HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | dreadsword's commentslogin

I'm going to guess the 2nd affair with a direct report who rose quickly through the ranks is from the board's perspective the more egregious of the two failings.

And: the public only knows what's made it out. Who knows what else has come out in private.


I think that's a nothing-burger but it's enough to force him out. They probably have more cards in the play. Unfortunately we will never know of them.

Having sex with a report is a very serious no no. There are very valid questions of one's ability to consent when your boss is also your partner.

Oh come on, having sex with a coworker is rape now? This is getting ridiculous. Why not just go the whole way and require all sexual activity to come with with a signed and notarized consent form?

No? Having sex with a coworker is not rape, and no one said nor insinuated it was.

Go forth and consensually bang your coworkers. Knock yourselves out.

When you have the ability to fire or promote someone, however, you hold significant power over their life -- potentially impacting their ability to eat, house themselves, etc. In those cases, it's valid to ask, "Is there a possibility someone is being coerced into sex because they can't afford to say no?"

This is question of consent. It's not an allegation of rape. It's only a question and there are probably times the answer is no.

You don't have to knee jerk react to someone pointing out an obvious potential conflict of interest and go "so everything is rape now?"


Quid pro quo sexual harassment is not a “nothing-burger”.

No sexual harrasment has been suggested, except by you, from your imagination

Ok, well there’s already a third mistress reported so why don’t we both sit back and see how my position ages :)

Are you genuinely confused over the difference between "mistress" and "sexual harassment"?

No, I don’t think I am. You can disagree with me without me being confused.

There was no sexual harassment reported. Having multiple partners is not a sexual harassment.

"Disagree" on what? There could be sexual harassment related to a mistress, but no-one has alleged that, except you. You simply made up an allegation that didn't exist.

Someone skipped all their HR trainings

Who? Me or that other guy? If you want to insult someone, at least make it clear who you're trying to insult.

Sleeping with a direct report is de jure sexual harassment and a violation of hostile workplace environment laws, especially when not disclosed. If you feel insulted because someone called out your ignorance that’s on you. This is common knowledge in corporate America

This is not true. Go ahead, show which specific law defines all relationships with direct reports as being sexual harassment.

You don't think the board of a listed company care about the CEOs bit on the side is being promoted? That's really not a good look for a company to admit that.

It's one thing to happen and another to put that out in the open.

Officials are corrupted? CEOs sleeping with other women including his subordinates? Snow is white? What's the deal? People at that level are basically playing politics, not laws.

However, the fact that someone decided to release all those information as PUBLIC, and followed that up with ANOTHER scandal, means that they are determined to get rid of them. As you said, it is indeed serious matter.

As the Chineses say: "Something weights as light as a quarter of pound if it's left alone, but can weight a thousand tons if put on the scale".


> CEOs sleeping with other women including his subordinates? Snow is white? What's the deal?

The problem is that you don't think it is a problem. It goes on because there are no consequences.

Maybe in '29 the Epstein perps will actually be prosecuted


Because reality deems that this is not really the problem, I was about to mention the Epstein thing -- everything in that file is 100x worse than what Jensen did.

If we (the common people) really want consequences, we will need to do a LOT more and put things in our own hands instead of relying on our representatives -- oh but that's too populist for HN's taste.


> we will need to do a LOT more and put things in our own hands instead of relying on our representatives -- oh but that's too populist for HN's taste.

I'm with you on the first half, and see the second half changing. The fever may have broken in the US electorate.


That was my thought --- an odd and offputting choice of identity

I always thought this about Soylent but it never seemed to stop anybody.

When they show you what they are, believe them.

This had far less macross saga than I'd hoped!


Why do people conflate AGI & machine consciousness / self-awareness?


Why is anyone still talking about AGI? Every thread starts with asking whether we have AGI, and then backtracks into trying to define what AGI is, and splits off in a dozen different directions.


How can something have general intelligence if its incapable of understanding reality sufficiently to distinguish itself from not itself?


Arguably LLMs are showing that self awareness or self reference is a property that comes "for free" or as a corollary of more generic requirements. It used to be that self/consciousness would be a very mysterious and difficult thing to achieve but the point is that in practice they didn't even have to try, it just came as a byproduct of learning from the input data (corpus of human examples), and also the ability to talk about arbitrary things and thus itself.


They very clearly are not self aware. I regularly see them responding to their own statements as you/your (i.e. not having been generated by themselves). They do generally generate language in a manner consistent with the self awareness that we have and encode in our language, but that's the limit of it. Its the appearance of self awareness not actual self awareness.


Since LLMs have rudimentary internal models for concepts it is implausible that they cannot also have one for some simple sense of self. But a lot of people prefer the reductive explanation that the machine has never actually decoded anything at all from the language corpus.


Its really easy to test if an LLM is actually self aware when you have your own harness. Simply take a conversation with one LLM and continue that conversation with a different LLM and then ask the new LLM about what it wrote you earlier. Mostly the result will be that it will tell you about what the other LLM wrote as if it was what it wrote and it will not deny that it didn't write any of it. I say mostly as these they're nondeterministic and do go off the rails from time to time. The only things LLMs are aware of is what's in their context and the middleware + harness completely controls what is the context before generation begins.

There is a huge difference between being self aware and being able to effectively generate language relating to self awareness.


This is not a sufficient test, it basically reduces to the logicist's plea against LLMs.


That statement lacks substance.


My statement is concise and says in one sentence what is wrong with the two paragraphs you wrote. Less being more.


That statement is wrong. Twice.


In which case the computer can save a lot of bother and use printf("I'm self-aware"); Job done.


I assume science fiction is to blame. All the AI were either written as machines of pure logic that exploded when exposed to the liar's paradox, or conscious like Star Trek's Data.

(Though at least with Data the script writers had other characters openly dismiss the possibility he was sentient; the technobabble may have been nonsense, but treat it as a space opera and look at how they portray the human condition through each character and it gets much less absurd).


I've tried it - I've been playing around with a vibe coded application that crawls municipal websites, indexes and embeds, and then does rag retrieval. It came from the need to dig up specific information that's scattered across PDFs, multiple web pages, etc. - exactly as you described. AI does a decent job (w/ RAG) of synthesizing.

https://opencity.services/chat/winnipeg

how do i report a noise complaint?

It depends on the type of noise:

- Loud party or people-related noise: call the Winnipeg Police Service non-emergency line at 204-986-6222.

- Animals making unreasonably loud, unnecessary or excessive noises: report it through 3-1-1.

- Mechanical equipment noise like furnaces or air conditioners, or noise from construction tools used by a company or resident: contact Community By-law Enforcement Services at 3-1-1.

- Planned event noise: you may need a Noise Permit at no cost, but it is not for construction work and should be submitted at least four weeks before the event.

The City also says noise-generating activities within 150 metres of a residential property are generally prohibited before 7 a.m. and after 9 p.m. on weekdays, and before 9 a.m. and after 9 p.m. on Saturdays, Sundays and statutory holidays.

------

YMMV. A big part of the backend is categorizing hits and misses, with an eye to helping municipalities clean up conflicting information, fill obvious gaps, etc.


This works fine when you're sicking enforcement on someone and don't really care, the bigger the blast radius the better, you just want to know who to call.

Where it falls apart is "how do I" type questions because usually the legally factual answer is some huge complex state diagram where three local and four state agencies theoretically have discretionary jurisdiction over a your petty af project or business but the in practice answer is that some agency rubber stamps them all with minimal fuss. You can't make the legally factual answer clear because the degree to which people support the status quo is largely predicated on ignorance, but you also can't come out and say in writing that you have a policy of rubber stamping boring stuff.

Basically the same reasons that all but the most minor and narrowly targeted attempts at permitting reform fail.

The thought is nice but in reality you're basically asking the government to give up power and it takes obscene amounts of political capital to force that to happen in most cases.


I forgot about this problem, this is so true, but I will say that maybe surfacing these contradictions is the first step in fixing them.

Especially at the local level, we have a huge problem with opaque bureaucracy whose only function is to privilege incumbents (such as developers with connections) and make life difficult for anyone doing something unusual (even if it technically complies with all legal requirements).

This is where people usually point out POSIWID[0], but ideally government agencies should stick to what it says on the law/regulation, not have some hidden purpose that was never put to a vote.

[0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_purpose_of_a_system_is_wha...


Honestly if your city has a 311 style thing, I'm not sure there's a ton of need for an LLM. Eight or nine years ago my grandmother visited me in New York and accidentally left her pocket book in the cab. Since I had paid for it with my credit card, I was able to see the medallion number in the transaction, so I called 311 and said that I wanted to get in touch with a specific taxi. It prompted me for the medallion number, which I told it, and then it transferred me to a call with the dispatch service, who then transferred me to the specific garage, and they called the driver and told him to call me, so we were able to meet up again and get the pocketbook back (turned out he returned to where he had dropped us off to try to find us, but since we only had a short stop there, we took another cab back to her hotel after, so we were gone).


I'm trying to do something similar but more general, pulling in city pdfs but also meeting transcripts, budget data, municipal codes and permit data, and providing all this through an mcp. I've used it a number of times for personal interactions with my local government, it's been very helpful.

I'd be interested in connecting and sharing ideas/feedback/learnings if you are.

https://civicmined.org


hey, really like your idea and have been brainstorming the same kind of tool! not as far along as you or the OP but I would love to hear about what your roadmap/plan is for a tool like this. all about helping the ppl. should i try the email on your site?


Does running a proprietary system rule out competition and restrict you to recreation? I have no idea what the FIFA-equivalents is for bowling, but I imagine there is one, and I imagine that it has a list of rules for lanes to qualify as competition venues, including scoring systems from approved vendors, etc.

Not sure if any of that's relevant to you!


Yep, USBC. You're exactly right, they do have pretty precise requirements for sanctioned league play. But casual 'open' bowlers don't care about that stuff for the most part. So if we're not running a league, we can flip back and forth and run the two systems in parallel (less maintenance on my very-expensive-sanctioned gear at the very least)


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: