HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | ctippett's commentslogin

Admittedly I still need to do some reading on the current ruling, but how this isn't seen as an open and shut case of vindictive prosecution (if that's even a thing for this branch of law?) is astounding. The administration couldn't have made it more obvious there was no merit to their designation of Anthropic.

Decisions by Executive Branch Agencies <> Prosecution

What prosecution? There’s no legal prosecution going on here.

You'll note that I alluded to that in the parenthesis.

[flagged]

I'm not even sure your comment warrants a response, but surely you can't have meant that as a response to my comment?

Sure did- Anthropics behavior absolutely merits their designation. Private sector leadership is going to decide how the military should act? They are shirking their civic duties, plain and simple and the use of their tech should certainly be called into question.

If you attempt a less adversarial tone with your comments you'll be less likely to get flagged and you might actually get to have the substantive discussion you're clearly impassioned to have.

Yes, anyone and everyone should have a right to refuse contracts with the government. Is that difficult to understand? If you find it difficult to understand then perhaps democracy and capitalism isn't for you.

Maybe, but only in a very idealistic, unrealistic, sense.

Could you imagine a hypothetical where we're at war and a private company has a potentially war-ending tech (nuclear weapon say) that they refuse to sell to the government?


Yes I can, and I'd lose faith in the government and loyalty and willpower to fight if that company refused and the government forcibly usurped it.

What if the private company had a vaccine to prevent a pandemic?

The job of a government is to look after the interests of the people who elected it... Is there no point that you think the rights/needs of the many should outweigh the ideological rights of the individual?


If the individual doesn't have rights, then the many don't have either for many is composed of individuals. And yes, I will have the same opinion on that private company. But morally you can see the difference between a company refusing to help in making unaided killbots vs a company releasing a vaccine?

Sure - I agree with Anthropic's position here, but at the same time it makes sense that the military doesn't want to use them, and there are certainly situations where the government needs to be given the powers to do what they are elected to do, but hopefully limited to extraordinary justified situations.

And with trumps government, I have little faith if it will be a controlled careful and limited decision.

It's absurd. Imagine Henry Ford blocking support for the US Army in the 40s

Henry Ford should have the full right to do so. The USA isn't involved in a world war now in any case. The only "wars" it is involved it right now are ones it started itself pointlessly.

So it’s involved in wars.

Show me where war was declared? If its not war then why are special war related concepts are being brought up?

So it’s only war if it’s declared war? I guess this is peace then.

I am not the one saying that.

Yes, if they think the government is going to be irresponsible with it, and their weaponized smallpox is liable to cause a global pandemic that will also kill many of their countrymen, it seems entirely reasonable for the company not to sell it, or be forced to sell it either.

In the abstract though, we're just playing the "what if" game. If a company had the nuclear bomb near the end of World war II instead of the government holding it via the Manhattan Project is a different scenario than we're facing today, and if the government in question is the USA, Ukraine, the Nazis, or Russia also makes a difference. The weapon is also hard to abstract away. AI isn't a nuclear bomb, nor is it a weaponized virus/bacteria or a chemical weapon like anthrax or sarin, nor is it simply propaganda leaflefts distributed by airdrop.


Perhaps. Good luck skipping out on paying your taxes or filling out the census

If you can only make such absurd examples then you have failed. Paying taxes are not a contract between me and the government. They are a forced fee extracted of me. Everyone should be worried about the government threatening to issue supply chain risks if they don't like you rejecting a contract with them.

Paying taxes is a tad different than being a DoD contractor.

both fall under the umbrella of civic duties

Its not a fucking civic duty for my company to be forced into entering contracts with the government. Its my civic right to tell the government to pound sand without fearing forceful retaliation.

I followed a similar trajectory for similar reasons. I was playing with wireguard around 2020 when I learned of Tailscale and since then haven't looked back.

Just the other day I was able to set my sister up with access to my Plex server and the ability to piggyback on my UK internet connection to stream BBC/Channel 4 content from Australia. It took all of 5 minutes to get it working.


Same trajectory, but I've now migrated a lot of my previous tailscale stuff to Cloudflare tunnels -- it opens up the attack vector a _little_ bit (that can be mitigated) and it's app-free (which made it viable for a lot of my non-tech users). Still love tailscale and use it all the time for remote access to very sensitive stuff (ssh).

Interesting. I've obviously heard Cloudflare tunnel, but haven't looked into beyond knowing that it exists. Was going "app-free" the primary motivator in your case for the switch?

I have a few services I've configured static routes for on my router (so my wife can access them without needing to have her phone connected to Tailscale all the time), but other than that it's never been much of a pain point.


Correct. It's not so much "modern macOS" though, it's a feature of APFS[1].

  > Most of us still think of file systems in simple terms, like HFS+. Duplicate or copy a file, and macOS copies all the data to a new storage area and makes that a different file. Thankfully, APFS is much smarter than that, and regularly – indeed, as a rule whenever it can – doesn’t copy any data at all. What it does is create a clone file, which is a bit like a hard link, in that the file record points to the same data as the original. Unlike a hard link, the clone is a separate file, with its own iNode.

[1] https://eclecticlight.co/2021/05/29/explainer-deduplication/

  > Are incidents such as this a likely side-effect of ubiquitous, low-cost, perhaps even disposable Internet hosts?

The whole write-up is excellent. I was already impressed by the author, but the prescience of this comment... wow.

Just finished watching the series. What a great show.


They show a similar level of respect to their parent company as John Oliver does his.


You surely mean his "Business Daddy"?


The Simpsons have lightly mocked their parent company Fox too.


Apparently Rupert Murdoch absolutely loves when they rip into Fox and associated assets. Married with Children used to do the same thing.

I know a few people who have met and worked with Murdoch and all have said he is perfectly pleasant to be with and has a great sense of humor, just a shame about absolutely everything else he does.


From what I hear, Larry Ellison has no detectable sense of humor. Something about a lawnmower...


I commented this only a few days ago on a different LG related thread. What LG are doing is indefensible and we should all vote with our wallets when considering a new TV... but for those who already own an LG TV you really owe it to yourself to jailbreak it and make it "yours", so to speak.

  > OpenLGTV[1] is a collective, non-commercial project for legal reverse engineering and research of LG (Smart and non Smart) TVs firmware, which is partially Open Source.
  > The main goal of the project is to improve the functionality of the TVs by adding new features, fixing bugs and providing new software.
[1] https://openlgtv.github.io


This looks old and outdated if you have anything newer than a tv from 2021 sadly


The chatter on their Discord leads me to believe there's still a pathway to jailbreaking even on the latest version of webOS. I'm still rocking an older TV so can't verify this myself, but I'd be very surprised if you couldn't still get root on a new TV.


thank you for the link!


My TV is several years old at this point, but I've never had a single ad show up on it. Telemetry is easily blocked via DNS filters and the homebrew software blocks system updates.

Modern versions of Apple TV, Plex, Disney, etc all work fine. The only time I ever watch YouTube is on the TV because it has SponsorBlock baked into it so I never see an ad there either.


Jailbroken LG TVs are the panacea of locked down spyware TVs.

Although like OP, if I ever lose the ability to run root, then that's the day I look for a new TV (lord have mercy).


I don’t think I will ever again connect a tv to the internet


I wonder how long it will be until TVs have some sort of cellular modem built in. Maybe some form of LPWAN - your TV may not be connected to the internet, but odds are there's one in range that is.


Damn... The faraday cage around my TV will worsen the picture quality.


I was playing around with LG TV homebrew a while back. Still have the same TV, and in the age of AI, I'm considering putting a coding agent to work on a dump of the filesystem to see what it'd take to run stock Linux on it.


There's an active Discord server (I know, I know...) for LG's jailbreak community and there are some incredibly talented folk on there who know the ins and outs of webOS to a crazy level. I'd recommend checking it out if you're interested in that sort of thing.


Not sure if you can post the full link but what's the /invitecode for the server? I'd actually be interested in joining since I've been interested in this


Happy to share it! The community is called OpenLGTV[1]. You'll find a link to their Discord on their website.

  > OpenLGTV is a collective, non-commercial project for legal reverse engineering and research of LG (Smart and non Smart) TVs firmware, which is partially Open Source.
  > The main goal of the project is to improve the functionality of the TVs by adding new features, fixing bugs and providing new software.
[1] https://openlgtv.github.io


> I ended up using a tool called ‘z3’. It’s kind of magical? Every time it finds a solution I get a surge of joy.

This resonates so much. I had a similar feeling after going to my very first operations research lecture. Solving seemingly incomprehensibly complex problems by framing them as a bunch of simple constraints and getting a solution seemed like such magic.


Yeah this was my experience too. I have an undergrad business degree, but got nerd sniped by an optimization problem, found a solution with constraint programming, and ended up going down a 15 year operations research rabbit hole with it.

Many people say that the way to tackle a hard problem is to break it down into smaller problems. I disagree. The best way to tackle a hard problem is to break it down into a defined search space and as many seemingly-redundant constraints as you can possibly list, then dump it all into a solver, go take a nap for a few hours or possibly a month, then come back to the problem solved for you.


Found minizinc/CP-SAT recently and I’m obsessed


z3 or constraint programming comes in very handy in at least one challenge every year in Advent of Code! https://adventofcode.com


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: