HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | cm2187's commentslogin

Unless I am confused, it doesn't look like ubuntu server has made available the fix.

It’s time to switch away from Ubuntu and go upstream to Debian.

While I wholeheartedly agree with you, Debian hasn't patched yet, either. See my sibling comment: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50551026.

Lol no

Debian is unfixed too




Amazing that they don't disclose these CVEs to the major Linux distros before going public

Also it's not clear that selling GPUs to China is helping China. It does help their training capabilities in the short term, but starves their potential GPU manufacturers of revenues in the longer run.

China is going to onshore GPU manufacturing no matter what. Letting Chinese companies import GPUs isn't going to make them take the foot off the gas pedal. This effort is government subsidized.

It also shows who is behind all the leaks that lead to his downfall. Why Bessent is after Jensen, I don't know. Perhaps a roadkill in an internal struggle with Lutnick. But it does feel highly politicised.

Jensen has been smuggling top end AI GPUs into China. Getting the wheels turning on prosecuting him isn't "being politicized", it's pushing forward against a corrupt justice system that refuses to uphold the law.

Pretty sure this isn’t settled fact, based on the retractions.

> Getting the wheels turning on prosecuting him isn't "being politicized", it's pushing forward against a corrupt justice system that refuses to uphold the law.

It can be (and IMO, though I can't prove it, probably is in this case) both.

Just because the correct law and order path is now being taken doesn't mean it wasn't kickstarted by political in-fighting. Circumstantially it really seems like it was.


> Just because the correct law and order path is now being taken doesn't mean it wasn't kickstarted by political in-fighting

The case against Jensen is a slam dunk, one which any prosecutor would salivate over. I wonder how we got to this point in America where pursuing even an open and shut case is somehow bad because it 'doesn't mean it wasn't kickstarted by political in-fighting'

In essence, it puts the bar for prosecution at proving a negative (hey, do we know it wasn't the result of political machinations). No wonder we have the state of corruption we have in the country.


The right question to ask is "Why is it wrong to sell GPUs to China?" If US doesn't want to sell, they'll learn how to make their own AI GPUs.

They will learn to make their own AI GPU's eventually. But they will suck for decades until they can replicate or take over TSMC.

Because it's against the law.

Jensen Huang claims the law is not good, but the rest of us don't get to choose which laws we can break because we think they are not good.


People choose to drive over the speed limit every single day.

And you face the consequences if caught. The difference is, you are advocating for Jensen not to face the consequences once he is caught.

Seems like the comment is more directed towards OP's statement, "but the rest of us don't get to choose which laws we can break because we think they are not good."

The "rest of us" do choose which laws to break when choosing to speed.


Because all laws are equivalent..

From the US perspective, it's more like people choose to run red lights every single day.

And those people are sometimes punished. Just like Jensen.

Is he being punished? Because not being CEO of a multi-trillion dollar company doesn't seem like punishment to me at all.

But this push forward happens to start with Jensen instead of say Lutnick, Trump, Noem, Musk, Zuckerberg. There’s no guarantee anyone else gets prosecuted either, so calling it a push is optimistic.

I would hope such a push starts with people responsible for an agency that has killed, kidnapped and illegally detained thousands of people. That still literally disappears people by erasing the records of where they’re being detained. That’s where the politics comes in..


Believing anything coming out of the Trump administration is “pushing forward against a corrupt justice system system” is pretty sad at this point.

It's also ridiculous on it's face: a member of the administration "pushing forward against" another arm of the same administration - and the corruption is limited to only the other arm, one is led to believe.

That sounds like a serious crime, why wasn't he fired for that? Did they not have any proof or something? Did the media put out that narrative so people like you would repeat it?

highly politicized yes but I don't think it's Bessent who's after him. Who stands to benefit the most with Jensen gone? Literally everyone wants to see him win.

- US market likes stability and SF tech circles love him. I dont even remember him picking fights with anyone (elon, trump etc

- Taiwan, Japan and South Korea. He has God-like idol status with local suppliers and young folks there

- China. Assuming Alice is really a spy, China would want Jensen to stay CEO. Hell they even get weekly report on how many sex he had this week.

- Malaysia / Singapore. The flow of money keeps coming in with Jensen turning blind eye to China rerouting purchase via these countries. They want him to stay too

The only people I can see who would benefit most is one of those small circle of China hawk in Trump sphere (maybe democrats have their own china hawk circles too).


> Why Bessent is after Jensen,

The prize isn't Jensen, then. The prize to be won is most likely NVidia itself, and it's soon going to be run by someone hand-picked by the most nakedly corrupt whitehouse administration in history.


Violating United States export law tends to get political, yes

So far, there is nothing from FCC proven this.

There is circumstantial evidence, and it’s worth noting that seemingly Lutnick (and bizarrely even once Nvidia itself) managed to kill investigations into it. When people are taking pains to look the other way it does imply rule breaking, but yes it’s still only an implication.

Red herring. The FCC doesn't have jurisdiction over the relevant export restrictions.

The Commerce Department (Secretary Lutnick) is responsible for enforcing the chip export ban / US collecting a portion of the profits according to Congressional statute.


And for the moment I haven't seen alleged violations. Exporting to DC in Asia outside of China is a legal loophole that the Trump administration preserved.

"preserved" or: "left as a trap"...

Honey or otherwise, he didn't show good judgment. Repeatedly.


Hasn’t Bessent pretty consistently taken positions that benefit Anthropic or echo its talking points (whinging about “distillation attacks”, etc.). I’ve always thought it seemed fishy.

Shouldn't editorializing classified leaks be looked into, by the way?

Feels like someone from New York Times needs to go in front of the Congress, national security concerns, cornerstone American company decapitated, yada yada...


You want them to quote verbatim from classified leaks? Would that be better?

That is exactly what a leak is. A copy of a document regardless of its 'confidentiality'.

Cf. the Pentagon Papers & everything published by Wikileaks (none of whose thousands of leaks were ever challenged as not being legit).

This abuse of the term 'leak' to mean "we learnt this in confidence and won't show any evidence of what we are alleging" is pathetic and harmful to public discourse.


Not sure the average representative is the right benchmark, that's not the real insiders. The real insiders would be in the upper ranks of congress, with prominent seats in commissions, part of security briefings, and with front row in draft legislations (the average representative first discovers the proposed new law when a 7000 pages final version is dropped on their desk 20 minutes before the vote).

Sure, or friends of the representatives who just reward said representatives later after they leave congress, etc.

If she was a spy and wasn't flagged to him by the FBI, it's the FBI's fuck up. Are private citizens expected to run their own counter-intelligence agency? The spy thing is only problematic if he knew she was one and somehow didn't inform the FBI.

As for the extramarital thing, it's a private matter between him and his wife. Unless someone alleges there was any sexual harassment involved, but I have seen no claim that it is the case so far.


lol insane take. Unless the FBI informs me, every single hot single lady in my area that wants to fuck me is legit.

If you are running the most valuable company in the world that produces items so strategic geopolitics is shaped around them ? Then yes - US counterintelligence at that point should have had a channel to you to tell you - dude! She may be a spy - pls stop.

And just letting it go on is either a sign of gargantuan incompetence or willful action by them . Not sure which :)


Have to stay positive, AMD stock price is up!

I remember Jensen saying he doesn’t have a contract with TSMC. The whole supply is based on a trusted relationship and handshake deals between the two CEOs. I wonder if that relationship is transferable to his successor.


There is no secret about the mismatch. Voters last week have elected people who are openly hostile to datacenters, and for some of them hostile to AI outright. The demand is there (at what price is a longer term debate). But if you can't power on new datacenters this doesn't do any good.

To give you an idea of the scale. US has currently about 50 GW of DC online. Depending on the source, you are looking at between 60 GW and 400 GW of new DC currently planned. For reference the total dependable capacity of the US grid is around 1000 GW.

I think there is a scenario where compute cost sky rockets while chip prices crash, as they end up unused in warehouse because of the lack of power and DC capacity.


> Voters last week have elected people who are openly hostile to datacenters

Voters themselves were hostile towards data centers in all but one of the ballot initiatives (40 out of 41).

But the “elected people” you refer to (I assume Democrats) seem to me to be more about not having one-sided secret deals for data centers in folks’ “backyards”.

Specifically, the detailed stances seems to be for things like: cover energy demands (no rate hikes), no excess load on power grid, water protections, and transparency with the communities they are in. Some also call for more regulation (which is a knife that can cut both ways).

This seems reasonable to me.

If anyone wants to cast stones, I think targeting the folks currently in office who somehow thought it would be a good idea to defund extra power generation just because it happened to be renewables / clean energy might be one place to look.


That's a fantastic scenario. When the 5900s become cheap we'll all play with rolling our own data models.

Data centers can be build in Mexico or in a different friendlier to AI jurisdiction.

Is Mexico stable enough to house very expensive and easily stolen GPUs (or whatever we call them now)?

The world of private military companies (PMCs) is constantly expanding.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Private_military_company


Bytedance (China) is building a 40 Billion USD AI data center in Ceará, northeastern Brazil.

Canada is.

Perhaps rogue datacenters full of stolen GPUs will be the next cartel pivot after avocados, very cyberpunk

Bit more difficult to hide that much power. It makes grow lights look like a hairdryer.

AI has been passively hostile to society. VC cash has too. Non of that is irrational.

You want them to embrace a tech that exacerbates inequality and its founders promote that?


Does it exacerbates inequality? There's no question that some people are going to get rich, and they might be the wrong person and we should hate them. But prior to the advent of AI being able to generate video and audio, an aspiring film maker would have to slave away at a shitty job and claw their way to relevance in order to try and get Sony/whomever's attention, and the rich people would finance their movie dreams. Now with AI, that budding young artist can make a feature length film for a couple thousand dollars instead of having to beg Universal or Walt Disney for a hundred million dollars to make that movie.

Like, to me it's backwards.

There's the parable of the five monkeys. There are five monkeys in a cage with a ladder to bananas. When a monkey would climb the ladder to get a banana, the zoo keeper would spray all the monkeys. So they learn not to climb the ladder. Eventually. But then they replace the monkeys, one by one. when a new monkey tries to climb the ladder, the other monkeys stop them. Eventually, even though none of the monkeys currently in the cage has ever been sprayed, they still enforce the rule because, well, they don't know anymore.

In Hollywood, you have to earn your place. You can't just come in and make movies. Walt Disney would not stand for that. You have to spend decades learning first. AI weakens those technical and financial barriers, but people are gonna argue that you have to earn your place.


Yes. The nerds in SF openly discussed being part of the permanent underclass. These folks know what they're doing.

I don't see the previous poster saying they "want" anything.

Every civilizational advance “exacerbates inequality” because smart people can use it to become more productive, but dumb people can’t.

By that logic we should ban books. This is Boko Haram ideology and you are just a communist who thinks he should be protected from competition.

Instead of “making everyone well off“ here is what will actually happen, because that’s what happens every time communists seize power: everyone will get poorer, because they will be outcompeted by more sane jurisdictions, eg China.

Communists never waste a second on how wealth is actually created. To them, money just exists and the main problem is that isn't distributed evenly.


> what happens every time communists seize power: everyone will get poorer, because they will be outcompeted by more sane jurisdictions, eg China.

Chinese Communist Party, guide us to Capitalism?

If the communists can learn how to use markets, capitalists can learn how to redistribute. It's not impossible, we did it 100 years ago last time capitalism drunk-drove the world economy into a ditch, I just hope we can do it without a Great Depression and World War this time.


> Chinese Communist Party, guide us to Capitalism?

Yes please.

> capitalists can learn how to redistribute

By that measure, the West hasn't been capitalist since Roosevelt. Which would be accurate btw.


That sounds like “Threatening me with a good time”. It will be very cheap for me to buy my hardware. Unsurprisingly I have power at home, and I can use the free power I have during the day from solar to do all sorts of cool things on my own hardware. It will be like the 1980s and 90s again.

If democrats complete their movement to "ludditism" as a party, I will burn my DNC registration and work with the red team. Good timing since MAGA got spanked and should be on the way out.

I'm sympathetic to DSA types, right up until they call for bans on super intelligence, RSI, or data centers. Remember progressives, it wasn't "socialism" that lost me.


Me too, and I didn't need to wait 30 years for that. They were corrupted when floppies were still the default.

But surely they see the backlash on HN and reddit. I find it odd that they don't seem to communicate at all on that.


Many people will not pay much attention to the opinion of the average Reddit user these days.


Deservedly. But the HN audience is generally on the other side of the median of the IQ distribution than Reddit’s.


Believing this in any way is it's own evidence of it being untrue.


I think you'd fit right in on r/Gifted.


They've actually raised it to critical today. Hopefully a fix tomorrow.


The governance types maybe don't inhabit HN in high numbers.


Or simply don't care.


Not really. As far as I can tell the reason Intel routed seems to be because of an explosion in one of their fabs making Xeons which reduced production, and because no one buys new desktops and servers anymore because of the cost of RAM and storage. Given intel isn't big on AI chips, they are a casualty of the AI bubble.


> of an explosion in one of their fabs making Xeons

I guess this is related to Israel, isn't it? Meaning a fab they had installed there. Or maybe I'm thinking of the wrong Intel property blowing up.


Link ?

Their newest workstation chips (Xeon 600) are awesome. But limited supply.



Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: