HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | cs_throwaway's commentslogin

I wonder how many math professors think they were actively working on well-known unsolved problems. Is it just a small elite club, or is it every tenured / tenure-track professor in all R1 schools?


I am at an R1 school, I know at least 4 or 5 people personally (Profs and Postdocs) whose entire research programs were annihilated. Like they wrote grant proposals that are totally obsolete now.


UBI is politically dead on arrival in the U.S.

A lot of people put a lot of their self-worth into their work and that’s a good thing that won’t change.


UBI is investing in dividend ETFs.


There is no nice way to tell someone that you’ve scooped them, and this is industrial scale scooping.

A few papers have been retracted, but it looks like many are withstanding intense scrutiny. Lean is making the results more likely to be correct, but I think making them harder to understand.

The world has changed and you’ll know a math department is making a serious attempt to adapt when it teaches a required Lean course in freshman year.


Why do you believe that learning Lean is a better use of time when the AI is clearly better at writing and interpreting Lean than it is writing quality papers? At this point, Lean is for autoformalization, no one is really supposed to read it.


Well, you don't necessarily need to read the proof, but the proof is useless if you don't read the specification.


That's fair, but I would argue that reading the specification is very easy by comparison. A quick one hour tutorial is usually enough judging from my students' experiences.


The Lean proof to Fermat's Last Theorem is 13 mil lines.

The one for the quasi-Riemann Hypothesis is half a million.


Indeed! Almost none of these most math folks are likely to read. The only thing to read is the statement, which is only a handful of lines in both cases. The point of Lean is that if that statement compiles and is validated by hand to be equivalent to the natural language statement, then it is true. That was what I was trying to say here.


Let us know when it is clear that UCLA does not hire the candidate with the most top-tier journal papers.

It’s more likely that instead of spending a 100K/year direct grant on two PhD students, PIs will hire 1 and have the student spend 50K on AI.


More likely is that frontier labs give huge discounts of EDUs if they consent to allowing training.


Plus requiring attribution in papers.


Maybe, but I suspect that AI in maths will soon become so prevalent that it's use will be assumed by readers whether there is attribution or not.


My understanding is that top tier math programs don't hire based on journal pubs and haven't for a bit. Math journals are pretty slow and hiring is really via reputation building based on one or two big wow ideas / proofs propogated via arxiv and talks.


It’s just as unlikely that this will cease. hiring a professor at a top school because they were an excellent math teacher… It won’t happen.


Maybe someone on the NYU team forgot to opt out of “improve the model for everyone”.


If you know how to use an agent, and I do, you can have do in minutes what would take a undergrad all summer to do.

But undergrad research has always served two roles: getting my work done and the pleasure of giving the best students the chance to go beyond the curriculum, which is designed for the average student.

I think the impact of AI on undergrad research opportunities will be zero. The bigger impact is reduced science funding. I have directed lots of PhD student grant funding to undergrads who deserved it. I don’t see myself doing that in the near future.


This is a good use of TIP division funding. Whatever they were doing before seemed pointless.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: