HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | dleslie's commentslogin

It's not just SWE. All human intelligence is now of questionable value.

Keep in mind that LLMs are just the hot product of the here and now. They will enable us to now rapidly construct a variety of intelligence services.

If human intelligence doesn't hold value we won't train children for it so aggressively. And with lower demand for education will come a decline in all matters of society.

This is an existential threat to civilization.


> It's not just SWE. All human intelligence is now of questionable value.

It really isn’t. Not even remotely. Trusting the word of mega corporations that convert this rhetoric to cash is perilous at least on a personal level.


Every local contractor I know is using AI for mock-ups, advertisements, administration, answering calls, and so on.

Every health care provider I've seen in the last year uses AI for transcription and synopsis, at the minimum.

That's just the regular folk. AI is cutting deep into science and research. Schools are overwhelmed by its use by students.

And frankly, from what I've seen it does a much better job than _most_ humans at all of these tasks. It's only the exceptional humans that remain ahead. Let's not forget how regrettably disappointing human mediocrity really is.


Very common response which has nothing to do with human intelligence being of questionable value. It goes to demonstrate the success of LLMs as a product. It neither proves it nor disproves the original statement.

If LLMs are being used as a substitute for human labour then the success of LLMs in the market has has everything to do with the value of human labour. In every case I mentioned there has been human labour replaced by LLM effort.

And this is still the early days. LLMs could plateau in capability at this moment in time and still have a great deal of opportunity to penetrate markets currently reliant on human intelligence.


The topic is about value of human intelligence. Your definition could also classify calculators and you have yet to establish a causal connection between the current goal post and the original statement.

Calculators _did_ replace human labour. Computer was once a professional designation, after all.

The dangers in this line of thinking is, you won't want to live in a society where majority of the humans have no work. Try living in a country with above 10% unemployment rate.

What I want and what I think has very little impact on the path civilization is taking.

Besides, what I think is that AI putting us out of work is destined to be the least of our concerns; we are going to experience far worse thanks to our failure to curb carbon emissions and ecosystem destruction.


Can you please let the product team know that there's space between Pro and Ultra pricing?

I can't afford/allow for ultra pricing for personal projects, but Pro runs through in about two days of casual usage for me. I've paid for extra credits, but my god are those not worth the price.

I would love to pay for a sub that's between Pro and Ultra.


Second pro sub is the usual middle ground, same as with other providers. You can switch to second account using an alias (agy2='unshare ... exec agy' to remap $HOME/.gemini to e.g. .gemini2).

Although using another provider for the secon sub is probably a better idea since having a different model doing review would uncover more issues than asking the same model that generated the code..


I can't afford much more than another 10 to 20 bux a month; are there any other providers in that price range that are worth it?

Neither one has privacy (model training off) so it’s pretty much just a toy or for open source folks whose codebases get stolen by Google either way

is this actually true? there's no way to turn it off?

why would anyone use Google then? gotta pay for your IP to get stolen? lol


If errors like this are acceptable because of the version number of an otherwise decade old project, then that's ample evidence of why Zig is not ready and should not be used for any software that needs surety.

You know that GNU libc to this day essentially calls strlen() on every call to sscanf(), which is pretty much the same issue? And that this behaviour, present in many other implementations of standard C library (including Microsoft's), was responsible for e.g. slow JSON parsing in some very popular online games [0]? Does that mean glibc is still not production-ready?

[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26296339


sscanf is quadratic in the worst case, and has been flagged along with the bulk of the rest of the libc string support as being hazardous or potentially harmful. Its continued existence is for compatibility, but new projects should not use it.

First of all, sscanf doesn't need to be quadratic in the worst case; it absolutely can work without finding the NUL-terminator first. Second, I'd like to see that list of "flagged along with the bulk of the rest of the libc string support as being hazardous or potentially harmful" functions. Does this list include strchr()? Because if yes, your original argument fails to stand.

strchr relies on null termination and returns a pointer. It's absolutely vulnerable to abuse. There are many CVEs related to the use of strchr.

So why do you consider zig's less-than-performant implementation of strchr to be so egregious as to serve as its condemnation while you give glibc a free pass for exactly the same blunder? Why the double standards? In fact, it's even worse with glibc because it's four times as old as zig.

It's not a problem in isolation. And like I said, the c standard string library is generally considered harmful and dangerous; it does not get a pass.

And besides the stability issues, their response to Bun was enough to make it clear that it is a user hostile project. I would never trust a vendor that behaved in that manner to a long standing user, financier and advocate.


When you're setting expectations about a project, it's never a bad idea to listen to the creators themselves.

https://ziglang.org/download/0.17.0/release-notes.html

> Zig has known bugs, miscompilations, and regressions.

> Even with Zig 0.17.x, working on a non-trivial project using Zig may require participating in the development process.

> When Zig reaches 1.0.0, Tier 1 support will gain a bug policy as an additional requirement.


https://blog.jetbrains.com/blog/2026/06/05/why-zig-isn-t-1-0...

I did not say it's acceptable, just not catastrophic, especially since workarounds exist.

I've used zig in similar capacity in production in the past and personally I would take the slowdown just to avoid dealing with MSVC :)


A version number starting with 0 is not just evidence, but a direct statement by the maintainer that software is unstable/pre-release no matter how long it has been in development.

A few things:

- Splitting your community is a concern. The classic example is multiplayer DLC: if not everyone can access it then it will risk low adoption.

- Presales and first week sales are hugely important to financing projects. Not many games achieve a long tail.

- Developers are expensive. Paying a team of artists and designers and programmers demands that they generate enough revenue to make it worthwhile.

AI opens this door because:

- Its capacity to be constrained fits neatly into mod frameworks.

- It's incredibly cheap to operate, compared to the human team.

- Users are comfortable with its SaaS model and so won't be deterred by a subscription model.


I have friends that enjoy knitting and sewing. Those are great pastimes made commercially unviable for most because of great leaps in logistics and automation. But they are absolutely valid and enjoyable hobbies.

And the skills they provide are transferable. Patience, attention to detail, staying on task.


It's just tough to hear a mainstream "impactful" line of work be compared to knitting and sewing. Say what you want but people thought that their work was necessary to the advancement of society, or at least something bigger than themselves. Whether you agree with them or not, reduction of the job to a hobby takes that away from them.


I feel like this belittles knitters and sewers!

There's also a tension in your comment. Are we prioritizing "advancing society" or programmer feelings? If it's the former, then it doesn't matter if AI is better than humans, whatever moves us forward faster is better. If it's the latter, then we're talking about holding back progress for the sake of a programmer's feelings.

For the record, I'm a lifelong programmer who loves AI because now I can experiment with new ideas at a scale I could not before. I feel zero loss. In fact using AI brings back the magic of technology that we lost in the 90s with the "business-ifying" of tech.


I find this comment fascinating for a few reasons. The first is that it has the underlying assumption that all "progress" is good (regardless of what we're progressing towards). From my perspective, it seems like most of the progress being made is towards bringing about a sort of techno-feudalism and environmental collapse. Maybe a little bit less progress would actually benefit humanity?

The second thing revolves around this:

> In fact using AI brings back the magic of technology that we lost in the 90s with the "business-ifying" of tech.

This is the complete opposite of my experience. AI seems like the logical conclusion of the business-ifying of tech. Get rid of all those pesky nerds, and the MBAs can just create whatever grift pops into their head.


> From my perspective, it seems like most of the progress being made is towards bringing about a sort of techno-feudalism and environmental collapse. Maybe a little bit less progress would actually benefit humanity?

I'd argue you're conflating two independent axis: technological progress and societal inequality.

AI is useful today and is getting more powerful and efficient. This is obviously great for humanity! It's enabling discoveries that were previously out of reach, and allowing us to accomplish the same amount of work with less effort.

AI is also generating massive amounts of money for the wealthy and powerful and increasing inequality. This is not great for humanity!

I do think it's important to keep in mind that this centralization of power and wealth is not caused by AI directly: the pattern exists whenever there's a desirable but scarce resource. The same argument that AI is increasing inequality can reasonably be made about concrete, steel, and steam engines. The problems caused by AI are really human problems at their core. It's possible AI could even help us fix them! (I'm not at all hopeful.)


LLMs haven't enabled any discoveries that were previously out of reach. If you disagree, name one?

>AI is useful today and is getting more powerful and efficient

No, it's getting less efficient at an exponential rate without proportional performance gains

>do think it's important to keep in mind that this centralization of power and wealth is not caused by AI directly: the pattern exists whenever there's a desirable but scarce resource. The same argument that AI is increasing inequality can reasonably be made about concrete, steel, and steam engines.

The goal of these LLM companies is to funnel all economic activity through their models. LLMs only exist because of how they strip mined human work without consent or compensation. I.e. LLMs do directly cause the centralization of wealth and power by how they were designed and how they are meant to be used.


> LLMs haven't enabled any discoveries that were previously out of reach. If you disagree, name one?

While not an LLM, protein folding is now often done via transformer.

> No, it's getting less efficient at an exponential rate without proportional performance gains

AI is expanding in both directions. Sure, it's eating the world with its compute demand and the bitter lesson bites, but we're also seeing drastically improved efficiencies employed alongside. The cost per task is dropping fast.

> The goal of these LLM companies is to funnel all economic activity through their models.

That's what all companies want, AI or otherwise.

No arguments here on the ethics of AI companies though.


You can argue the degree to which they influence each other, but technological progress and societal inequality are definitely not "independent axis".


We live in a capitalist society, where human (intellectual) labor has immense value and grants social mobility.

Take away intellectual labor and society becomes inherently less equal, i.e. feudalistic.


I think progress is inevitable. Sometimes good, sometimes bad (in my perspective). I love AI but I don't like the eco-damage required to power it (not just water/electricity, but rare earth mining and the human rights violations that go with it). I don't think you can go backwards though.

I was just pointing out the logical tension in the comment I was replying to.

> This is the complete opposite of my experience. AI seems like the logical conclusion of the business-ifying of tech. Get rid of all those pesky nerds, and the MBAs can just create whatever grift pops into their head.

I have dozens of extremely nerdy projects going thanks to AI. I wouldn't have had time for any of them because I was too busy making money to spend 100+ extra hours programming my wildest tech fantasies, but now that's possible!

AI also makes it possible to do hardware programming, reverse engineering (when Anthropic isn't censoring itself) and all manner of other geeky pursuits.


Sure, I agree that progress (towards something) is inevitable. But in the dichotomy presented ("progress" vs. "programmers feelings"), I took progress to mean "the things we're currently making progress on [with regards to AI]." Which I would say are largely a wealth concentration machine, and will probably be a net negative for humanity. To more directly respond to the original question of "progress or programmer feelings", I would ask why we can't just do something else entirely?

I'm genuinely happy that you're having fun with it. I can't get over the feeling that _I'm not building anything._ To me, it seems like hopping on an IRC channel and copy-pasting code from a greybeard instead of writing it myself. I just don't find that satisfying at all.


You clearly don't care about the eco-damage or else you wouldn't be using Big Tech's LLMs lol.

And let's not kid ourselves, you aren't programming anything. You are paying Anthropic to brute force the code for you with their supercomputer which was only built thanks to the rare earth mining and human rights violations you claim to be bothered about.


There is truth to what you're saying. I desperately want local models to be powerful enough to use and I'm sure they will soon enough.


> Get rid of all those pesky nerds, and the MBAs can just create whatever grift pops into their head.

They have a hard time dealing with those people that tell them their ideas are bad, unethical, or illegal.

Now they have their Fisher-Price steering wheel hooked into the drive train of the business!

https://doctorow.medium.com/https-pluralistic-net-2025-08-18...


I'm just saying that before programmer feelings used to be loosely aligned with advancing society: fun work (for some people) was useful work. Now that's starting to be decoupled and it sucks when your choices are hate your job and contribute or do fun stuff and don't contribute. Granted this is the dilemma most people have faced, but for people who like their work as it is right now it sucks.


I'm a programmer and I'm having more fun than ever thanks to AI. I do think a lot of programmers are pretty conservative by nature, so maybe that's the group that's struggling more. If I had to wager, I think the camp is split between those who spent a long time in university vs self-taught hacker types (I'm the latter).


I just don't understand how it can be fun to commission work from Big Tech


I'll take open models any day of the week. We're almost there but they're not quite good enough yet. Re: fun, don't you have a backlog of incredibly weird experiments and projects you'd like to build? I did and now I'm building them, it's very fun (and educational).


The people who spent a long time in university are actually better off than the self taught hacker types and this has mostly to do with the fact that so many people go through university without learning how to program.

University is not easy, so how did they skip the easy part? How did they get good enough grades everywhere else to pass?

Turns out: They must have done something that has nothing to do with programming but it is still computer science. What was it? What did they learn???


I will say, as a mathematician who likes to make simulations, this part of GenAI has been a boom.

At the same time, I do wish it wouldn't do my proofs as well lmao


Fair enough. I don't mean to speak for all programmers (I'm not one). In fact I'm an academic so that's probably why I'm upset.


> Granted this is the dilemma most people have faced

I don't agree. There are many creative and useful fields: engineering, law, finance. And others that don't require as much creativity but may be enjoyable due to social factors: medicine, teaching, emergency services.

The dilemma that people have faced is that they don't want to do earnest work, but still need money to live. There are enough types of work that are useful and stimulating in different ways that everyone should be able to find one, so long as they are given opportunities as children (we do a decent job of this in the developed world). At least, that was the contract. Many fields, not just software, are facing existential crises.


I guess when I said what you quoted, I meant for most people (developed and developing world) throughout history, or at least as long as "work" has existed.


Sure, life sucked for most people for most of history. Can't contain my excitement about the anticipated mean regression.


Sewing had been a relevant skill for 10s of thousands of years. Programming has been relevant for 10s of years.


ok and? both are allowed to suck? most people have lived for 10s of years not 10s of thousands of years so it's not like that "ancestral memory" matters anyways.


>impactful

Programming is the art of automation, and is being taken to new levels. It'd be quite damming to the field if a substantial % of the world's output over many decade hadn't brought us here, tbh.

Were builders crying when the Hagia Sophia was built? Projects come and go, nothing is forever.


I don't understand your last part about the hagia sophia


interstingly i think what you are talking about is pretty apt, but not the way you are framing it. knitting and sewing were impactful things in their time; clothing has been something humans need for a long time and more skilled craftsmen were able to produce hgiher quality garments. new techniques increased durability, wearability, comfort, etc. machines commoditized that and made it mich faster to produce garments, so turned these into hobbies and the odd artisan fpcused and made new improvements, but not as often as before.

programming will likely be the same. fewer people who care to be craftsmen, more hobbyist, a few artisans who really dig deep and make new patterns (we still dont see AI sampling out of distribution).

>reduction of the job to a hobby takes that away from them.

this is your personal feeling. they never had anything in the first place, just that the market was valuing a certain skill for what it could output. the perspective you are posting is purely a construct.


Sure it is a construct (it's how I feel at least).

I didn't mean to say sewing and knitting weren't impactful - on the contrary, they are analogous to programming: they were impactful but now they're basically hobbies. Maybe there are more developments left in the clothing making process - not sure.


The percentage of programming work that was advancing society was very, very small.

Knitting and sewing were "mainstream impactful work" for a long time, much longer than programming was.


I think you're undervaluing the skill and technology behind clothing, as well as the impact of clothing. But that's probably a reflection of how technology has allowed us to take it for granted.


for sure but the point is that sewing isn't really necessary anymore. if all the knitters disappeared tomorrow, the majority of society wouldn't feel it . If (say a few years ago) all SWEs disappeared, that would be a problem for a lot of people. The feeling of impactfulness is gone when things are reduced to a hobby.


That may be true today; but the trend is towards that no longer being the case sometime in the not too distant future.


yes, that's my point.


It also ignores the fact that among fashion enthusiasts (hardcore consumers NOT producers) handmade and artisanal clothing is generally preferred.


it's like how I can still get a typewriter and use it for the experience, or like how I could write ORM scaffolding by hand or just let the code gen write it, I see AI as nothing more than a keyboard extension, the amount of freedom you give it depends on the instruction/prompt


At that point it’s probably worth taking a more mainstream hobby like music or dancing, you’ll have a much bigger community of passionate folks. I suspect that will happen to programmers as a hobby folks too, they might discover they like playing music instruments instead.


Actually laughed out loud at the idea of a bunch of stereotypical programmers going to a dance class


Richard Stallman, one of the most stereotypical of programmers, was fond of Bulgarian folk dance.


The new learn to code haha! I personally find dancing to be the hardest of public hobbies to even think about doing, guess I'm too shy


I've tried (more than once) to learn salsa, I did about as well as most white male programmers do at it. :P


Not to mention your friends still enjoy receiving custom made knitted stuff as presents, or your neighbors if you see someone struggling. Or donate it somewhere, or put it in a display shelf to be reminded what you can actually do. Maybe in the future, programs and custom made hardware might be the same :)


> Maybe in the future, programs and custom made hardware might be the same :)

One step closer to the matrix. Send the white rabbit over, I've got your floppies ready to go. No ai, and developed without an active internet connection, so you can listen to music safe in the knowledge that your music isn't listening to you.


>Patience, attention to detail, staying on task.

These skills are all less valuable today, btw, along with roughly anything that would have allowed someone to thrive economically pre-2025 in spite of occasional accusations of high-functioning autism.

The issue is not that programming is getting automated. The issue is that the only skills that retain value are in low supply among programmers - and every other career you've considered retraining for.

Great time to be in sales.


As a sewist, when I sew things, it's also because the mass market doesn't make the exact thing I want. The software mass markets, both proprietary and open source ones, has also failed many consumers. The developers in Adobe tells me to pay $20/mo for PS, while the developers in GIMP takes 20 years to implement proper text outline. What is the point of enjoying how the software is made if people don't get to use it for what they want?


There's still a big ecosystem of people selling homemade sewn/knit products online, selling at craft fairs, selling sewing patterns, running classes, etc.

Even in something as heavily automated and mass produced as clothing, there's still a market for smaller scale, higher quality products.


Writing code was the "downtime" for me, it existed between boughts of intense problem solving. With AI agents my time is shifting heavily towards solving problems and I have less downtime as a result.

I worry about burnout.


With LLM and current economic situation my job is doing 5 things at once and after 7:30h my brain is just in panic mode. On remote this isn't a huge issue but in the office (which I'm obligated to be twice a week) I just don't know what to do so I eat 3 meal 5min each pretending this is normal.

Then the next day after this brain haemorrhage inducing experience I just waste 2h remotely on gathering mental capacity to simply know what next I need to do and next 2 says I repeat until weekend.

Simply because my boss is developer in love with LLM and machine gunning 20 PR daily.

Not to mentioned PR with more code than I can reasonable can understand and say anything about it in a project I didn't touch.

So, currently I can only say I hate my life. I'm looking for an idea which pays similar but is as mindless as humanly possible


I don't know your full situation, but as someone who has gone through full-blown real burnout: it's not worth it. In this economic situation, we do need to grind to keep our jobs but if you're getting close to burn-out I would *strongly* advise prioritizing avoiding burnout.

I went from being a passionate programmer spending all my free time working on code, to be unable to write a single line for even my most loved personal projects for 6 months. Fully awake, in the middle of the day, I would boot up my computer and within 10 minutes my body would put itself to sleep. I'd wake up hours later with my laptop barely past the login screen. It took me 6 months before I could do personal projects again. 1 year before I could do professional work again. 2 years before I could juggle both. I've fully recovered (or at least I did right before LLMs hit the scene), but it takes a lot of time and I lost a lot of money not working for that year. If I could go back in time, I would have quit that job earlier because it is far easier finding jobs as a passionate developer rather than a recovering burnout.


"Gathering mental capacity to simply know what next I need to do" is not a waste. That is work. In fact it is the most important work with LLMs. If you spend all day in a hammock dreaming up what next needs to be done (and it's the right stuff), and then type a few sentences into the LLM to generate it overnight, that is better time spent working than spending all day cranking out 20 PRs that are of mid-low value.


Yeah, if you're wandering in random directions all day long (20 PRs a day is rarely working towards a clear goal) then you're not going to get far. Taking some time to figure out where you're headed is probably way more beneficial in the long term. And it's also something LLMs suck at, they interpolate extremely well but haven't got a clue what's next.


That sucks.

Do they know they are, essentially, expending you?

It seems like your boss is doing work that doesn’t actually add value without you to review the code. But maybe the company isn’t set up to fairly evaluate the fact that review provides more value than creating code, with a workflow like your boss’s?


> Do they know they are, essentially, expending you?

I don't about the OP's specific situation, but there are definitely managers and management consultants that consciously try "expend" their employees.

Jeff Bezos is a famous example. IIRC, to avoid "complacency," he wants constant turnover of employees. Hire new people, burn them out while they're new and enthusiastic, then replace them. That's why it's occasionally leaked that Amazon consider such-and-such employment market mined out (e.g. everyone's either worked for them or is wise to their ways), so they have recruit further afield.


You're making me extremely glad that I didn't accept a job with Amazon. Life is way too short to live like that


My boss is young, passionate guy overhyped with LLM claiming at least once a weak my and my colleague days are counted and LLM will fully replace as and we are cost.

When I joined I thought this is peaceful place, after a month this changed tremendously.

And this is third job like this in a row so I have no hope to find anything even slightly as peaceful as 5y ago


Your boss is a dick, not a passionate guy


This was implied between lines


> claiming at least once a weak my and my colleague days are counted and LLM will fully replace as and we are cost.

This is just what bad managers everywhere have always done: try to make their employees scared for their jobs. They usually believe it's motivating, or some such nonsense.

Watch some of the youtube videos about how to stop giving a fuck. And look for another job. There are plenty of jobs, even in software now, that have better management.


So he's basically signing up to do your jobs once you're gone? Or he thinks he's also expendable? Either one doesn't sound too good.

Get resumes out.


> claiming at least once a weak my and my colleague days are counted and LLM will fully replace as and we are cost.

If my boss talked to me this way I would leave as soon as possible. Update your resume and get searching, I wish you the best of luck.


Since your boss thinks the LLM knows what it's doing, letting your boss approve his own PRs would be a win-win.


I think the fun part of stuff you could do is setting up dev environments that are augmented. Not only the code creation part. But also the reviewing, testing , quality benchmarking and more. Arranging this is not easy and definitely an engineering challenge.


Maybe this will provide some historical context. Capitalist automation is an anti-worker, anti-union ideology even though in theory automation is a good thing. When automation is used to reclaim time for workers or to increase pay, it is a good thing. When it is used to dispossess people or enforce work speedups, it is anti-worker.

https://jacobin.com/2023/03/automation-union-busting-product...


invent new downtime. that's what i'm doing by writing this comment.


Music is an excellent downtime.


Please don't tell me you still play with your fingers, rather than prompting AI to make songs ...


I learnt sheet music and played my first two piano pieces from scratch. It's the kind of meditative when you pay attention to learning little bits of it.


You mean you aren't already using a Neuralink and letting the AI pull the music straight out of your head?


I sincerely hope you are joking


they most definitely are :)


Speaking of which, why is AI still so bad at reading sheet music? Only Astra seems to be doing relatively OK but is crazy expensive at around $3 per page in my experiments. All the others are just rubbish, at this task that I expected to be a solved problem, to be honest.


I have an electronic keyboard and an acoustic guitar near my desk. Great to slow down with either


The LLM would just decompile the compiler and write code that matches the implementation.

Especially now that there's a website that explains clearly that the spec is not to be trusted.


I've stopped shopping on Amazon entirely, and the impact on my credit card bill has been substantial.

It's not simply that products are priced poorly, but it is also that they seem to be priced just at the threshold where the purchase remains sufficiently convenient not to shop locally or elsewhere online.

Because of their predatory practices it seems online prices are roughly identical for Western branded products at all online retailers. For Chinese brands, it's long been cheaper to use AliExpress but shipping isn't as fast and returns aren't as convenient.

But that's perception. I blocked Amazon and continued shopping as usual. The volume of my purchases is now through local retailers, and I'm buying roughly the same amount of stuff but I'm spending a great deal less.


> Within Microsoft’s cloud and AI sector, monthly AI spending limits have reportedly been slashed from $100,000 per employee to approximately $10,000 in the majority of instances.

They were allowing $100,000 per month per employee?!

That's incredible. Just a few years ago that would have been zero.


I'm curious if they have any data showing whether it benefits productivity. I get by on the free tier of ChatGPT, and do 100% of the coding myself. It has never been a bottleneck, and I like to keep my skills sharp. AI helps in analyzing problems, getting quick answers to technical queries, reviewing code, etc. But running my own business I'm incredibly careful about expenses.


The whole world is working on this right now, but in some cases it can be extremely money saving. We had a couple of engineers who build a web portal to control some IoT devices because there wasn't one in the market. We've done similar things like that in the past, where we'd buy development from the outside. I can't give you exact costs, but getting it developed is around 5% of the price in AI and HUMAN hours, and then another 10% (bringing it to around 15%) for human hours rewriting it to run securely (and maintainable) in our cloud.

We're working on bringing the last 10% down by giving non-developers various AI skills such as a compliance module that can be pushed to specific Entra groups which will make sure their vibe code madness will stick to external dependencies we've approved. (There are still hard checks later).

For other tasks it's running on guesses, and sometimes you can save help people €1000 a week by teaching them how to use the AI better.


Yes, that sounds like a reasonable use case. But very different to the 100k a month by meta and microsoft.


We have some data and hard numbers.

The question is does it scale properly? Answer: it depends.

What is the value of a project going from six months to six hours? You can look at saving the man hours but how long can that go?

What about a project that takes $100k in tokens and generates $200MM? The difficult part is determining how much was AI is the multiplier.

We are finding both to be true while quantifying requires new accounting.


Does six hours factor in maintenance? Also, I think it depends on the project. I was able to get a a number of quantum computing programs knocked up in braket with the help of various AI tools to run some simulations It would have taken me months on my own, but I got knocked out in a few prompts with free AI tools. It's a real eye opener.

However, that's very different from building and maintaining a product that will be used for live customers, where you have to consider security implications. This is what we're talking about here for Meta and Microsoft, and it's what I do for my actual coding job.


The daily work has been accelerated by AI about 5-26x between individuals and teams. The security implications are real and we are at the same time finding old gaps only discovered using the tooling.

There is a level of trust on the model, the harnesses, and the operators that is required to move quickly.

To build that trust we are building systems and processes and getting the mindset that trust is the speed limit.


This is so ridiculous lol. not paying 20 bucks for a sub has to be a handicap


Not for me. I end up using chatgpt about once a week for my actual work, and maybe once a day for non work related things. Certainly if you need the subscription it's worth $20/month or whatever for a personal sub, but I don't seem to need that at the moment. I'm more curious about the $10k or $100k/month being value for money with people using it to do their entire coding.


the $100 and $200 plans can basically give you enough usage you can never write code by hand again. If you cant save yourself 25% of your time at least isnt worth $200 then maybe you should rethink this business


Coding is much less than 25% of my time, and as i said above I want as much coding as I can get. I do very well thank you.


We have projects that would burn through a subscription in a matter of hours. The scale of some people are doing is impressive.


It was the first limit impressed but majority of employees went nowhere near it.

Then they tightened it down again and again. Right now, it's at $2k/month or $24k/year and the model restrictions are and to go wider.

Still, most employees are not hitting the limit but enough are that there's an exception process


Just a cool million+ annual expense per headcount.


Notably, the limit per employee != actual average usage per employee!


I presume failing to hit your target (limit) saw you on a performance improvement plan, or even worse not invited to the pizza party.


Is that the sound of a deflating bubble I hear?


Microsoft bloat really knows no bounds.


It is a social movement of note and importance because of the power wielded by its adherents.


You might call it a capital movement


> It is a social movement of note and importance because of the power wielded by its adherents.

We should tax the shit out of them, if only to reduce the unelected power their wealth buys.

Just like we should tax the shit out of the non-EA ultra wealthy.

We can have a democratic society or we can have the concentration of great wealth in the hands of a few. We cannot have both.


EA people tend to be in favour of raising taxation. The "giving what we can" pledge is essentially a pledge to voluntarily increase your own taxes in lieu of government taxes.


Giving away your wealth in ways you think are the best for society is not the same as letting society decide for itself through democracy.

And they support raising taxes because it's a good way to signal that you're "for the people" and cheap if you care about power more than money. A billionaire CEO will stay a billionaire if their income tax is 90% and unrealized gains tax same as their portfolios growth, and stay a CEO even if they go broke.

The important part for them is power over other peoples lives because that's exactly what you need if you believe you're a special "rational agent" who is responsible for pushing humanity in the right direction. That power can come from shady think tanks, government jobs or controlling a trillion dollar company.


I strongly agree, but I don't think the USA is capable of doing that. That sort of socialist communitarianism is at odds with the objectivist individualism that they commonly valorize, and underpins most of their heroic stories.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: