HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | cmiles8's commentslogin

After yesterday, OpenAI looks like they’re toast. When the current cash runs out it’s going to get very ugly there.

Microsoft has still some cash from decades of office 365 subscriptions.

Anthropic has been on a nose dive since the start of trading. At this point almost everyone that bought ANT since the start of trading yesterday has lost money.

Thats not exactly helping to shake the reputation that this IPO was an attempt to offload this thing to “dumb money” and GTFO.


The money is not lost until the share is sold.

It is though. Because of the opportunity cost if nothing else.

This is the way

This is printed on the bags one's left holding.

The cat's not dead until we open the box. Schrödinger's share.

IPOs historically heavily underperform hence the saying "It' Probably Overpriced". The market is selling off today so high beta stocks fall more than the average.

What I want to say is that the move is expected and has nothing to do with dumb or smart money in ANT specifically.


> The market is selling off today so high beta stocks fall more than the average.

Alternatively, ANT dropped because its value dropped, contributing to the market being down, both directly and indirectly. People thinking "if anthropic isn't worth as much as we thought, other stuff probably isn't either".


You really over estimate how much "people" matter in the stock market. You know what matters? Indexes, 401k, wealth funds, large institutions. You know what doesn't matter? A bunch of people buying/selling ANT. Look at every single IPO that was popular every, everyone of them has a price action of GME. They eventually get indexed, just as ANT will and the float will increase and the price will probably still look closer to TSLA, because it's a volatile industry based on "possibilities" rather then "probabilities".

I have also heard of the IPO dip you are mentioning. I would want to see some historical data to determine if this sell off after IPO is normal or abnormal. The decline doesn't seem to fit the pattern I recall being discussed but I don't know about the rebound time. I think their debt commitments are just out of sync with their income. They are looking at exponential increase in capability, exponential increases in compute needs and just tried to eye-ball too many exponentially growing trends and are now in a pickle. I think they assumed they would have created such value by now with some novel discovery, that they would be able to cover their checks. They are pretty close, just a few dozen billion dollars or so, so like if they could figure out how to capture just like 10% of a few markets with their tech, or get some ANT-drug blockbuster on the market, they should be golden. I think they have a hard deadline in front of them and are working hard to beat it.

I wouldn’t characterize a 22% decline from the start of trading as “expected.”

There’s folks out there sitting on sizeable paper losses on Anthropic now.


ANT is currently trading at a low for the day. Literally every single person that bought Anthropic after the start of trading has now lost money. Let that sink in.

If that’s not the definition of “dump this thing on dumb money and cash out” then I don’t know what is.


The valuation is what the shares trade at, and yes the market is current very irrational. You’re not wrong to call out that by any sane measure a more realistic valuation is a small fraction of where it’s currently trading.

Most folks in finance I talk to think a realistic valuation backed by actual math is likely around $400-500B. Now that the investment bankers got their payday for this hype fest, expect numbers in that range to start coming out from analysts at the big banks.


400-500 billions when? Because if they think that’s the right price in the near term they would be crazy not to short. Otherwise that’d be just their opinions. I’ve heard plenty of other price point.

Well somewhat ironically the main job AI now makes mostly obsolete is SDEs. Impacts elsewhere are much less clear. So folks will have jobs, but most of the SDEs of the world will likely need to find new jobs.

It’s been dropping ever since the first trade and appears to be down at $1.26T now. The fact that just a few weeks ago folks wanted $2T plus tells you how far off the original valuations really were.

And with this now below where OpenAI has been trying to value itself on the private markets that doesn’t bode well for OpenAI. If I was at OpenAI I’d be very worried about the picture today paints.


As someone who is not very well versed in this area - is there a requirement for OpenAI to IPO? Could they just go on as a private company and be fine or is there some sort of forcing function at play?

Investors would want returns.

Employees would want to cash out.

If there is no exit in horizon, employees look for better ventures, and new funding may be hard to come. New funding (debt or equity) will be needed if cash flow is negative.


Isn't the main reason so they raise money so they don't go bankrupt, private investment is running dry.

> Investors would want returns.

> Employees would want to cash out.

Oh where are the times when you invested because you expected dividends and employees were being paid out for performance in yearly bonuses...


Angels and VC use the pejorative "lifestyle business". But your own tidy business is a reasonable path to wealth.

Angels may be very open to the idea of dividends. VCs are apex predators who eat loan sharks for breakfast.

Angels and Dividends has not been a happy path IME. They also want the big return and clear path to exit.

'May' is doing quite a lot of heavy lifting.

I thank my lucky stars the company I work for does just that. We're most vested in the company and the more so the employees. Times however had changed and greed is easier.

Mostly tax treatment. Dividends are taxed as income, increases in value are taxed when you sell.

> Dividends are taxed as income

Not if the dividend is a return-of-capital distribution. This is common in REITs to hack around the taxation issue. It reduces your cost basis, so you essentially trade off income tax now for capital gains tax later.


RSUs are employees being paid out for performance, and dividends are not tax efficient. RSUs + increasing stock price is better for employees.

Yeah but these are concerns after the IPO.

I don’t understand, RSUs and stock options require a publicly traded stock to be valuable.

Exactly, but this thread is talking about what happens when a stock isn’t publicly traded (“no exit in horizon”).

Indeed. Now it's just a matter of finding someone to hold the bag. Turns out it's the rest of us!

If you invested you took a risk. Sometimes you bring home bread. Sometimes you are left holding an empty bag.

I think if Anthropic's valuation holds up in the public market, OpenAI could remain private. If ANT starts dropping then OAI insiders will feel like they need to cash out quickly.

Wasn't OpenAI a non-profit (hence the name)? How do they get to do an IPO?

They had a somewhat complicated structure where a non-profit with lofty goals was nominally in control of the for-profit entity and had the ability to kill it if that seemed to be the in best interest of humanity.

Long story short, the board briefly fired the CEO Sam Altman because they were starting to eye that kill-switch and they didn't have confidence that his leadership aligned with the the non-profit's mission.

Then a few days later OpenAI and its employees decided that, no, actually they like the money that Altman seems to bring in and they hired him back. If one were being charitable maybe there's an argument that the money is important to implement the ideals, or, maybe now that there's a competitive LLM marketplace, bowing out wouldn't accomplish anything. Regardless, now it's just a bog standard Valley company which is partially why they can IPO. Maybe not in a strictly legal sense (it's a PBC now, which the FAANGs are not), but functionally. So it goes, so it goes.

I could be distorting some things. I'm only passingly familiar with the details of the matter. Feel free to correct me if this seems substantially inaccurate. Cunningham's Law and all that. ;-)


The only article about it I read at the time claimed Sam's ousting was part of a takeover attempt by Microsoft, and Sam coming back was somehow MSFT being thwarted.

Perhaps both your rendition and the MSFT thing are sympatico but it's confusing to me at the moment.

Having two wrong answers surely will kick Cunningham's Law into overdrive here... one can hope, anyway.


During the window when Sam was ousted, Satya offered to hire him and any OpenAI employees he wanted to come work at Microsoft - it wasn't really a takeover attempt, at least not publicly.

I asked the Google AI about it, essentially I was interested why FAANG didn't scoop up the AI labs when they were small, an the AI said this was the reason why OpenAI was started non profit and Anthropic went PBC. As long as they were non profit they could not be overtaken. Not sure if that's actually true, but I interesting theory.

OpenAI was founded specifically to prevent Google and Google alone to achieve AGI. It definitely would not sell itself to Google no matter the price. Anthropic did court Google as an early investor.

Google owns more of Anthropic than floated today — about twice as much. Amazon owns more.

That's old news.

They managed to trick a judge into breaking open the charity and making it a for profit company.

Like imagine if the dogs trust just got a judge to let the management turn it private. Think of how much money they could steal.


"public benefit corporation" which means practically nothing

Probably the third word of that description is correct.

Just the AI version of "don't be evil". How did that turn out?

All smoke and mirrors.

Plenty was written on their "transition" in the past.


In theory, if your company is massively profitable, you could stay private and give your employees enormous yearly bonuses--"dividends".

But that rarely (never?) happens, especially for high-growth companies like this because they're investing their revenues in growth.

I'd say HN is split on whether ANT's growth will lead to massive profits in the long run.


While a company can get away with not booking big profits (if it reinvests its cash from trading profits), a company can’t survive for long with negative free cash flow. Before long it simply can’t pay the bills and make payroll.

A lot of folks point to Amazon and say “but they weren’t profitable for ages and look at them!” But the difference is during that time Amazon focused religiously on free cash flow. It was printing money during the growth years and just choosing to reinvest it. AI companies are black holes for cash and they keep having to raise cash from the outside, which is far riskier proposition.


> AI companies are black holes for cash and they keep having to raise cash from the outside, which is far riskier proposition.

Earlier this summer, I asked ChatGPT if it could justify the ~$1 trillion valuations for OpenAI and Anthropic.

Its response was that maybe Anthropic could grow enough to eventually justify $1T, but it was highly skeptical of OpenAI.

Take that with a massive grain of salt, but I thought it was interesting.


I think Stripe follows the model your describing while still being private FYI

> is there a requirement for OpenAI to IPO?

Strictly speaking? No. But the people who shoveled money into it want an offramp, and that's what the IPO is. So for all intents and purposes, yes they need to IPO.


Correct they can stay private, but the private markets are drying up. They’ve been struggling with their last raise and they need more cash badly. So at some point going public may be the only way to get the cash they need to pay the bills coming due.

Today did not look like a good signal, but I'd interpreted it as suggesting OpenAI likely never getting to IPO, restructuring, coming out the other side looking like someone's subsidiary or as a sort of shared AI utility company owned by multiple hyperscalers.

You think the circumstances still suggest they have to do it?


Honestly it looks increasingly unlikely OpenAI can go public. It seems more likely they’ll get acquired by some big tech outfit. Investors will get some or all of their money back. Employees mostly get screwed with their equity being worth little to nothing and the buyer gets the IP.

An Nvidia/Microsoft joint venture?

No requirement, no. The question is whether OpenAI can secure necessary funding without going public.

They shouldn’t need funding if they’re a stable business that makes a profit.

By stable do you mean profitable?

I'm not here to defend companies running a loss and asking for investors/handouts, that's for sure. It is worth noting, though, that its common for companies to raise funding before turning a profit.


Then they'd lose to the business that raises funds and spends more than its profits.

That's a very simplistic take. These companies may have revenue, but that revenue and even more is needed to develop the next generation of models. Model generation is extremely hardware and energy intensive. The revenues, high as they are, do not cover that.

Sure, if they were making money.

They aren't. They depend on investment infusions to continue to function because they don't have a product that they can sell profitably.

Normally, this is seen as an impediment to gaining future investment. Rational people still think that way.


You need to invest money to make money. That’s always been true for any business. The question is for how much, in how long, and what the return would be. For something without precedence such as AI nobody knows the answer. You are either right or wrong. There is no rationality in this case.

The problem I consistently seen here on HN though is folks not understanding the difference between “investing to grow” by using your cashflow vs via investor money. Burning cashflow and thus not being profitable is fine. Literally having no money and constantly borrowing or asking for more is not.

It’s uncharted territory to have companies of this size unable to produce positive cash flow and seeking continual infusions of cash just to avoid going bankrupt.


I vaguely recall Facebook being required to go public because they had over 500 investors

They got rid of that law to fleece retail investors.

I believe you can also just fulfill the reporting requirements of a public company without going public if you have more than 500 investors.

> ...or is there some sort of forcing function at play?

Yes. They need to find a bagholder before the bubble pops.


> Could they just go on as a private company

No? What comes after a pump is why

/s


because of obscure details of how this particular IPO works, $83 ~= 1.4T, so now having closed at $97, it should be worth 1.75T. Yahoo finance et al do not have the correct number of shares.

That’s including many to-be-created shares for employees when options open up. So technically Yahoo etc is correct. The higher “valuations” assume the market won’t discount that valuation when that future shareholder dilution occurs.

The higher valuations are a bit of funny AI bubble math as most companies have future theoretical shares outstanding and nobody includes those in the present market cap number.


But if the market "knows" this dilution is coming, why not price it in now?

That said I'm in the camp of "how does it matter?"


Because what cannot be priced now is how much selling pressure that dilution will create.

If you're a buyer, you'd think people who get issued those options will hold them instead of selling. And you'll also assume that for the options that do get sold, there will be buyers at the same price you bought, if not more.


1) nobody really knows how many shares actually get created. Depends on a lot of factors so it’s a guess at best.

2) Many companies have this situation where there will likely be future shares issued. But the math on market cap is simple… number of current shares times price. Thats how it works.

This nonsense of “but but if you include this other thing and then assume X it’s higher!” is just made up nonsense math said by folks that wanted the number to be higher. You could do the same funky math for most companies but again that’s just not how “market cap” works.


i thought the market cap number is wrong (at ~1.27T) too, given that the stock ended the day higher than its initial price. it really market cap really should be substantially higher than 1.4T but every where it's quoted as 1.27T. what's going on? am i missing something

The higher numbers are assuming additional shares that don’t yet exist will come to market but somehow not dilute existing shares or cause the price of existing shares to drop when folks start selling these shares that don’t yet exist. All that is A) wishful thinking at best, and B) not actually how market cap works.

The current market cap of the company in so far as the collective value of all actual shares is around ~$1.27T. Thats the generally accepted value of the company now that its publicly traded and yes that is much lower than they were reportedly originally hoping for.

It’s more of a problem for OpenAI though as that’s lower than where OpenAI is trying to value itself now.


1.4T is the post-money valuation

You are confusing different numbers. The $1.1-2T range being discussed prior to IPO was the fully diluted valuation which includes employee shares. As of close, that valuation is at $1.76T. Significantly above the opening IPO price. Usually the gap between market cap and full valuation is MUCH smaller, so we don’t discuss it, but Anthropic has awarded unbelievable amounts of shares to employees.

I can't edit my comment above and I think it's not clear so let me try again.

Trading Point Fully Diluted Market Cap Opening $2.022T $1.474T Intraday Peak $2.088T $1.522T Closing $1.762T $1.285T

To be clear, market cap and full value closed DOWN on the day. However both figures remain comfortably within the desired and forecasted range. Most analysis discussed the fully diluted figure prior to IPO. There is a large and unusual gap between diluted and market cap.


The actual market cap peaked at $1.5T

But a day later (November 20) it already dropped to slightly above 1.1T.

From an Anthropic perspective, this is a pretty big win. They raised more than they expected, so now they are less likely to flame out based on their debt commitments. Sure, it looks bad for the AI trade but I'm pretty sure that doesn't matter to Dario (might to a lot of their staff, though).

> It’s been dropping ever since the first trade and appears to be down at $1.26T now

The chart of the stock price is so ridiculous, it has a straight 45 degree-ish angle line from a fake “prev-close” for some number from “yesterday”, all the way up to the opening price, and right after that, it drops, then stays flat afterwards but sliding

And so, even though it’s been steadily dropping since open, because there’s a much lower “previous close”, then it’s still shown as a big gain for today (+17.7% !)


IPOs will almost always start trading higher than the IPO offering price. If they don’t the banks have royally fucked up the IPO and the underwriters are generally prepared to buy the stock to make sure the price is propped up at the start of trading.

The steadily decline once trading started isn’t great but it will take a week or two for a realistic price to settle. Theres so few shares actually trading right now that it’s just the same shares flying around in circles at the moment.


$83 is what they priced the IPO at (this is what you paid if you purchased IPO shares via your brokerage). The straight line is because it didn't start trading until almost noon so there are no data points for the first part of the day. The price immediately shot up to $111, then fell to close at $97. So it really did close up 17% on the day.

So, already quite a few bag-holders?

Might be the last hurrah for tech IPOs for a while.


Night be or might not nobody. Nobody knows

I think today will be the “jump the shark” moment for the AI bubble. Anthropic will go down in history as managing to get to the exits just as the doors were closing, and for everyone else that’s still private from this point forward it’s good luck and Godspeed.

Yep. They rolled themselves under the garage door just in time. But they had to choose between saving themselves and saving that huge bag of swag that wasn't going to fit.

No. They sold a very small number of their shares.

If this is the end of AI trade (a ludicrous idea for me), then Anthropic absolutely didn’t make it.


The markets do not seem positive today on the idea that the AI trade is going well, if you look at the datacentre-business-related stocks: Sandisk, Coreweave, Nebius, Micron etc. all losing big, Oracle and Nvidia continuing to slide pretty quickly.

(Whereas Apple and Google — companies with device-focussed consumer AI — are OK)

Yesterday you could explain away the sell-off by saying people were selling stocks to buy ANT. Not sure what the explanation can be today when ANT is falling and has twice got within touching distance of its IPO price.

Re: a small number of their shares: worth bearing in mind that Amazon and Google between them own 28% of Anthropic.

It looks to me like the market thinks the music is about to stop.


Anthropic just made $81 billion dollars from this IPO, that's a pretty huge bag of swag in my book.

For comparison, Google's IPO raised $1.6 billion.


It’s a massive number for sure, but so is their cash burn. It won’t last for long and they’re going to need more cash and fast. If they get a junk bond credit rating, and general consensus seems to be they will, it’s going to be very interesting to see how they try to navigate that.

Seriously? You’re comparing it to a company that IPOed 22 years ago?

$1.6 billion in August 2004 is worth ~$2.85 billion today.

Adjusted for inflation, Anthropic raised 28 times more than Google.

It's a logical fallacy to suggest it's silly to compare them.


It is not silly to compare them, but the comparison is not very favourable to Anthropic once you put the two sums in context.

Anthropic will burn through the amount of money they raised (by selling between 5 and 7.5% of the company) in twelve months — on their immediate commitments for next year ($70B or so) and their projected losses for Q4 2026 alone (over $12B).

They are loss-making, and while they have a pretty pile of investor cash, they have hundreds of billions of dollars of future commitments; their commitments until 2030 are about three times the size of it, I think, even if you add in what they just raised?

Add to that: it's not really clear that their only product lines make them money unless you exclude the cost of training them.

Google was profitable at IPO and had been for at least the previous year, the IPO floated a similar share of the company (7.23% apparently) but raised more than 3.5 times their yearly operating costs, or roughly about three times their total outstanding commitments at that point, according to their S-1.

Google was in a healthy position, and basically put the cash in the kitty to use for future projects.

Anthropic is in a historically huge debt and obligation hole. It has sold off a chunk of the business so they can run just to stand still, and its problems get worse after the next year, while its cost and difficulty of raising debt is likely to increase (unless JP Morgan and Goldman Sachs somehow convince the ratings agencies to give them a non-junk credit rating).


Hey, cool, they will have $12B of that left at the end of next year if they spend it all on their existing, immediate commitments for just next year.

And that remaining amount just so happens to be the rough prediction of their Q4 2026 operating loss.

5-7.5% of the company just to kick everything down the road for a year and really make little to no progress.

ETA: Google were profitable going into the IPO, and raised three times their annual operating costs anyway. So they got to use that money to do new things. These are qualitatively different IPOs.


It's a down day in the markets generally. Volatility isn't surprising, even given the scale.

It’s the single largest IPO failure narrative in history.

1.4T is just not a failure in any circumstance

Facebook dropped way more when they IPO'd

I'm confused why it seems to matter a lot between $1.25T or $1.5T. These are incremental differences compared to the “T” in those numbers.

Because at these lower valuations it strongly suggests the door for the likes of OpenAI has closed just as they are in increasing need of cash.

Remember recent headlines that OpenAI was struggling to raise cash at valuations above where ANT is now trading.

Net here it’s is a good day for those looking to cash out of ANT and a very worrying signal for others elsewhere that were hoping to cash out too. Cudios to Anthropic for recognizing that there was likely only room for one foundation lab going public and they got there first.


There’s also the worrying implication for PE, which is that their book values, having been inflated by optimistic private market estimates and circular financing out the wazoo are suddenly snapping back to reality and force multiplying the value-crash because it baked in both the supposed investment as well as the health of the financiers. If NVDA eats a repricing of their Anthropic debt and simultaneously ANT’s demand has to be reigned in to secure their financial solvency, the result is NVDA getting cents on the dollar for the assets it thought would be investments. Would love to hear if I’m wrong here.

Okay I get it. I looked it up and OpenAI last round was $1.25T so indeed this is meaningful.

Yes. There’s lots of debate about the actual market cap of ANT right now for… reasons, but the official cap per accepted measure is 1.25T or so. With OpenAI almost certainly worth much less this is another highly irrational market behavior that will need correction sooner rather than later.

Why would OAI be worth less?

They’re lagging in enterprise where the margins are and winning in consumer chatbots where there’s poor margin.

On near every objective measure of performance and business health their numbers look worse.

These valuations only make sense if you assume large future growth. OAI has vastly better mindshare outside of HN.

For consumers, yes, but consumers aren’t where these companies will make most of their money.

Right — OpenAI's once-stated belief that consumers will be 50% of their income looks insane even if you grant them that ChatGPT Sites, for example, is actually really well-executed and looks like the basis of an identifiable consumer product.

The reality is that most consumer AI is going to be on devices, and Apple managed to buy theirs for literally $1B per year (plus say a couple of billion for the private cloud data centre rent), from Google.

Apple Intelligence and Google's Android AI offerings need to be only incrementally better over time for ChatGPT to end up struggling and enshittified with ads, and both Apple and Google have the advantage of being able to design the device around the product and roll out deeply embedded features.

OpenAI has a slight advantage in the EU, because there they are an app consumers can install, and Apple is still hamstrung by legislation. But European sentiment towards US AI companies is not exactly positive!


Yeah what’s $250B between friends?

I’m honestly worried about the irrational exuberance in the market right now. It’s outright scary. This feels like 2007 or 1999.

I hope employees are able to cash some out to get the reward they deserve, but the fundamentals don’t look good here. And to be clear they’d be selling to folks that are unlikely to see upside.

This quote from Margin Call feels applicable here:

Sam Rogers: The real question is: who are we selling this to?

John Tuld: The same people we've been selling it to for the last two years, and whoelse ever would buy it.

Sam Rogers: But John, if you do this, you will kill the market for years. It's over.

[John nods grimly]

Sam Rogers: And you're selling something that you know has no value.

John Tuld: We are selling to willing buyers at the current fair market price.

[Sam lowers his gaze]

John Tuld: So that we may survive.

Sam Rogers: You would never sell anything to any of those people ever again.

John Tuld: I understand.


The lock-ups are specified in the S-1. "Non-founder directors, officers, and certain current or former employees or consultants" can sell up to 10% of shares they hold on day one. Just who those "certain" current of former employees are isn't clear.

Others can sell in waves beginning 27 days from the filing of the IPO prospectus.

Founders can transfer 29% of their stock 180 days after trading begins, with the rest of their holdings after a full year.

I have been through a couple of IPOs and the 180 day rule was the one I remember. We were totally locked out. At the time of the IPOs of those companies, we also didn't have the same secondary markets that are present today.

This seems like a very good deal for employees to get some liquidity.


6 months is standard as far as I know. This seems like a very good deal for employees.

I hate to play the pessmist, but I believe the AI boom will go the same way the 90s internet boom did: the bubble will collapse thanks to premature overvaluation, but the technology will eventually prove itself and transform society.

It will also go like the 2007 crash: once all the layoffs happen, employers will realize that they can do the same work with a fraction of the workforce, thanks to automation. It will be a jobless recovery.

So we may get the crash AND the AI takeover. I just hope governments are able to respond fast enough to radical societal changes.


This is what I believe as well. Neither Anthropic, OpenAI nor Alphabet have any moat when it comes to the technology. All have models close enough to each other, and switching costs are low. The valuation here doesn't make much sense, even though the tech itself is solid.

> but the technology will eventually prove itself and transform society.

Are anyone really doubting this part?


Tons of people are. Lots of people are in deep denial about it.

>I'm honestly worried about the irrational exuberance in the market right now. It’s outright scary.

$2T is a big number but this Anthropic IPO has been straight down since open, so I wouldnt say the market has gone completely insane.


They're trying to offload all this into retail and pension funds and line their pockets after all this hype campaign. We should be very worried with money in the market for the next months.

They are only floating about 6% of the company. If this was a cash grab they could have gone vastly bigger (in total raise) at a lower valuation.

Maybe they didn't want to make it look like a cash grab.

It’s a cash grab for their shareholders and investors, not just the company. I’ve been through a couple of big tech company IPOs and have never seen one with such a short lockup expiration

They only needed 6% to cover the initial investors. The remaining will be selling next.

Didn't some of the indexing firms recently decide to hold the line that your company must have been profitable in order to be part of the index?

Thank god.


> And you're selling something that you know has no value.

No, this is cope. The difference with CDOs and llms, is that either you like it or not, they have massive value. They can already automate most of the boring white collar work. Fewer and fewer human decisions remain. They are not perfect, but they are improving massively. The value is there, people are hooked+ brain rotting, they will be dependent forever


The value of proprietary models is rapidly tending towards zero. So the quote isn’t entirely off.

The only money to be made is in selling compute and Anthropic rents all that.


The market is down. Anthropic is up.

I expect this will be the general trend. Not every day, but broadly over time. Anthropic will slowly at first, then quickly just capture most of the US economy. $2T is low for the first company in history on that trajectory.


The market cap didn’t reach $2T. Their headline is wrong. It reached $1.5T and has been dipping

Does it matter for what I wrote? Not at all. Basically irrelevant. I said the market is down and Anthropic is up. And, indeed, the market is down and Anthropic is up.

It isn’t up in any meaningful way, and it communicates that you do not understand the basics of the topic you’re talking about. An IPO is literally financially engineered to pop… that’s why the float is so low and their partners (the hyperscalers) committed to invest billions in the IPO, to make it pop and sustain the price. That’s what the banks are literally hired for. The stock opened around $115 and is right now at $96.18.

Stock at $85 right now

The blast radius is quite large, but appears less contagious than what happened in 2008.

Lots of folks that bet big on AI are going to lose their shirts, but this doesn’t look like the “banks are failing every weekend and the global financial system is on the verge of collapse” situation we had in 2008.


No? Look at the underwriters of Anthropic shares. Mostly banks

It’s not really a liability for them. Certainly not an existential one.

The H1B program has been heavily abused for years. While there has been some collateral damage with the current crackdown, it’s pretty hard to defend what was going on in this space prior to the crackdown.

The latest action by the administration is to eliminate the 60 day grace period that non-immigrant employees have to either arrange their affairs prior to leaving or find a new position.

https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2026/09/11/2026-18...

Forcing people to leave the same day they lose their job is completely indefensible.


I have seen plenty of defense of that action, such as the claim that "immigrants have no rights." Typically, the same people also defend the executions of Alex Pretti and Renee Good. People who aren't completely ignorant of reality know that the administration's actions have absolutely nothing to do with "protecting American workers."

Adam Serwer could have never imagined that his amazingly poignant phrase "The Cruelty Is the Point" would continue to be spot-on for almost eight years now: https://archive.ph/vuY5r.


I agree it’s harsh, but it’s a response to fraud and abuse.

Folks massively game the 60 days and many were also fraudulently applying for B2 visas saying they were a tourist while really just hunting for jobs. That path has mostly been shut down with denied visas or the attempted B2 to H1B reversal.

The H1B is a guest worker program. Anyone on the visa shouldn’t be under any illusions otherwise. Most other countries apply similar strict enforcement so the Us was extremely liberal here prior to the crackdown.

I agree some of these changes are harsh but folks that are upset really need to focus anger and blame on those committing the fraud and abuse of the system. Pretending like there wasn’t a serious problem with fraud and abuse is just ignorance.


Adjusting status to B1/B2 is neither fraud or abuse, and is a completely separate issue.

Great comment. I will also so that folks upset by this should direct their anger at a visa system that is intentionally designed to subjugate the imported labor by keeping them in a tenuous position for their tenure. We could fix this by giving labor visa holders more labor protections and mandating a lottery system with higher wages. We don't. Why? Because that is a choice. Purpose of the system is what it does. The US, from a systems perspective, wants immigrant labor that is disempowered, and this is one pillar of that (other pillars are undocumented labor for the ag supply chain that no one is willing to normalize with a path to citizenship).

Well given that we know the Trump administration isn't doing this are we not allowed to criticize their actions that immiserate people?

If the B2 abuse has been curtailed already how is this a response to that?

> Most other countries apply similar strict enforcement so the Us was extremely liberal here prior to the crackdown.

Yeah citation needed. Care to share an example of any other country where you're out of status the day you leave the job?


[flagged]

I have no children and rent. I would find leaving the same day extremely difficult.

H1B is also not a temporary visa. It's renewable indefinitely with an approved I140.


[flagged]

The word semantics aspect of the argument here doesn't hold. Renewable statuses are called "permanent" like permanent residency in Canada which requires renewal subject to conditions.

> Renewable is temporary.

A green card needs to be renewed too. Only citizenship is pretty much permanent...


> There is no guarantee your I140 will be approved.

You misunderstood. The I140 has to be approved prior to renewal.


Why 14 and not 60? Is some American worker going to benefit by having this person leave 46 days earlier?

> Is some American worker going to benefit by having this person leave 46 days earlier?

A different foreigner can enjoy more housing supply and lower prices, 46 days sooner.

Unless you assume every immigration issue is citizen vs foreigner?


The one thing they need to do above all else is ban body shops from sponsoring. That is the core of the abuse and they'll never touch it.

Well the indentured servants that need to compete with China on an industrial scale need to come from somewhere. It just turns out the program importing them is based on a system of caste & race, and achieving goals isn't necessarily a part of bilking people.

Also, pointing this out tends to be a form of noticing the emperor is indeed, not wearing clothes...


> indentured servants

Highest paying industry worldwide.

> caste & race

Yep, we all know of elite leetcode interviews around caste.

/s


> Highest paying industry worldwide.

The finance industry produces more billionaires and centi-millionaires than the tech industry.

Always has. Always will.

Do you see people from that one country succeeding in finance? Nope.

Hell, that one country lost the AI race. They are nowhere to be seen at US frontier labs or US quant HFT firms.


Sorry can you clarify what you mean here? Which country are you talking about?

I think he's talking about India.

> nowhere to be seen

big if true


> Sorry can you clarify what you mean here? Which country are you talking about?

India.

And they tend to report/flag comments that talk ill of them.


As they should. Racism should be curbed.

Criticism of a group is not racism. The USA does not sell GPUs to China/the Chinese. Is that also because of racism?

Perhaps they must reverse course immediately to be more socially acceptable! Good idea, yes?


don’t worry man, I won’t flag

> Hell, that one country lost the AI race. They are nowhere to be seen at US frontier labs or US quant HFT firms.

Maybe look at what happened to that country for the last few centuries and how much time it took the US after independence to become a super power in anything.

By your own logic, I could say finance has lots of nepotism and racism that prevents qualified people from entering.

But nothing will convince your ilk as you engage in blatant racism without a shred of data.


So the alleged implication here is then that this wasn’t really sales to Singapore but “sales to Singapore and definitely not China wink wink”?

That’s a lot of chips for a small city state.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: