HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | csallen's commentslogin

People do this with all powerful words. They see how effective a word or a label can be in shutting down conversation, changing behavior, etc. And they say, "If only I could use that term in situation X, too, in order to get what I want." And so they expand the definition of word. And expand it, and expand it, until it applies to basically everything. Which is extremely frustrating in the interim, because it's an abuse of the word. But the word gradually loses its power as a result. Which is relieving because the abuse ends, but also frustrating because it was (in its original form) quite useful.

You see this with a lot of the -ism and -phobic words. For example, by 2020, it was common to hear even the most liberal of people saying things like, "Everyone is racist." Whereas 20 years before that, to successfully brand someone a racist could have ended their career.


One of these I always find most revealing, perhaps because it’s slightly less political than other examples, is homeless.

When an ordinary person here’s the word homeless he immediately thinks of a person sleeping on the street. But the government / activist term is far far broader. It’s intended to tie larger issues of affordability into the very publicly salient issue of people living on the street.


Great example

Then you just move once they're more expensive. They have essentially no lock-in.

Well the stock is high because shareholders have been predicting massive future growth. If a CEO is going to stabilize the price, that means they have to give investors confidence in the same or at at least similar growth trajectory. Which was aggressive.

Imagine you're about to get on a rocket ship, betting that this famous maverick rocket pilot can take you to Mars in 2 days. He already made it to the moon in 12 hours, record time. And he invented the ship, too. Then the pilot gets caught having an affair with the stewardess, gets fired before the trip, and they bring in a normal airline pilot who's never been on this ship before, never even flown a rocket ship, and who starts talking about good old fashioned normal speeds, and making it to Mars in a few years' time or so. Or, you know what, maybe just orbiting the Earth a few times instead.

You might be tempted to pass on the trip, no? And you wouldn't be the only one. Suddenly this rocket trip which had lots of passengers is completely empty, with no one to fund the trip. This so-called stabilizing force has killed the trip.


Nice analogy but there’s just one problem: it assumes arriving at mars is the end goal. But that’s not how companies seem to operate. They’re about indefinite growth. Which clearly isn’t possible and ends up killing a lot of companies as they eat themselves from the inside just to keep greedy shareholders happy.

There used to be a time when people would invest over the course of decades and enjoy the dividends they received. But these days it’s all just about the short term rewards.


Tragedy of the stock market: infinity can hit a company even if both management and shareholders are fully committed to modest long term stability (apparently this is absolutely not what happened at nvidia).

A company can get into the sights of "infinity believers" even if they try not to. Infinityists will honestly believe that the stock is a very good buy and whenever a "stability lover" has to sell, they will outbid the next stabilityist. Price goes up, it becomes more visible to infinityists and so on. Eventually infinityist will outnumber stabilityist and management will enter "or die trying" mode on promises they never made. Or be replaced.


Hmm, that was fun to read at least! I wasn't really thinking about "normal" when I said stabilizing though. I was thinking more like "I'll save the company!" but only plateauing the price and restoring, at best, a slight upward trajectory. If I owned no shares, that certainly no longer looks as attractive, but if I was all in, I'd more than welcome it!

You're entitled to your opinion, and I'm not saying I disagree, but you should be aware that it's just an opinion. You're stating it as if it's some sort of objective fact.

Many people could just say the exact opposite of your sentence, i.e. "not a disqualification" and "can still be trusted". Furthermore, These people could supply many historical examples of leaders who did similar things and went on to remain great/effective leaders of the things they were charged to lead.


>> You're entitled to your opinion, and I'm not saying I disagree, but you should be aware that it's just an opinion. You're stating it as if it's some sort of objective fact.

It may not be a fact per se, but in the United States it is widely agreed upon that romantic relationships with subordinates is a big no-no from an ethics perspective (due to power dynamics and high potential for abuse), in addition to being a serious liability for the company.


Exactly how would this constitute a “serious liability” for the company?

When a manager has a romantic relationship with a subordinate they could, theoretically, show that employee favortism and/or make their work life miserable. Now any promotion or raise or privilege or punishment the employee receives is under scrutiny. Did the Manager have any say in it? Was another employee dismissed out of hand for the position because they passed on the manager's advances? All of this is a problem when the romantic relationship is known and on the level, when its an affair it is VERY problematic. The employees involved in the affair may sue for retaliation due to some circumstance, or another employee may sue because they feel they were passed over for a promotion or position. Others might have suspected something and been made to feel their job was in danger if they asked questions.

> With all the business efficiencies we've made with computers as devs and IT, we should all be working 3 days weeks, instead a few people are so rich they can buy elections.

It's never going to work like that, and you don't need any dastardly, sinister, or conspiratorial explanations for why. It's a natural side effect of the market being competitive.

When tools and technology make people more efficient, some people take that to mean they can work fewer hours and get the same job done. Which is true. But other people take that to mean they can work the same amount of hours, and get way more done. This is also true.

In a market in which two companies are competitors, and one takes the former approach and one takes the latter, which company do you think will still be around in ten or twenty years? Obviously the latter. And that pressures people in the former group to demand more output and stable working hours so they can remain competitive.


> In a market in which two companies are competitors, and one takes the former approach and one takes the latter, which company do you think will still be around in ten or twenty years?

That is an argument of faith (that companies where employees work longer survive more than companies that optimise differently), and I am not convinced it is supported by evidence.

One could argue that all other things being equal, companies with employees doing more hours are more productive (even though I seriously doubt that, there are diminishing returns very quickly). But then I would argue that if a company drives their employees harder, there are leadership and management issues, so other things are not equal. And this is associated with younger workers (adaptable: good, inexperienced: less good), high turn-over (so, long-term information retention issues) and lower worker satisfaction (so the whole thing is self-defeating in the long term).

Besides, there are many, many factors involved that have nothing to with with working time. Again, leadership, strategy, operations, marketing, personal connections, dumb luck…

Personally I think there is an optimum somewhere, and at some point you get more out of your workers by making them more invested and motivated than making them work longer.


If we got rid of some of the greed and gave the workers a taste then maybe?

But everywhere I have seen people overworked has terrible morale and low productivity in spite of the hours.


I don't disagree with you, especially for large companies that have enduring advantages and momentum in the market. But a huge amount of market growth/disruption comes from startups. And I think it is very difficult to compete at that level without working harder than average.

This isn't entirely true, or we'd all still be working 80hrs like factory workers at the start of the industrial revolution.

I think it also remains to be proven that the company that works their employees the hardest will necessarily outcompete the others.


The 40 hour work week was the result of strikes and legal maneuvering by unions that led to labor protection laws in the early 1900s. Otherwise we would likely still be working those 80 hour weeks (alongside our kids).

It’s not necessary that the longer hours actually translate into productivity, just that the boss feels like it should.


And the fact that the strikes had a chance was largely due to improving conditions including, among other things, a working legal system that made it harder to flat out kill strikers.

Well, good organizing, too.


The answer is obviously that an overseer (i.e. the state) must enforce a floor to avoid a race to the bottom, because that argument implies then why not work 14 hours, 6 days a week. Like safety laws enforcing a common standard so companies are not out-competed by ditching safety measures, labour laws are also part of keeping the playing field fair in an competition economy.

Yet after 100 years of explosive technological growth we still have the labouring hours of the 1930s...


You can also curb greed with extremely high taxes at the top. We did it after the Great Depression, top marginal tax rate was something like 90% over 10 mm per annum.

The result was that business owners invested in their workers and long term health of their business so it would continue to give them 10 mm per year instead of trying to cash everything out every 1/4.


I don't know if it curbed greed, but it funded Social Security and the Interstate system infrastructure.

Curbs the effects of greed is probably a better way to say that.

What's wrong with it? I haven't used it, just curious to hear its faults

How many people have actually experienced a super loud data center, or a data center that's polluting their water supply, or polluting their air? To me the opposition seems to be 99% from people who are just talking about this because it's part of the zeitgeist right now.

Even the story you linked about the water supply, it was wastewater not drinking water. I'm not saying that it's good or even okay for wastewater to have bacteria in it. But if people en masse are against data centers because they "could pollute the entire town’s water supply," based on a singular case of one data center's wastewater having some bacteria, that gives me pause. This seems more like a trendy issue than a practical one for most people.


What's your reasoning? What makes Claude Code better? Genuinely curious to learn.


1. A lot of people already have Claude Code set up, and it's easier to keep using that than to install something new.

2. Lots of people are used to Claude Code's interface/commands/etc. and don't feel like paying the cost of learning something new. The benefits would have to outweigh those switching costs, and it's unclear that they do.

3. Claude Code already works with your Claude MAX subscription[0], which gives you an incredible amount of usage of the top-tier models for cheap, which can't be matched by any open-source options. And most people won't exhaust this usage, so they have no real need to use open-source models.

4. Although it's hard to 100% confirm this, there's reason to believe that Claude itself works better with Claude Code than with other harnesses.

5. There's no real lock-in. If tomorrow you decide you don't want to use Claude Code, you can just switch to something else ezpz. So there's no reason to worry that you're digging a hole and locking yourself in. Thus, there's no urgency to switch away.

[0] Yes, open-source harnesses can use your Claude MAX subscription, but does this "benefit" of open-source harnesses really outweigh the costs of #1, #2, and #4 above?


>4. Although it's hard to 100% confirm this, there's reason to believe that Claude itself works better with Claude Code than with other harnesses.

I thought this was pretty much well established that all of the labs have model - harness pairings for exactly this reason

Whale Paper. https://arxiv.org/abs/2609.00196

EMNLP talk from like 2 weeks ago https://aclanthology.org/2026.findings-emnlp.2207/


Yeah I thought so too, just didn't want to overstate it. So actually, a pretty big reason not to use an open-source harness if you're using a big lab's model.


I created hlock https://docs.hlock.ai/ to exactly tackle some of these problems: it lets you port your harness configuration across the different harnesses (open source and proprietary)


You realize this is about Cursor, not Claude Code?


I'm responding to a comment, not to article, and the comment is asking about open source harnesses, presumably in comparison to all non-open source harnesses, not just in comparison to Cursor.


> I'm still not sure why I'd pick one where I'm locked into a specific model family

I'm guessing mostly because they subsidize a lot of the costs


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: