HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | caturopath's commentslogin

Yeah, Apple, Microsoft, and Google all had somewhat of dull times with weaker innovation when their founders stepped back. Disney entered its "Bronze Age" after Walt stepped down and I think fans/critics consider this a much weaker period until the 'renaissance' ~30 years later, though I think their parks might have seen a lot of advancement.

I know nothing about Walmart, but ChatGPT gives me this list of supposed milestone dates

1962 – First Walmart opens.

1970 – Walmart goes public.

1971 – First distribution center opens.

1980 – Annual sales reach $1 billion.

1983 – First Sam's Club opens.

1988 – First Supercenter opens; Sam Walton steps down as CEO, succeeded by David Glass.

1990 – Becomes America's largest retailer.

1991 – Enters Mexico, its first international market.

1996 – Enters China and launches Walmart.com.

2002 – Becomes the first company to top the Fortune 500.

2016 – Acquires Jet.com for $3.3 billion.

2018 – Acquires majority stake in Flipkart for $16 billion; changes corporate name to Walmart Inc

If that's right, it sounds like they indeed switched from innovation to expansion around the time Walton left. Like Disney, they've done some impressive stuff much later. Microsoft can also be said to have had a renaissance after a quiet time. Maybe Apple and Google will some time.


If someone was going full Chicken Little, I suppose "these things happen" could be reassuring, but that doesn't seem to be what Blank or the top commenters here are saying.

I tend to think indeed the effects will be bad in terms of Nvidia's ability to execute and in turn bad for the world. I don't understand exactly why Nvidia has stayed so unique a leader for so long when the prize is so juicy, but as far as I can tell it's because they are super able to get shit done; as far as I can tell, it isn't just because they could book more TSMC time than AMD or Broadcom or even because Intel hasn't quite mastered the fabrication.

Not saying firing him wasn't the right move after the level of unethical and illegal behavior and amount of indiscretion he's shown.


Just wait 10^53 years and see if the mass has decreased.

I use the name "Human" for that but it overrides with its knowledge of my name from other stuff quite regularly.

For example, there's probability 0 of worlds where charge isn't conserved.


CPT symmetry isn't conserved, so that's not necessarily a given.

We don't know the mechanism which generates the gauge symmetry that makes charge discrete or generates conservation laws from symmetries, so it's risky to be too prescriptive about what is and isn't possible.

In the limit you can imagine a meta-technology which manipulates the mathematical structures that generate reality instead of just assuming the rules are fixed. That might or might not be possible, but the rules have to come from somewhere and there's no absolute guarantee they're hardcoded.


So, what I meant to say was that using the computational gadget from physics, none of the branches will violate conservation of charge.

However, my post sucked and I didn't get around to emphasizing that. In quantum mechanics, it's possible for some state to have zero probability, and it's those probabilities that we're talking about everything being possible.

There's also the epistemic side where we know that there's a chance our theories are wrong in any given way. Those can't go to zero based on our model since the whole point is we're not restricting to a model. BTW, I really like your example as a good, clean limiting case.

-------------

I'm sure people have come up with theories that violate conservation of charge, but they'd have to break U(1). I don't know what conservation CPT would break, if any; Noether's theorem shouldn't apply to it as a discrete symmetry.


Charge IS conserved!

The C in CPT is not only a change f charge but also a change of electron <---> positron, and quark <---> antiquark, and ...

The conservation or charge comes from the U(1) gauge symmetry. That is almost obvious if you ignore the mixing with the weak interaction, but after the mix you still have a U(1) gauge symmetry anyway.


I thought that in an expanding universe, mass isn't conserved. I don't see why charge would be conserved in that case.


Mass isn't close to being conserved. If an electron and positron annihilate, they become two massless photons, for example. You don't need to invoke an expanding universe.

In an expanding universe, energy isn't conserved. (Unless we do the trick we always do with energy and just define it to be conserved https://youtu.be/lCgKTpIzjRk?t=174 )

I don't know exactly why you think this applies to charge conservation. The U(1) symmetry is where charge conservation comes from and it isn't affected by an expanding universe.


The photons have energy, so through mass-energy equivalence, they aren't massless, I thought.


Sorry for the too late reply...

There is "rest mass" and "relativistic mass". The GP is talking about "rest mass" that is not conserved even in simple examples.

Most modern books try to eliminate "relativistic mass" because it's misleading, for example is good to calculate acceleration perpendicular to the movements (for example in a cyclotron) but it's not good to calculate acceleration in the direction of the movement.

So most modern books they call the same idea just "energy" and use that "energy" to calculate gravitation. "Energy" is conserved in special relativity and almost conserved in general relativity.

But the "relativistic mass" is useful in some problems and is widespread in popular culture and don't ask about the weird parts of the mass of the proton, so it's difficult to kill the idea.


When an electron flies beyond the cosmological event horizon, it disappears for good.


If so, this has interesting implications for the cause of the baryon asymmetry problem.

Either the baryon number started non-zero and was conserved; or non-conservation of baryon number (protons vs antiprotons etc) have to be paired with equivalent non-conservation of lepton number (electrons vs positrons etc); or it can happen without simultaneously balancing the lepton number, and charge isn't conserved.

Unfortunately (for me) those implications are above my level. I can't usefully converse with an LLM about it, as this isn't a domain I know well enough to detect if it's making stuff up.


This would matter for bigger versions of the same thing. For side-by-side, the aspect ratio is unimportant since you naturally unfold to have two of them.


Not sure if I'm misunderstanding you, but of course the aspect ratio is important. If you unfold a square, you don't get two squares.


I think the person you are responding to is not thinking visually. They basically seem (to me) to think reformat-flowed fixes this, and that having the view of a web page alter because you open a book, is "not a bad thing" when you (and I) are of the view, if you maintain the aspect ratio and simply decimate how many pixels are available to show it, the actual "change" in the layout is kept to a minimum WHICH IS THE INHERENT GOOD HERE -the whole point of the A, B and C series is that the scaling function preserves the ratio of sizes of the contents, under the quality change of bigger or smaller fidelity of presentation.

Unless there is some upsight I am missing, I think the OP just "doesn't get it"


The upsight is that they are responding to a point about side by side apps, not a single full screen app on the unfolded screen


I don't think this is a killer logic either. If you consider that the apps were both running, both full screen on the folded state and alternate which is in view, and now can come into view side by side when you open, surely the "good" is that nothing positional in the layout or styling changes, when you move from swipe-and-select to side-by-side.


>If you unfold a square, you don't get two squares.

yes, you do. Two squares will fold together into the space of one square, and the same with 2 A4 sheets of paper, or two 8½x11 sheets of paper, two of them will fold together to make one of them.


I'm not exactly sure what you're trying to say, or what would refute what I said.


You said: "If you unfold a square, you don't get two squares."

In the context of this discussion, it is reasonable to assume that any "square" available to be unfolded is something approximately like the folding phone, consisting of two layers joined by a hinge. When you unfold that, you go from having a square to having a rectangle equivalent to two adjacent squares, and usable as two adjacent squares.


I see. I agree (obviously, it's a fact), but in the context of this discussion about aspect ratios and why the golden ratio would be relevant to this situation, it is reasonable to assume that the point here is that a full-screen, unfolded image would scale exactly to a half-screen/folded image with no change in aspect ratio.


>it is reasonable to assume that the point here is that a full-screen

wrong. you answered under the context of yunwal's comment https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49630931#49634166

  > None of that matters for a phone.
  Of course it does. They show the most basic example right 
  on the page, which is that you can side-by-side full screen 
  apps. 
which is talking about the case of two separate apps running side-by-side (unfolded), as was shown in one of the pictures of the device.


Right, which is under the context of hbarka’s comment

> The iPhone Duo is designed with this in mind. The aspect ratio any way you view it, folded or open, is preserved. Apple design knows a thing or two.

which is talking about the aspect ratio being preserved in the open and folded/half modes.


that's not how threading works

there were plenty of other threads under that comment in that direction


> it is reasonable to assume that the point here is that a full-screen, unfolded image would scale exactly to a half-screen/folded image with no change in aspect ratio.

Sure, but aside from being interesting from a mathematical standpoint, there are no practical implications from that fact. When the user unfolds the phone and rotates it by 90 degrees, the fact that they're left with about the same aspect ratio (modulo whatever changes with status bars, etc.) means very little for UI design in light of the much more important fact that the screen doubled in size and thus the application's layout should be using the extra screen space to show more information, and should not assume that a majority of the screen is easily reachable by a thumb.


Think of Beethoven's ninth symphony or a foot massage. You probably don't have the sensation of hearing or of your feet being massaged, you just think about it. You can even do stuff like increase the tempo or decrease the pressure, just like aphantasiacs can turn the Eiffel Tower upside down. They just don't have the experience of seeing.


Other correctly point out it does matter what language the code is in since the human does sometimes need to read and understand it.

But also, I suspect the article is just wrong. "The hard languages got easy first" isn't true in practice and the impressive examples given are not representative or as magical as the poster makes them out to be.

The takeaway might be right in the end, but the post isn't right in the beginning.


The article doesn't seem to be about replacing nurses staffing their phones with AI. It seems to be about making sure the care they're providing is what the company wants.


I'm not sure the for-profit approach is exactly what's to blame. HMOs like Kaiser are legally forced to spend a certain fraction (80% percent for the worst case, more for large group plans) of their premium revenue on medical services. They can't save and pocket the money like a traditional for-profit enterprise.

This doesn't seem like a money-saving measure exactly. The main AIs the article talks about is making sure nurses on their nurses' lines aren't being assholes. I guess this used to be spot checked before so you save on that? Maybe? It seems like they are trying to solve the problem of some of their nurses staffing their nurses' line not treating their patients the way they're supposed to.


> spend a certain fraction (80% percent

Increasingly health insurance companies and healthcare providers are intertwined. So they may spend 80% on healthcare, but then a big chunk of that could go to the urgent care clinics that they own.

And even if they don’t own the provider, they don’t have much incentive to lower total cost because 20% of a larger number means more total profit.


> Increasingly health insurance companies and healthcare providers are intertwined.

Kaiser is an HMO. They are the insurer and try to have their employees, such as these nursing lines, perform almost all of their care. Shifting from one line of business to another is purely internal and can't game Medical Loss Ratio like your scenario.

> they don’t have much incentive to lower total cost because 20% of a larger number means more total profit

There is some bad incentive here for sure. That being said, insurers do compete on price so they lose customers if they charge more than other insurers. Also, regulatory rate review can decide whether they can raise premiums a given amount.


I’m not talking about Kaiser. I’m talking about companies like UnitedHealth Group Incorporated who own UnitedHealthcare the insurance company and Optum the healthcare provider.

> That being said, insurers do compete on price so they lose customers if they charge more than other insurers.

Yeah but that’s a second order effect. Most companies are incentivized to cut costs because they will directly realize the profit. Insurance companies are incentives to cut costs only to grow market share.

I understand the point of the profit limits, but I don’t think it works very well in practice. I think it would probably be better to just have private companies without that profit cap and add a government insurer to compete with them.


Right, but the article was about Kaiser and I was talking about the thing the article was about.


Sure, but the person you replied to said

>Maybe healthcare shouldn’t be primarily for profit?

Which is a far larger topic than what the article was about.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: