HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | eclipticplane's commentslogin

I started drawing my font and, pretty quickly, thought it was trash.

Then I recalled my handwriting itself is trash.

Now I can write my illegible Christmas cards without cramping my hand!


Too late, why would anyone want to go back?

#1 company I am will celebrate once they are replaced in our stack.

"Hey, I talked to one of your engineers" tactics is scummy.


s/Never trust a man with two first names/Never trust a man with two last names/.


Wait, why is VideoLan hit by this? Do they stream content themselves?


https://pastebin.com/zHkErGHP google translated version of article explains that the tax is not on any specific type of data but on any data delivered to french citizens/corps.

I don't have VideoLan's internal metrics, but if they're saying it'll cost them millions they're saying they deliver over ~18tb (or ~36tb for a tax of 2million) to french peeps per year


Because it's the actual generator of the bits that is supposed to pay. Which means you let a French person download anything at all, you're supposed to pay. If someone downloads your software from a mirror, the mirror can "identify you", and you'll be charged. No matter where you are.

This is supposed to let the French tax authorities collect 20B in additional tax revenue.

And yes, I don't see how Youtube (or Facebook, or Tiktok, or Netflix, or even something like Steam ...) can operate with such a tax in France.


>If someone downloads your software from a mirror

Who pays the tax in 'anonymous' p2p schemes?

If I upload to a french server from a ukranian server that I seed through a swiss based VPN using a norwegian seedbox that I paid a friend for in cash, how does the french government bill me? Do they subpoena the ukranian server to see where the data come from? Does the swiss government, not seeing any legal issue with my data, comply and hand over my norwegian server? Does the norwegian seedbox provider or my friend at the company foot the bill because they've no record of me?

What about networking stacks in which the requester can't necessarily identify where the data genuinely originated? Suppose I torrent a genuine Linux ISO in france. Do all of the peers get fractional bills? Or is it on the distro maintainer? What if the data didn't really originate from any of the peers but was fetched for me by the peers and the peers don't tell me (or therefore the ISPs) where they got the data from?

What if I put, say, VLC in an encrpyted zip. The ISP and therefore the french gov would see this as data coming from me since it doesn't hash as VLC, but they also can't prove that it came from me if I demonstrate that it was actually downloaded from a forum.

What about anonymous data? If 4chan is mirroring images for me that I uploaded from a McDonalds and a french frog downloads it, how do I get a bill? Does 4chan eat the bill or forward it to the McDonalds? Does the McDonalds eat the bill or hire a tech to cross-reference cameras and IP logs? What if I paid for the food in cash? Do they check some mythical "who owns this laptop" database provided by google/meta/microsoft? What if my laptop isn't in those databases? The local McDonalds is forced to foot the bill as they can't provide a patsie?

If I send a friend a video on via facebook messenger, who foots the bill? Facebook didn't send the data, I did. Is facebook going to rewrite it's eula to allow them to bill me for "woops your friend was in france at the time"?

This may all seem like hand-waving what-aboutism, but there are legitimate questions at hand. If public data is expensive and there are routes that do not result in billing, why would anyone choose the expensive route for any reason other than ignorance of the free route? If those who know would choose the free route, how is france going to collect all, most, or any of their booty?


Most of what you say is called tax evasion. The rest of your questions are far too complicated legally to answer, but many governments cooperate to prevent it. I might also mention it's criminal (meaning you get locked up if you get caught, you don't just have to pay). So I'd say you run a pretty big risk.

But in general, I must say that's something I really wonder about. Because what Anthropic and OpenAI (and Google, Facebook, Microsoft, ...) did was also very large scale violation of copyright law, with technically even also includes tax evasion (they didn't pay authors, and had they paid them, they would have had to registers VAT on that amount). And they did it before that became legal, so they took a risk that could have resulted in very very large criminal sentences. And now we're of course seeing that the justice system isn't fair and won't destroy billionnaires just because they commit large scale violation of the law. But I do wonder: how do you decide to do this. Copyright violations have gotten sentences of up to 2 months plus 50,000 in damages PER INFRACTION. Sam Altman, Dario Amodei, Mark Zuckerberg, Larry Page, Bill Gates all had their companies commit literally hundreds of millions of infractions against these laws to get their models started, knowing full well it was illegal ... AFTERWARDS congress has declared it's kind-of allowed (yes, really via a specific organization so that congress can claim they didn't do anything, but it was congress power being used to do it) ... but ... 50000 times hundreds of millions ... if congress had acted differently the punishments would have destroyed any billionnaire's fortune. How do you take such a risk? I don't understand.

Clearly: billionnaires get protected and small authors (frankly even quite big ones) got universally fucked. That's the net effect and 100% intentional. What I can't understand is WHY. If this had been put up to a democratic vote, it seems to me guaranteed billionnaires would have been convicted.

Btw: BOTH US AND EU have declared it legal, which I also wonder how that happens. But please don't start with "that's how the US works", or "of course Trump". I mean I see that too, but every important country leader could have stopped that change, including pretty far leftist figures like Pedro Sanchez could have stopped the EU from accepting this. They didn't.


The tax seems to be general, not limited to video/audio. Like downloads of the VLC client.


Man, still does not fix the one bug I care about: being able to quickly `⌘+F, ⌘+V` - the find textbox does not respect keyboard shortcuts: https://github.com/ghostty-org/ghostty/discussions/11159


I have a fix in my fork: https://github.com/ghostty-org/ghostty/commit/95c7fc322802a6...

Inspect + build yourself


And this disregard for non-tmux usability is why I stopped using Ghostty. First it took up until 1.3 to get search, then fixing this significant quality-of-life problem is clearly not a priority.


I was really hoping a fix for this would be included in this release.


Thanks for sharing. I thought I was the only one with this problem. It’s very irritating and has made me question why I left iTerm.


Hah, I literally just looked at filing a bug for this and then found myself unwilling to jump through the hoops. At least I'm not alone.


"aviate, navigate, then communicate" only matters if you are the one in control of outcomes.

Customers could have simply revoked keys and not re-launched services with rolled credentials (that from your post, may have been re-stolen), but instead you let this fester.

What a disaster for Railway. I hope you get through this stressful moment, but this should be the end of Railway.


Which secrets were they using?


So far I found they accessed my S3 buckets, used my OpenAI key (which OpenAI thankfully detected odd behaviour and revoked the key automatically), did readonly operations on my Valkey instance, etc.


What were they trying to do with OpenAI tokens? What actual requests were they making?

Was it just to create damage? i.e. create unnecessary spend to cause trouble? Or were they trying to use the LLMs for a specific reason?


The secret ones


Link?


I tried to re-find it but could not.


We can thank Google for that.


Copyright law; you can't copyright a recipe.

The "life story" is a means to it easier to issue takedown notices, and report rehosters for copyright infringement.

Google isn't involved.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: