HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | dmm's commentslogin

What do you mean by this? This article seems to be mostly about govt surveillance and not gun rights.


A stated core purpose of the second amendment is for ordinary people to be able to keep a government in check by force or threat of force.

Some people view the actions of ICE, like in this article, to be crossing a line that would normally provoke a response from second amendment types.


The people who would normally argue "but muh 2A!" are either applying to be on ICE, are on ICE, or just support what they're doing, completely oblivious to the obvious.


Certainly some


Those people are the people who want gun control and therefore don’t have any guns.


The #1 reason sighted by 2nd amendment loyalists for needing such liberal gun rights is to protect us all from government overreach. I assume that's what he means.


Common misunderstanding. The reason is to protect themselves from government overreach (and other threats), not you or anyone else. You were supposed to get your own gun to protect yourself, that's why the right needs to extend to everyone.

(disclaimer: this is not my opinion I'm just explaining their logic)


Agreed. I'm pro-second amendment, what is the there to comment on here about guns? seriously asking.


A major portion of vocal 2A advocates cite the need to own guns in order to protect against government overreach. The argument being made is that the government is now overreaching but the 2A advocates aren't actually using their guns to protect against it.


I mean, a major portion of vocal 2A advocates voted for the government overreach, or else don't actually care either way as long as the government doesn't touch their guns.

But they'll still lecture you should you ever dare question the utility and necessity of it. They'll still claim their guns are the only thing holding America back from tyranny even as ICE and the police pick them off like ducks.


Hmm what was the reason for the second amendment?

It wasn’t self defense, it wasn’t for recreational fun, it is to provide a physical check on government overreach. Therefore it’s sensible to discuss it during times of government overreach.


But I don't bring up the second amendment when complaining about income taxes either. Again, what part of what ICE is doing infringes on the second ammendment?


The point isn't to preserve roads, but to expose the true cost of damage to the industry causing it. It can be phased in over time. Trucking will become more expensive and businesses will respond by optimizing transportation and raising prices. This will be offset by much lower taxes because trucks cause the vast majority of road damage from vehicles.


Yes, this is the perfect time to do so, after all, what could possibly go wrong?

Really, there is a contingent on HN that seems utterly divorced from reality. The trucking industry as a whole profits ~30B annually in the United States. That is an absolutely insane number of miles hauled. Many of these operations are barely hanging on and whether or not 16 trucking companies going bankrupt in a month due to fuel prices is normal or not I couldn't tell you but on the off chance that it is this might not be the time to experiment with what other things you could do to that industry.

For contrast: Amazon profits number in the hundreds of billions (300B+ iirc) and that is just one company vs a whole industry.

Effectively that means that they are making pennies of profit per mile driven and that any kind of destabilization of that industry will instantly translate into either shortages or further price increases.


So you agree this externality should be internalized? What time in the past would have been better to implement this?

Maybe you're right and putting this off is the right decision. If we get automated trucking and those thousands of trucking companies are replaced with a handful of tech companies it might be easier to implement reforms.


Such a tax would be highly regressive I think.

When a government collects taxes they have to think how to invest that money to maximize gdp growth. Subsidizing road infrastructure is a pretty good use of those funds IMO, though admittedly I’m probably biased as a transportation engineer.

CA uses fuel taxes to fund road infrastructure, which isn’t the worst approach… the heaviest users (‘heavy’ both figuratively and literally) invariably pay the largest share, although EVs are messing up that equation.


> the heaviest users (‘heavy’ both figuratively and literally) invariably pay the largest share

But the point is that the heaviest users(semitrucks) cause almost all of the damage (literally >99%) but don't pay for most of the maintenance. This represents a subsidy of trucking companies. They cause damage that they don't pay for. This is an example of the economic concept of an externality, which is bad and should be eliminated.


All of the retailers and businesses were able to do business when new tariffs where introduced, which was complex, messy and changing weekly. The costs were passed on to consumers. Retailers and businesses that use trucking have really nothing to do, they get a bill just like now. Trucking remains as it was.

Then, its upto them to figure out more efficient means of logistics. Companies that can figure this out will survive in the marketplace. Competition weeds out inefficient companies.

None of the things you say happened when tariffs changed. All companies were fine and made more profits. The economy didn't collapse. (Source: See stock market and profits of companies)


How is saying "this business is barely viable" an argument for subsidizing it?


That you need it to survive.


Airlines are barely viable. They are surviving.

"The quickest way to become a millionaire in the airline business is to start as a billionaire."

Why do you think trucking industry* in its current configuration is the most optimal configuration that can ever exist and it needs to be frozen for posterity?

*It is never about the trucking industry, but the mega businesses that use trucking. They know how to do logistics, which is how to do multi-modal transportation (ship, train, trucks, last mile delivery). Amazon built new warehouses everywhere in US. When the pricing reflects reality, warehouses + multi-modal transportation will reconfigure.

Its just like saying Layer-1 of networking in 1970s (1Mbps Ethernet? Token ring?) is the perfect way to transport packets, we should freeze it in time and never think of anything better. Layer 1 in the real world is transportation.


Trucking is also one of the largest sources of employment in the country. It's quite literally the backbone not just because they haul so much, but because they are a massive source of income for families.


I'm not saying trucks are bad or that we should get rid of them or that truckers shouldn't be paid or anything like that. If we closed the externality of trucking causing more damage than they pay for then trucking and transportation would get better. The trucking companies would have more information to make decisions about what routes/equipment/etc are worthwhile.


> whataboutisms

Not a Trump supporter but from the ones I've spoken to it's mostly this. Something like, "They all do it, he's just honest about it."


They'll screech about Pelosi and give it zero additional thought.


Unlocking the pixels also requires an internet connection, to determine whether the device has any restrictions on it.

From the grapheneos installation instructions: """ On device model variants (SKUs) which support being sold as locked devices by carriers, enabling OEM unlocking requires internet access so that the stock OS can check if the device was sold as locked by a carrier. """

https://grapheneos.org/install/web#enabling-oem-unlocking


connection != account

You can do the Pixel unlocking whilst driving by the random McD.

I'm quite surprised it flies with the team.


>connection != account

That's not much of a distinction considering that it's trivial to create an email/account (without a phone number, even!) with fake information.


That's a massive difference to me (you rightly called me out on that one).

One is 5 seconds on wifi, second is grumbly attempts to create throwaway email to create the throwaway account.

I agree in principle but disagree because I hate unnecessary friction.


I switched to deSEC because they allow you to create tokens for DNS-01 validation which are tightly scoped to a single subdomain. This means I have a VM running "service1.foo.example.com" which is not publicly available but can still get certs from letsencrypt, but with a token that can't be used to issue certs for other domains.

It works great!


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: