HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | chaicodes's commentslogin

Thankyou so much for the feedbacks, I'll pick them up in next few versions. If you try it again in a week or so, you'd find a lot of these issues resolved.


Hey guys, thanks for putting it here, I am Chaitanya I built Munder Difflin, I am here to answer all your questions(except nylonstrung).

For people who haven't tried it: Munder Difflin is a local multi-agent harness that wraps around your existing claude code and codex subscriptions(we literally support almost all harnesses/coding agents).

Simulations are deterministic, they do not consume tokens, infact most of the users(20K+ in a week) say that it has reduced their token consumption due to a benchmarked memory layer acting as a hive mind called mempalace.

Common use cases apart from coding: 1. Create triggers that runs an live agent with your context(Webhooks, slack, scheduled) 2. Almost any kind of automation for yourself(I make it review PRs, send cold emails with enriched context, manage discord, Send myself analytics about how app is doing on email an end to end AI video production and posting workflow in 1 prompt and then some)

I'd love to hear your feedbacks on it.


It's interesting but It was hard to tell from a quick read if this was a fun game with LLMs or a productivity tool. You could stand to make that more clear.


...I agree but I also kind of like it? More software should aim to be both useful and fun.


my last comment was flagged - presumably i didn't make it pedantic enough for someone, so let me try again:

why do you feel the need to pigeon-hole this work? the greatest things in life are more than one thing at once.

EDIT: stealth edits of your comments is naughty-naughty.


I don’t think GP is being unreasonable. Half of this webpage kinda sounds like parody and the other half serious. It’s valid feedback.


did i say he was being unreasonable?

i asked him why he's pigeon-holing it. and you, too? don't hackers enjoy a little bit of playful ambiguity in their lives? must it be all serious all the time?

sheesh.


Sir, this is the Internet in 2026. We don't allow playful anything unless the intent is clearly labeled and approved by your local decency csar. Please continue to refrain from double entendre, sarcasm, irony, or any other form of misunderstandable communication. Every thought must be of clear intent to the community so we may apply the correct direction of moderation to facilitate the amplification or suppression of thoughts in line with the already accepted and centrally approved community morality. Thank you for your cooperation.


Or just like, don't mock people for asking what the intent is.


UNDERSTOOD. WILL COMPLY.


Ya damn right u will ;P


If you want to over-analyze people's reactions, sure I'll help:

They're pigeon-holing because it can't be both. This isn't a situation where there's real overlap.

Ambiguity is a lot more fun when there is substantial overlap, and on top of that ambiguity for the question of "is this useful" is bad ambiguity much more often than it's fun ambiguity.


> it can't be both

Really? Do you have a proof of that?

Looking outside the realm of computer software, are you familiar with the concept of satire? "A Modest Proposal" is both funny and deadly serious at the same time. And it's been studied for hundreds of years.

So I guess we'll just have to agree to disagree.


A modest proposal isn't serious about what it suggests. It's not a real way to solve either problem it talks about. If that's the best comparison, then this is straightforwardly not a productivity tool.


I'm sorry I was not able to explain to you how things can be two things at the same time.


Some ideas can overlap, some ideas can't. By ignoring the specifics of this situation, you confuse yourself into being wrong.


Sigh.

"I'm right, you're wrong" doesn't make a very good proof.

EDIT: I'm going to bed. You may have the last word.


I really don’t get what you’re going on about. If it’s actual satire, then it is not real. If it isn’t real then it’s not a tool I can use for my job which is what it says it is.

I still don’t freaking know if this thing is a joke or not.


Satire is merely an analogy.

I think maybe you're having trouble with metaphor and ambiguity.


[flagged]

The people moderating this website are deranged, sadly


I never did Digg but I remember the issue there was the "power users".

Power corrupts, almost always. Most people are horrible when given power. The only thing holding them in-check is their powerlessness.


porque no los dos?


“send cold emails with enriched context”

What’s the difference between cold and spam?


Nailed it. I constantly get “cold emails” that were clearly written by an AI that read 2-3 pages on my web site, my LinkedIn bio, and something else on my social media. They all follow the same formula: try to break they ice with something funny about somewhere I took a photo recently, then segue into what I do for work, then offer to help me do it better - usually by offering leads or CRM improvements.

It’s such an obviously repetitive recipe that someone must have published as an example somewhere, and now lots of people (or bots) are trying to follow it, all mining for gold that doesn’t exist.


I often get cold emails from people interested in my very specific hobby (see website in profile). These are desired and fun.

Mind, they are not written by LLMs. I would consider that spam, outside of very limited circumstances (maybe a non-english speaker using an LLM for translation).


I have no desire to get either so functionally nothing.


most cold emails end up spam, only a small fraction end up being useful. My cold email strategy respects google's limits are very personal and mostly not for selling.

Why I mentioned this here: Everyone knows about cold emailing, this is one of the ways I describe the personalisation and integration. It does, slack, discord, and practically works with anything that has an api key.


The name.


How is this different from a Hermes agent? Any major pro? Besides the cute graphics.

And why do you need E2E encrypted comms between your own agents? What is that protecting against? To prevent other agents snooping and maybe getting derailed? Or do you support conversations between agents of different users?


Let's say if you are away from your computer and your collegue asks you for a report that's anyways gonna take you one prompt on your agent.

Your Collegue's Munder Difflin agent can directly talk to your Munder Difflin agent through our network, you'd want your messages end to end encrypted.


When you say no code leaves your machine, how does code get evaluated by your LLM of choice? Doesn't Claude see your code when you send a prompt just like it usually does?


Yes, but you can use local models with opencode/pi


Cool project! I’m still trying to figure out if this sort of thing is the future, or something that the big AI labs will subsume into their products on their own soon. Or something that won’t be necessary in a few months when LLMs get smarter.


You won't see big AI companies allowing other providers in their native agents/harnesses. I believe this is a great opportunity for open source projects like us.


What an exciting project, Chai. Congratulations on your work.


Thankyou so much <3


I don't want to contact you for pricing.


Too bad, man's gotta make money to live in the capitalistic society.


That is possible while openly stating your products price.


Hey thanks, I'll update the pricing on website today.


Does it work with local LLMs?


Yes, it supports opencode and qwen clis, both of them can be configured to work with local LLMs.


Why does it build Nemotron 3 Ultra on startup if Opencode was selected? Can I do Opencode to Ollama (local) or Ollama directly @ the moment?


when did you launch, how many users you have, and what's the business metrics if you don't mind sharing.


We launched 8 days ago on product hunt, been working on it for 2 months before that.

We are piloting our TEAMS plan with 5 businesses and currently have over 10,000 end users and over 30,000 agents spawned on the community version.

About to launch our PRO tier for the power users of community version. We are optimising for everything that'll increase their productivity.

Hope it helps, also I am looking for an angel investor if anyone's interested in making this big.


don't let the crankles get you down. this thing is delightful.


This is still better than what I got at some of the subreddits, I can handle it.


HEH. It still doesn't make it right.


I love it!!! But please, change that "GOD orchestrator" label, as a believer, I find it profane and offensive.


To get past the uh… man I really lack the words to describe the responses that you’ve already received, but I guess to avoid them going forward, I would re-label the point your making as being more culturally sensitive. It’s not asking people to accommodate your faith, rather your culture. It removes the convicting tone and imposition of your beliefs that others wish to derive from your request and instead communicates a desire for representation that isn’t “mandated” but appreciated.

It probably won’t prevent people from getting worked up over the request but it sheds a lot of potential hate and ammunition.


Perhaps consider reframing the term from referring to the God in which you believe but as merely a reference to just the top agent in its little Munder Difflin universe?

Seems like both a mental model which more accurately represents the meaning of the "GOD orchestrator" term, and solves the meaning disconnect closest to the source that is troubling you, thus being the most effective and efficient solution for everyone?


Everyone is a believer.

What exactly do you believe and why should anyone accomodate it?


Is that satire?


God no, I would believe...


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: