HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | dcminter's commentslogin

> Who, exactly?

I'm on your side of this, but there are Rust zealots out there and they're incredibly annoying.

(Edit to add:)

As a longtime Java guy (after a decade or so as a C++ guy) what drew me to Rust wasn't actually memory safety; that was table-stakes for me and Go might have lured me in if that was all I wanted. The low-cost (cognitive complexity is a cost) of memory safety was a factor, but it was the expressive type system that sealed the deal.


Which ironically has been available since Standard ML in several descendents, including Scala on the JVM, yet Rust keeps getting the glory.

Sure, but it's nice to be able to trivially distribute a binary so JVM based languages have a hindrance there. I'll set performance concerns aside as for my purposes they're usually irrelevant.

Otherwise Scala was nice in some respects, less nice in others (purely a matter of personal taste).


There have been AOT compilers since Excelsior JET back in the mid-2000's, among others in the enterprise and embedded commercial space, nowadays GraalVM and OpenJ9 are available as free beer, so paying for AOT is no longer an issue.

Scala also has a LLVM backend.


Right, but there's too much reflection in JVM language libraries for this to ever seem a very appealing option (to me, YMMV).

I'm not saying the choice is strictly rational, just that when I came across it Rust ticked a lot of my boxes and I've since then found it a pleasant language with no more than the usual level of frustrations.

I like Java too though, so draw your own conclusions.


> I'm on your side of this, but there are Rust zealots out there and they're incredibly annoying.

I mean, I keep hearing about them, and they just literally never show up anywhere I am, and I'm pretty active in the Rust community.


I dug out this example:

https://forum.qt.io/topic/142885/rewriting-qt-in-rust/10

They might not be that common but they're definitely out there, and memorable, and irritating. You can see why it colours people's impression of the community.


I skimmed the topic. This is a forum post seemingly asking an honest if ill-informed question, and it seemed to foster an interesting and informative debate about why Qt isn't a good candidate for being rewritten in Rust.

I didn't notice any toxicity from either side at all, though admittedly I did just skim.


Ok, maybe "zealot" is the wrong word, but the guy (says himself he) doesn't really know Qt or C++ but is very sure that they should rewrite in Rust.

I think that's the kind of interaction people find irritating even if you don't see it.


Yes, that's a myth.

I, like many others, still think that a language that requires a bug in the compiler for a certain category of error to be exhibited is preferable to one that has no such guarantees. I like C but it's not crazy to consider rewriting a tool in Rust for memory safety reasons.


I recall getting asked for my mail address at a UK retail electronics store some time in the 2010 to 2015 time period. They wouldn't complete the transaction without it. I walked out and bought it from Amazon UK instead. I figured if I was giving my mail address away I might as well get the benefit of the cheaper sticker price.

I've not been very sympathetic to the demise of bricks & mortar retail since then.


It's better to rely on a distant and unaccountable corporation than on the people in your community.


Ah yes, the people in my community who will try to defraud me with insurance "deals" definitely much preferable.


yeah because just like every store clerk wants to know where you live and what color your morning urine had, every neighbor wants to scam you out of your insurance.


The store I was at, Currys/PC World has a track record. No, I won't be buying my sausages and bread from Amazon, but also no, I won't trust a high volume high street retailer more than Amazon either and I may as well go to them for the convenience and lower prices.


UK too. "Realistic" was their in-house brand btw.


That was for radio & hifi kit, but they had a bunch of others.

I remember Enercell for batteries, Supertape for cassette tapes, Genexa TVs and VCRs, Archer TV/radio aerials and distribution systems, Micronta meters, and, of course, the Science Fair 200-in-1 electronic project kits.

The branch opposite my school had several "characters" amongst the staff who would amuse themselves by pelting you with dud resistors if you refused their entreaties to sign up to the Battery Club. A great place for nerdy teenagers to visit, but I can't imagine them actually ever having sold very much...


Archer and ScienceFair are familiar brands. I haven't heard of the other ones - though it probably just means I didn't buy any of those products.


Oh the memories!


Vaguely related to your offtopicism, my favourite detective fiction author was the genius behind the real life "Mustard Club" teaser campaign.

It had various marketing paraphenalia and I'm a proud owner of a membership pin (in the shape of a mustard pot natch).

Nothing to do with Cleveland or radio apparatus sadly.


What flavour of hackathon and what does "done right" constitute for you?


One hackathon project I did, we made a minigolf game what you play with your phone on a selfie stick. It was made of websockets and sshtunnels and the worlds worst python physics engine.

Another of my hackathon projects is now a company finishing up a bridge round, with our 510k equivalence paperwork submitted to the FDA a few months ago. It consisted, at time of judging, largely of powerpoint slides and burnt teraflops.

I would categorize the first as a hackathon done right, and the second as the astonishing incentives that whisper “don’t do this hackathon right”


Learning to dance a social partner dance (not a choreographed dance). There are interesting analogies with grammar and syntax in how some of dancing works.

Most unexpected benefit (perhaps predictable to an outsider, but I didn't see it coming) was getting married and moving to Sweden :)



I taught myself BASIC on a ZX81 (from the manual) at a tender age, and even I think this book is pretty niche. Amazing! I'm tempted...


FYI it's a somewhat regional or (in the UK) class stratified grammar distinction.

While nobody would say "fewer sand", "less" is in practice often used by native English speakers for both count and non-count nouns so it's not really wrong so much as it is revealing.


> is in practice often used by native English speakers for both count and non-count nouns

Alternative explanation: native speakers are wrong sometimes.

It really boils down to:

- Less + uncountable noun (money, energy, code, sand)

- fewer + countable noun (trees, cars, grains, volts, coins)

If instead we prefer to attribute it to class and say using the correct or wrong way is a class signifier and that both are correct, and that language depends on usage and there are no grammar rules really but only consensus, we can also do that. But then "Why waste time say lot word when few word do trick?".

I prefer the first explanation.

P.S. Same with "if I were" turning into "if I was". I guess usage turned that one, and that is fine too. I make that mistake often.

In Spanish these guys (https://www.rae.es/duda-linguistica/el-nombre-de-la-y-es-i-g...) also officially changed the name of "y" (i griega) to "ye". The argument: it is easier for new speakers. I will say "i griega" forever I am afraid.


There is no English Grammar Institute to tell us what is right and wrong, so English grammar is necessarily descriptive and not prescriptive.

It may annoy you, and you may be convinced that you are right and others are "wrong" but if a substantial body of people use English in a way that you dislike then it's just tough shit I'm afraid.

> But then "Why waste time say lot word when few word do trick?".

Because nobody actually talks like that, that's why.

You don't speak Elizabethan English, or Regency English, or late Saxon, or Old English, but you presumably don't think those are "wrong" - why do you think Estuary English is wrong; could it be gasp because you're in a different linguistic group? /me clutches pearls...


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: