I canceled my subscription after like 12 years because I realized all the things that made it great aren’t really needed anymore. The “it just works” tooling, refactoring, jumping around code, etc.
Now my agents mainly write code under my direction and I review it either in the harness or on GitHub.
I hadn’t opened it in ages and when I did need an IDE something like Zed was more than sufficient.
Part of what I've loved about JetBrians tools has been the navigation and deep semantics for large code bases. Zed is pretty basic in that regard. My agents usually get what I need, but when they go off the rails, cleanup gets interesting.
But I'll admit to keep my skills from atrophying, there are some projects of mine I don't touch with AI.
Code review is the problem I'm currently trying to figure out for myself. I've never liked GitHub PRs but I'm not 100% sure what I want instead (which is possibly just: it feels like it should be a VS Code plugin... But maybe I don't like VS Codes interface that much either?)
The only issue I’ve run into with Podman is that, like docker, I can’t have the container’s process be part of my shell’s foreground process group. For docker the daemon (either rootful or rootless) makes that inevitable, but podman has better rootless support, so I’d been hoping.
Unfortunately, there’s an unconditional setsid during podman’s container setup, which as far as I could tell exists so that the container can be detachable.
(This was all so that I could have the same job management with Ctrl-Z, SIGSTOP, SIGTSTP, fg, and bg, regardless of whether the process I’m running starts up a container. The only way I’ve found to have that is by handling chroot/unshare myself.)
UNIX job management is fundamentally broken already in that it simply can't be properly nested, even with PID namespaces. If the "container’s process [is the] part of my shell’s foreground process group", then it can not, literally can not, job manage its children.
Clearly, the solution is to extend the `kill` syscall to accept the PID as a Gaussian integer, with both real and imaginary components. That way, we can preserve the current behavior of `kill(+123, sig)` and `kill(-123, sig)` as sending a signal to a single process or to a process group, respectively, and will then allow `kill(+123*i, sig)` as sending a signal to all processes that are either within a process group have a direct or indirect parent within that process group. I don't know what we'd use the negative imaginary numbers for, but I'm sure we could think of something.
If not for the uncatchable SIGKILL/SIGSTOP, I'd say that any process that calls `setsid` is responsible for ensuring signal propagation across the pgid. But since those are uncatchable, I tend to shrug and figure that I'll avoid setsid wherever possible.
There was a proposal at one point that would have had `unshare(NEW_CGROUP)` place the process into a child cgroup, rather than merely changing the name of the current cgroup. This would have meant that cgroups could actually be used for nested process management. Unfortunately, there's no guarantee that a process can ever make nested cgroups it wouldn't be sound for all supported resource constraints, so that proposal never went in. But that would have been nice to actually have nestable job management.
> I'd say that any process that calls `setsid` is responsible for ensuring signal propagation across the pgid.
How?! After a process calls setsid(2), it becomes a leader of a new process group so it stops receiving signals from its former process group!
> But that would have been nice to actually have nestable job management.
Yes, it would be. Just imagine: a simple, straightforward way to group a bunch of processes (and their potential children, inescapably), signal them all at once, wait for them all at once, etc. Instead, we at best ended up with docker compose and k8s. And they kinda do solve that problem, no question about that but it's just so incredibly heavyweight...
> How?! After a process calls setsid(2), it becomes a leader of a new process group so it stops receiving signals from its former process group!
By limiting its usage to the period between fork and exec, so that the process calling setsid knows that the parent process is propagating signals to it.
So, my phrasing was inaccurate to the point of being entirely incorrect. I should have said that any process that calls `setsid` is responsible for ensuring that signals are being propagated. (And saved! Definitely didn't make a mistake on the internet and then play it like I was right all along.)
> any process that calls `setsid` is responsible for ensuring that signals are being propagated.
Well, again, the process that calls setsid(2) ceases to receive the signals from its previous process group, so there is nothing for it to propagate. The only way this propagation can work is with cooperation from the parent process of the setsid-calling process: it will need to manually pass the group-wide signals to its setsid-calling child — which it can't reliably do for two obvious reasons.
> By limiting its usage to the period between fork and exec, so that the process calling setsid knows that the parent process is propagating signals to it.
Wait. Are you implying a scheme where the process A, that wants to do setsid(2), forks itself, and it's this child process B that does setsid(2) and all future actual work, while process A merely lives in a "while(1) { sig = sigwait(); signal(pidB, sig); }" loop forever? This almost works but doesn't survive SIGSTOP/SIGCONT/etc. and, of course, you can't propagate SIGKILL. And SIGKILL-propagation is arguably one of the main attraction of the process groups — you send SIGKILL to the process group (or a container, for that matter), and all of it dies with no further work on your part.
EU protects it at a federated level, and no contract terms can override mandatory local statutory rights. Indeed most US-centric EULA clauses are considered invalid or unenforceable in the EU.
It feels like a mismatch in expectations. It's fairly obvious the developers consider the persistent undo feature to be a convenience for short-term continuity if you are exiting and re-entering the editor over a single edit session, not a long-term storage of the history of the file. All of their decisions make perfect sense in that context, but it seems that expectation is not shared by some of their users, who considered it to be an important piece of data meant to be kept long-term. This feels a bit odd to me, given the tendency for undo systems to be fragile anyway, and the documented fragility of this persistence. The author of this article even had deliberate workarounds for some of this fragility which I feel would put me in 'should I even trust this feature?' mode. To me the main fix would be updating the documentation to scream even more loudly "Don't expect this to stay around!".
To me it's a bit like storing your important files in a ramfs and then complaining that your OS doesn't respect user data when it crashes. Sure, it's not exactly a documented behaviour of the system, but you're also not storing your data in a place the developers of the OS expected you to put important data.
> but you're also not storing your data in a place the developers of the OS expected you to put important data.
So exactly the opposite of persistent undo?
The short-termism changes little here, losing weeks' worth of work just because you deleted it recently by mistake and then upgraded with the app deleting the undo, is also bad
That's the point, though, undo (in most applications) is a fragile place to hold much work, regardless of whether it normally survives restarting the app. You could argue about whether it should be that way (infinite, robust, persistent undo is a nice safety net in general), but I would not assume that is the case unless it's very well documented otherwise (and the UI is adjusted accordingly: you really need an undo tree, else a large series of undos followed by an accidental edit will also wipe out a lot of data), and neovim's documentation does not say that it is intended to work that way.
It's some sort of industry standard, though, isn't it? Google Chrome on Android auto-deletes the history database silently if it deems it corrupted (e.g., due to a bad write on a system with low storage). You just open your browser one day and it's all gone.
If you ignore it, do you continue allowing edits to the file? Now undo history is corrupt and useless anyway. Or do you disallow editing until the user manually deletes some hidden, implementation-detail file for a feature they probably never use?
If making a breaking change to the format of the file, why in root's name would neovim not just make its own new file!? Import the vim version if that's desired into persistent-undo.neovim and then just go from there. I don't understand their choice here at all nor why you're acting like this is complicated or there was some need for them to reuse the exact same file as vim?
To support you further, why would neovim users have any illusion there would be cross compatibility between undo files? Separate undo files seems the obvious and expected choice.
reply