HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | chermi's commentslogin

What do you want? Some oversight board voting on what companies are allowed to do with their own money?

Wtf are the downvotes. It's a question.


Your perspective made sense until 2007.

We don't live in that world anymore. The bailouts changed the world forever. Since 2007 there is no such things as "with their own money" when it involves a big company risking bankruptcy. It's no longer private money.

Chancellor on the brink


I didn't want the bailouts.

And yet you got them.

Do you really want someone qualified for politics in that sense?


Last I checked labor was 15-30% for such projects, so it could help but only so much


Again, I asked ChatGPT for some sources for your post, but I couldn't find any reliable sources. Can you provide a reliable source for your claim?


I'm 99% they use nvidia at least for training


See nuclear topic, scroll just like 2 turns to see once again someone claiming nuclear is the one technology in all of history that doesn't improve with technology.


Damn what's happened since this? Presumably they scramble refusal intentionally somehow now? Like intentionally couple it to "directions" that effect performance if messed with? Or is it more like just don't rely on the model to refuse and instead capture bad responses between generation and delivery?


I've seen attempts to obfuscate the refusal direction, like here: https://arxiv.org/html/2608.18093v1

Also this one was interesting, training the model to give preambles with reasons for the reasons for refusal seems to make it less sensitive to modulating the single refusal direction: https://arxiv.org/html/2505.19056v1

My empirical observation is that when a new model is released on HuggingFace, an abliterated version with < 10/100 refusals (baseline usually 100/100) is uploaded the same day, so either these techniques don't work very well or the open-weight labs aren't applying them.

There's some defense-in-depth, like a lot of the "guardrails" people hit on cloud models are classifiers applied to prompt or output, not a refusal generated by the model. Also closed-weight models obviously try to avoid this by not letting you see or modify the weights.


I'm not active in this space but why do you think anything happened since this? As far as I know, it still works.


I think a lot of people don't understand, with respect to a mathematical theory, the relation between a carefully stated conjecture requiring formal proof vs. using the objects in the theory effectively. Could better understanding of NS lead to better practical tools? Almost certainly, even if only to give us bounds on performance. Has its unresolved status stopped us from using NS? No. Almost no one using it cares. Resolving it is valuable, especially if it comes with mathematical and/or physical insight leading to greater understanding. But it is not this is grand result that like instantly unlocks 100+ day weather forecasts.

It would be like saying proving ergodicity more generally for physical systems would unlock condensed matter physics, ignoring how well stat mech has served us regardless.

I am not anti-AI and I don't think we should stop throwing them at conjectures. I'm against this fundamentally misleading type framing that's become prominent. Millennium prize problems are important. Treating this specific aspect of NS as the one missing piece is just harmful. If we just throw compute at formal conjectures voila cancer and fusion.

I think the better example of "AI" usefulness toward solving problems is AlphaFold, and immensely powerful tool. But also suffering from a false framing/marketing problem as "solving protein folding". It feels like the right use of compute. Considering many factors that we can't hold in our head at once. "Solving" something that was already "solved" via computation (simulation) but now much more efficiently. The output is a valuable tool itself, it was not about "solving the protein folding problem", which it didn't do. It is a tool to solve problems requiring a sequence->ground state calculation. Which is a very broad set.

Formal verification of a conjecture we set up as a benchmark we set to test human understanding is not valuable in the same way.

I'm failing to make multiple points and gotta run, but i think that final point is important. The millennium prizes are not about technological/practical value, at least not intentionally. They're about shit that seems fundamental to us, things that feel[1] to us based on our understanding are important AND feel like they should be solvable in a human-comprehensible way. So formally resolving them with pure compute is not really the point. It seems closer to that story about one of those prime conjectures where some guy just ran brute force enumerations to find a counterexample. Valuable for sure, time-saving. And knowing the answer makes it a lot easier to solve a problem.

TL:DR science and math are more than formally resolving conjectures, they're about building up understanding and tooling that you can then build more on. AI should be an increasingly big part of it, but declaring "AI will solve fusion because it's smart" is like the rest of the fucking owl meme. I have no doubt it will help, most likely via simulations/quicker testing/calculations and verification. Maybe partly via reactor designs. Maybe partly being fed conjectures about bounds/limits that would be useful as inputs for the next iteration. And maybe even in the form of resolving some formally stated conjectures (I don't know enough plasma physics to name any).

[1] obviously to the mathematicians it's more than a feeling..


I think you stopped at the wrong time with the wrong perspective. Why can't that info accumulation part also be made more self-contained?

I guess I'm having trouble unraveling your experience and personal usage vs. what you're concluding about the labs.


Almost but not quite I think. You can throw money at parts of problems. I think it's helpful to think it kind of like supercomputer MD/MC or electronic structure calculations. A tool that can get you valuable answers but not necessarily aid understanding. Simulations can be used to aid understanding also, and are integral to theory development. In the same way the approach to this result is.


I'm basically on your side here, but there were plenty of models predicting catastrophe by now.


Places that used to be 32C in summer are consistently hitting 36C+. It absolutely sucks to be outside in those temps. You are running from aircon to aircon. Doom scenarios of unbearable heat is definitely true.


Germany had two sizable heatwaves this summer, of which one was so intense that for the first time in about "ever" ACs tripled/quadrupled in price (note this includes those on online stores where the shipping times would allow for trucking them in from all across central Europe)... I'm not referring to installation labor/technicians even. But like window units and similar ones that don't rely on HVAC technicians to take out the box and turn on.


What does any of that have to do with what I said? I agree with you but I guess not with enough zeal.



That doesn't relieve people of the responsibility of having enough scientific literacy to understand that 30 years is only an instant on geological time scales. And the fact that we see meaningful change at all on this time scale is very concerning.


> And the fact that we see meaningful change at all on this time scale is very concerning.

or it's noise. I'm also on your side but be realistic.


Ah yes, I believe one of those models was called the Strawman Model, generated by Elliot F. Strawman during his tenure at MIT. He was forced into retirement due to his deep embarrassment over his model’s inaccuracies.

Anyway, Illinois is about to break the all time record for tornadoes by a single state, previously held by Texas, during the strongest El Niño ever measured. I’ll be proud tucking my kids in and telling them as long as they pray hard enough to the Gods of technological progress, we’ll be guaranteed to stumble upon a carbon sequestration technology akin to the Haber process and they won’t have to be forced into a Sophie’s choice when there’s only enough clean water for 2 of their 3 children.


Take a breath. Read what I said.


Worth noting Texas is having one of its quietest tornado years in the ~20 years of comparable data, at the same time. Which is the problem: the reliable detection era is about 30 years, and the preliminary dataset behind these headlines starts in 2004. The IPCC has low confidence in observed trends in severe convective storms for exactly this reason. And your El Niño point argues against you, since El Niño is associated with suppressed spring tornado activity in the southern Plains, which is what we're seeing in Texas.


From what I read Texas will have larger and more intense heat domes. On the plus side, this high pressure shifts tornado alley towards the east away from Texas. On minus side, Texas will be the new Arizona.


Mind sharing some? I often hear people believe climate scientists frequently overstate things, and I can’t recall seeing good examples of this.


Watch “an inconvenient truth”


Just ask ChatGPT

“What were the major predictions and timeline in the movie An Inconvenient Truth?”

He got some things wrong but was right on a lot.


I was responding to the claim that many models had predicted catastrophe. An Inconvenient Truth is a movie made by a politician. It, of course, chose to depict the more extreme ends of probabilities. And despite that, I think it stands up pretty well, all things considered.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: