HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | cbmuser's commentslogin

No, it’s not and you have no clue what you are talking about.

There is a reason even Germany is still heavily dependent on coal despite investing hundreds of billions into renewables

It simply does not work without dispatchable energy sources.


Batteries are the best dispatchable energy "source". This is the obvious next step for Germany and others.

Germany still uses coal, but I wouldn't say they are heavily dependent. They consume ~100TWh per year of coal (20% of total), down from ~300TWh in 2015 (50% of total). They plan to close them all by 2038, and they are on the way to do so even before that.

But coal is a political problem because the are producers, thus a good chunk of voters work in that industry. Political parties that promise to keep coal running could still get many votes.


Yes, it is possible. You need to penalize fossil fuels with CO2 charges, but that's needed to get a nuclear powered economy too.

Your argument about Germany is obviously BS, basically "it didn't happen yet therefore it can't happen". Solutions must apparently leap fully implemented into the world or else they are impossible, by your logic. Do you apply the same logic to nuclear, since no country gets the majority of its energy from nuclear (not even France)?

Storage can be dispatched, you know (and it's not just batteries.)


France gets the majority of its electricity from nuclear yes, 70%.


This is what you wrote upthread:

> All western civilization is built on 24/24 7/7 available energy (from direct use of petroleum or electricity).

Petroleum != electricity. You were talking about more than just electrical power. No goal post shifting!


Not at all. I never spoke about global energy use, of course neither nuclear or renewable can replace oil use now. Nobody is even trying, but some use is slowly being displaced toward electricity, like with electric cars and heating with heat pumps. High temperature industrial heat is still out of reach (which countries produce fertilizers or cement with electricity ? none).

But it's a lots slower than newly added power generation by renewables so there are market distortions (cheap uneconomical electric power from renewables is wasting investment in nuclear for example, just stupid) so we have economic warfare between germany and all its producing neighbors (see France/Scandinavia) for example.


> never spoke about global energy use

You said "a civilization". Is that not a global concept? But regardless, there is no country which gets the majority of its energy from nuclear.


Mycle Schneider does not even have an academic title. He is simply an anti-nuclear activist.


Not going to happen in the foreseeable future. Fossil fuels did not change there relative share the past 30 years.


Between 1950 and 1980 the home market for computers was non-existent.

So of course this didn't change in the 30 years following 1980, right?


Which perfectly proves that 90% of the comments in this thread have no clue about energy and think that running a grid on solar and wind only plus some batteries is a solved problem.


Yes, “just” need to build some TWh capacity batteries. No problem at all.


The world builds several TWh of batteries every year.

https://about.bnef.com/insights/clean-transport/china-alread...


Not going to happen.


So, you are telling me that you can survive by eating seven times the daily ration of an average human and then it nothing the rest of the week?


It's certainly more survivable than eating 1x the daily ration once a week.


China is currently building almost 40 nuclear plants at the same time.


Yeah but that is over the next 10-15 years.


They are currently building half of all the nuclear plants under construction around the world.

You are right that China has structural advantages when it comes to building nuclear, and they are making use of them.


Its basically a drop in the bucket. If you look at five year plans the nuclear share is continually dropping.

By 2030 there is 110GW planned of nuclear and 2800GW of solar and wind.


Effectively nothing at the scale of their grid


Compare the average specific carbon emissions and price per kWh between Germany and France and tell me nuclear is not competitive.

Nuclear is so competitive that they had to ban it in Germany to get rid of it.


Germany has been spending a lot recently to build new power generation. Of course it’s expensive.

France is now on ancient fully depreciated nuclear reactors that are soon in dire need of replacement. Of course it’s cheap. But they have huge investments ahead of them to replace, upgrade, refurbish, etc. They have identified that that need to expand renewable energy to 50% of power generation, at least.

We’ve also seen recently that Germany has had to save France during hot summers when their reactors have had to shut down.

What’s the lesson from France? Build lots of nuclear all at once many decades ago when labor was cheap and then stop investing and letting your infrastructure rot, and you’ll have cheap power for some limited time? Is that something anyone can or should copy today? No.

Now, even VALCOE (value-adjusted LCOE) of wind and solar is coming down well below all other fossil and nuclear alternatives. So how can you say betting on renewables was the wrong at this time? It has been expensive to transition but long term it’s drastically cheaper than everything else. And we haven’t even started getting the benefits of how repowering old renewable power plants is significantly cheaper than building new ones.


Even on many days with sun and wind Germany is burning gas for electricity 24/7.

Simply not stopping the most modern nuclear plants we had (like Isar 2 in Munich) would have made a nice impact on costs and CO2 emissions.

Building new (nuclear) ones is probably not worth it, though.


You're reading from the playbook of bad nuclear bro arguments.

The implication you're trying to draw there is a non sequitur. That situation doesn't contradict what I said. Moreover, France is going to be dragged kicking and screaming into the renewable age because they can't afford to subsidize nuclear builds enough to make a nuclear approach work.


Denmark highly depends on imports.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: