If we are going to privilege privately operated transportation providers like Waymo with special access to streets relative to individually operated vehicles, we need to rethink whether a private company's terms of service should govern the rights and privileges of users of such services or if users should have more substantial protections.
Waymo has chosen to monitor travelers in a way that drivers of their own cars would not be monitored, while the government has chosen to ban privately owned vehicles from some spaces (like Market Street in San Francisco). This coerces individuals into sacrificing privacy and other rights.
Imagine if your phone company listened to all your calls and reported you to the police if it didn't like something you say.
And what happens when a private company like Waymo partners with a municipality to integrate into its transportation network? Is that now privately operated vehicle or part of a public space system like a sidewalk or the road itself?
Waymo is not like mass transit or even a taxi: only one group of passengers are in the vehicle at a time. Subway and bus rules don't cleanly apply. It's closer to a rental car that drives itself.
We as a society are turning to rely on or even require private companies for much of our essential infrastructure and interpersonal fabric: communications, payments (decline of cash) transportation, surveillance (Flock), places of congregation (virtual town squares), etc. Meanwhile because they are private they are not bound to privacy and other protections like the state itself.
As others have mentioned, it's really matured a lot and at this point is one of the best cloud-hosted, team-managed coding agents, when factoring overall UX, testing and QA lifecycle via its sandboxes, and its ability to be controlled with an API. We use it quite heavily.
It's coming from a different starting place than Claude Code or Codex are as individually controlled single-developer tools. Devin has been more persistent in pursuing the direction of something that operates more autonomously at the team level, as a peer. And while it might be slightly behind in raw harness ability (maybe?) it's probably ahead on the team-focus.
Yes, perhaps fair. But my point was somewhat narrow. I wasn't saying that team-managed agents are good to go for all cases and that they're better than individual dev-managed ones. Just that they have gotten better and that of those Devin has some of the better UX.
Our experience might also not be typical because we have built infrastructure around making Devin and similar agents work better. And for the record no ties to Devin/Cognition. Just pay them too much as a customer.
The key is consciously making that choice. What people don't want is to be forced into a way of living by others. People can accept what they have a hand in discovering and choosing.
Kinelo is building the "org structure" for humans+AI working together, shoulder-to-shoulder, as peers. We help coordinate tasks between each actor in a company, handoff context, and provide a voice and "seat at the table" to AI coworkers.
We're a small team, just hired our first GTM lead and a new product engineer. Getting ready to grow. We'd like to find another strong, experienced software engineer who can span everything from talking to customers to designing robust architectures to inventing new UX patterns.
We offer competitive salary and very meaningful (~first batch of hires) equity, with a founder previously exited to Apple and strong fundraising history (~$10m).
Please email us at jobs@kinelo.com in addition to applying on Greenhouse. For the engineering role, tell us how you think the job of a software engineer is changing.
I compared the writing style of Opus 5 vs Fable 5, and Opus 5 continues many of the "Claude-isms" of its 4.8 predecessor in a way that Fable broke away from.
Opus 5 still uses "carry the argument", "worth stating plainly", ", and the trap", "The X matters more", the use of "move"
If it's "read as an article" or something then yeah it's crap and Fable's current style isn't actually better than older models. For flowery speech old models are perfectly fine.
For quickly parsing the agent output, it's formulaism isn't a bad thing.
Fable's writing does have a property of going over my head, which didn't happen with earlier agents. Asking for clarification doesn't really give good results.
We've gone full circle where I once again use classical search just to look up what the fuck it's yapping about. It's much quicker and more accurate to take a glance at Wikipedia, than to ask the agent.
Could these complex/hard to read Fable outputs be sign of some kind of industrial level of intelligence, which us humans may have a hard to comprehend, while it may be also hard for machine to use simpler texts to properly outline all nuances and complexities of concepts it output?
(1) it’s not that I can’t understand their output, it’s just written in a way that is very homogenous and same-y, with very boring cliches and phrases that don’t quite match their context
(2) a pretty strong sign of intelligence is being able to explain complex things in simple terms
It's very much number 2 in my experience with it. Predominantly whenever a really advanced word or phrase is used it can be substituted for a much simpler one without losing useful context. And it seems to really prefer to use them a lot.
It's more like Claude models entirely suck at extracting key points. No matter how hard I emphasize that it needs to pick the "load-bearing" facts and claims, it cannot stop itself muttering around. It never nails the core logical structure. GPT is better at that.
If you feed Fable or Opus primarily handoff documents from a previous context instead of human written prompts and are working on something sophisticated it rapidly reaches a level where it's hard to actually comprehend for a non expert. I've received incredibly obtuse outputs that contain more mathematical formulas than English words with programming workloads.
I recently wrote a short paper with Fable, and, with some prodding, I was able to get some non-painful prose out of it.
I just found my prompt:
The writing style could really use some work. Avoid Claude-isms like "stated fairly", em dashes, "load-bearing", overly punchy phrasing like "keep the signal, govern the response". This is a technical document, not a marketing campaign.
Like "It's not x, it's y". It actually has 4 or 5 of those counter-factual, linguistic pause, factual patterns it uses.
"The [goal/ambition/etc.] is larger: statement", is another oft repeated phrase.
And then generally, it loves dramatic pauses in statements like "x exists in y; in practice z". It's the weird punctuation it uses. A massive overuse of colons and semi-colons instead of words like and, but, because, althoughy etc. that humans normally use.
Interestingly, Fable caught the gist and I didn't have to enumerate every Claudism. "Punchy" seemed to be the operative word. My new operating hypothesis is that Claude (Fable in particular) defaults to optimize for concision and "turn of phrase". If we can turn that off, the prose is way more natural.
Claude responded "The arguments and structure are unchanged, but sentences now state claims directly instead of building to a turn of phrase."
I'm OK with colons and semicolons as I tend to write that way.
Yes, these models are very good at writing code but they absolutely suck ass at prose. The prose is annoying and repetitive. At least we only have to deal with it in prompting if you're writing code.
Oh, and comments. You have to do a good amount of prompting to not get shitty 10-line-long comments everywhere.
Yes - THIS! I can't even believe how exhausting it is to read. I'm not sure why or what changed in Fable. Did they do this writing-style output to give it more token compression during/for training or to prefer output for less money?
I love it for a few things, but it's gotten really hard to spend any extended amount of time with it because of the lack of mental model I seem to be able to hold while working with complicated problems.
I'm guessing it's just not enough time doing RL on human feedback.
"Early in RL verbose, grammatical" (if you search) :
We need to understand the operator.
The 5D line element is ds² = e^{2A(x)} (ds²_4d + dx²), where A(x) = sin(x) + 4 cos(x), x in [0, 2π].
The internal coordinate is periodic.
The background is a warped product: metric g_{MN} where M,N = 0..4.
The internal direction has metric e^{2A(x)} dx²?
Wait, the ds² is e^{2A} (ds²_4d + dx²).
So the internal metric is e^{2A(x)} dx².
Actually if the total metric is ds² = e^{2A(x)} (ds²_4d + dx²), then yes, internal metric is e^{2A} dx².
vs. Post RL
We need determine eigenvalue problem for spin-2 fluctuations h_{μν}(x,y) with TT in 4d and depend on x.
For metric of form ds² = e^{2A(x)} (g_{μν}(y) + h_{μν}(y,x)) dy^μ dy^ν + e^{2A(x)}?
Wait internal metric is e^{2A} dx²?
Actually ds² = e^{2A} [ds_4² + dx²].
So internal metric is e^{2A} dx²; warp factor same for 4d and internal?
Yes.
We need equation for h_{μν}(y,x) = h_{μν}(y) ψ(x) maybe with normalization.
…
I can understand it with less cognitive load in the post-RL version versus early in RL. This resonated with my experience using Fable, especially digging hard problems; it feels like I'm reading the "early in RL" version of that model explanation.
The exhausting worthlessness of all LLM writing is so palpable that we need a new theory of the value of culture that has no relationship to the content. Back to the old Aura of the Artist arguments from the Industrial Revolution
I've found Opus 4.8 and Fable 5 both difficult to learn from purely because of how annoying their writing style is. I'm finding GPT 5.6 Sol to be much better for this.
One nice thing but ChatGPT is that good image model means it can generate good infographics occasionally to illustrate. These become naturally compact in text.
Easy enough to change. I have a Stylometry Skill fit to my preferred style—a mix of me and Terry Winograd. Give Opus 10 of your best paper thst you wrote and tell it to build a model of your style. hHard to distinguish except I make way more typos.
I know this is not "as designed," but I kind of like it? Because, as long as it stays this way, it's still at least possible to tell if a human wrote something. Like, I know it's not much, but it gives you the ability to classify information as human generated or machine generated. Machine generated information may not be useless but it is different and IMO needs to be treated with a different level of skepticism. Not that you can simply trust human writing but it seems like the type of people who would publish machine writing have a different distribution of motives than those who would publish human writing.
I do think they're gonna figure out how to fix it at some point. :(
I found 4.6 more amenable than 4.8 to style directions, we'll see how 5.0 does. Super-small-sample-size: I think part of its "Claude-ism" style comes from its propensity to try and "proactively" move the conversation/work along. Not sure how this would fare in non-obviously-productive environments, I'd guess "it's still annoying" considering your evidence.
I'm also thinking of another benchmark: (quantified) stylistic range across different prompts. Just putting it out there if anyone wants to do the work for me :D
Waymo has chosen to monitor travelers in a way that drivers of their own cars would not be monitored, while the government has chosen to ban privately owned vehicles from some spaces (like Market Street in San Francisco). This coerces individuals into sacrificing privacy and other rights.
Imagine if your phone company listened to all your calls and reported you to the police if it didn't like something you say.
And what happens when a private company like Waymo partners with a municipality to integrate into its transportation network? Is that now privately operated vehicle or part of a public space system like a sidewalk or the road itself?
Waymo is not like mass transit or even a taxi: only one group of passengers are in the vehicle at a time. Subway and bus rules don't cleanly apply. It's closer to a rental car that drives itself.
We as a society are turning to rely on or even require private companies for much of our essential infrastructure and interpersonal fabric: communications, payments (decline of cash) transportation, surveillance (Flock), places of congregation (virtual town squares), etc. Meanwhile because they are private they are not bound to privacy and other protections like the state itself.
We should rethink this direction.