We're off the front page, so I don't know if you're still responding here. I just put in a fairly trivial project to evaluate pricing - a half dozen passives and two transistors on a ~1x1in pcb. My JLC quote is $74 (incl tariff) and yours is $599/$923. JLC will ship Nov. 1 via DHL, you ship either Nov. 19 or Nov. 9. So the summary is that China is 1 week faster and 10x cheaper. Maybe the bottom line is that there's a set up fee that's dominating this price. If that's the case, it would be really valuable to be up-front about it because that would help identify use cases where y'all's service could be economical.
I've been tracking PCB manufacturing in the US for some time (I think I opened my CircuitHub account ~10 years ago) because I love the idea of bringing manufacturing back to the US. But some mild negative feedback - I'm unimpressed by the over promising about pricing and timing that I've seen in this thread; it DID cause me to look at you guys again, but at the same time reduced my trust level. I recognize that there are economies of scale to be had here and maybe things will get better with more business so I wish you the best!
I’ve had really good results recently with Fable 5.1. The typical process that it uses for routing is to pin a few key traces (using the kicad python api) and then use freerouting for the others. I’ve also noticed that if I push hard for “carefully designed” routes, eg for a 38 pin connector, it will write code and make much better looking results.
I’d say that at the moment it still requires you to look at its results and point out their weaknesses and/or route a couple of traces yourself and then hand it back.
This project from a couple of weeks ago is a great example. I’m new to ST MCUs: in addition to the PCB, Claude brought up the firmware and driver. https://github.com/ckemere/hub-imu
I’ve always been impressed with Deisseroth. Since the early optogenetics days he always was excited to share materials. (I have fond memories of driving back from a visit to Stanford with vectors plucked from their freezer, what MTA!?) And he was eager to promote young scientists not only in his own lab but also in others (like myself) that were innovating in these spaces. And in every talk I’ve heard, he’s shared credit really openly.
There’s a big contrast there to how some scientists operate - hoarding ideas, being cautious in collaboration, demanding credit. I’m so pleased for him!
"The river interceptor design was clearly based on existing solutions" like Mr. Trash Wheel, Dr. Richards says. "Rather than work with the organizations who had successfully been removing trash from rivers for years, they ‘reinvented’ a similar design, at a much higher cost, and claimed to be innovators."
This is a great summary of lots of flashy commercial and non-profit work. Proposal for a product: AI-assisted "Who is already doing this?" database. Extra credit for linking to audited annual reports.
Reminds me of the endless "12 year old wins $25k young innovator award for inventing a solar panel that can go on the roof of an EV to charge while you drive!" type proclamations