HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | dguest's commentslogin

The "shoulders of giants" aren't just those of other scientists.

There's a whole view of history in which the major advances aren't caused by great people but rather by incremental improvements to measurement, manufacturing, and the economic base that powers them. Maybe it's less popular because asking students to memorize names and dates is easier than asking them to understand technology.

Something similar happened in end of the 1800s: searches for a luminiferous aether through which light propagated came back empty, which lead to Lorentz invariance and eventually special relativity. The whole development took a few decades. Physics wasn't just waiting around for Einstein to discover it, he just happened to be born at the right time.


I know it's all a spectrum but the US also technically hits all these:

- I know companies where "attended an Ivy" got your application into the right pile.

- I felt a new warmth from a few of my friend's parents when I told them I'd ended up in a "better" school.

- Marriage prospects (for some) have always hinged on social standing.

I guess people who have experience in both countries could comment: is S. Korea that much more extreme?


We'll get another stone age before you know it!

I was going to say that Democrats have no power to uphold laws, that's up to the executive and the national executive hasn't changed.

On the other hand a number of governors have changed (Texas in particular just went to a Democrat, and there are SpaceX interests there). They by definition can't prosecute on a federal level but they do hold some enforcement power.


The legislative branch has the power to hold the executive branch accountable for not enforcing the laws should they so choose. That's why impeachment and conviction exist.

I've been in a near miss in a plane: the pilot in the other plane was clearly inexperienced, not following radio protocol, and we got within O(200m) of a head-on collision which certainly would have been fatal for everyone.

Thing is, the sky is big. You can have non-fatal near-misses that everyone learns from. In trains they literately railroad you into a head-on collision when things go wrong.

I believe that aviation is safe because of standardization, but there's also just a lot more space to almost mess up.


Maybe because cryptography is funded better than the rest of math.

The big AI companies spend millions on some of these proofs (15M was one estimate for the Naiver-Stokes thing). Had anyone has spent millions on them before this? There was a 1M prize but that certainly wouldn't convince anyone to spend orders of magnitude more to solve the problem.

Meanwhile the three letter agencies are spending billions on cryptography. They have programs that recruit students starting in high school. So maybe they are sending the spooks to suppress OpenAI's cryptography breakthroughs, or maybe they just already outspent them.

That to me is the point that isn't getting enough attention: pure math isn't that well funded. I agree as much as anyone that these proofs are an unprecedented breakthrough for LLMs, but let's keep in mind that the money they are throwing around is also unprecedented.


Maybe it's arrogant to say as someone working in pure math but I highly doubt this is the cause


What do you think the cause is?

I'm not trying to argue there is a single cause, either (sorry if my either-or phrasing implied that). I think attributing any general feature of an academic discipline to a single cause would be missing a dozen other contributing factors.

Of course three letter agencies are watching this carefully, and I'd believe they were weighing in somehow, as they have in cryptography in the past. My point was that we shouldn't ignore the overall sparsity of funding in pure math and science projects. A lot of (probably most) contributors to bleeding-edge research have a number of other jobs in their position.


It would be cool if they embellished on the buildings and towns a bit: realign them on the grid so that they actually look good, embrace the medium. Maybe even tweak some of the narrow valleys to be more aligned.


How does it infer what's underground? Does it include tunnels / mineral deposits / bunkers?


Direct link to article: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.08147


That's true for theoretical physics.

Experimental physics takes it one step back: it's all about setting bounds on what is potentially possible. A model of the universe might say that the numbers are between zero and one, but there's some other model that says there could be 3s.

Note that this epistemic uncertainty is not the same thing that the article is focused on. The article is mostly about one specific model, which itself has some randomness baked on.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: