HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | collinmcnulty's commentslogin

I think a lot of “inevitable” things have lost their air of invincibility in the last couple weeks and Google being able to shove AI to people who don’t want it is one of them.

Acting competitively is releasing a competing feature of your product (e.g. Reels vs TikTok). Anti-competitive is buying off the competition (buying Instagram). I don't see how this is a complicated definition.

There are plenty of acquisitions which I think are competitive, but the market conditions are the critical evaluation point.

Where this breaks down & this is something that the FTC needs to learn from the past (poor in retrospect) approvals and redress in the future is who the acquiring company is and how quickly they could bring something to scale which would stifle future competition.

When facebook acquired Instagram, it has ~900M MAUs and Instagram had ~30M MAUs (3-5M in just the last month or two before acquisition, accelerating very quickly). By facebook's own account their MAUs and growth rate was considered a threat, so they acquired them to remove the threat. Fast forward 14 years, Instagram has 3b MAUs and displacing them is going to be __very hard__.

If you were to apply that same retrospecitive lens to Google, they've been able to acquire Google Analytics, YouTube, DoubleClick, Android, Google Maps and others to take them to hyper scale, completely dominate a particular product space because of their existing massive user base.

Not an easy job for the FTC to get right, but (in my opinion), it is clear that the FTC have been acting on an incomplete understanding of how hyper scale companies operate, how they can influence a market with their user base etc.


> There are plenty of acquisitions which I think are competitive, but the market conditions are the critical evaluation point.

There is an easy circumstance when an acquisition is never "competitive" -- when the takeover target is a healthy business and the acquiring company is a major incumbent in the same market.

Conversely, something like Google buying Android isn't a merger problem. Google's market share in mobile phone operating systems at the time was essentially zero. They were buying it to get to market a little faster and it's very likely that if they'd built a new one instead of buying it, Android would have died and their thing would have ended up where Android is.

Because it wasn't Android's technology that won. Take the median OS and then make it free by funding its development with Google's search engine revenue and also give it free advertising from the largest advertising company. The OS isn't the reason that became one of the two major mobile platforms.

But the problem there not being the merger doesn't mean there's not a problem. It'd be the same problem if they'd developed it internally, because the issue is that it's "free" but it isn't. Anyone can "run Android" on their competing device but they can't then run their bank app because that requires attestation which requires Google. It's an antitrust problem that isn't a merger. Those are a thing too.


This is a tautology.


MIT opencourseware has an intro to finance course that was taught as the financial crisis was unfolding. I highly recommend it.


Only if you beat the fascists. Otherwise it gets real black-and-white real fast


Can we please stop giving weight to CEOs talking their book? Like of course IBM wants you to think this, it would be great for them if it’s true. And maybe it is true! But IBM’s CEO saying it’s true tells me just as much as if a frontier lab said it’s not: nothing.



Great term. Plus the related "Politician Said a Thing!" journalism


thank you, I was trying to re-find this the other day


But you know - it would be funny if somehow Open Weights are the thing that completely save IBM


Linux already served as a life-preserver for them also.


It was a brilliant move at the time for IBM, and has helped them shift their business more into providing services and support.

I imagine they are panicking a little with LLMs reducing the reliance on external companies for software support, so they are really hoping to shift it to on-prem AI, which is where the bias in his statement comes from.


I think AI could very well support a return to on-prem computing.


It’s a conversation point off which a discussion can be had


the only credible "conversation" is "well he would say that, wouldn't he?"


"we are delighted..." said a spokesman


I do not want to rain on your parade, but I find attempts to impose a coherent timeline on Zelda miss the opportunity to engage with it as a legend, a story told over and over with certain essential parts but many changing interpretations. How our very familiarity with the story creates the opportunity for surprise. There are so many fictional worlds with sprawling lore, and so few that engage with the retelling of stories and myths like Zelda does.


The games we are playing aren't retellings of the same story though. There are numerous sequels for one. Second the concept of a timeline isn't just in Hyrule Historia, it's referenced in the games themselves; for example the hero of time in Twilight Princess and Breath of the Wild.

It's loose, but it's there. These are separate stories, retold many times or not, and the cyclic nature of the battle for the triforce is established game lore.

I believe it's also misleading to say Nintendo doesn't care about the timeline stuff. They care but also make a conscious decision to keep it light and not overly bound or caught up in it.


This is what I mean. The cyclic nature of the battle in game lore is itself the series engaging with the concept of legend. The characters and the player both have a vague concept of the legend but not its exact contours this time around.


I agree, but Nintendo greatly damaged opposition efforts to timelining by... endorsing one. In an artbook, of all places.


Eh, even before 2011 with the official timeline and the Skyward Sword prequel-to-all-games, there was plenty of textual content to support a timeline.

AoL was a sequel to LoZ. ALttP was a prequel to LoZ. LA was a sequel to ALttP.

OoT is explicitly a prequel to ALttP.

OoT splits into at least two timelines. MM explicitly follows the child Link who preempted Ganon's ascension. WW explicitly has you fight the Ganon defeated by adult Link. TP explicitly places itself as a sequel to the "child timeline" and so also a sequel to MM.

The only games which lacked an explicit placement to the rest were the Four Swords series and the Oracle games. Not small exceptions, but exceptions none the less, and that's only if you ignore interviews. (And interviews would give you Minish Cap preceding Four Swords preceding Ocarina of Time.)


Junk ratings are not investment grade. They’re rating this debt as at least a little bit sketchy.


From the article:

"The rating action, which has not previously been reported, shows Anthropic is close to achieving the investment-grade status that would allow the start-up to lower its borrowing costs and tap a wider pool of institutional investors including life insurance companies and pension funds.

Bankers for Anthropic and rival OpenAI have lobbied the largest rating agencies to grant the AI labs investment-grade ratings once they go public."


The fact that the only rating published is ‘junk’, and that it was from a small agency tells us quite a lot. Given the fact that Anthropic (or its representatives) likely ‘shopped’ for a rating means that this was the best anyone was willing to give them, and that the larger agencies probably refused to rate them without more information. I would have been surprised if the bankers hadn’t lobbied for the highest rating possible, as higher ratings increase their profits from the IPO.


The whole point is to slowly build credibility, starting with easily $wayed small ratings entities, then launder that credibility into a slightly larger one, rise and repeat until financial disaster.


Anthropic is planning an IPO and this is information investors would like to have.


If you declare bankruptcy, your creditors absorb whatever losses are unrecoverable. So it would depend on who is lending them the money.


If the people in the US get watched and silenced, how will they effectively pressure the govt to not bomb children in the Middle East?


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: