That's basically a listing search page that allows you to sort by price.
What else do you expect "collective bargaining" to do in a market where every tenant has a different landlord? Your landlord isn't going to care if the tenants of 10,000 other landlords threaten to move out. They only care if you threaten to move out, and then to credibly do that what you need is to show them the unit you could move into which is asking for less.
The real problem is that you need the unit you can threaten to move into to first exist, rather than its construction being inhibited by zoning etc.
> Collective bargaining your landlord can't ignore is you and your neighbors all withholding your rent payments until your leases are renegotiated.
How is that collective bargaining when your neighbors have different landlords?
All you're suggesting is to stop paying rent, which anybody can do on their own, with the usual consequences of your credit getting ruined and then the landlord serves you an eviction notice and changes the locks.
Consider the economics of what you're suggesting. Your unit costs $800k when it should cost $200k because of artificial scarcity (zoning), so then the landlord has to pay $800k for it and charge rents high enough to pay back that loan. The way you fix that is by getting the cost of the unit back down to where it should be, i.e. building more units to alleviate the scarcity.
Demanding that the landlords charge less without reducing what they have to pay for the building doesn't work, because then who is going to sink $800k to build a new rental unit? Who is going to keep renting out their existing units at a loss instead of turning them into condos or similar? Which then makes the scarcity of rental units worse and causes rents to go up.
You can't solve a supply problem by bargaining with someone the law still effectively prohibits from increasing supply.
The landlord class is very powerful and they use that power to suppress the housing supply so if collective bargaining puts them out of the game that's a good thing!
It still isn't "collective bargaining" when you all have different landlords.
On top of that, "puts them out of the game" means that there are no apartments to rent. And it wouldn't even work because you'd not only still have the non-landlord homeowners lobbying to suppressing the housing supply, you'd have the banks making sure you can't actually wipe out the landlords since the landlords owe them way too much money for things to happen that way.
> Less homes to rent = more homes to buy, how is that a bad thing?
Suppose you don't have a down payment to post immediately but you'd still like to sleep indoors over the next five or ten years.
> Less rent for landlords is more money in the hands of people to fund housing development, that's good for banks too!
The landlords were the ones using it for that to begin with. They use the profits from one building to buy another one, and "buyers able to pay the construction cost" is the thing developers need to build new housing.
Meanwhile the tenants would have just ruined their credit by defaulting on their lease and then can't get a mortgage to pay the developer even if they did have same down payment.
> Non-landlord homeowners have overlapping interests however they are not organized or politically powerful as the landlords are.
That doesn't really help you when they're two thirds of the voters and don't need to be organized to vote for the candidate who promises to screw you for their benefit.
There is such a thing as a Tenant Union, and in fact they are currently spreading across the country as renters turn to collective bargaining. It works!
Should rentals be seen as economic opportunities for hyper efficiencies? IE should the market be structured to extract the maximum profit from renters?
Not clear to me that is the right approach, or if owning rentals should be more of a fixed income approach (or even speculative - profits only come from the sale of the property).
The general premise of the rental market is that if rents are high, the profits from building new rental units will justify the construction costs and then new units will be added until the rents go down, i.e. until it stops being profitable to add more.
This actually works unless you inhibit the construction of new units. Naturally that's what we've been doing, which is why it isn't working. But the solution is to stop inhibiting the construction of new units.
Because the alternatives don't actually work. Unless you can build enough units to meet demand, there aren't enough units. Which means you either have high prices which suppress demand because people who can't afford them are forced out, or shortages because you're imposing some inadvisable price controls and then instead of being unable to get a unit because you can't afford the rent, you can't get a unit because they're all occupied and no one is adding more.
Seattle has more problems than that. They recently lost an illegal takings case where they used the scorpion and frog defense -- You should have known we'd apply additional affordable housing conditions that make your venture unprofitable.
Is Starbucks competing against Pete's Coffee, or are they competing against your home brew? Is it McDonald's vs Burger King, or all fast food against home cooking?
I'd wager the technical advantage is on the backend not the consumer facing. You'd be surprised how unsophisticated an unoptimized a lot of industries are.
On the manufacturing side of the world, "did this thing show up when I expected" is a remarkably difficult yet valuable question.
Thank goodness it's no longer at the whim of the ruler of the moment. Trump can only threaten FCC licenses of broadcast companies, not corporate charters of every industry.
reply