HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | dmantis's commentslogin

I'm very happy when marketing means competing for quality and customer satisfaction instead of the borderline-criminal behavior like Meta's and many others.

Everyone was told initially that capitalism works exactly this way and many would love to live in that world. Unfortunately we live in a spyware world with trashy race-to-the-bottom products. So proper business practices are met with gratitude and I don't see anything wrong with that. They do earn money from that, so what?

Earning money by providing your customers with high-quality products is not a bad thing.


In their defense, I'd say that in the world where is more ideological companies where your motivation is to bring good and not earn numbers, we might have much had better conditions for everyone instead of the constant race to the bottom.

Maybe, just maybe, you shouldn't be a rat and actually follow your words no matter how profitable it is to break it and, you know, be sure to pledge your life for it. If you say you make it for public good, then do it and never lie. While I understand the discomfort, I don't understand why people are so protective about being thieves and liars. In theory such a pledge must never affect you if you behave like a proper human being.


I don't think the only way is the ID verification. That's what the spying side pushes as a narrative, but there are ways to validate each other without global registries and any government connections.

Web-Of-Trust was a good idea with poor implementation way ahead of its time. Closed communities work pretty well and seem to be almost unaffected.

So yes, the public internet is dead but I believe that it will be solved with some sort of reputational/vouch systems and invite-only groups where you have to contribute to be accepted and have an incentive to protect that seat instead of posting slop/spam/other agenda to be banned.


I think even pre-LLMs, the problem was more the size of a community rather than whether it was closed. The bigger it grows, the more it orients itself towards the lowest common denominator. Every community I ever cared about was rather small. Places like Hacker News, which I think is among the better large ones, I honestly don't think I'd care much if it disappeared tomorrow.

But now with AI unfortunately I agree. Not sure if there is a way around closing off communities. Even for communities that actively use AI within.


https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1%25_rule

99% of the people are in read-only anyway. The community can be closed for contributions, but open for reading. That might cut bots, ads, propaganda and espionage, but retain the sharing function for those who need without losing much.


The bigger the "community" is, the less it's actually a community. HN is not a community but a social media feed, e.g. like Instagram but with text instead of video. Lobste.rs might be a community, I don't know because I don't have an invite. Most physical hackerspaces (not makerspaces) remain communities even as they get thousands of members.

Who's creating the next Internet?

The moment you assume someone creates it, you have a problem. It has to arise organically out of the individual actions of all of us.

I think of the "fediverse" as an example of this. It's usually defined as the ecosystem around the ActivityPub protocol (i.e. Mastodon, Lemmy, etc) but I think it should be redefined more broadly to mean "the ecosystem of federated/decentralised publishing and interaction", which would include ActivityPub but also blogs, websites, email, RSS, ATproto. If we really have a fedi-verse, then it can't be controlled by one entity.


> the ecosystem of federated/decentralised publishing and interaction

That is what I meant, yes. People built the internet, and people will build the next internet, too. I was wondering who's already doing that.


It's lacking a search engine.

To be honest, I don't really get the question.

Do you assume there should be some single big guy who creates the social spaces?


Sorry, it was a loaded question. I was more asking who's working on the foundation for this next phase of the internet. Who's working on decentralized reputational/vouch systems? Who's working on zero-trust proof-of-authorship or proof-of-being? Who's working on privacy-focused proof-of-identity? etc.

"Who" is also plural in English.

But how is that an "internet"? The point of the free internet was to be free to communicate with whomever.

When you seclude yourself in bubbles, you might feel protected, but really you expose yourself to becoming irrelevant.

The crucial problem is, people confuse message with messenger.

When comments are objectively true and faithful (representing the topic correctly), it doesn't matter who wrote them.

The other way around, knowing somebody personally doesn't guarantee their messages to be true and "not spam". The important thing is to check content thoroughly for actual truth and point out deviations. Just like in an ideal scientific discussion. The remaining social part is a question of civil discourse and enforcing that.


> When comments are objectively true and faithful (representing the topic correctly), it doesn't matter who wrote them.

This disregards the humanity of understanding a thing. I vehemently disagree.


Objectively true statements don't depend on any human understanding them for being true. So it doesn't matter who acts as their messenger.

You conflate two disparate things there: you as the reader understand something as a human. Who wrote it plays no role for the true content. Expressions of human sentiment are another thing entirely.

When LLMs are used to astroturf and manipulate human community building, they rely on such sentiment to stir emotional reactions. Without a rational, objectively true, basis to stand on, that remains sterile if people value truth.

The problem we currently see comes from people foregoing that rooting in objective truth entirely. They act on pure sentiment and are prone to automatic manipulation by it.


You seem to be externalizing the cost of verifying that a thing is true. The cost is nontrivial.

Consider for a moment that all of science is, in some way or another, the search for truth. I have a hard time seeing that any one person—or even any one person with an amazing computer program—can substitute for generations of humans trying to achieve that goal. It is extremely difficult to know what is objectively true.


What a weird take on things: you are currently externalizing the non-trivial cost of verifying that a thing is true.

When you want to understand something as true, you are the one who has to verify it, implicitly. People currently are used to others (supposedly) doing that for them. That doesn't mean, it wasn't externalized.

Now, you're right about individuals being overtaxed without the collaborative effort of society. You have to have chains of trust to have any chance, or personalized AI (which again you would have to trust).

But I was talking about the process of filtering truth collectively. You start from what you believe to know now, team up with others sharing your opinions and go from there. Revising your preconceived convictions is part of proper science.


> Objectively true statements don't depend on any human understanding them for being true. So it doesn't matter who acts as their messenger.

All such statements are pretty worthless.


AGPL doesn't prohibit commercial usage. The vendor just need to provide the sources for the service.

Cyberpunk runs even on steamdeck, it doesn't need an extreme machine.

Have you seen the current prices on Steam Deck? Almost $800 for the base model.

And I assume they will only continue to go up. When it came out, purchasing one seemed like an easy decision. But I paid half as much for one with the same CPU/RAM (and upgraded my SSD for cheap).


I might be wrong, but I believe Slint has qt-style dual-licensing and provides AGPL version for GPL projects.

I assume you make an open source project giving the critics about proprietary nature, so it shouldn't be a problem.


Wouldn't Rust's Result or Go's error checking prevent that?

While not mandatory, a person would probably use it instead of the * hack.

Simply because the calling side wouldn't have an option to forget the check like with the NULL case


Rust and go still make it pretty easy to not check results if you don’t care about the success value (lots of code just does `let _ = foo()`), but if you do want the value (like with a hashing function), Rust makes it really hard to not check the error too. There’s no syntax to say “assume this worked and give me the success value, including whatever garbage is there if it’s not set”:

- result.unwrap() will panic if it failed

- result.ok() throws away the error but gives you a None value instead (still can’t use it as if it’s a success)

- matching on the Ok variant and doing nothing on the Err variant, you only get to use the success value inside the Ok arm

Etc etc.

The problem is when the compiler says “NULL is a valid instance of T”, which go lets you do, and rust doesn’t (without using the unsafe keyword and intentionally casting a null pointer, which you don’t do by accident.) Go lets you write code like `var hash string; hash, _ = hashfn()` and it compiles and now you have null instead of a valid hash.


> NULL is a valid instance of T

This by the way is Tony Hoare's famous "Billion Dollar Mistake"


Minor nit, strings are never nil in Go, so that would be "" instead. Usually nil is only a valid instance of pointer-to-T. The point stands though, a common pattern is "defer foo.Close()", the Close() signature almost always returns an error and almost no one checks it...which is probably fine, but not automatically fine.

A NULL pointer for error would be a safe interface where you get a trap when there is no value.

Average professional politician is a psychopath fighting for power no matter what.

At least these guys might be honest about their hubris and arrogance and won't smile to you while slaughtering your future or robbing your family.


> As an investor there is no way to protect yourself

Why? BTC is pretty stable longterm and nobody is going to touch your cold wallet. Anything that has an owner or legal entity is not decentralized, subject to either rug pull or censorship and shouldn't be touched, sounds very easy.

Everything that promises you any return is a scam in crypto, simple as that.


> great amazing decentralized censorship-free drop in replacement

It's not and never supposed to be and everybody who uses it in any significant amount knows that. Don't mistake a cryptotoken with a cryptocurrency.


I love monero but then you have the problem that very few exchanges support it and if you need to convert big amounts of it in common currency it gets quite hard to do compared to eth/btc


Well, nobody said that the true anarchy would be easy. No government actually wants to approve the original spirit of crypto, everything they allow is either a toy or a scam they can take advantage of.

Then people get into shitty casino tokens that are widely available because the state doesn't care about a little gambling and got surprised that they are in the casino in the first place.


This is absolutely what true anarchy looks like. Before you can blink, someone else has taken over, and now you have a new boss, only worse.


Not the case at all. True anarchy is community governance where a very local group of people start working together. Anarchist meetings are not restricted to, but include, looking like a bunch of people in a room, voicing their problems with this week's chief speaker as moderator, and then everyone in the room splitting off into working groups to address each problem. The chief speakers rotate around the group each week to avoid moderator bias, and each working group might reach out to other anarchist groups to exchange information and resources freely.

This is but one model developed within academia for an entirely anarchist organisation, there are dozens of others and they have been both studied for efficacy (they tend to work better than a more hierarchical structure), as well as put into practice in real life within certain organisations. To this date there are a number of non-profit organisations and coöperatives that use this governance system to improve the situation where they are locally and achieve their goals — whether that's "everyone working to improve the local community" or "make good products for a client".

The entire point of anarchism is that there isn't One Big Guy, it's that it's people, deciding on a system and working together on a small scale — this then translates to the big scale through cross-group meetings, information sharing, and resource sharing. There is a lot of evidence within the social sciences to back these methodologies up as being very efficacious compared to traditional methods of group organisation, as well as being more democratic than traditional alternatives.

This additionally tends to be how some kinds of open mic nights work, as well as some kinds of modern speakeasys.


> True anarchy is community governance

It’s a bit antithetical to anarchy to start defining true and untrue configurations. It’s more accurate to say that while anarchy permits chaos, it also permits self-organization, one mode of which is hierarchy-free community governance. Most of us have experienced this among friends when e.g. deciding where to go to dinner.


This is one of these circular relationships. You and your friends can experience true, free, cooperation exactly because you don't have to be on guard 24/7 against enemies, because you live in a civil society that has rules, and people to enforce those rules - ultimately by coercion through violence.

Peaceful anarchy evaporates when bad actors arrive. I wish it wasn't so. A structured civil society is the nearest we've managed to get to being able to live in relative freedom almost all of the time. It's the least violent, least coerced option we've been able to find.

The other way would be to go live in a group by yourselves off the grid, and as long as every one of you is good and decent that will be fine, but the moment one of you goes bad, you either have to choose violence or they will do whatever they want to you.


"A structured civil society is the nearest we've managed to get to being able to live in relative freedom almost all of the time. It's the least violent, least coerced option we've been able to find."

Can you source these claims?

Civil society only seems to be getting LESS free and MORE violent all of the time. And in America, I constantly have to protect myself against enemies be it scammers or the thug who tried to mug me for my wallet.


> enemies be it scammers or the thug who tried to mug me for my wallet

This is much less frequent than the violent-death rates of pre-civilization groups of humans.


The term anarchy is used in academia for all kinds of non-hierarchical civil societies. Academia being academia, they chose to stick with a dumb label. But the set I think OP is describing is more intuitively understood as non-hierarchical social systems.


>evaporates

Not going to school GP (presumably not one of the hill peoples[1] for which self-defense is mother nature)... ?

Actshually, Jura Federation dissolved

(Not too sure about bad actors in or around it)

[1]https://www.elliptic.co/insights/myanmar-earthquake-how-a-re...


It's also not prohibited to kill bad actors without trial.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: