HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | danaris's commentslogin

> Maybe it's worthwhile to remember that money and paying for things arose from the necessity of trade.

Initially, yes. But that was in a situation where (broadly speaking) people had roughly equal levels of resources, and they developed money to have a consistent way to value those resources.

Here and now, the money the super-wealthy have now represents control of those resources. You and I don't have much to offer in that context.

And if (as CodesInChaos alludes to) we are positing a future where the super-wealthy controllers of AI also have sufficient robot-power to replace human manual labor, why would they not also have sufficient robot-power to kill anyone trying to take those resources back from them? Certainly, this is the calculation many of them are already making.

It is abundantly clear that if they are allowed to continue down this road, beyond a certain point the only way back will be by overwhelming force. And if they are able to continue farther, then beyond a certain point assembling that level of force that may no longer be practical even in the rosiest of scenarios.


I think there's a very meaningful difference between relatively casual conversations like those here on HN (however much good information there is in them—and there's often quite a bit), and well-researched, structured information about specific topics put on dedicated websites.

Sure, I'll comment on HN for free in my spare time because I enjoy the interaction. But if you want me to spend 30 hours researching what the best 5 places are in Berlin to experience some specific aspect of local culture are (or, hell, even something much more specific to my own interests), then put that together into a coherent and well-presented webpage, I'm going to need some kind of much stronger motivation. Like being paid.


> it will trivially aggregate it from other sources.

Hahahaha no.

A website like All About Berlin is compiling a lot of information that simply doesn't exist in any structured way online. (Alongside some that does, of course.)

By its very nature, the Google AI Overview is eating its seed corn. It should not exist, and should never have been allowed to exist.


Precisely what AI excels at is compiling information and giving it structure. It certainly doesn’t need a human doing that for it…

When I say "any structured way", I mean things like even mentioning that the thing you saw is in Berlin.

If you lose sites like All About Berlin, then there's a very, very high chance that any given piece of information about it existing online doesn't have enough context and metadata around it to even recognize and compile it. If it's even on a publicly-available site, and not on a private forum somewhere behind a login wall.

AI isn't omniscient or magic. It can distill structure that's very dilute, but it's much, much harder for it to bring together information that genuinely doesn't have that structure in the first place and add it in.


Have you seen what AI compiles?

If AI was that good at compiling things, no one would need to do user interviews. You could just ask what features need to be built and it would do all the hard work of compiling random comments, figuring out the communities and conversations, alternate sources of info, and then figure out the answer.

That is what AI should actually be able to do. Instead, it hallucinates. I’ve asked it where a local public figure studied and it came up with a school in a different city entirely.


Well...yes. That's the problem.

There is no way to have a registrar that can guarantee they will block all actual abuses, while also guaranteeing that they will block nothing else, in a way that can be spelled out in black and white, requiring no human judgement, and no trust in them.

And this is generalisable, too. There is no way to universally specify "good" and "bad", or even "good faith" and "bad faith", in any domain, in a way that does not require human judgement, and thus trust in the ones making the judgements.

That's just part of living in a society. Either we agree, in some measure, to trust each other and work together, or we rapidly come to the conclusion that the only way forward is to code our own DNS system, registrar, and OS from scratch, and then run it only on hardware we have designed and built from scratch with our own hands. And run it only on solar power, so we're not dependent on the grid. And have it directly connected to at least a half-dozen separate ISPs, so you don't have to trust any single one of those. And... And... And...


> If the status quo is not neutral, does neutrality exist?

No. It does not. It is, and has always been, an illusion of the privileged.


Inaction inherently supports the status quo. That's not "neutral", it's not apolitical, and it's not a way to avoid ever having to take a side.

It's also not "if you're not with us you're against us." It stems from a genuine analysis of how systems work, especially systems of oppression.

No one is exempt from politics. No one can avoid being part of the system, one way or another. It's just that some people are privileged enough that the status quo supports us in ways they never ever notice, the way we never stop and think about the air we breathe. Others aren't so lucky: their continued existence is labeled by many as "political", especially if they want to be seen in public or involved in government.


> But it's obvious that nobody really cares about it after all.

That's not remotely obvious.

The push for digital sovereignty is only a few months old. Governments work on timescales of years—or even decades.

It's certainly true that it would be good if they could be a bit more responsive, particularly in this fast-paced digital age. But demanding them to be doing that already, today, is just not living in the real world.


> I just don't see much political appetite for austerity/entitlement cuts/more taxes

One of these things is not like the others, one of these things just doesn't belong...

Austerity and entitlement cuts are what we've been trying since Reagan. They haven't worked. They don't work.

Raising taxes is unpopular, sure, but a) it can actually solve the problems—not just the symptoms, but make a good hard dig in at the root causes—and b) if we do it right, only a tiny fraction of the people will have to bear those increases.

Because what we need to be doing is returning tax rates to what they were like before Reagan. Before "trickle-down economics". Before all this black magic shit that has never worked, will never work, and any actual economist with a brain and a functioning heart could tell you would never work right from the start.


Haha thanks for the unexpected Sesame Street :-)

Yeah, I'm generally onboard for higher top tax rates, some additional higher brackets, and higher tax on investment income, ideally paired with lowered rates on the lower brackets/higher standard deduction. This would hit me, but I think we need it to avoid some of the more extreme populist futures.

But we also really need to fix spending, especially procurement, the amount of wealth that we're collectively being cheated out of via terrible government contracts is staggering, there's a large network of extremely inefficient businesses that live off of the federal govt. Also, the medical system, though my understanding is that Medicare is generally getting a better deal than private insurers.


I'm fully onboard with being careful about government contracts—indeed, many of those terrible contracts are deliberately so; they're part of the corruption that's funneling money from the many to the few.

But 99% of the time, if you say "reduce spending", everyone, on both sides of the aisle, will hear "stop helping people", which is deeply counterproductive, as well as being cruel.


I think people have been trained to hear it as "stop helping people" by people who really don't want to decrease spending.

I think people have been trained to hear it as "stop helping people" by people who really, really want to never ever help anyone but themselves.

The problem is, with the way things are right now, it's basically impossible to tell how much is profit.

Profit, for various entities, is baked in at every level, in multiple ways that are very difficult to disentangle from the actual costs without getting real auditors on the ground with access to all the data.


And it's not just profits, it's inefficiencies (in the service of making profits) everywhere.

A whole ecosystem of unnecessary middlemen baked into laws and policies.

which the government is notoriously excellent at solving!

While it's probably true that no one specifically seeks to remove resiliency for its own sake, basically the entirety of our corporate world has, over the past several decades, been relentlessly redesigning everything in ways that remove resiliency. Because resiliency is almost inherently antithetical to efficiency. At the most fundamental level, if you want to make sure you have a backup of your data, that means you need at least 2x the amount of storage. And, of course, if you want to make sure you can operate even if a critical employee gets sick/is hit by a bus/goes on vacation, you need to hire extra employees.

And that's anathema to companies nowadays.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: