HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | dgently7's commentslogin

no opinion of if this is a good idea or not or the overall statement of the thing... but isn't support a big part of what these saas companies are really providing... its not just salesforce, its salesforce and customer success teams and 24/7 support etc.

i suppose this could provide that also (dont see that they want to) but then its just back to vendor a vs vendor b and vendor a in this case has a lot of history and inertia with the companies these guys would need to switch.

maybe that wouldnt be a big deal longer term, but near term i think we are probably still in a "nobody gets fired for buying ibm" phase at the moment.

ya you could save a ton on that salesforce contract and sticking it to them might feel great, but the project to migrate and then self support this with your own employees is non-trivial and would be a pretty monumental risk to take. like you might as well just internally vibe code a new solution that is perfectly tailored to your biz vs getting a knock off vibe coded version of a saas thing that you only actually use 20% of.


I never use customer support for these types of things unless there is a literal bug or downtime

I don't want to pay for customer support that other incompetent users rely on to function


i think that you are kinda making my point. you dont go to your enterprise support person for like end user doesn't know what button to press support, you go to them because literal bug or downtime is hurting your biz somehow and this saas is critical to your operations and because its a critical service for your biz you want that extra level of support. (at least i think thats how the big corp logic goes)


seems like the only way to do that is for the spaces and services we use to charge fees instead of relying on ads. but also they'd need to be non-profit and well governed or else they will enshittify.

not saying its not possible but people are pretty hooked on the internet being "free" (not realizing they are just the product)

it does seem like the time is right for something like the fediverse except that its like 20% too complicated for regular people to understand...

So like maybe something that is a verified humans only, publishing / sharing, social connection managing, community building platform that doesn't rely on huge cloud infra (you own your own data and host your own content) monstrosity, that you pay a nominal fee for so there is 0 ads allowed and a legal contract that forbids the company from selling your data ever.

no problem right? just sell it as real and "healthy" social web. (not social media dark patterns and infinite scrolling, actual human connection and community building.)


Ya. cant say id thought about it before today outside of a general idea that mobile games are full of dark patterns and thus annoying and bad.

if you'd asked me would they do it i would have said totally, but there is something different here about the level of effort they actually do go to not just to manipulate the game into a state where it can force you into the highest value ad state, but how much effort it goes into to manipulate the player so that they keep coming back for "one more hit"

a game with dark patterns but still a game is what i think i expected before. now its pretty clear you cant or shouldn't even really call this thing a game anymore. There is no "game design" in forcing a player to lose because you have an opportunity to sell a better ad. this is just ad tech wrapped in a game like package.


suspicion isn't enough to actually detain tho (pull some one over in this case)

the aclu post points out that the pretextual stop is the actual problem here. all that suspiciousness wouldnt matter to this woman if she hadnt been detained. the fbi dude could have been suspicious as hell. could have decided to follow her around or like done some other actual investigation to get actual evidence that would amount to probable cause and enable a detainment.

cops dont have a right to stop you so they can go fishing.

the article doesn't seem to mention what actual authority an fbi agent would have to enforce a local traffic law about "staying in the left lane".

it does seem like this was a pretty clear rights violation and i hope the aclu fights on her behalf.


comfy and nuke are not even in the same ballpark. they arent really even solving the same problems. some overlap but like wildly different approaches. other than both being "node based"

comfy is getting more features all the time but i dont think id put it in the same category of "professional imaging software" that nuke holds the top spot in.


it definitely started that way, like with radio before it. early programs were directly paid for by advertisers and the adds were right in the middle of the show presented by the hosts! (kinda like how yt does it now sometimes but even more so)

its literally why we call the whole genre of soap operas that. they would all be sponsored by soap and cleaning product companies trying to reach stay at home moms as their target market for the ads.

ads were along for so much of the history of tv... its easy to forget because recently netflix made it seem like we could just directly pay for content as just entertainment (like movies always were).

but those days are gone and we are returning to the roots. i dont think a single streamer doesnt have an ad tier and we are starting to lose the ad free pay more options too (disney, amazon)


That it was ok in the past certainly doesn't mean it's ok now. And TV advertising wasn't as sinister as it is now with targeted ads that require a detailed profile of every viewer. Everyone just got the same ads.

If blocking ads won't be possible anymore then I'll just pirate everything. And jailbreaking TVs and other hardware.


ya agree, a targeted ad is a very different beast, its not so much the targeting thats the issue either. id much rather only see ads for stuff in interested in than stuff i really dont need. its HOW they come up with that targeting. scraping stealing tracking all the other bs that makes that targeted ad feel creepy and gross.

and if you think its not gonna get so much worse with ai able to generate 10x the ad variants... or maybe even personalized ad versions.(one day, probably too expensive now)

good thing its never been easier to hack everything, maybe we can also figure out how to hack the legal system enough to make shady stuff like recording you in your house a felony. i feel like we should start with making it so that terms in a eula cant bind you to take specific actions. inal but in the case of 2p consent states if you go to your friends house and he doesnt tell you that his tv's eula said that it'll be recording all the time then he's in trouble, but the company actually doing the recording.. scott free because they said in the eula it was the responsibility of the owner to tell everyone who comes near the tv it might be recording. ...why would you ever click that agreement that you were forced to click to use the thing that you already bought and setup, what is the actual recourse for not saying yes? go return the tv and pay the restock fee? idk that doesnt sound like a reasonable contract/agreement that should ever be enforcable. which would mean its actually the tv companies doing all the wiretapping in 2p states...

hmm.. i know im wrong in many ways but i can dream that the law could be actually reasonable.


Yes I love it when I see mistargeted ads because it means I've been able to stay outside of the dragnet a bit.

I have been watching a bit of prime video and getting ads for cars, baby diapers and gambling sites, all things I have zero interest in buying lol. I've not had a car in 10 years and I'm single and don't even buy lottery tickets. I keep sites isolated a lot in Firefox containers but Amazon of course has my purchase history there (there aren't many other ecommerce options left around here) so I'm surprised they don't have me figured out. But I'm glad.

I'm not really sure about the legal system but I'm in Europe, it's a lot more restrictive for that kind of stuff.


there is a huge amount of jazz now that is using videogame music as the source material.

like early jazz used popular but older songs and reinterpreted them, knowing the source tune really makes it much easier to get into the overall genre I think. no links handy to help you find it but pick a game you like and search for a jazz cover.


scrolled down like 100 posts to find one that actually referenced the op's game directly.

I'm pretty sure the point of the game was to make a statement and make people think/talk and boy-howdy op you did a great job.


i have a theory that not only is it great that its possible to create your own tool, but its actually the best possible way.

there is no one right system that works for everyone. or as op pointed out even one system that works for a single person as their needs change over time.

the thing that everyone should do is create their own system that works just for them. unfortunately its still a tradeoff even if llm does all the building, upfront effort and ongoing effort to establish the system and maintain/iterate.

the analogy that comes to mind is tailored clothes. most of the asanas etc. of the world are built to fit a broad number of people pretty well, but its people fitting into the clothes. diy is like a tailor cutting the clothes to fit you exactly. and just like tailored clothes vs off the rack, if you change shape the tailored ones are going to be easier to adjust.


why do i need 1000s of people to use my software? its far easier (and more fun) to just make it exactly how I want and keep it for myself?

but also there is a problem of choice when you get to these plugin sized software. just look at the mvave fm1 custom firmware scene... a week or two ago there were like 10 choices... a month ago there were like 2... today its like 60+ just listed on this one site.

as a hopeful* user of these firmwares I can only pick one to be on the device at a time. at the pace people are making them there is no way ill be able to try enough to actually find the really great ones. even with the in browser simulators. what if that next new one is the really greatest... the humans with the judgement to know what they like are the bottleneck and we don't have days and days to try all the new software at the pace we can make it.

but also if i know for myself what i like... i can just add one more to the list that is exactly how i want it. which is exactly my plan. try a few see what feature i like or not then make one that is just for my needs.

*dear bezos i can not wait any longer for my package with mine to arrive.

https://fm1-editor.com/firmware/ one of probably many firmware lists out there.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: