate tokens all day, sure, host your own infra. For people that aren’t maxing out hardware, using someone else’s is a pretty economical option. $20 with deepseek flash gets you a LOT of agentic use, and as the frontier moves forward with new models, so do I.


GLM5.3 costs $1.40/M on openrouter. 5.2M tokens per day is $7.28/day, which makes break-even take 83 days.

But let's compare apples to almost-apples! Qwen3.8 flash next is $0.47/M on openrouter, so $2.44 per day, so 246 days to break even. I say almost-apples because on this $600 system we're running an IQ3_S quantization. The hosted model is running... nobody knows what quant. It probably varies bases on the time of day.


It really depends on caching and your use case.

My deepseek bill for the last 30 days was $2.91 for 354 million tokens for agentic coding. My heaviest usage month was $14.97 for a billion tokens at deepseek. If you are doing turn based agentic coding, 90ish percent of tokens or more are cache hits.

I have another use case for deepseek that does not hit caching at all, and I pay $2 for 12 million tokens every month. I could get that down by choosing slower providers, but speed matters for this use case and saving $.50 doesn’t.

Both those use cases are bursty. I can’t sit and wait for a server to chew through my requests, especially with my non-cache use case. Anything less than 200t/s output and I start looking for a different host.

As far as quants, direct from deepseek is full quant. Good providers tell you the quant. Even the budget ones typically won’t go as low as iq3, though. FP4 seems to be the lower limit of providers that I see.

I would love nothing more than for local models to be up to snuff, but for my purposes, they get blown out of the water on all fronts by api access. Your machine has a payoff measured in multiple years (assuming you can build it for that price: $300 worth of ram is not much unless you go for ddr3, and a $500 gpu is pretty minimal) and would be a really poor fit for what I’m doing. It seems to be a great fit for you, and that’s pretty awesome.


imho those prices are artificially deflated to serve as a loss leader. Either subscription cost goes up or some other model such as advertising fills the gap.

I don't really understand the argument being made here. The best models are better, but they're not that much better. If I'm paying only 20% as much for 20% less performance, I can make up the 20% and have abundant cash or compute left over to spare.

The other thing that matters to me is the tooling. I could use Deepseek Harness with Claude but I'd rather support the same people that brought me DSH.


> imho those prices are artificially deflated to serve as a loss leader.

As a consumer I don’t care. The price I pay is how much it costs.

I’ve been hearing arguments that they could increase the price at any time. For years.

Instead the opposite has happened: A $20/month subscription has become more capable than it was 6 months or a year ago, by a huge margin. I can get so much done within a day of the $20/month subscription that it’s hard to believe it’s so cheap.


I mean no one should expect them to increase the price in the growth phase where money doesn't matter. Post-IPO when growth has a declining rate, they will (hopefully) have some lock in and blast prices as much as the market will bear.

Hardware will get faster. Models will get better.

By the time they reach this point of raising prices, if they ever do, the cost of models with current intelligence levels is going to fall a lot.

So all of these arguments about buying hardware now and switching to open models now to prepare for future price increases are still wrong if they’re argued on the basis of being locked out of cloud intelligence costs.

The cost for a given unit of intelligence is only going to decrease.


That's wishful thinking IMO. Hardware hasn't been improving at a rapid rate and clearly these companies are losing money and burning investor cash at a ridiculous rate. The party has to stop eventually. The price will go up. I expect everyone will have to pay API rates eventually, possibly even higher API rates than the current ones.

> Hardware hasn't been improving at a rapid rate

Yes it has. GPUs and consumer hardware today is much faster than it was 5 years ago and it will be much faster again in 5 years.

> and clearly these companies are losing money and burning investor cash at a ridiculous rate

As every startup should.

The inference is not losing money. I don’t know if you missed it, but it was revealed a while ago that they’re actually making decent money on inference.


So they will stop training new models? Also to refinance their gigantic debt (non-cancelable commitments) they will NEED to make more profit.

Hardware isn't the moat. Or at least it's not the idea. The moat is software, the targeted end goal isn't just better iterations of the current format of models. It took something like 9 years to create "AI" to the point of where it exists today. Then it took another 12 years to get it to an affordability inflection point where it was possibly logical to mass market them with ChatGPT.

Right now, the labs are trying to speed run that into the next level of advancement. Not just bigger better models of the current iterations, but some sort of proprietary software that is on the level of NLP or transformer architecture.


This makes no sense. DS4.1 flash is the cheapest model basically everywhere

From those retailers with billions of debt?

Seems more like a final fight against open weight models than a sustainable business model.


Anthropic has so much cash that they earn a billion dollars a year in interest alone.

Seeing comments about the major AI labs breathing their dying breathes because they have so much debt is really fascinating. The ideologies have started to exist in their own little bubble divorced from reality.


debt has to be paid by their customers at some point. Do you really think on top of the raised hardware costs they have a big enough budget to pay? Or would they switch to open weight as long it is good enough. I'm not sure which side here is the ideology. Where is the profit spike from all these AI customers?

What are you talking about? Anthropic doesn’t have debt. They have so much cash that they earn a billion dollars a year in interest.

Customers don’t have to pay off a company’s debt.

It feels like some of these anti-AI rants don’t even care about the facts. They have a story they believe and they’re going to be angry about it no matter what the facts are.


Well, it's not called debt, it's just a non-cancellable commitment. It needs to be refinanced anyway.

Cool story bro

Speaking of Warren, worth mentioning this site⁽¹⁾ by an ex-missileer at F.E. Warren.

https://missileer.watch/


Have you looked at Karabiner Elements⁽¹⁾? It’s extremely capable; see a config like this⁽²⁾ for inspiration.

⁽¹⁾ https://karabiner-elements.pqrs.org/

⁽²⁾ https://github.com/pdelfino/karabiner-config


Yes I'm using it because I don't use a standard Apple keyboard with my Mac.

The issue is mostly the user interface design is mouse first, not keyboard first. Windows was more than a little better on that front.


With Hammerspoon⁽³⁾ and the Accessibility API, I’ve found there’s not really much I can’t do.

For example, I use the Claude desktop app, but when I copy something from it, the Clipboard gets multiple content types, including RTF and Markdown, but I usually want the latter. So I wrote a quick snippet in Hammerspoon so that when Claude.app is the active app and the Clipboard changes, strip all the parts from the Clipboard except the “UTF8” part so I get just the Markdown (unless the Shift key is held down, which leaves it as-is). No more “formatted text” when I want to paste the Markdown.

My biggest problem now is that when I help somebody else on their Mac, I’m so used to “my controls” that I have to stop and think how to do things the normal way.

⁽³⁾ https://www.hammerspoon.org/


This would be much more interesting if it just exposed an API and didn't force Lua on you.

I have it, regularly updated, from my efforts 10-15Y ago to try to get a Compose key working on OS X.

I failed.

I just haven't bothered to remove and clean up again.


Gyms need reminders these days:

Don't Vibe Code in Between Sets

Keep your rest time for recovery, not React components.

Please refrain from writing code, checking commits, or prompting Al during your workout.

Be present. Lift harder. Ship later.

https://x.com/iansbrash/status/2112219912475156650/photo/1


I've been using https://davidhoo.github.io/MarkdownReader/en/ lately and like it a lot, especially the Quick Look previews and the "mdr" tool to open files or directories.

It even lets you switch to "Source Mode" for quick edits.


The U.S. Census Bureau runs a Business Trends and Outlook Survey⁽¹⁾ (aka BTOS) every two weeks. It goes out to 200,000 U.S. businesses (out of 1.2 million total). One of the questions asks about AI (now SI) usage, and it's a steady climb.

⁽¹⁾ https://www.census.gov/hfp/btos/data


Thank you for jumping in to the fray and providing additional context, data and updates!


You should look at Pragmata Pro⁽¹⁾.

Hand-hinted by Fabrizio: ”More than 9000 characters optimized from 9pt to 48pt to guarantee the best possible readability.”

It is the ultimate “programmer’s font” and well worth the money for something you stare at every day and the next best thing to a bitmap font in today’s “Retina resolution” world.

Accept no imitations.

⁽¹⁾ https://fsd.it/shop/fonts/pragmatapro/


1000%. Paid upfront years ago, installed it everywhere I look at code, and the world’s a better place.

You can preview working with it with Blink.app for iOS; I’m unaffiliated but satisfied. Comes with PragmataPro preinstalled.


+1 for another happy customer. I still wish there was a wider version with all the same bells and whistles, though!


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: