HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | e3dd's commentslogin

"Most companies seem to still be in denial about it, and hope that if they add some more AI into their product, or do it just right, it will make sense. But it won't. AI is destined to sit on the outside, and products to be reduced into a bag of tools for AI to call."

Missing a lot of nuance.

It can both be true that a newcomer figures out an experience in which the tooling sits behind the scenes and has figured out various competitive advantages that may even result in monopoly.

Your posts carry an arrogant tint - check yourself.


Amazon retail's economics are actually pretty fragile. Amazon would argue their retail business is being cross-subsidised by AWS lol. They may have intentionally designed it to be that way.


Correct but more so the lack of access to great teachers.

LLMs are not the solution to providing the best teacher at scale that people think it is.


" It's organizing and packaging it in the right format that's always been the key issue."

LLms dont help here either.

Part of learning is about struggle. Seems many here want to disregard that fact and just run to the LLM lmao. Yeah you can do that - the knowledge won't really stick.


But it becomes different knowledge. You learn how to manage an LLM to create the thing you need instead of writing code to do the thing you need. Still a learned skill. In some cases, still a struggle.

The initial creativity is still with us, not the LLM. It's the Art/Craft thing - we have the Art, the machine does more of the Craft (and it always did do a fair amount of the Craft).

I'm seeing folks who couldn't (for whatever reason) work out how to code, starting to produce some amazing stuff with the LLM doing the coding now. It's their creativity, their project, their vision, still. The fact that they didn't write the code is meaningless.


That is teaching familiarity with AI tools, having given up on the thing the student was supposed to learn.

From what I’ve seen, the ability to prompt quality output with AI is entirely proportional to experience and skill level.


I think the goal of (this type of) education is to enable the student to do something, rather than attain some idealised state of knowledge.

> From what I’ve seen, the ability to prompt quality output with AI is entirely proportional to experience and skill level

In my direct experience, it's not my coding skills that I'm using for this. I don't even look at the code any more. It's my experience of developing stuff and managing projects that is enabling me to run the LLM better than a newbie [0]. Teaching someone to code so that they can run an LLM is probably not the most efficient way of doing this.

[0] though I have friends who can't code and are producing better stuff than I am, by just prompting and making mistakes.


Sorry, I think you misunderstood, I'm saying the same thing, LLMs don't package information in the right format, but good mentors do.


Yes. And I want to hire people who can tell when the LLM is right and wrong.


Erm this is reality period forget about the govt.

Do you do things without expecting something of benefit in return e.g. work?

Humans are conditioned to be like this. Govt indeed cares what you can do to extend its power and reach.

Not rocket science.

Thats why Ive never understood people who resist - you will be far better off in assisting and getting ahead of it to try and shape it. Then you MAY have a chance. Resisting it? Youre just delaying the inevitable I'm afraid. Funniest part is a lot of these resistors assist people like Zuck. Absolutely hilarious.

If people truly had a backbone the labour class wouldn't so easily get rag-dolled but they do. Putting your freedom and well-being on the line takes a lot - you need to lose everything to do that.


Don’t forget the part where massive swaths of people who won’t risk anything at all, sneer at those that lost it all, because they aren’t perfectly aligned on some pet topic.


I agree. Yes.

Btw I've already accepted my role as an assister. Haters come at me. See you on the other side!

I've long accepted that people by-on-large cannot be helped, western society has knowledge and understanding in abundance and yet... they lack self-control and self-respect. They need someone to instill it in them.

Peter Thiel's recent remarks on being evil is better than being bad captures this reality of life quite well.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: