Only if you think that progress comes from divine inspiration in the ineffable depths of the minds of great men, as opposed to smart people applying themselves to problems using the tools they have available. A lot of new ideas aren't so much someone figuring out how to do something, as someone deciding that something is worth doing. Amazon's infamous patent on "1-click purchasing" wasn't some kind of flying car that the world would have been forever robbed of, had Jeff Bezos not been incentivized to disclose his monumental trade secret.
> figuring out how to do something, as someone deciding that something is worth doing.
I do agree that there's a logical causal chain to any idea, and that causal graph could maybe be considered as some pre-existing "truth" built grown from all the rules/constraints that exits. But, I don't think being able to explore those "undiscovered" vertices is completely about "worth doing". If you get a chance to work in a field of experts, you'll see that some are significantly better at predicting/finding those vertices. More than that, you'll find that ideas will be proposed, but their fellow, collective, experts will claim it will not work. Either way, they see the path clearer than anyone else, and put in the effort for it. To me, and the patent system, that effort is worth something and deserves to be protected. The alternative is they put in the effort and everyone just copies their work, so less motivation to put in that, sometimes expensive, effort.
Do I really "have root" if you've put an "unavoidable warning" in the bootloader that I can't remove? It sounds like you're still asserting primary control over the device and giving me a limited playground. Your suggestion is "we're going to run code you don't control on your device, and it's going to run before any of your code, and there's nothing you can do about it, but don't worry we pinky promise to only make it print a warning scolding you for wanting root."
Nah. No thanks. I want actual freedom, not a longer chain.
The point at which we are performing unnecessary surgery to remove perfectly functional assistive technology from people because of some legal fantasy is the point where we need to seriously ask ourselves whether the legal fantasy is really doing anything useful, or whether it's merely some self sustaining cancer on society.
You're not likely to physically damage a computer by running your own software on it. There's no excuse for not having an easy "reset to factory settings" and a bootloader that's hard to brick. Anything with an SD card slot or a USB port can boot from it; anything with wifi can download a fresh factory image; anything at all can have a "recovery mode" that you don't need to touch to tinker with it. Tinkering is only dangerous when the manufacturer makes it so.
A popular approach right now is to have a quadcopter arrangement on a large fixed wing, which can either fly normally or even spin to make a large rotor.
I dunno what was in a ringtone subscription. I used to work at a ringtone company, and it was $1-$3 per ringtone ($1 for monophonic, $2 for polyphonic and $3 for wav/mp3/whatever; which yeah, is more than a high quality download from iTunes... But $25/month is a ton of money.
Even with free ringtones, I'd send myself about three if I got a new phone. These days, I just keep a copy of the Nokia dubstep ringtone on hand in case I turn the ringer on, but it doesn't happen.
We keep paying ever higher architectural prices for system isolation: user accounts, memory protection, unix permissions, capabilities... and it's all for nothing, when a determined program can almost always escape its sandbox. Should we just give up and assume that all software on a machine is cooperative and non-malicious, and just do our best to make sure we don't run malware in the first place? "Defense in depth" soon slips into "don't worry too much about this layer, the next layer will catch it.
tl;dr Just run as root bro, focus on the exterior attack surface, and don't download random crap.
One silver lining I haven't seen discussed much on HN: The latest LLM agents are good at decompiling binaries, which should help detect supply chain attacks.
I suppose the next round will involve supply chain attackers including bioterror-related symbols in the poisoned binary so LLMs will refuse to decompile it.
Anyways, I'm hoping someone will create an open-source project which distributes the work of binary analysis, with binary certification and user reputation systems etc.
This would also be an excellent goodwill project for one of the big AI companies, since this whole situation is kinda their fault.
I heard a story that before there was the internet, when various defense labs with computers wanted to send data to each other they would load the data onto a drive and then send it over to the other defense lab using a truck and a couple armed Army guys.
That seems like it would still be secure. These days you could even encrypt the drive...
This is also from the era (and probably still true today) where it is easier as a mid-level dude in the Army to get an armed escort to another location than it is to get permission to mail something USPS.
How can they simultaneously argue that 1) this is a patent infringement, the entire legal basis of the claim, and 2) it is a unlicensed disclosure of proprietary technology? The whole point of patents is to disclose technology.
reply