HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | debazel's commentslogin

Because joining group A means you will soon be out of a job once group B out competes group A.


You seem to be the only person that got my point so thanks I guess.

I am actually pro Union but yikes the left needs to go back and actually read some Marx.


The side effect of this is also that the value of software itself has never been lower, so starting a new software business isn't very attractive in today's market.


the cost of developing software has never been lower. That is maybe 10-15% of the value in a software business believe it or not. If you can do the other 85% it's a great time to start a software business.


It doesn’t have anything to do with indexing more than one thing.

The issue with truly random IDs is that inserts are scattered throughout the B-tree index, which cause page splits, fragmentation, and poor cache locality. Using a timestamp prefix makes new IDs sequential, so inserts tend to land near the end of the index, which avoid all the B-tree trashing and improve write performance.


Yes, which means that you should probably be able to provide your timestamp to the database so it can use it for optimizing its index, rather than trying to shove it in your ID


If you did that you would also have to provide the timestamp every time you wanted to look up an ID, and now we're back to UUIDv7 again.


Sure but at least you are being honest about it. For what it's worth the database can handle this internally without you needing to hand this back but if you have a bad one then yes you should probably have it give you back a location hint that you use for future queries


How would it internally sort your index by (timestamp, ID) without you later having to provide the timestamp to locate the ID?


Sanctions force them to treat you terrible, it is the intended effect of sanctions.


Don't you say. You don't even know what was that horrible treatment exactly - didn't even ask, why would you, right? - but you've promptly explained to the guy that it was his fucking fault - he's from the sanctioned country after all, he should know his place and be quiet. You guys are just adorable, aren't you?


Look at the fuel cap, the green part of the front wheel, or the vertical frame split behind the fuel cap. AVIF smooth the details out too much.


Why do you think YubiKey would be an allowed option? Sites will require Google/Apple password manager and use this as a proxy to prevent bot accounts.


What do you do when Apple ban your Apple account?


> any tool that becomes more powerful tends to become more specialised and expensive to operate,

Isn't that exactly what is different about AI automation? AI is more generalized and cheaper to operate.


Any time big corp implements strong sandboxing they'll inevitably put the user inside of the sandbox.


That's a valid concern, but not an argument against sandboxing, in my opinion.


Sandboxing is great, as long as the user has absolute control of it and final say on what goes in and out of it. No program needs to know what else I run on my system that might go against the program creators interests. Like for instance me running a bot do the grunt work of cancelling a gym membership through their app should not be possible to prevent. Sandboxes where the system, or even worse the application inside, decide that the users wishes aren't worth respecting is an attack (that tragically often succeeds) on the user.


If AI continues to improve at the current rate for 40 years then there is unlikely to be such a thing as a career.

Manual labor and trades is likely to be one of the last things to go, so the whole "dropout of school and go into trades" crowd may have been more correct than ever, though their original reasoning was not.


> Manual labor and trades is likely to be one of the last things to go

Yes, this is likely true. Plumber & Electrician on existing construction will likely take a long time (relatively speaking) to automate. And even if we end up being able to do it, it could be that humans will be the cheapest option when it comes to a lot of manual jobs especially given that there will be a large supply of unemployed humans in many scenarios.


I wouldn't bet a single dime on that, especially with the advancements in robotics (have you seen the Chinese robots?)

Especially if the timeline is 40 years (as opposed to, say... 4.) I have no doubt AI-assisted robotics development would have solved the plumber and electrician jobs in a decade or two.


I’d say if we have robots that can install AC in any old european building, then we have reached both AGI and AGLabour.

But I’m not sure it will take 40 years. I’m quite sure Astra could figure it out, it’s just too slow and robots are too weak. The speed will improve, and robots may lag shortly thereafter but by not much. I give it 1-2 years for AI, and 5-10 years for robots tops (perhaps even quicker).


This may well be offset by the flood of people entering those trades. Likely the days of tradespeople earning high salaries will be over as well.


All a career is is an exchange of value between people. They'll certainly exist but what is valued will shift, as they have been for centuries. Basically you can't just look at what LLMs will do, but you have to also consider how that will affect the broader economy and what our response to such will be. So what happens when LLMs start to bring the value of most digital cognitive work down to something approaching $0? It will just create a large vacuum in the economy that will ultimately get filled by other things. The obvious things that will probably increase in value will be stuff done/created in the real world, creative work, and so on.

It's also quite likely that the next big era for humanity will be the space era. And that stands to create the biggest labor boom in human history. It could also happen far faster than many might expect, even moreso as there will be competition between countries, especially as those left with only terrestrial claims will see their influence relatively wane. Space jobs and industry can also, in some ways, act as a more productive Works Progress Administration [1] to compensate for any temporary economic instability that LLMs might bring along.

[1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Works_Progress_Administration


If it crashes, there will still be trades jobs but they won't pay enough to eat. What can you charge for electrical work when everyone is either broke or an electrician?


Don't you think a robot can fix your toilet as well?

Why are meta glasses such a big deal? Because they need training data for manual labor.


The challenge is not will robots fix toilets but will the economics support it if we end up with most of the world unemployed and without careers. Yes of course we can hand wave basic income and government intervention but reading the room (e.g. last 70+ years of US labor and capital trends) it’s not the most likely outcome, even if it is the most game theory optimal for all.

Realistically the outcome of highly capable advanced AI is an economic dark age more than anything else.


I read The Mountain in the Sea by Ray Nayler a couple years back. In it AIs were running ocean fishing fleets. They figured out that robots were too expensive and prone to malfunction at sea, so they would have the robots kidnap people on shore, drug them and then have them wake up on the ships too far out in the ocean to be able to escape and thenm tell them they could get back home if they work.


Humans were doing a hundred years ago in reality. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shanghaiing


We will always have jobs that require humans, they just don’t pay enough right now. Teachers, therapists, childcare, doctors, and whatnot.

And jobs that require humans’ responsibility.

People can do people stuff, machines can do machine stuff. And market will react accordingly.


It's hilarious to read stuff like this.

Robots automating everything and humans not needing to work was the stuff paradise fantasies were made of.

Sure, it would be the end of capitalism (which, I guess you could describe as "economic dark age"), but people these days have so little imagination what life outside of capitalism looks like that ideal societies sound like a horror story.


Yeah it surely is lack of imagination - not the fact that humans have evolved hundreds of thousands of years to survive in resource constrained environments.


I know, right?

Communism was a horror for multiple reasons, but two big ones were: the planners didn't have the data or ability to actually plan (the interactions in a market economy did that much better), and not doing the work you were assigned was a crime (that is, slavery).

AGI and AGLabor solves both these problems. If you don't need workers, you don't need to coerce them into work. And planning and massive data collection (and management in general) sounds like something AGI would work very well at. The conceit that the lower classes are disempowered before the capitalists never struck me as well founded.


It's ironic you talk about communism, because fundamentally this is a problem of "owning the means of production", i.e. who controls the AI and the robots.

If it's you and me, then hey, we can all live happily ever after pursuing hobbies and art, provided for by our mechanical friends, within the limits of resource availability.

If it's an AI trillionaire, things aren't so rosy. If they don't need workers, why would they even bother allocating outputs from the robots to keep us alive?

I don't doubt at all that some group or another will enjoy the fruits of artificial labour. The question is how we are going to get there, and whether that group is most people who are live today and their descendants, or just the families and friends of trillionaires.


My hope is that all wealth becomes concentrated in the hand of one person, thereby becoming worthless.

I guess one could make the argument that with enough control, a trillionaire could amass a private robot army. But I think regular humans still win (after an epic battle of course).


The AI overlords will eventually consider the majority of human lives to be worthless. Let's face it, one day we will need to fight for mere survival.


> Why are meta glasses such a big deal? Because they need training data for manual labor.

Meta glasses are a terrible example for the case you're making a point about: 90+% of whatever video they'll capture will be trash data.

It'd be much more efficient to set up dedicated sites just for producing the very same training data you're claiming they harvest.


Unlike code, with a toilet it can be very unpleasant and/or expensive if AI gets it wrong three times before fixing it correctly.


Why would you pay for a robot to do it when you could just hire one of the 20 million new plumbers (ex-developers, high school graduates, etc.) who just retrained and entered the field?


Better to train on our own adaptability, which to an extend includes an advanced understanding of personal mental health


Yes, all we know is that things will change, but we don't know exactly how. So - increase your tolerance to sudden life swifts and learn to enjoy uncertainty.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: