HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | colonelspace's commentslogin

This reads like the architect in The Matrix crossed with the asshole in the bar in Good Will Hunting.

I used Claude to document the wire and firmware protocol for an expensive piece of equipment I own where the only software available ran on PowerPC OS X.

Is this just "vibes"? Maybe, but I now have a full, verified spec, against which to build software for myself, also with a little bit of "vibes".

Is this a good or bad thing?


> Is this a good or bad thing?

that is entirely dependent how accurate the spec is


that is entirely dependent how accurate the spec is

> verified spec


How much is vibe verification worth?

I'm currently teasing apart numerous ancient Text to Speech synthesizers with Sol and the amount of times I ask a follow up question that forces it to correct 5 things it's already said/documented is ridiculous.


I don't know. You tell me.

What degree of verification would make you say it's worth something?


You would have tell you. My point is that it's clearly less than a true verified spec. Even in a harmless area like mine, it's at least horribly obnoxious. Not worth too much to me because unlike you I do have papers and open codebases to study if nothing else.

But this is your unspecified expensive device. A verified spec wouldn't have you send a command or configure a table that bricks or damages it. A vibe verified spec very well might. How much is that worth to you? What are you willing to lose?


The spec was derived from disassembling/decompiling the firmware and two host applications and one diagnostic application. The firmware source C was then reconstructed, and using the original compiler/assemlber/linker a byte identical firmware build was produced.

This all occurred after recording on the wire traffic while running the equipment with the original software, against which the spec was verified.

> How much is that worth to you? What are you willing to lose?

Well, nothing is free I suppose. And I was willing to take some calculated risks in order to reach the goal of new software.


I'd say 100%, since it's a spec? what's a spec worth if we don't know how accurate it is? this isn't exactly a post apocalyptic world where even junk is valuable

I wouldnt say implementing an official spec with an llm is vibe coding.

Hard to judge though, most people are just winging it though and shoving it out the door as if its impressive.

But yes, I think its probably bad because you probably didnt learn all that much and became more reliant on Anthropic. Unless you dont care about learning, then who cares.


If it was an official spec that'd be one thing. But it's a vibed spec, too.

.


That was kinda harnessed and prompted by a team of security experts, so there's that.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: