Because they can't bear to make vehicles smaller. That's the real terror on American roads. Something like 60% of vehicles are huge because it makes the driver feel better. And indeed, it makes the driver safer in a collision - at the cost of making everyone else in the area less safe. Something has to be done to stop this trend first and foremost.
After that, when vehicle sizes start trending down towards reasonable, we can look at getting speeds up without reducing overall safety.
I think the reason trucks are so huge these days is not the ride feel. It's the EPA gives more lenient pollution restrictions based on size of vehicle. So instead of making the engine less polluting, just make the truck bigger and keep the same engine. It's like a cereal box that's only 1/3 full.
The idea to introduce light trucks in passenger-car shape to get around pollution limits was the car manufacturers' idea. However, the US public ran with it and bought because of the perceived higher safety and social status that comes with driving a larger, heavier vehicle than everyone else. And they continue to buy to attempt to one-up each other even though the pollution limits now apply to SUVs as well as smaller passenger cars.
My understanding was that the American domestic auto manufacturers were getting their asses beat by foreign competitors who made much better cars. American companies could differentiate themselves with giant vehicles that wouldn't be practical in Europe or Asia. But because the giant vehicles became status symbols the low end started imitating them and now nobody sells cars in the US any more.
It's definitely a blend. I bought something HN would melt down over mostly due to the ride quality. I can drive from Houston to El Paso and not feel it.
I don't buy cars based on their pollution capabilities like some Captain Planet villain. Maybe other consumers are different.
I personally get a massive benefit from USPS being cheap, despite the fact that I send no mail. It provides a massive low-cost physical delivery network across the country, with service to every address. This is a benefit to me because it makes business and personal communication simple and reliable. If I need it personally, it's there. If I don't, I still rely on thousands of parties who do.
Your position is like claiming the interstate system is useless because you don't have a car, ignoring how all those goods your life relies on actually get to you.
Parent poster is exactly the kind of person who argues that using tax dollars for school is wrong because they, personally, do not have kids. Because they can't realize that they indirectly benefit from it.
John Green: "So let me explain why I like to pay taxes for schools, even though I don't personally have a kid in school: It's because I don't like living in a country with a bunch of stupid people."
We (the public) have already been forced to accept that students' education is directly linked to the property taxes. In other words, students only deserve the education linked to an average the the worth of the community. Its some of the grossest discrimination against student, based purely on family and locality worth.
Poor community? Sorry Timmy, your schools SUCK.
Rural community? Get to farming Timmy. You dont deserve a GOOD education either.
Living in a rich suburb of a big city? Congrats, your schools are well funded and low student:teacher count. Your education will actually be pretty damned good.
I'm not describing a theory. I'm describing the world in which I live every day. It's much better for me, right now, in the real world, for the service to be cheap. Even though I've mailed nothing for at least the last year.
There are limits. USB keyboards are just always going to be slower than PS/2 keyboards. You can close the gap, but USB is just fundamentally adding wrapping layers that introduce latency over the direct polling PS/2 used. And there's a lot of this at the hardware level, where standardized connections with complex protocols replace weird custom connectors. USB is most definitely easier to plug something in to than PS/2 ports, where you had different ports for mouse and keyboard and they weren't interchangeable. (Ok, some very late motherboards supported using either in a single port, but it wasn't the way most PCs worked.)
You can do a lot at the high levels, but everything needs to be reworked from the hardware level up to match the latency of older systems.
> USB is just fundamentally adding wrapping layers that introduce latency over the direct polling PS/2 used
PS/2 did not use polling, it was entirely event-driven. On keypress, the keyboard sent a serial message to the 8042 controller [1], which then raised the appropriate interrupt line on the CPU, which caused the keyboard ISR [2] to be executed. The serial clock was a bit flexible, but usually sat around 10-16 kHz [3], and so the 11-bit serial message took at most 1 ms to send.
It is USB that uses polling. The keyboard describes itself using endpoint descriptors, and after obtaining these, the host controller periodically polls it with an IN token, to which the keyboard responds with its state changes since the last poll [4]. The earliest USB keyboards preferred fairly slow polling rates, but modern keyboards can be polled every 1 ms [5]. If directly connected to a motherboard USB port, a modern USB keyboard will have pre-software input latency on par with a PS/2 keyboard.
Yeah, I'd say the bigger point is that the latency gap isn't really there anymore. Old keyboards, cheap keyboards, expansion ports, and external hubs can still cause problems, though.
You understand the Luddites were 100% correct, right? "Luddite" is a compliment, not an insult. The Luddite position was "mechanization of labor will concentrate money and power in the hands of capital holders to the detriment of everyone else". If that's not what you thought it was, that's because you have been lied to by people who have been attempting to manipulate you. Apparently successfully.
If you can't understand what the machine has done, math is not being done. Math is not pushing symbols around to find sequences that follow all the rules. Math is the process of understanding how those sequences of symbols map to meanings. If you can't follow the proof but have validated it's correct, all you know is that it's a proof of something. Is it a proof of what's claimed in the adjacent plaintext? Who knows!
Math is about clear communication between people first and foremost. That's why Shinichi Mochizuki's claimed proof of the ABC conjecture isn't accepted - he's unable to communicate it to enough mathematicians to get a consensus on its validity. LLMs generating Lean proofs are basically following that same schema. Sure, something has been proven. But what? Where's the clear communication explaining it to the satisfaction of other mathematicians?
I mean it's just patently absurd. It is trendy to use this hubristic, and frankly bureaucratic, definition or requirement on math.
People can do math alone. They don't have to share it with others. Mochizuki was doing math (with errors). The aliens from Arrival could do math and we wouldn't necessarily be entitled to that. It doesn't make these things not valid math.
The only benefit of defining math through this vulgar social reductivism is to benefit the status quo. So you see some experts and expert-adjacent commentators using these math slogans but never critically justifying those words. Case in point, the above commenter asserts "...math is foremost about communication.", but the very next sentence does not explain why it is foremost, it just uses the sentence as a premise for the following sentence. Guess what, that is exactly how ideologues argue, by question begging fallacy. Ironic that STEM people who ought know better fail to catch this simple rational mistake.
Math that isn't communicated is valueless - by definition.
Applies to STEM generally, because the foundation of STEM is peer review and independent testing and confirmation.
Even if the practice never quite lives up to the theory (true) that's no excuse to hand-wave away the requirement as if it doesn't matter.
Proofs that can't be confirmed are valueless because no one learns anything from them. The value of a proof isn't just in proving something but in inventing new techniques and insights that can be reused for other applications.
Brute force searches are fundamentally less valuable, because the creative foundation of math is discovering leaps of logic that solve problems with insightful shortcuts that can be generalised and reused for other applications.
> Math that isn't communicated is valueless - by definition.
That is quite a bold claim.
Math can always be used as a tool just to achieve results. This can include even novel math. Due to the maturity of the field it is just becoming more and more unlikely that somebody will come up with something novel without realizing the significance.
One example: Quicksort was almost not published because Tony Hoare initially considered the idea behind the algorithm trivial. In the end, all he wanted to do was to sort some numbers.
Maybe there is a polynomial time SAT solver running somewhere just because some overworked engineer implemented it for a completely different problem. And he was just annoyed that all existing libraries were so slow and he doesn't realize that he is sitting on a proof that P=NP. Who knows.
"Mathematics is commonly explained and recorded in symbolic and concrete forms that are easy to communicate, rather than in conceptual forms that are easy to understand once communicated. Translation in the direction conceptual -> concrete and symbolic is much easier than translation in the reverse direction, and symbolic forms often replaces the conceptual forms of understanding."
Human understanding is important, but I don’t think it’s the end all be all. There’s no reason to expect humans to be the best mathematical reasoners in the universe. And if math is important, beyond being a human art form, I think we should explore that math beyond our understanding.
I'm on the side of human understanding being fundamental to mathematics, but I'll try arguing from the other side.
If we consider the reductionist view that "math is just a tool" to solve problems, and machines can generate new tools that are actually useful, then it can be argued that we don't need to understand how those tools work internally for us to benefit from its usefulness.
My hope is that such a view is given its proper place as a worthy pursuit but that it does not consume the entirety of the field of mathematics as a human activity with culture, philosophy, and art. And I feel the same for the field of software.
I mean, I could not understand 95% of all the math out there due to skill issue, and it’s still valid. If machines can understand the math and humans can’t, we can’t validate it, but that doesn’t make the math itself invalid.
It could be logically valid but irrelevant? Allowing for the atrophying of all our skills is dangerous? While simultaneously building ever more complicated edifices that control our lives? Not a doomer but you really just want to shrug and say it ain't no thing?
Perhaps humans have peaked due to the fundamental biological nature of our brains and AI will eventually surpass us in mathematical intelligence.
That has been the ultimate goal of creating AI -- not to simply match human intelligence but to surpass it. If it surpasses us, does that make it irrelevant? Everything around us is powered by mathematics, most of it I don't understand, and soon perhaps everything will be powered by mathematics that everybody doesn't understand.
Because we kinda suck. Wars, poverty, destruction of the environment, etc. Maybe AI will be worse -- the are plenty of movies on that subject -- or maybe it will be better.
> Is this going to lead to anything other than displacement in the long term?
We may have already damaged the environment enough that we're going to die off soon anyway. So without AI, we were already on that path to "displace" ourselves -- I don't think that argument is that compelling.
Perhaps this is the natural evolution of intelligent life. Eventually the sun will die and everything we are will be gone forever, maybe this is the only way that something of us survives.
> Do you ever stop and ask why we’re building the world we’re building?
We're not building a world. We're just ants. Individuals making individual decisions that have nothing to do with the rest of the world. You don't have to look too far to find humans that literally care nothing about humanity as a whole and everything about themselves.
> To what end does a world we cannot comprehend or rebuild from first principles serve us?
We already live in that world. You wouldn't even be able to build a toaster from first principles without the knowledge and infrastructure that already exists.
I mean, ideally to the end of poverty, disease, climate change, war, starvation, etc. You can disagree about whether this would be the outcome in practice, but I don't think 'why might we want to create something smarter than us' is a hard question. Humans losing their status as top dog is really a trivial price to pay for the potential return.
I don't understand that what you mean. Disease and climate change seem like clear cut technology problems, and the rest, save for war, have obvious technological solutions. What does it mean for them to be human problems? Should I expect them to solve themselves?
Current technology is sufficient to greatly reduce climate change, there just isn't the political will to do it.
Obviously not every disease can be cured, but even diseases that were essentially gone are coming back because people have just decided they don't care anymore. There are measles outbreaks happening all over the place right now.
mRNA vaccines are a medical marvel and a significant portion of the population has been convinced that horse paste is a better solution.
There are enough resources available that poverty and starvation could be essentially eliminated or at the very least drastically reduced. We just don't do it because people would rather hoard wealth instead.
The technology is here, but too many people profit from not solving the problems
They killed your comment, but you should know that you've posted it on the world's #1 AI propaganda site, where literally trillions of dollars are at stake and ROI depends on the correctness of the discourse running among the meat LLMs foraging or lurking here.
It's not that their argument is wrong or not worth discussing, it's that it is utterly irrelevant when the question at stake is whether the math is valid and useful or not. It's effectively whataboutism.
Perhaps, but two things:
1. most people don't understand this level of maths either
2. math, unlike most natural language, can be (dis)proven without a person understanding.
The second one is very important. While it is a matter of pride that some do understand, and (given enough time, in my opinion) will continue to understand, it is sufficient to be merely correct even if one does not understand why. This is a nice feature of math: it remains true regardless of understanding.
The obvious caveat is the machine needs to prove it in the end, even if we can not.
The underlying tautologies always existed. Making them accessible to us as truth and usable for one or more functions is what's invented by people (and potentially by AI) via insightful proofs and narratives.
I think the nuance they are pointing towards is that we cannot with any certainty say one way or another, as this is an unsolved problem in mathematics, and may possibly remain unsolved forever.
Your opinion is a possibility but it is not grounded by any proof, as such it is nothing more than an assumption. I think the more intellectually healthy approach is to list out the possibilities and figure out what they entail, rather than to throw all your eggs in one basket blindly, which amounts to a leap of faith or a retreat to commitment.
But that's just my two cents, take it or leave it.
I absolutely do not understand what are you talking about.
The question whether the tautologies exists regardless of whether we know about them or not is absolutely not a problem that is studied by mathematics and can be proven by mathematics.
Correct, these questions lie outside the internal practice of mathematics. If you want to see where that computational mindset breaks down, read Carnap's "Empiricism, Semantics, and Ontology" regarding internal versus external frameworks (or have an LLM summarize it...), or look into Brouwer's Intuitionism, or better yet into Lawvere and Topos theory, where the "underlying tautologies" literally change depending on the categorical environment you construct (but this may take some time to wrap your mind around so don't expect to understand much right away). Or, given the thread topic, you can just prompt an LLM to interactively walk you through how classical logic fails in a constructivist topos, or if you have interests outside of applied math or mathematics itself, you can ask it about foundational questions in science and mathematics, which unlike the prevailing opinion in many tech circles, aren't resolved.
A lot of the Cascade range is basalt, and you don't need to cut down very far to expose it. A result is that most waterways in Oregon have revealed a lot of basalt around them, at least in the mountains.
Yep, there's a ton of it to be found especially in the Columbia River Gorge. For anyone not hip to Nick Zentner, allow me to introduce you to this national treasure...
Climbing on columnar basalt is interesting. Vantage / Frenchmans Coulee (2 hours or so east of Seattle) has a bit of a bad reputation but some of the routes are decent.
Fortunately, we now have 50 years of evidence of the negative effects of this philosophy on the ecosystem. Being strict in both results in net positive effects for the entire ecosystem. Trying to be lenient in what you accept results in HTML5, where the exact parse tree for every possible input sequence is specified in order to enforce compatibility. It's no longer lenient, because that doesn't work.
One is „accept a wide array of syntactically malformed input, ill defined, substantially complicating the parser“, the other „accept two trivial extensions to the standard that are widely used and don’t affect the resulting data in any way.“
So far nobody has tried to get trailing commas into the standard AFAIK.
Comments were explicitly disallowed from JSON since the beginning, because they could be used as a side-channel for vendor-specific extension mechanisms and harm interoperability.
After that, when vehicle sizes start trending down towards reasonable, we can look at getting speeds up without reducing overall safety.
reply