HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | cferry's commentslogin

Not sure it is a good thing indeed. As long as attested systems don't have momentum, application developers (and their funders) that target Linux have an incentive not to use it. When the userbase mostly has an attestable configuration, a developer using it will only annoy (and exclude) those who explicitly don't want it... and are today running Linux, among others, for that very reason.

This site is a prime example of the worst kind of enshittification that could happen around an IPO. I left when the first moves around that were looming (API restrictions and 3rd party app ban). This is one of the rare decisions of mine that I have yet to be critical about.

When I read old.reddit.com was disabled for non-logged-in users, to be sure I'd never hit this site again even by mistake, I put a rule in my router's DNS resolver to lie and pretend an NXDOMAIN.


When it comes to attestation, it's purely promoting business and state interests against yours. No security comes with it, it's purely control.

Imagine being the owner of a small business who is now required, to do business with any providers, to have a rogue executive that is loyal to them rather than you, and overrides your decisions; your provider refuses to sell you any materials if this executive is not obeyed. Do you think any business owner would accept that? I think on the contrary, this practice would be outlawed by Congress or the relevant legislative body in a matter of weeks. Those who voted seatbelts in. Then it's exactly that, if you replace business by computer.


You’re telling a story and the story is consistent, but it’s still a story. Besides you’re making a lot of assumptions about me, my beliefs, and what might be of concrete benefit to me.


> The logical labor response should be to not work for companies that require remote employees to submit to constant visual supervision.

Or make this kind of intrusive monitoring illegal? Preventing this kind of abuse is exactly the reason there are labor codes.


> Is it wrong to require people to use certain tools?

As the state or a representative thereof, yes; that's why public service is either run by itself or contracts to operators who must then abide by requirements (like no discrimination, unconditional access to information, social pricing, or similar provisions depending on your jurisdiction), that they would scrape the very day their activity became free market.

In France, even banks, a sector without a public actor in most countries, are legally required to open accounts ("droit au compte"). I don't mean _any_ kind of account, but at least one. On which banks naturally don't make a profit...

Google or Apple on the other hand, have no legal duty to let you in, which means in practice that they can lock you out of public services that they gate access to.

BTW: overthinking is how society moves forward :)


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: