HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | diggernet's commentslogin

No love for Comcast here, but I'd be a lot more sympathetic to AT&T's argument if they were actually willing to offer their fiber service to me.

https://groundworkcollaborative.org/work/the-walmart-watchto...

Apparently to support surveillance based pricing.


And even more so, anyone who was dismissed for an inappropriate relationship, if he's brought back.

Love your rules.

My personal situation imposes even stricter versions of your #1 and #2:

1. No network, no problem. Anything core to the house has to work with Wi-Fi or automation server shut down.

2. Smart functionality must not remove dumb functionality.

As one example: having a physical switch that controls a light and the switch can be operated by automation is good. Having automation control a light and the switch just tells automation what to do is bad.

This does make things hard sometimes. For instance, your sprinkler controller doesn't pass that bar. In fact the only one I've found so far that has a local API for automation plus full "dumb" on-device control (no Wi-Fi, no app) is RainMachine, and they are gone. If only OpenSprinkler hardware had a touch screen for local UI.


> 1. No network, no problem. Anything core to the house has to work with Wi-Fi or automation server shut down.

This is one of the reasons I love Zigbee, the device network is entirely independent of my computer network, can not directly communicate to the internet in any way, and every device I've put on the network so far can be configured to directly communicate with other devices so basic functionality remains operational even if the controller goes down.

For example, in my living room I have a Lutron Aurora dimmer dial locking a standard switch in the on position, then plugged in to the outlet that switch would normally control is a Leviton dimmer module. Both connect to the network controlled from a PoE Zigbee dongle, but have been directly paired as well so pressing the button on the dial makes it directly tell the dimmer module to turn on, rotation commands are sent direct, etc.

The controller also receives these commands when it's active and can add to the functionality for inputs like double-click, but if it's down the basic functionality still works entirely as a normal person would expect. You walk in to the room and see a knob on a switch plate, you turn the knob and the light brightness increases regardless of the state of the internet, my home server, or even my network as a whole.

The other major advantage compared to Matter/Thread is that it's not IP based so it's impossible for any Zigbee device to ever have a cloud dependency. No matter how much some marketing dingus might want to, it can not be ruined.


I haven't done any direct pairing yet, but Zigbee certainly rocks. Everyone is pushing Matter and Thread, but with the basic premise of devices being globally addressable, I just have no confidence of being in control of them.

Agreed.

I'm a strong proponent of everything-over-IP in an ideal world, and love the fact that Matter mandates IPv6 which forced a lot of embedded vendors to finally support it, but the IoT vendors have demonstrated that if they're given an internet connection they WILL abuse it to lock you in to their platform.

Matter over Thread is nice because it functionally provides an "IoT VLAN" by default and can only reach the internet or even the LAN through a gateway, which can be fully controlled by the user making it the best of both worlds.

As for Matter over WiFi, for the reason in the first paragraph I've maintained a rule of not buying WiFi IoT devices unless the device has a real need for direct access to the internet or high-speed data from the LAN to do what I want it to do, and Matter doesn't change that. It is nice though that hypothetically I could have a Matter-over-Thread switch cause a WiFi device to do something directly without needing to go through Home Assistant.


The best devices have a local web interface so you can control them with your computer (like how you control your router).

Unfortunately, almost no lan connected devices sport such an interface.


There’s a pretty active ecosystem of ESP32 projects for HVAC systems. I’ve been working on a few that add Apple Home and Matter support with a local web interface for basic and advanced features. The web interface exposes things Apple Home or Matter protocols don’t represent well. Vane positions, different modes (dry, fan only), equipment diagnostics, remote sensor control, and even peer to peer communication for fully offline control (no WiFi needed). Plus it gets me a control path independent of the home automation stack. There’s a lot you can put on the device itself these days.

With another project, based on the ESP32-S3, I was able to cram grafana style scrubbable charts, full activity log, refrigerant circuit diagram, equipment topology, etc. I'm pretty excited for the ESP32-S31 since it's a nice jump up in performance.


Shelly switches are great for this. For example, I have one behind a regular wall light switch for the front porch. The physical wall switch always toggles, but the local on-device script turns it on (if it’s not on) at sunset, and off (if it’s on) at 10:30pm. All configurable from the local web server. Only needs ntp (your choice) in case of restart after power failure.

Local web interfaces are great, yes. And it's pretty cool for me when devices have them. But they don't meet the no network requirement for people around me. Gotta have direct control of things. I mean, the landscaper isn't going to connect and use a web browser to adjust the sprinklers.

I tried to stick to this philosophy, specifically the part about it working even if my local automation server is down, for a long time. But I finally found an automation case where I wanted functionality where I could not simultaneously have the functionality and have the switch continue working when the server was off.

Specifically, I wanted the switch to turn on different lights depending on the time of day. In the evenings in early morning I wanted it to turn on the dimmer floor lamps, and during the day, I wanted it to turn on the brighter Center room light. This was not possible without turning the switch from a light turning on device, to an automation activating device.

I thought really long and hard about if I was worth the trade off, and in the end I decided that my automation server was only likely to be down for significant periods of time if the power was out and the lights weren't working anyways. If I run into a situation where this becomes a problem for me, I'll reconsider my decision. Which is a great thing about the local control. If I make a decision that I don't like I can just change it.


There are some things that just don't have a dumb equivalent. I haven't run into any of those yet, but it's early days. At least having the one light not working for a while is probably not a disaster.

Unfortunately, even at a descent rate of 30,000 feet per minute you've got a full minute to anticipate the impact before you don't feel it.


Back in the day, the industry was run by computer enthusiasts who saw computers as an amazing tool to improve lives and enable and empower people. Today the industry is run by money enthusiasts who see computers as an amazing tool to extract money and manipulate and control people.


Fences can be made out of the tree that fell. Even post holes are optional. Only thing you need to pay for is some cheap wire mesh, and that may be reusable for repairs.


The OP mentioned having fences to keep their dogs in the yard. It depends a bit on the dog that they have, but I wouldn't trust untreated wood, using cheap wire mesh, without post holes, to keep dogs in a yard.

I also wouldn't expect the fence to hold up well if the yard had anything that would attract deer or bears.


2.009 appears to be some kind of class id. The actual class discussed was in 2017.


That's my main problem with Thread. With Zigbee I have confidence that the mesh is 100% local and offline. How do I get that confidence with Thread? How can I really be sure that something isn't helpfully opening it up to the world?


They are an invasive species in most of the world. Wiping them out is restoring the ecosystem.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: