HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | cmiles74's commentslogin

I have to disagree on the punishing aspect. They enabled Gemini for student accounts and there was a significant backlash. They then added some configuration so that schools can disable AI features, stating that if all AI features are disabled then they will _also_ disable Google search.

If they didn't want it to sound punitive, another solution might have been more appropriate. Google search today has a "Web" item (listed under "More" at the top of the page) which does provide search reasults without the AI overview. I think this indicates that this feature isn't so difficult to provide to schools, their paying customers.


The move is 100% punitive on the part of Google. From the recent CNN article:

"Google is rolling out new controls for schools to limit students’ access to the company’s AI tools. But if schools opt out of AI altogether, they’ll also lose access to Google Search."

They are saying that if schools would like to disable all of the AI tooling in the Chromebooks used by students then Google will also disable access to search.


>They are saying that if schools would like to disable all of the AI tooling in the Chromebooks used by students then Google will also disable access to search.

THAT is a clearer answer than any I received. If the demand is "let us turn off AI features generally, but keep search with AI" then that seems like an extremely reasonable request. I'm not sure if that is the request but it's not outlandish vs. maintaining a contractually provisioned no AI search engine version.


No?

They are very clearly saying they want the AI summary and chatbot in the search results gone.

Because it is a way for students to cheat.



Google sold this product to many schools during the pandemic. In my opinion, it is an epic fail on their part that they have ignored the needs of this market segment. That they now expect them to come up with their own solution to a problem that Google has created seems unreasonable to me.

This is a trivial change for Google. I worry that the rationale is that if they force-feed the AI summaries to children then those children are more likely to grow up into customers willing to purchase LLM products or be generally more willing to accept LLM content. Which is kind of gross.


My guess is that the IT staff at most schools is either not great or close to nonexistant.

K-12 IT employee here, I lurk HN a lot and made an account to throw in my 2 cents.

Anyway, both are generally true. My district uses a hub model, where support staff are dispatched out to schools and network infrastructure/business ops are centrally managed. But our model is common to larger districts; smaller ones often rely on small general-purpose IT teams - maybe a handful of people.

Obviously, being both public-sector and education, the pay isn't great because the funding isn't there. I like to think most of my colleagues are competent, service-minded people, we're just understaffed. We don't usually experience a lot of turnover, just growth from 2020-2024, but the economy has made some folks reluctantly move on lately. I'm hiring now and the strongest candidates withdrew when they realized what our salaries were. We're in a metropolitan area - rural districts have even weaker candidate pools and lower funding.

My district's leadership has embraced AI as part of our students' future, so they're taking an "allow it, but regulate it" approach and Google's change doesn't impact us. I have mixed feelings about how tech is integrated in grade schools in general, but this _is_ something of an added burden to workaround for under-resourced districts who don't want it.


Like teachers, they are overworked and underpaid, and, as you put it, close to nonexistant.

I used to work at a state college and during a major tech turnover we had 1 tech employee for 3 campuses across 3 counties. That 1 was me. 5000 students, hundreds of staff, and me keeping the lights on for 3 years.

The instant someone offered me $1 more an hour I quit.


...And watch your updates take longer as they now update several columns over several tables instead of just one column in one table, and be sure to ensure that changes don't leave any data in an inconsistent state. I don't think this is an "enterprise" issue, it's about maintaining your data, and that effects 99% of applications that store data in a database.

And they were proven to be true. From the Wikipedia article:

“To date, five manufacturers have pleaded guilty to their involvement in an international price-fixing conspiracy between July 1, 1998, and June 15, 2002, including Hynix, Infineon, Micron Technology, Samsung, and Elpida.[3]“


Yes, that is a fact.

What hasn't happened is that they have been found guilty in the latest class action lawsuit. Which is what this discussion is about.

So far the court has only decided that the lawsuit can proceed, which indicates there is some substance to it.


I have to disagree with you there, the parent comment is claiming that this has happened before and they cite that Wikipedia article. ;-)

In my opinion, the fact that this has happened before, and that the companies involved eventually plead guilty, is an important piece of information for people following this story. Especially in light of the statements from the companies involved today.


The comment said "this isn't the first time", present tense, meaning they are currently being found to have done it again. That's not true (the finding has not happened yet), and what the person you're going back forth with is arguing.

Fair enough, I see what you mean. When I read it, I was thinking along the lines of "this isn't the first time they have been accused of this."

It seems 50/50 to me that an LLM would come up with a similar solution.


That's very GitHub Copilot + GPT 4o energy.


Or things will settle down enough that people start looking at the numbers and doing the math. LLM tooling can generate code and often that code is correct. In my experience it takes about as long for the tooling to generate the code as it would for me to write the code myself and it also costs more money (my time plus the token cost). The more complicated the task the more likely I have to go back and get the model to re-work the majority of it as it made some assumptions that, after a little thought, turn out to be problematic.

IMHO, at the end of the day it's been about the same amount of time, the cost is a little higher and I don't feel as confident in the end product. I suspect that I am not the only one that feels this way!


Cursor should not be shipping extensions that are branded Anthropic if Anthropic didn’t create that extension. If that’s really what happened then that needs to change, ASAP. Now that it has happened, IMHO, it is partly an Anthropic problem: the malware has their branding and their name on it, I don’t think they can just brush that off.

Does Cursor have some process that just scrapes Microsoft’s extension catalog and lists them in their own? If that’s hostile works then it’s broken and needs to be fixed.


I'm on my phone, "If that’s hostile works.." should be "If that’s how it works..."


I mean the initial translation kind of works too.


> Cursor should not be shipping extensions that are branded Anthropic if Anthropic didn’t create that extension.

Well, duh. From what I can tell, that’s literally the hack. A bad actor shipped an extension on the Cursor marketplace that wasn’t made by Anthropic.


No, you misunderstand (not surprising since 99% of the coverage on this story is wrong). What happened is: someone published an extension called "Anthropic.claude-code". That someone was not Anthropic and never was Anthropic. They just used the string "Anthropic" in the name of their extension. The comment you are responding to is saying that Cursor (the organization that manages the extension marketplace) should have prohibited someone from using a popular AI lab's name in the title of their mystery meat extension. They're probably right about that.


I think GP’s objection to the claim that Cursor allowing non-Anthropic to do it for 11 hours was partly “an Anthropic problem.”


It is an Anthropic problem. It's also a Cursor problem.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: