HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | eatitraw's commentslogin

Author of the article here! Yes, of course, I've tried this sober — merely shifting attention does not work.

Thanks for the report. Some people do report being able to cancel it while sober. For most of them, defocusing their vision is required, which is not particularly surprising - you are removing the surrounding context.

Could you please tell me more about downshifting the visual cortex? I am planning to publish an update on this illusion, with various sober attention techniques to establish a baseline for future research.


I don’t find the illusion to be very effective in a sober state, so I’m not really sure what to think of the idea that 5-MeO “cancels” it. The one on the right barely seems bigger if at all, and I feel like I can context switch it similar to the Necker cube you mentioned. I guess I’m not impressed :)

At least I learned 5-MeO isn’t a song visual experience, I thought it was for some reason. On N, N-DMT you wouldn’t be able to look at anything.


> The second sentence is a link to a Substack essay

The author of the second essay here! It's a pro-nicotine one — the OP just linked to the very end of it. Moreover Gwern himself reviewed my essay during Inkhaven (https://www.inkhaven.blog/), a 30-posts-in-30-days program.

I asked Gwern explicitly if he ever feels responsible for getting some people addicted to nicotine. His answer was something along of the lines of: “No, I explicitly warned people that (1) vaping/smoking is addictive and (2) if you ever was addicted to nicotine, even sublingual nicotine is enough to get people addicted”.

I do think it's important to warn people that they should be careful with the substance and watch their usage, so I included the screenshots in my essay!


That's a complete cop-out then.

He should have reasonably foreseen that that would be the exact effect.

Most normal people reading his piece would come away with the opposite conclusion.

The title alone: "On the benefits and lack of demerits of nicotine (research up to 2015)"

Is enough to make people go 'oh, that's ok then' without investing in trying to understand the subtlety of the argument made. You can add 500 references and spend 30K words but you've already lost by the first line of the article.

It would have taken 10 seconds to put a bit right at the top that says 'do not see this article as an excuse to go smoke or vape' or maybe even something harsher than that. With great power etc ...


Most countries have laws that tax all tobacco sales and direct those proceeds into public education campaigns that warn of the dangers of nicotine. These are multi-million-dollar PR campaigns; I like gwern’s essays but they don’t stand a chance against that level of background radiation. A normal person essentially cannot be convinced that nicotine is safe.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: