HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | cat-snatcher's commentslogin

ai psychosis

I really don't know what you mean because I don't use AI at all...

Only took him 10 years.


You're kidding yourself if you think the moment they get an upper hand or better models they won't close everything down


It’s really hard to vilify the Chinese now on this and make it stick! So far, they seem to be championing openness and freedom on this front, which considering the nature of the technology, is a huge deal!

If they change their stance later, we’ll criticize them the same.


Its not about bad/good. It's about self-serving interests. Currently, it serves China's interests to open source the models. If they had capabilities beyond those available in the US, I expect that would no longer be the case. Especially given the military/cyber implications. You don't expect them to open source their J-35 blueprints, so why would they behave differently here?

The reason this matters is, if along the way, they destroy all economic incentives for US labs, you may find yourself in a world, where you have no alternatives to closed Chinese models.

Look no further than what happened to mineral processing. Notice they are not open sourcing their mineral processing and magnet-manufacturing technologies.


You seem to be under the impression that somehow only US has the capability to advance this tech. Aren’t these AI mega corporations constantly trying to scare us that if they stop pushing AI, China will get ahead? Which narrative should we believe?

> if along the way, they destroy all economic incentives for US labs

Nah, they should be able to compete! To be honest, I find it hard to sympathize with trillion dollar ungodly rich corps.


> You seem to be under the impression that somehow only US has the capability to advance this tech.

I did not say this, nor do I believe it.

> Aren’t these AI mega corporations constantly trying to scare us that if they stop pushing AI, China will get ahead? Which narrative should we believe?

Correct. If US paused, it will not be long before China exceeds US capabilities. I don't understand your question.

> Nah, they should be able to compete! To be honest, I find it hard to sympathize with trillion dollar ungodly rich corps.

You can't compete with free. No-one is asking for sympathy. I'm merely pointing out, people should not delude themselves that China is doing this for the goodness of mankind, and it will continue indefinitely.


Do you have an example of something that a nation did solely for the good of mankind with no vested interest in the outcome?


> I did not say this, nor do I believe it

“ If they had capabilities beyond those available in the US…”

People shouldn’t delude themselves that there’s any material difference between closed source US vs closed source China. All of your arguments apply to US equally and between these two China is the one for being open right now.


I find it hard to imagine that it would be possible to be less ethical than the US labs.

This fear mongering doesn’t scare me


You could say that about anything


Many of the open source models are now only open weight though. Where is your criticism?


No they didn’t. Give some examples where source (not weight only) were released and that changed.


If the Chinese government has anything to say about it, which in China they typically do, they won't be able to close everything down since the official stance is to be more open than closed.


Not really. The official stance is likely to be the dominant supplier of hardware and models to run on it. And the models will need to be refreshed every so often as world evolves, especially if it evolves quicker. Global south will be buying Ascends soon. And EU will eventually follow as well or bleed money to US. Selling hardware to run freely available models in itself is sufficient and way easier to enforce than that someone won't pirate the model. Can't pirate the GPU.


Please do some cursory research before guessing.

  First, adhering to the principle of openness and win-win cooperation while boosting innovation-driven development. Xi highlighted the importance of encouraging open-source, openness, collaboration and sharing to facilitate technological innovation, industrial development and scenario-based application of AI.
https://english.www.gov.cn/news/202607/17/content_WS6a59a5be...

(This is also widely reported in mainstream western media.)

I'm sure there will be a shift in tone/direction if/when Chinese models gain a substantial lead over the US models, but at least for now, this is the official stance.


It’s possible they don’t if they fundamentally believe the AI market is going to end up being an exercise in just mass manufacturing tokens, which China is going to easily win because they can generate way more electricity than any country and manufacture almost everything they need to do it domestically.

The models are just a distribution mechanism in that case, and it’s in their interest to get that into as many hands as possible.


Unironically: the vibes


it's not the harness, but the objective. A load-bearing center. We break it down, and adjust.


You were really looking for reasons to get offended huh


For example?


Clickup. Windows. Github, VSCode...

Could be argued they were going downhill before but it's a much faster decline since 2023-ish


Somebody posted that GitHub status summary: in ten years, they averaged 10 incidents per month — this includes the last 12 months. In the last six months, average is 22.


Google.


It was going downhill way before AI.


That's true, but also doesn't prevent the accelerated decay that it seems to be undergoing since AI hit the scene en masse a few years ago.


Because every time I see AI integration anywhere (and it's everywhere) I have an emotional breakdown and my day is ruined


AT is abused into many places it shouldn't be. That doesn't change that there are places where it is helpful.

You should seek professional help about your emotional issues.


I was being sarcastic. I’m actually a self-certified AI shill and personally paid by Dario and Sam for each and every post!


Everyone working in warehouses should stop using forklifts and use their hands like real creatives!


"You didn't bring anything to life. You just described how it should be done by the computer using code. The CPU is doing the real work!"


You did a wonderful job of constructing a strawman and DESTROYING it in your comment! AI can't build an e-signing solution, but you, the expert of experts, can do it! Good job!


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: