HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | derac's commentslogin

I often get answers in non-english languages. I don't understand why they aren't forcing the language that the user is browsing with unless otherwise specified.

I think they’re probably just passing some context on the user (region) and instructing it to use that language. I assume many queries you cannot trace to the user language because they’re just some generic search terms (‘taj mahal’,’Donald Trump China’ or whatever) so they probably instruct the model to answer in a specific language and they overdo it a bit

But my browser is sending my language.

Your browser's language doesn't necessarily map to what you'll want responses to be in. A lot of people speak different languages.

Why wouldn't those people set the browser to the languages they speak?

Because the translation of that specific software might be superior in e.g US English?

So this hypothetical user is setting a different language and then complaining that they're getting that language?

It's not that complex. Say your OS or system setting is US English and you're downloading say, an app in Spanish that was developed with that in mind, you'd want that, wouldn't you?

It's not that complex. If I don't speak Spanish, I don't want it, no. If I do, then I'll go to my browser settings, and set my preferred language to Spanish.

But that'll translate the entire browser to Spanish, which you may* not want. All due respect, but you don't seem to be in touch with reality on this one.

Just because you speak a language, doesn't necessarily mean it's your preference all over the place. Or let's say you're Dutch and you live in the US. Your OS is in English, and imagine if telegraaf.nl auto-switched to English.

  (**) The web and apps are full of less than ideal translations. And AI has actually worsened it.

Well, I'm Greek and live in Greece, and el-GR/en-US has served me fine for decades.

When I was googling something about oil refining equipment it started answering in Arabic, obviously.

he's implying that anthropic employees want Jensen gone because he doesn't care about existential risk and such + he's pro open weight models and if he's getting cards to china he is propping up the models they like to whine about.

Except Google already has marketshare for search and their Flash model does a decently good job there.

I have seen techniques for smart selecting objects and moving them around in the scene.

That 200M figure needs much more justification as well, humans recieve huge amounts of data through their senses, particularly vision and touch.

A nice source for this might be "The unbearable slowness of being: Why do we live at 10 bits/s?" [1].

A lot of people seem to think that training is limited to the 10 bits/s of processing mentioned here. But raw sensor input (mostly visual) is in the order of 21 quadrillion bits per year [2], according to the same paper. It seems likely to me that learning uses much more data than is ultimately expressed in behaviour.

[1] https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S089662732...

[2] Assuming 16 waking hours, and 10^9 bits/s of input that the paper mentions. 16*3600*365*10^9 = 21.024*10^15


That "raw sensor input" is massively, hideously spatially and temporally redundant.

Even the shallow encoding patterns of AV1 can easily crush a raw video stream down by a factor of 10^3 without losing either spatial coherence or semantic loading.

Humans live in self-similar environments and perform self-similar activities. Any practical training dataset has the "natural human data" beat on diversity by a crushing amount. And a system that can learn deeper patterns makes the sensor streams more redundant, not less.


If it weren't massively redundant (ie identifiable patterns) there would have been no point evolving brains to parse the raw sensor input.

Learning something from a lecture, seminar or a book is close equivalent to learning from text/tokens.

Nah. The "huge amounts of data" humans receive are incredibly self-redundant.

Incorporating non-text data into AI training runs has repeatedly demonstrated that for general reasoning capabilities, no data type beats text in value per byte.


It is very redundant, but there is an incredible amount of it and we can "train" continuously and much more efficiently.

This is only true on the surface. Yes, making a model a good debator can be acchieved like this, but every current frontier model exhibits the same semantc confusion when it comes to actual mechanics of physical objects. Understanding how not to pass the ball through the glass is not a property of textual reasoning. This is also very visible in model generated code where the ball and the glass plane very often intersect. Easy to identify in syntax (compilers will do the job for you), easy to miss on the concept level.

This becomes more true the deeper you look.

LLMs used to "fail at spatial reasoning forever". But each new generation would fail a little less. Then we got the likes of Astra, and ARC-AGI-3 straight up died.


The data is massively compressed and pruned. Where are the input tokens in an LLM?

Kimi 3.1 Pro is 2.8T vs this at 770B. I find that the jump in parameter count gives less tangible benefits like better "taste" and long context coherency, but it depends on the problem if that matters obviously.

Videos 1 and 4 on vision and computer use are wild. They depict the model finding a 2m feature from a large satellite image, then determining where a photo was taken. Is it just me or do the Chinese model releases have less concern about looking like a military weapon? I don't think it's a bad thing necessarily, it seems honest. Also the music they choose for it is hilarious.

China hit maximum tech dystopia a long time ago. Now they can enjoy tech because they know its already maximally invasive and there is nothing they can do.

Last time I went to China, a friend left her phone in a taxi (I guess a "didi") near a train station. She ran to the train station's police station, pestered them into looking at the recordings, got them to tell her the license plate of the car, and figure out how to call the driver. Her phone was back 20 minutes later.

If you're going to be surveilled 24/7, at least you gotta make it work for you.


> If you're going to be surveilled 24/7, at least you gotta make it work for you.

I don't get it.

There was CCTV at the station, your friend arrived in a taxi. And we're supposed to be amazed you can call up the taxi company and quote a numberplate off CCTV ?

Can be done anywhere in the world.

Would have been far more impressive story if she had arrived in a private car, dropped off by a work colleague or something.


> And we're supposed to be amazed you can call up the taxi company and quote a numberplate off CCTV

No. It was just a thing that happened to me that I thought was funny and interesting, because running to the train police station and asking them to track the didi was not something I'd ever have thought to do.

I'm sorry my little anecdote didn't satisfy you.


> I'm sorry my little anecdote didn't satisfy you.

It wasn't that. Its that you made a reference to the Chinese surveillance state in the same post. Your example didn't fit the evil-bogeyman narrative you were aiming for.

Sorry if I was unclear there.


> Your example didn't fit the evil-bogeyman narrative you were aiming for

What in the world are you talking about. If anything, I wasn't sure if recollecting that anecdote was minimizing the harm of being surveilled constantly. The last thing I expected was being accused of an "evil-bogeyman narrative."

> Sorry if I was unclear there.

Yes, thanks for clarifying. Now I understand that this has nothing to do with me or what I wrote and is 100% projection on your part.


> What in the world are you talking about.

You used the words "If you're going to be surveilled 24/7, at least you gotta make it work for you."

The implication being quite clear you were inferring it was only possible in China's surveillance state, when it was not.

How about we cordially agree to disagree and move on ?


> The implication being quite clear you were inferring it was only possible in China's surveillance state, when it was not.

Jesus fucking Christ.


Last time I did that, I called my phone from my friend's phone, asked the driver to come back, and paid him for the trip.

Her phone doesn't ring.

> figure out how to call the driver

Which country are you in where you cant take "call the driver" for granted?


Going from license plate to phone number would be one hell of an endeavor in most US states.

I expect the US police to have this capability; < 1% expectation that they would share it with a random citizen who walked in.

“Powerless to help you, not powerless to harm you.”

I don't quite understand the question. If she had had her phone, she could have called the driver using the information from the didi app, but she had no phone, so she didn't know who to call.

Herself, I’d have thought.

Her phone doesn't ring.

They can enjoy tech because people see tech improving every aspect of their lives. Nowhere in the the world have people ever seen the rate of technological progress that people in China have. Imagine going from having practically no electronics, to everyone having a cellphone, self driving cars, high speed rail across the whole country, drone delivery, and so on. Naturally, people who've seen technology dramatically improve every aspect of their lives would be optimistic that further technological progress will bring even better life.

Meanwhile, in the west, the standard of living has been eroding for the majority of the population. Technological progress is associated with layoffs, loss of agency at the workplace, and diminishing life prospects. So, it's no surprise that there is growing opposition to AI.


I can imagine it because the same thing has happened in my life time. The difference for me is that the tech isnt used to suffocate any of my human rights.

Tech in China isn't used to suffocate anybody's human rights either. In fact, more people in China see their country as being democratic than in America according to the latest Democracy Perception Index from the Alliance of Democracies Foundation.

https://allianceofdemocracies.org/democracy-perception-index

What makes this report interesting is that the organization publishing it was started by an ex-NATO chief and claims to unite democracies, meaning Western liberal style democracies. So it can’t be accused of having some sort of anti-Western bias. Their methodology is also straightforward, where they simply ask people if they feel their government works in their interest and whether they can hold it accountable. That’s the whole ballgame, because if people don’t believe the system is democratic then it inherently lacks legitimacy no matter what the constitution says. While people will surely attack this methodology, the sheer fact that a NATO-connected group published such a report gives its claims a certain credence given how dire these results are for the Western model of democracy. France now ranks alongside Kazakhstan, Yemen, and Zimbabwe in its own citizens’ eyes while the U.S. is split down the middle with about half of Americans saying they don’t think they live in a democracy anymore. China, on the other hand, sits up there with the Scandinavians and Switzerland, and Chinese people overwhelmingly say the system works for them. Notably, we can also see that perceptions of transparency, rule of law, and free speech are on the rise across the board in China.

And before you start trying to claim that people in China are simply afraid to speak their mind, the same report shows Russia at -21 points and Belarus at -9, so that whole excuse falls apart. Turns out that people living in states the West labels as being authoritarian do, in fact, complain when they’re unhappy.

Various other western publications have reported the same thing for many years.

https://www.tbsnews.net/world/china-more-democratic-america-...

https://www.newsweek.com/most-china-call-their-nation-democr...

https://www.csmonitor.com/World/Asia-Pacific/2021/0218/Vilif...

Turns out the US is the place where human rights are actually being suffocated.


> Tech in China isn't used to suffocate anybody's human rights either

Explain the mass uploading of secret screen recordings in more than ten phone brands sold in China in a component called SystemHelper, disclosed in the past few days, including but not limited to Xiaomi, Samsung, OPPO.


Ah yes, because American companies absolutely do not vacuum up all your data. Also, big news to me that Samsung is Chinese.

Whataboutism, so predictable.

Also, read again what I said, 'sold in China'.

Does it hurt so much when your fantasy turns out to be fake?

Oh, and you haven't explained the uploading. Maybe your last visit to onlyfans is now in a server, you know.


Screeching whataboutism is what low intellect individuals do to justify applying a double standard. What Chinese companies do in China is basically the same thing that Americans do in the US and everywhere else. Yet, people claim America is a free country. So, apply the same logic to China?

If you need to be explained why companies like to harvest customer data, then what else is there to say about you.


First, work on your English before embarrassing yourself in public.

Second, work on your logic skills before embarrassing yourself in public.

Third, you still have not explained why recording phone screens and uploading the recording without telling the phone owners is not 'suffocating anybody's human rights'.


This is why Baidu's CEO can shamelessly claim Chinese people are willing to trade privacy for convenience years ago.

EDIT: typo


That makes a lot of sense.

Yes, why do we have undercover domestic spies and enforcers? Is that something we want? Vote!


[flagged]

It still blows my mind he won the popular vote.

This timeline is fucking _wild_.


The most popular candidate was "I didn't vote"


DNC did a great job endorsing that candidate.


Downvoted but absolutely correct. This is what happens when you neglect working people's needs, they will always side with the authoritarian that promises a better future. Neoliberals need to be purged from the DNC if they ever want actual power like the New Deal Coalition held onto (controlled both Houses of Congress for 60 years, won 10/12 Presidential elections with their candidates too).

Nixon literally won his election by promising national price controls. The people love economic relief, even just the promise is enough to win elections.


Read my lips: No new taxes - remember that one?


Yeah and they won the election based on it. This is why it's extremely important to not just say what people want to hear but actually do it too.


That's definitely why Trump is -27 net approval.


That's just buyers remorse. He told us how he intended to govern. His opponent told us how he intended to govern. The voters were not mislead.

(and his approval would be the same mid 40s it always was if gas prices were reasonable)


He’s never achieved a majority vote in any election, FWIW. His claim of a mandate was just as brazen as all the other litany of lies - he’s a lame duck lame duck. The true shame is on the congressional republicans for letting him sully them so deeply and follow him in his self immolation of the entire government and America in the world. The rebuilding will be a major test of the successor, and it’ll be fascinating to see if the Goldwater republicans can become the party of reason again rather than this reality TV idiocracy.


> The true shame is on the congressional republicans for letting him sully them so deeply and follow him in his self immolation of the entire government and America

This is the problem when your entire identity and principles boil down to "doing what the social superior tells you to".


This is not idiocracy. It's the prequel. In idiocracy, they understood that they were dumb and put the smart guy in charge.


for 20 minutes, and then they tried to kill him


His party knows the system and focuses on getting elected instead of focusing on getting the popular vote, because the popular vote doesn't elect you...


> He’s never achieved a majority vote in any election

Trump won the popular vote in 2024 [1].

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2024_United_States_presidentia...


I assume they mean literally. He won a plurality, not a majority.


Americans aren't angry because Trump was wrong, they're angry because it's not working.


After denying project 2025 and then carrying it out almost exactly? They were misled.b


What?


During the election Trump denied knowing anything about Project 2025 and he has enacted a lot of it. I dont know why voters trusted him on that but here we are.


Trump is globally famous for lying. It's possibly his most well known attribute? What's the argument here?


The argument is that what he promised and what we got are very different. Saying people voted for this isn't genuine IMO.


> Saying people voted for this isn't genuine IMO.

Those people voted for the lies, knowing full well that they were lies, and then are acting surprised that the lies are lies.


"The lies are lies" being a true proposition is too meta for the average human brain.


It’s not. It’s because he took inflation to the Moon. If he hadn’t had Hegseth at his side, and hadn’t gone into Iran, he’d probably still be treading water.


Covid spending took inflation to the moon. Just as economic theory predicts.


You know what was even worse for prices? 100% tariffs and blowing up the fuel supply. The government has just chosen to lie about inflation.


> Covid spending took inflation to the moon

Yes. Then the party that did that got trounced. Then nobody learned any lessons.


Inflation under Trump is half that of when Biden was in. https://finance.yahoo.com/economy/policy/article/inflation-u...


It wasn’t solely Biden that created that spike. Trump passed the CARES act that minted close to 3 trillion in his final year of his first term. Biden passed a trillion dollar bill too. I don’t blame them since it was to combat covid. I’m not jumping for joy because it’s half, I’m mad because it’s ticking back up.


Biden absolutely signed a series of inflationary bills into law and then didn’t do anything to mitigate it. (The initial Covid relief kept us out o a depression.)

Biden’s inflation peaked worse than anything Trump has done. But telling voters you’re only slapping them after the other guy punched them is about as effective as you’d think. (There is zero sense of urgency from the White House around this either.)


> Inflation under Trump is half that of when Biden was in

And how did that work out for Biden?

Voters don’t like inflation. Blowing up energy prices by launching a war of choice while shutting down domestic production because windmills isn’t smart policy.


Yep. For a lot of voters, it is literally as simple as high gas prices => vote for the other guy.


Actual or stated? The article lists a lot of things whose prices went up more under Trump 2 than Biden - regardless of what CPI data from the Trump government says.


Uh, wouldn't that be the same? Let's say factually and statistically. In any case, I posted that to balance what the other guy said which was misleading at best


> what the other guy said which was misleading at best

Current inflation is a fuckup [1]. Pretending it doesn’t exist is a fuckup. They aren’t unprecedented fuckups. But they are consistently punished.

Inflation is exceptionally high right now for a developed country. It’s feeding into cost-of-living issues that are animating voters.

[1] https://www.bls.gov/cpi/ 7.2 annualized in September


[flagged]

> Which has absolutely nothing to do with what I'm pointing out

You had no hard numbers. I’m providing them. How aren’t you following that connection?


No. Actual numbers and numbers stated by an unreliable biased entity are not the same.


You can Google for the same information as I did over the past year. I won't do it for you.


And won via a plurality after losing the popular vote in the last election. The least popular president in history can’t win a majority of popular vote. It’s not shocking he’s deeply unpopular, he never was popular. He’s a won twice on a technicality of the republic created to ensure the rural states wouldn’t be dominated by Virginia in the original establishment of the union.

He’s a pariah everywhere on earth, most especially at home. The sad part is the democrats couldn’t mount a successful campaign against someone so unfit to lead. Now there’s nothing left to do but clean up the mess and undo the terrible harm he has caused and repair what can be once he’s finally out of our hair.


Eligible voter turnout in 2024 was <50% for 18-24 year olds, and <65% for 25-44 year olds in the US.


Unless 100% of people vote it doesnt count as voting?


People who don't vote don't oppose the winner.


No?

"We did vote". Except that an extraordinary number of people that could vote, didn't. So when somebody says "vote, people", they're obviously talking to those people that chose not to vote.


Any idea is worth entertaining, to avoid the realization the purity spiraling ideology is just as reviled by 90 % of the people as is racism.


I think my idea for this is that a candidate doesn’t win the election unless they get more than 50% of all eligible votes, not 50% of the votes cast. If there is no clear winner the seat is vacant, but a new election is scheduled for two weeks later. Districts and states that don’t care to vote simply don’t get a say.


> I think my idea for this is that a candidate doesn’t win the election unless they get more than 50% of all eligible votes, not 50% of the votes cast.

This would think out the representation significantly, and applied to presidential voting would be rather dificult. The highest share of eligible voters in US history to support a US President is 42.6% for Ulysees S. Grant (Harrison and McKinley both close behind with +40%). Not one President has ever broken the 50% of eligble voters mark, and even those presidents that won in relative landslides in the EC (Washington, Monroe, Roosevelt, Reagan, Nixon) all had shares of the eligible votes that were in the 30%’s.


Yes and the idea would be to change both politician and voter behavior. To me these arguments are like saying that because we have always put water into round glasses it would never fit in a square one.


Understood and appreciate the reply. It’s a very high bar to clear, though.

In Australia where there is compulsory voting (and fines for not voting) the turn out in the most recent national election was about 91%. If you have to get 50% of the eligible voters this means attracting about 55% of the ones who do turn up and vote.

In that same country, only 1 (Sydney) of the 172 seats in the House of Represenatives was won by a candidate with more than 55% of the vote but turnout in that district was ‘only’ 87.4%. Even though the candidate won 55% of the 87% of eligible vote, she fell 3700 votes short of winning 50% of all eligible voters.

Australia make it compulsory to vote and easy to vote, too, and they still can’t get everyone to the polls. And even in the safest seat in the country, you still have the clear winner - the second place candidate was 34 points back! - falling short of the 50% of eligible voters mark.

Grandted, Australia is a different system to the US, but I would be interested to understand how you imagine you could get people to vote when the threat of fines and prosecution still sees countries like Australia fall 10% short of perfect attendance, and then why setting a higher bar than 50% + 1 vote results in a better system.

I suspect one way might be to make it very easy to vote, expensive (in fines or in criminal penalties) to not vote, and then to restrict the number of candidates to a two. But the downsides to that (forcing people to make a political choice or be fined, offering only two options in a complex world) seem significant, too.


What if people keep not voting? Surely you'd also have to compel voting to make this work.

And what if there are, say, ten candidates?


Scored approval voting takes care of ten candidates. And sure let’s say after 3 elections with no winner fines could be imposed too, Australia style. But I would hope that having no representation while having the opportunity to have representation would be motivation enough.


there is no "scored approval voting". approval voting is literally score voting with a 0-1 binary score scale, and with the scores implicit in the state of an empty or filled oval.


Who would be fined for nobody winning an election? The voters?


The New England Patriots lost the 2026 Superbowl, and that list of losers includes all the second and third stringers who didn't play.


Because people in safe demographics (non minority, no care about reproductive rights) love to broadcast 'both sides are the same'.


[flagged]

It was more like Obama was so cool and had so much panache he won despite having an extremely incompetent team...and then both he and his team believed he won because of them and proceeded to self-sabotage the DNC from within.

To be clear, I'm not excusing him. I think he was very cool indeed but ultimately a weak president that lacked in leadership before and after his term


>NoidFonsense.

This is a dogwhistling incel username.


What do you think makes a person left-wing or left-leaning?


It depends on the context, but I think the heart of leftism/rightism is described by the idea of slave/master morality described by nietzsche and others.

In our nation it's a bit different, because the right wing is also seen as christian while the left-wing is more athiest. I would chalk that down to a certain duality that exists within each wing, which I think is desirable.


oh yeah? which attitudes do you take issue with?


Feels like you're trying to bait them instead of engaging in good faith.


Baiting them into... revealing what their argument is?


Baiting them into a bad faith discussion


By... revealing what their argument is?


No, and I'm not sure why you're purposefully being obtuse.

To be clear, they're baiting because their reply starts with "oh yeah?" which is a clear indication they are not truly willing to hear a different argument.


I think that leftists are motivated by some animosity for winners that makes them worship losers. So whatever strategy they develop tends to be ineffective in the long run. Whenever some figure breaks out and becomes effective at accomplishing some purported goal, leftists have to dis-associate with them.

Elon musk is an example. I don't think elon ever had an allegiance to the right wing, but he was basicially forced into some right wing alliance after far-left became critical of him for being a successful industrialist. It was breakup that basicially didn't need to happen if the left was more unified and diplomatic in their relations. Compare that to how right wingers dealt with their disagreements with him over immigration: it's not like the whole right wing shattered due to purity tests. Elon's worldview is essentially that of 2010s neoliberal reddit, same of Joe Rogan and whatever other figures that have supposedly "turned to the dark side".

Like for example, I think you could solve environmental problems more effectively by tricking the right wing into believing they were always environmentalists then by supporting leftist-environmental causes which have a tendency to devolve into grievance politics about natives and biodiversity and such. I think intersectionality is probably one of the worst memes spawned from leftist academia, it just feeds into attention seeking behavior and basicially prevents leftists from holding any reasonable goals within their own group.

But mostly I think the problem is like I said earlier, the emergence of control freaks. Like they try too hard to control the discussion and enact censorship, and most people see through that. It's like people who think they are smart by conciously moving the overton window to the left, but it actually invites a disproportinate response away from them. Thats how I would describe the current socio-political situation.


Cast a big enough trawl net and you'll catch a fish. No surprise there. But, you'll also destroy the ocean floor and kill dolphins. Many cars are being stopped using Flock every day. And many police officers are engaging in petty corruption, like stalking exes or doing unconstitutional searches.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: