HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | codedokode's commentslogin

There should be no need for hacking. If there is a right to repair, there should be a right to reprogram any computer - and penalty for implementing measures to prevent re-programming. Right to reprogram also means that the consumer gets a choice of firmware instead of being forced to use inferior factory firmware with limited capabilities and creates a possibility for firmwares market. Also reduces electronic waste.

Everybody except capitalists wins with right to reprogram.


Automation doesn't require connecting to Internet.


It will typically require some kind of network. And the person managing it will need access to that network.

It’s hard running that type of network securely, and costly to run it alongside a normal internet connection.

Cheaper to just use the internet connection and squint a bit at ‘securely’.


Is it really that hard to isolate some devices from the internet on an existing network?


They are all being sold on the idea of granting external access to a cloud application so that a third-party contractor can know when the system goes into disarray and pay for one less maintenance guy's salary.

Could the same thing be done with SMTP way more securely than opening up your firewall to some random AWS EC2 instance? Yeah no doubt.

Do you think grocery retail execs actually understand computers past Microsoft Word and Excel? I report to one, they can barely listen to me say the word WAN failover.

Like all things in IT, experience is the best teacher. Organizations will fail to invest in their technology, security included, and only then will the execs start to trust that the wizards in the backroom are telling them truths instead of asking for new toys - if they're lucky enough to still be the same exec that heard they should take security seriously before the Bad Thing happened.


In that case it's just a tradeoff between convenience and security, it isn't because it would be too technically difficult to isolate the systems. Whoever installed them could isolate them if there was no reason for them to be connected to the internet. I doubt most grocery store managers understand the precise engineering behind their freezers either, but they still buy them.

Very likely they were sold on these internet-connected systems without being told about the drawbacks, which is sad.


The people selling the systems often don't fully know the downsides themselves either and in a sense they're incentivized to not know as it makes it easier to sell the lie that there are no drawbacks to having your HVAC system exposed to the wider web. But you are also overestimating the average skill of an IT person in these environments and the capacity for their IT or MSP team to step back and evaluate the security of all the systems they have to manage. There's only the ability to evaluate convenience vs security if you actually have the time to formulate the question - if you're drowning in ticket submissions you will likely fail to properly catch every such issue. Certainly for these larger EU corps they should have the capacity to make those determinations, but who knows exactly how the management of these systems were delegated. My bet would be it was the responsibility of an under-resourced team with too much to do already.

I'm catching issues as I can as the head of IT at an org replacing our Danfoss systems with something else, but it wasn't until about 1.5 years since the initial decision to replace them that I'm finding out from a sub-contractor of the contractor that there's a cloud app our HVAC network will need to talk to - which is not-so-funnily enough a requirement by the state for us to receive associated grant funding for a portion of the new system cost. This was never mentioned to me at all as the head of IT. It's not even a convenience vs security issue, it's a misaligned corporate communications and approval channels issue. In other words, the capacity to secure your technical systems is downstream of political organization.


I never said technically difficult - as in impossible. Just harder. And more costly.

It’s more costly to do it properly, so most don’t.


> They are all being sold on the idea of granting external access to a cloud application so that a third-party contractor can know when the system goes into disarray and pay for one less maintenance guy's salary.

Even in that case there is zero reason for the devices to be reachable from outside the network rather than the devices reaching out to known hosts only.


that is harder to manage, and more brittle. hence more expensive. that is the reason.


Wow lots of supermarket managers on hn today


Supermarket managers got hacked today. Maybe they should take that as a hint to listen to others.


> On the bright side I'm sure the manufacturer

I initially misread it as "On the bright side, I'm the manufacturer..." (and earn a nice profit).


And centralized food destruction.


Those devices should be connected to air-gapped local network and not to manufacturer.


You don't seem to understand what these systems do at all. Air gapped takes about 80% of the usefulness away.


By the way, Soviet refrigerators are immune to this type of attacks.


because they are empty?


Obviously, because they cannot be controlled over Internet. Also, some consumer Soviet refrigerators are still operating, they were made pretty reliable because one could not easily replace one.


What genius decided to connect a fridge to the Internet? Make him pay the losses.

By the way similar thing might happen to geniuses buying Internet-connected cars.


Here in the UK, there's a £500 subsidy for home EV charge points... but only if they're connected to the internet.

What could possibly go wrong?


"What could possibly go wrong?"

The grid could stabilize as a side effect. And the cars are already connected to the internet.


people who like saving money decided to do this. For simple monitoring purposes. When you have thousands of fridges you want to know how their doing and you don't want to sent a person to inspect each one of them.


You could connect to an on-premise server. As a bonus, the manufacturer cannot disable them and extort money in this case.


They most likely are. Third party techs then access them over Citrix or VPN/RDP. There could be some cloud portion that aggregates data or pushes policies and schedules as well.


If the only usecase is monitoring, then why make the fridges anything else but report-only?

No firmware updates. no admin configuration. no ssh backdoors. just a transmit-only system


because the report code might have bugs


If it were transmit only, you could put it behind a data diode and buggy report code wouldn't matter. Even better, validating the code is a lot easier if it doesn't accept attacker input.


Monitoring requires one-way announcements, not bi-directional connections


Please find me a new car that isn't Internet-connected, genius. You're assuming consumers have a meaningful alternative.


Russian car mechanics know how to "unlock" Chinese cars that operate only within China and require a Chinese SIM card (they are sold locally at lower prices, so some people find it cheaper to buy a car in China and unlock it). Finding and disabling modems is definitely an easier task and can be done.


Turns out it's mandated by law in the EU too


Do they check modem presence regularly or you can rip the modem and show a middle finger to surveillance state?


This came up on HN somewhere, and the answer was that insurance will decline claims if the modem wasn't in at the time of a crash, so it's risky not to have it. That and you fail inspection, but that's of course easier to work around.


Wait till they'll mandate other things done to you via your car via the internet. ALl in the name of protecting you and the kids of course.


They will. First step, the government creates the mechanism, second step, adjusts the rules.


Easy, go to the used lot and get one of the remaining actual cars before they become collectible antiques.


Buying a car is the easy part.

In my experience, new cars have new car problems, but old cars have old car problems.

There’s no clear winner in every metric, just trade offs.


The lesson is, always expect to be paying to maintain your vehicle.


>new


Slate says “any minute now!”


It sounds like you are victim blaming. I apologize in advance if I interpreted you incorrectly.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Victim_blaming


Yes, I always find it very useful to condemn the mosquitoes when someone is bitten. If they aren't heartily condemned, they will be legitimized and emboldened.

The evil victim blamers say "why was she wearing that short skirt?" They don't realize that the mosquitoes are sexist, and that we can and should eliminate all of the mosquitoes so she can wear what she wants.


We can and should eliminate all of the mosquitoes. Especially the female ones.


No, we should not. Only those who bite humans and carry disease. (The vast majority does not)


Mosquitoes are not needed in the city. They can fly as much as they want in national parks.


Until we do, I'm going to continue to blame you for being bitten.


> t sounds like you are victim blaming.

It sounds like you think victims are necessarily blameless.


Gallipolli, 1915:

"Hey, maybe we shouldn't send men over the top only to die in a barrage of machine gun fire..."

"That's just victim blaming--it isn't our behavior that needs to change; it is the enemy's behavior that needs to change."

Victim-blaming is another term that is apparently becoming a meaningless vibe.


Offtopic: I only see "genius" used these days to describe an idiot. I guess this is how words change meaning over time. At some point in the future being called a "genius" will always be seen as pejorative.


I don't think the definition is changing at all. To me, we've just lost the ability to comprehend sarcasm.


That's because calling an idiot an idiot plainly is apparently considered uncouth and attracts downvotes, flags and downvotes often mean oblivion. In fact you will find do-gooders chome in with "be civil" but you flip the word and it's all kosher. The thing is all of us do and say idiotic things. So that makes a bit tricky indeed.

> in the future being called a "genius" will always be seen as pejorative.

If you are not a genius and someone calls you a genius, well, for you the future is already here, genius! (Shit I didn't really mean that :P)


There should be a name for this style of speech, using "good" to mean "bad".


There’s a lot of this in African-American vernacular. I’m not exactly sure what a “bad bitch” means but I believe it means attractive whore, but does it or does it just mean a good woman? Either way that’s two traditionally negative terms that seem to be used positively.


Irony? Camp? “genius is a camp - so good that it’s bad”. “In the sentence ‘this is the sh1t’, ‘sh1t’ is camp - so bad that it is good”.


Semantic inversion or contronym


Sarcasm


just like 'Nimrod' becoming an insult



Genius take!


The reason is easy to see: it would mean that Russia lost the war which is a disgrace. On the other hand, if the war is continued there is a chance that Ukraine will have to make a deal at Russian terms and remove its army from the disputed regions which would be a victory.


In 2023, the government told Prigozhin, a head of a private military company Wagner, that he must transfer the command of his units to the main army. This resulted in Prigozhin taking his army from the frontline, capturing the headquarters of Special Operation in Rostov, and marching on Moscow. During march, they shot down several planes and helicopters which were trying to stop them. At that night, several private jets were urgently leaving the capital.

So, mistreating veterans might not work out as expected.

More details: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wagner_Group_rebellion


How did that end for Prigozhin? Where is he now?


He made a deal (not public) with the government, he leaves Wagner and gets out of Russia and the government leaves him alone. 2 months later a private jet with Prigozhin and several Wagner commanders exploded in the air in Tver Oblast, not far away from Moscow. There is video online of the plane breaking apart and falling if you search hard enough.

The deal seems to not work out.

I think there were no official explanation for this incident, propaganda posts explain that they were using drugs and playing with a grenade onboard.


As I understand, Nebius is tiny compared to Yandex in Russia which has: a search engine, maps, an ad network, a taxi, a bank and contactless smartphone payment system, food delivery, with autonomous delivery robots actually operating in Moscow/SPb and not prototypes, a cloud, Amazon-like services, etc. Nebius has nothing of similar scale.


Doesn't seem tiny?

Nebius market cap is 57 billion.

Yandex is 65 billion.

Nebius focuses on AI infrastructure worldwide, Yandex focused on being a Google competitor in Russia ( if it survives it's DC's being destroyed).

Russias GDP is basically Italy.


Yandex robots are driving around Moscow and SPb delivering food to people. Where are Nebius robots? "AI infrastructure" means just that they rent out GPUs they bought for themselves and did not find a use?

Comparing GDP means nothing. Having larger GDP doesn't mean the country is stronger, it is just a number.

Also in this case, you are comparing not the GDP (actually produced goods and services) but a "market cap" which is a virtual number calculated by price of one share multiplied by share count. Yandex shares, I assume, cannot be traded internationally so the number means nothing. Yandex has a public report where one can find out their revenue.


Companies are valued on their potential. Yandex growth was 70% last quarter, Nebius was 454%. Nebius makes deals with Microsoft, Meta, ...

While Yandex could go bankrupt very soon ( 2-3/5 dc's closed, apps not working, robots not working, payments not working, maps show everyting in rivers and oceans, ...).

Nebius is currently going after their best growth driver. Can't blame them.


Comparing GDP, the market cap and other financials make way more sense than judging companies by how many separate projects and directions they have their spoon in.

Sometimes it's better to diversify, sometimes it's better to concentrate. There is no better decision to concentrate than to do it during the AI hype.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: