HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | captainclam's commentslogin

Wooow. As a total outsider, I did NOT realize how strong the anti-AI sentiment in game dev was.

The extent of AI use, which the author does not dispute, sounds really, really mild, i.e. "...they [House House] had used LLMs for "less than 0.1% of the code" to fix errors late in production." And this is still characterized as a "mistake".

I have no objection to this perspective, I am not part of this community and completely respect the efforts of any group to preserve an AI-free space for their particular discipline.

But surely a community built around a standard of 100% AI-free will quickly become quite niche, no? Especially when AI is used in a fashion that is absolutely orthogonal to the actual substance, like in this case where it corrected some bugs late in production.

EDIT: I wrote this comment before finishing the article. Author goes on to address exactly my thoughts:

"I'm trying to channel the energy I have into supporting spaces where other ways of using, thinking about and making technology can exist."


> "I'm trying to channel the energy I have into supporting spaces where other ways of using, thinking about and making technology can exist."

So interesting that the author used this phrasing because it suggests that handwritten code can't exist in a space where there is AI code or assets. But that doesn't seem to be true.

Maybe what he's getting at is that handwritten games can't compete in a field where there's also games being written with AI.


> But surely a community built around a standard of 100% AI-free will quickly become quite niche, no?

Indie games started out as a weird niche before becoming mainstream. It might serve the artform well for them to return to niche-dom in the future.


This really is not the message though. From the post:

“That’s why the worst possible reaction to a failed intervention is resignation. We may not know enough to improve our lot right now, but perhaps we could figure it out, if we tried.”

From reading the whole post, I gather that he’s truly not advocating some libertarian angle, he really is writing on the observation that policy is hard, and it’s nearly impossible to actually predict all the effects of societal intervention.

From my reading, I’m not sure even sure that he’s advocating caution or reluctance to social policy. Just goat sacrifices!


Well, my assumption was he doesn't really want more goat sacrifices but rather less interventions. Otherwise, what does he have against goats?

I think neither you nor the comment you are replying to are understanding what the article is trying to say.

It is saying, acts must be done to reaffirm the commitment to the goal, the goat is a litmus test as to whether the goal is worth it. Not to abandon the goal, some things are worth the sacrifice, but to be aware of it.


Supposing the "bubble" does burst...can someone sketch out the chain of events by which the economy crashes, i.e. ripples out and affects people with no tech investments or concerns?

When the internet was just getting started, I imagine it would have sounded ludicrous to suggest that soon, practically every single software application would have some networking component.

Similarly, I think it's a good bet that in the relatively near future, pretty much all consumer software, down to piddling little phone games, will be built with the presumption of some LLM/inference layer.

One very simple reason for this is that AI could dramatically change people's expectations for UI/UX across the board. I can see a future where the expectation is to have some natural language interface at minimum, or have UI driven a great deal by inference under the hood.

In which case, applications without these features become about as appealing as command line tools to the general public.


> it would have sounded ludicrous to suggest that soon, practically every single software application would have some networking component

Still does.


But how will my Poker app generate revenue without collecting geolocation data.

I can imagine that one of the aspects of being social creatures is that we are drawn to the entropy/surprise factor of natural language produced by a brain that isn't our own. Deriving a shared understanding without being able to precisely model the language output of someone else is like, the fundamental substance of conversation.

Maybe that's the key ingredient that's missing from LLM-generated text. Even when there is actual content there, there's this lack of surprise / uncertainty in its delivery that we require to stay engaged. We may not know what will be communicated, but knowing exactly how it will be communicated just kills our innate interest.


This presumes an LLM has something to say. The reason the text doesnt make much sense, is because it doesnt. It isnt "on topic" because it has no topic to be on. Sentences go on, are joined irrelevantly, and so on because theyre sampled from a distribution of "possibly relevant sentences". They aren't being addressed to a reader (whose mind is being modelled), on a topic the writer wishes to express.

Communication expresses an understanding. LLMs arent communicating.

LLMs generate code well enough. Code has no natural language semantics. Programming's condition of satisfaction is that the machine executes correctly. The condition of satisfaction of communication is that the communication expresses what there is to be communicated.

In the limit where an LLM is trained to repoduce an exmplar of communication, it seems as if it does so. In that limit, LLMs can reporduce anything.

If frontier labs wanted to improve "LLMs for communication" they would pay for reasoning traces to be produced which reproduced the thought process of writers/speakers thinking about their audiences. Rarely do such traces exist in prior datasets .


What I find they do badly in code is building abstraction and breaking the problem down in a way a human does. They don't seem to really build simplifying components unless you expressly tell them too, they are more than happy to just nest 10 deep or embed a 20 line called back function and use lots of shortened names. I find I can improve the code just by organising better and choosing some abstractions that make sense to the humans and then ironically you save tokens too because the AI will reuse it, but it wont create most of it itself. Its bad for domain work unless you are explicit about it.


> This presumes an LLM has something to say. The reason the text doesnt make much sense, is because it doesnt. It isnt "on topic" because it has no topic to be on. Sentences go on, are joined irrelevantly, and so on because theyre sampled from a distribution of "possibly relevant sentences". They aren't being addressed to a reader (whose mind is being modelled), on a topic the writer wishes to express.

While I don't like LLM voice either, I'd strongly disagree with this. LLM writing can be very tight these days -- sentences do not "go on" and are not "joined irrelevantly". I'm not sure when you last used an LLM, but it must have been a very long time ago; this hasn't been the case since late 2024 for frontier models, in my experience.

Obviously there's no underlying consciousness behind it all, but the verisimilitude is good enough for stimulating conversations on the recent research literature in my field, which I appreciate. For me, at least, the communication level is absolutely fine.

(YMMV, of course, and perhaps my bar for this is lower than yours.)


Constantly. Bns/tk/month easily. Large scale, all frontier models. Lots of writing tasks.

They seem to be getting better at the O(paragraph) level reporting on technical updates.

They're not yet at O(pages), and certainly no where near O(book).


100%.

And a corollary being that without any time spent on the "mundane", almost every single aspect of the work becomes the genuinely consequential decision-making steps.

Which I find exhausting.


I completely understand where you're coming from. While understanding the math and architectures of these large models can be edifying, it lacks some of the liberating/empowering spirit of traditional software. You can build a bespoke to-do app that is better suited to your needs than anything produced by some productivity software company, but you're totally beholden to one of the few big players for access to an effective LLM.

But there is so, so much interesting work and research to do at a much smaller scale. I work on drug discovery models, and none of my work requires data or infrastructure that are not generally accessible to the public (it's nice to have the computing resources of my institution but there are other ways to access a GPU).

So if you are really interested in this stuff, I would suggest looking at the endless supply of interesting problems in domains that are not dominated by huge frontier labs.


Ive been interested in exploring other domains as well, including biology, genomics, etc. Do you have any recommendations on where to get started?


Computer science turned bioinformatitian and AI engineer here. I have a BSc in Computer science since 2002 in 2013 I decided to start a Master in Bioinformatics and Computational biology and in 2018 did a PhD. Since my background is in CompSci, first before I started the master I just bought some popular science books about genetics, and biology the kind of books you see in bookstores like Barnes & Nobles, nothing too specialized. Then watched some videos about some things like Biochemistry, Genetics, DNA replication etc... then what really made a difference is taking a Mollecular Biology course, the one I took prepared me with all the pre-requisites and the book I used in the course are these : Essencial cell biology https://wwnorton.com/books/9781324033356

I feel that this book is clearly written and will give you all prerequisites to continue in a biotech, bioinformatics, computational biology or even biology graduate program if you come from a different discipline.

Good luck!


For genomics, look into viruses, in particular RNA viruses like influenza and HIV. You can fit the entire genome on your screen and learn to read it like code! There are some good text books about viruses that include genomics from scratch (I can't find the one I used now but could look later if you're interested). My advice would be to learn the biology first and understand why we care about genomes before looking into the computational stuff.


These are good points, though OP did specifically say that Meta is going to win "consumer" AI. I don't think the average consumer of AI is going to ever have to think about harnesses or worry about SOTA, they really will continue to interact with whatever is stickiest.


This exactly. The "harness" for consumer is not well defined but likely quite sticky if someone can build one. Meta is better positioned with its reach of whatsapp etc unlike anyone to try this.

Meta being meta, will likely run this as an "experiment mode" for 6 months to an year and if it does not work scrap it all and move onto the next thing.

There is a risk ofc muse does not work. But there is a good chance that with the ridiculous number of product teams doing A/B testing with insane number of people already on it, something will emerge that is interesting in a way it never could for their erstwhile Ar/VR foray.


The field is changing weekly at this point. Meta, OpenAI, and Anthropic have the most distribution right now so any can take this spot.

So why would you lock yourself in? They want you to lock yourself in, but if you build your own system, you won’t be. A layman will just use what’s best and get himself locked in, but they might be using an inferior model.

AI is a force multiplier. Doing the right thing with the right expertise is yielding dividends.


> So why would you lock yourself in...

Many people don't even know what locking in means. The crowd in this forum < 1% of the world do, you and I do, and maybe a few outside. There are only laymen outside of 99%. No one i know of knows or uses a harness. They don't know the large number of VMs built on say Hermes. They really don't care or have time. If you give them a ready made product thats a click away, and its good enough, they will use it.


But that’s who I’m appealing to. If you build a custom harness you have a 10x advantage over people who use Muse, GrokBot, Dot out of the box.


Yep. Reminds me of the famous HN lore about Dropbox https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8863 (note the 4 digit ID - early days!)

>For a Linux user, you can already build such a system yourself quite trivially by getting an FTP account, mounting it locally with curlftpfs, and then using SVN or CVS on the mounted filesystem. From Windows or Mac, this FTP account could be accessed through built-in software.


But this is what I’m saying, consumer AI is forever changing. Investing your time and money into a closed harness will put you behind someone running their own system that’s model agnostic.

If you’re on a forum like HN, would you realisticly invest your time and widgets into a closed harness instead of building your own? What if Meta’s model falls behind and all your things are on there? My advice is to invest in building your own because no one lab has shown they are worth using.

As far as “consumer,” I’m simply comparing consumer AI to a custom built one. One of OpenAI, Anthropic, Meta will probably win since they have the most distribution.


And, "stickiest", mind, where most are allready soul-sucked into the neverending doomscrolling dopamine nightmare that is Zuckbook - to beging with.-

First they "captured", or moated "communication". Now, they are going to capture "utility" ("I am actually doing something useful, not just doomscrolling. I can spend an extra 8h here. It feels good").-


The "average consumer" is a very small part of the revenue opportunity for LLMs and AI.

The real money is coming from C-suites trying to reduce head count or at least multiply productivity for their existing head count.


The following certainly does not describe all mathematics or all LLM operations, but its my mental model for why LLMs are so effective in several fields.

Lots of mathematics entails recognizing that a tool/techniques that works in one area can be adapted to a completely different problem. For a human to do this requires having a robust mental model of the technique and the problem itself, and probably having just the "right" mental model to see how they fit together. And we are talking about extremely hard/sophisticated techniques and extremely hard/sophisticated problems, so the ability to deeply appreciate either can require years of study. And on top of that, even if the mathematician has sufficient understanding to develop the intuition that the technique might work, they will need profound fortitude, skill, and patience to see the solution through.

Unlike human mathematicians, who will develop a deep understanding of only a relative handful of techniques and problems in their lifetime, LLMs have ALL written techniques, problems, solutions, etc stored in their internal representations. So when they ably match a problem to a technique, we can imagine the operation as a supercharged autocomplete, or even an extremely proficient search engine. Their stroke of genius is really a consequence of capacity, moreso than cleverness.


Yes this is it. So many breakthroughs in math (and other sciences) have been like "I went to a conference and happened to mention my work to someone in a completely different area/field and they said: well that sounds like something i just noticed in my research".

Combining spread out ideas is very powerful and LLMs are great at that.


I also work in drug discovery, and I completely agree; the extent to which the actual causal mechanisms of the efficacy of many drugs is woefully short of some human-appreciable first-principles based explanation. The point is especially undercut by hypothetically suggesting that this drug /does/ in fact pass stage 3 trials, at which point I can't fathom anyone would have a problem advancing it.

Really wish he had chosen a different example; this particular bullet point has been making the rounds on X/twitter to paint Tao as an example of some sort of gatekeeping luddite who would deny the world a post-abundance future in order to maintain the prestige of his particular career path...which is tough because I cannot think of a more responsible steward of our inevitable AI future than Tao at the moment.


I think his last point is important

* Could the AI solution be somehow misaligned by exploiting a weakness in the trial process or its math models?*

Maybe it’s a clumsy example but I think the difference is humans would follow the spirit of the trial process.

Could an AI find flaws in the process and then use them to get its drug passed? I think that’s the question.

Are you saying that the trail process is good enough that we shouldn’t worry about it?


I'm not necessarily an AI booster but I don't think it's at all true that "humans would follow the spirit of the trial process" Some of them will. But I've met far too many humans in all areas of life who will happily follow the letter and not the spirit. Sometimes out of malicious compliance, sometimes out of sheer exhaustion, sometimes because they can't tell the difference between the letter and the spirit and sometimes for a whole host of other reasons like laziness. There will be a not insignificant number of humans are not at this vary moment following the spirit of the thing.


Sure, we need redundancies and checks and balances in the system. You can’t trust everyone.

It’s not as though people who cheat the system aren’t reported or found out. Academics that lie in their research and companies that use loop holes are found out all the time. Maybe there is no will in some countries to do anything about it, but they are found out.


The important bit is that clinical trials already have those redundancies and checks and balances, and Tao didn't even bother to learn about those before going straight to reward hacking.

Academia and biotech is rife with reward hacking, I think the math people just don't get out enough to understand that entire fields have built up massive regulatory structures and lobbying systems around this already.


> humans would follow the spirit of the trial process

Yes. Pharmaceutical companies, famous for their sterling integrity, would never ever try to game the system. Pure as driven snow, they are!


Which is why it’s not just up to a drug company to self approve itself.


> humans would follow the spirit of the trial process

P-hacking has been a problem well before LLMs were wearing diapers


The accounts spreading that narrative on X no doubt have their own agenda. Before people start hyperventilating about "AI" conquering human endeavors, remember that the cash-strapped frontier labs are themselves still hiring human "Account Associates" and "Android Engineers" instead of saving those salaries using their own AI capabilities.

https://openai.com/careers/search/


Tao actually pictures the AI as having hacked the FDA, so as to pass the test despite the drug being lethal.

Picking out that one example and misrepresenting it on top of it indeed clearly is driven by an agenda. Or mere stupidity.

The central point in all of this is the misguided idea of "letting AI think for us". An over-generalization feeding into the society-wide problem of self-infantilization.


I think the best thing to say is that by thinking through the example, sharing it with people in the field, and then steelmanning it, he might have had some good points: 1) pharma would love to understand the mechanisms of drugs in detail but we don't have that. AI could help. 2) there is a possibility that a clinical trial run by AI could hack the trial get something approved when it wasn't safe or effective.


> there is a possibility that a clinical trial run by AI could hack the trial get something approved when it wasn't safe or effective

This possibility already exists and nothing about AI fundamentally changes it


Yes, obviously. Everybody here who works in pharma or is familiar with clinical trials and their history knows this.


>to paint Tao as an example of some sort of gatekeeping luddite who would deny the world a post-abundance future in order to maintain the prestige of his particular career path

why is it so hard to accept that a brilliant mathematician can have the same human flaws as anyone else i.e. ego, arrogance, jealousy and competitiveness?


Because he's not a randomly-selected person. He is actually known by people here, and he has a history of behavior that does not align with what you're suggesting he's doing here.

Like, it would be very hard to accept my best friend is a child rapist just because I discovered he had hentai that featured high school girls. It is a tenuous link at best, compounded with a demand that I ignore everything I know about him.

Could I be wrong? Sure. But you're implying it should be easy to accept with your "why is it so hard?" question.


i disagree .. ur conflating Tao's kind demeanour and brilliant work with his ego and self worth .. a lot of people admired Musk before his political shitposting changed their perception of him .. a good reputation doesnt make someone immune to criticism ..


my point is that you're ascribing personality traits to him based on a fabric scrap of evidence that people who have known him personally for years would not recognize in him

Your evidence is vastly inferior. It's not even substantial enough to base a hypothesis on. One slideshow and you build a whole headcanon around how viciously egotistical he is.

not to mention his stance on AI isn't even egotistical? Regarding AI in math, it's quite reasonable: math isn't about solving theorems. It's about conceptual understanding. Until LLMs actually are capable of conceptual understanding, they don't threaten mathematicians.

It's just like with art: they can make pretty pictures, but LLMs aren't making art.


a lot of mathematicians on X (which going by your tone so far im guessing you'll dismiss as an unreliable source of info) disagree with your assessment of Tao and are pointing out that ego could be the problem ... and if you think its insecurity or anxiety rather than ego driving his gaffes (i.e. a) his dumb take on the cancer thought experiment and b) telling his students "there's no reason to be this fast") then do explain why your interpretation is more plausible ...

personally i feel like you're resisting what im saying because it challenges your view of Tao and you're reluctant to reconsider it .. maybe im wrong, but dismissing what im saying as "not substantial" without actually engaging with the points doesnt exactly help your case .. it comes across more like you're determined to defend him regardless of the merits of the criticism, which is hardly logical and arguably looks like motivated reasoning ...

ps: saying AI images arent art but just "pretty pictures" is just cringey ... if it evokes emotion, provokes thought or creates an aesthetic experience, its art ... i mean im sure u have a pair of sports trainers and jackets .. that are made by a machine using synthetic fibers and not artistically hand crafted ... and ppl do view fashion as an art form ..


i dont know it would be very easy to me. its suspect that you bring that up as some trump card - just sounds like you have some sick fantasies in your head.


it's not hard to accept in general, but have you been following Tao for long? The combination of how virtuous he is with how informed he is with how smart he is is pretty special. He's also far from a luddite. He's been a leader of the computer-math charge.

Questions of AI policy are all hard and anyone who confidently says they know the right thing to do is too confident. Tao's fallible like anyone else, but yeah, as voices to pay attention to go he's very good.


Neil armstrong too should have been listened to .. and just like Tao .. he was quite virtuous, and informed and pretty special .. wont you say so ? and YET he was very vocal about expressing his skepticism about spacex before congress .. thank god his views were rejected .. or we might have missed the magnificent (and now normalised) sight of rockets landing vertically and the incredible engineering behind catching that beast of rocket with chopsticks etc etc

what im suprised about though is why arnt you and others here more suspectful of Tao's skeptisim of AI .. as Wittgenstein's ruler reminds us teh very thing we use to measure something else may itself need measuring .. so why should tao's expertise be any exception?


I'm not saying Tao is right, but (a) he knows a LOT more about about what's actually important in research math than I do (and probably than you do) (b) he's not just having a knee jerk reaction. Tao has been a major leader and advocate for computer-assisted math, including AI, and I don't think that has really changed. He's advocating for how to do it well. He's far from an AI skeptic protecting his turf. Is there any other person as well-versed in research mathematics AND AI-math as Tao? Maybe a few, but not many.

The dude keeps a continually automatically produced document of his takes on AI. He's not a skeptic overall. https://teorth.github.io/tao-web/ai-views.html . In this interview the interviewer describes him as an evangelist for AI in math and he doesn't disagree. https://teorth.github.io/tao-web/ai-views-interview.html

It seems like your inclination is to discount his experience with research mathematics. I agree with you that that's probably what Taleb would do - Taleb has a giant ego and basically operates under the assumption that everyone else has the same giant ego as he does but is (a) less honest about it (b) dumber than he is.


Taleb does have an obnoxious amount of ego, especially in his one on one street fights on Twitter, but his writings have zero ego .. on the contrary, his books force you to take a deeper look at yourself and almost haunt you if you try to BS your way out of confronting what those ideas expose about your own thinking ..

I also read and re read the link you shared .. it’s almost baffling that he is so incredibly hesitant on not being able to clearly take a position on anything and is so painfully nuanced in his writing as if he’s almost hedging every sentence ..

PS: All my life, mathematicians were made to look and portrayed like the ultimate truth seekers (both at school, by the media, in films and in the sciences etc) and all I see is in Tao is a man trying to so badly hold on to the main character energy … perhaps demonstrating a bit of humility like Lee Sedol after loosing to the machine would be in order … in his own words, he sees himself as a fox, not a hedgehog.. guess now that he's been outfoxed .. its best not to say unhinged stuff like "there's no reason to be this fast" or that absolulty out of touch "Math 2.0" cancer slide ... what. an. absolute. tool.


It's not hard to accept. Why are you drawing a false equivalence between a man having these flaws, and Tao's words in this case being rooted in those flaws?

As for you, what's your opinion about what he said and why do you think that?


i like that term "false equivalence" .. i had to google it .. very sophesticated way of saying apples to oranges .. but i digress .. yes you are correct in pointing that out.

> As for you, what's your opinion about what he said and why do you think that?

many years ago i had watchd Nassim Talebs commencement speech at AUB .. where he described russian mathematicians after the fall of soviet union .. who earned around $200 a month .. but continued doing work appreciated by only a small number of people .. and regarded displaying awards and regofnitions as a sign of weakness or lack of confidence in their contributions .. in contrast, when Tao was asked my Lex Friedman about Gregory Parlmen rejecting the millenium prize .. he gave a dissapointing non answer .. which reveals a lot about him as an individual (not as a mathmatician) ..

his reactions to OAI papers .. both initially on social media and now in his presentation .. carry that same ego .. and its quite evident that rather than mathematics being solely about the pursuit of truth .. he does care VERY MUCH about who idnetified the truth .. and that makes him only very human .. which is waht i initally said.


> ego, arrogance, jealousy and competitiveness?

Nah, he is simply being a politician.


yes


I think you misunderstood his point... it's the fact that if there's no human supervision involved in the "pass stage 3 trials", you don't really need if it passed it for legit reason (in which case everyone would be happy to let patients use it), or whether it found a "loophole" (eg hacked the submission to pass it without having succeeded the test)


The conflations about his example ("thought experiment") is twofold, the AI itself confounds the ethical intuition so it is wrong directly compare against what real medicine today does; furthermore, the very admission that real medicine in fact operates through unknown risks (e.g. Jannsen vaccine recall) is different than having a scientific standard that it should not have to be that way at least as minimally as possible.


all that isn't to say discovering and understanding mechanistic causality isn't a useful endeavour; it may be actually a faster, better way but no way to prove it.


Instead of bemoaning his specific and clumsy example, take the gift of this moment and don’t forget that he’s smart, confident, and usually wrong or completely ignorant outside of his own narrow field.

Don’t let the Gell-Mann Amnesia take you.


I think logic is squarely in his field, and even with simple logic, proposing the importance of second order effects on people who are dying is not tenable. Personally, knowing that he is indeed one of the smartest people around, and definitely much smarter than me, I cannot but be a bit worried that going with this example indicates traces of panic in the face of a shifting world. He’s smart but human, and maybe these weaknesses are not to bemoan but to celebrate in our current context.


One of life’s hardest lessons is that raw intelligence isn’t a superpower, it isn’t a substitute for actually knowing about the topic. The smartest person alive talking about a subject they don’t understand the details of is no better than a confident idiot.

Speaking for myself n I’ll respect his intelligence more when he discovers his limits and learns to act with humility outside of his narrow field.


I don't wish that he would have picked a different example or have done anything he's been doing in the last year and a half differently because he's really revealed in a very explicit way who he actually is and has apparently always been:

A devoted gatekeeper who ABSOLUTELY would deny the world a post-abundance future in order to maintain the prestige of his particular career path

Like many in academic math, he's obviously great as an individual researcher but severely lacks the skills, temperament, and character necessary to participate in the other duties his academic position requires (e.g. Dept Chairman) much less extra-curriculars like the politics and the future of AI. And, the signs have probably been there all along.

E.g. I first started thinking this way when I read an interview with him from 2019 in the Princeton Alumni Weekly:

https://paw.princeton.edu/article/mind-mathematician

In response to the "Mozart of Math" nickname, he bafflingly declares "all academics feel for the Salieri character."

Tao basically says he identifies with Salieri because researchers and academics spend their lives developing the high-level expertise needed to perfectly appreciate brilliant breakthroughs, yet the world casts them as mediocrities in comparison to history's absolute anomalies.

It's worth further noting that all of his context on this Mozart / Salieri stuff comes from the 1984 film Amadeus. In that film, Salieri is the villain! He's a gatekeeping loser that actively sabotaged Mozart and Tao happily volunteers that Salieri's his guy for some reason!

E.g. a more recent thing I'd like highlight is one of the "successes" of his Math 2.0 framework he put in his slide deck:

""" "Open exposition problems" as opposed to open research problems: finding motivated explanations of results whose known proofs are currently opaque. (The newly revised Caltech Mathathon is an interesting experiment in this direction.) """

After Tao and his fellow insecure gatekeeping luddites successfully bullied some Caltech grad students into handing over their event to them, he posted the following statement of absolutely pathetic cuckery on his blog claiming it to be the words of those same weak-willed grad students:

https://terrytao.wordpress.com/2026/09/28/joint-statement-ab...

Note that this "newly revised" event isn't just about writing new exposition on AI solutions, it's about a litany of grievances that people like Tao have had about the works of certain people in math that didn't allow themselves to be bullied like the grad student organizers of the Mathathon.

The letter, again which we're supposed to believe the twenty-something year old grad students definitely wrote themselves, specifically mentions not only OpenAI's Navier-Stokes work, but also brings up the Appel–Haken proof of the four color theorem (from the 80s) and Mochizuki's proof of the ABC conjecture (from the 2010s) as unacceptable works that causes their insecurities to flare up and must be defeated by next-gen gatekeeping.

I'm sure I could think of less responsible potential stewards of our inevitable AI future than Tao, but he and the sorts of people he's aligned himself with really should have no place at all in a position like that.


Glad you outed Terry as the bad guy that jealous Salieri was in the film.

I was misled into thinking that his "all academics feel for the Salieri character" comment could've been--in the dimmest of possibilities--paraphrasing Grothendieck that he felt outclassed by his peers:

“Since then I’ve had the chance in the world of mathematics that bid me welcome, to meet quite a number of people, both among my ‘elders’ and among young people in my general age group who were more brilliant, much more ‘gifted’ than I was.” (Récoltes et Semailles)

Perish the thought.


I can guarantee he was not paraphrasing Grothendieck and, if you've seen the movie, you'd understand it's not some cynical performative humility either.

You should actually read the article. In addition to that great mask-slip moment I mentioned, you'll see yet another reason why he's malding about OpenAI's Navier-Stokes work and a few other fun Easter eggs!

It's interesting that you mention Grothendieck tho. I don't suspect Tao is much of a fan. No doubt, there are plenty of honest mathematicians of reasonable character, especially of the "problem-solver" and applied variety, that don't exactly worship at the alter of Alexander Grothendieck for reasons that are essential aesthetic or practical, but I would say he's the archetypical mathematician that people like Terence Tao specifically endeavor to gatekeep from contemporary academia and, ultimately, erase from history altogether.

Based on a very recent guest post on his blog by Noah Giansiracusa:

https://terrytao.wordpress.com/2026/09/16/let-the-diners-int...

Tao believes the works of Grothendieck (mostly as written by the mathematicians that became the Bourbaki group), the Bourbaki group, and those that followed are an active liability to their gatekeeping mediocrity cartel in the AI era. So maybe we can look forward to him making all that even more explicit in the near future!


I was not familiar with the mathathon, and I suppose I am ignorant of the circumstances in which Tao allegedly bullied students into changing the event. I don't personally have any reason to doubt the veracity of the "Joint Statement about Mathathon", but perhaps you have some insight that I don't. I will say that I would imagine that any input from Tao, even in passing, probably has outsized influence on the organizational direction of the event due to his preeminence, but I'm not so sure that necessarily rises to the level of bullying.

But from what I gather, the theme of the statement is to expand the scope of participation to include work that is quite literally the /opposite/ of gatekeeping, i.e. taking proofs that are popularly understood to be opaque or difficult to understand (from any source, AI, human, or otherwise) and developing a new way to communicate them that is more accessible to more people.

I do see how it may come off as a slight to the original mathematicians who developed those proofs. But developing new ways to communicate already established concepts should not diminish the original works. There are probably much better communicators/teachers of relativity than Einstein ever was. No one out there thinks any less of Einstein because of Sean Carrol's "Spacetime and Geometry" textbook.

And this to me reads as only embracing the use of AI in mathematics, which is not gatekeeping behavior. Tao continues to emphasize that once proofs become effectively automatable, deeply comprehending and being able to transmit that understanding to others will become an increasingly important aspect of the field, the natural way for mathematicians to use the time that was once occupied by developing the proofs themselves.

Literally all of this is about expanding the accessibility of mathematics, which once again, I perceive to be quite the opposite of gatekeeping. Maybe we have different definitions of that term.

Also I have not seen Amadeus, so no comment about Salieri.


You should have at least looked into the Mathathon, specifically what it was going to be before Tao et al. highjacked it from its organizers, before white knighting for people like this.


All you need to know about Amadeus and Salieri is this one scene: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tI7xtD3bMD0 (skip to https://youtu.be/tI7xtD3bMD0?t=443 if you want to see the AI humiliate Terrance).

IMO (not humble) it's one of the finest moments of cinematography and acting I've seen.


Huh. I guess I don't agree that this would at all characterize Tao's relationship with AI. I haven't read a single thing from him to suggest that he is "seething" over AI's remarkable capabilities. In fact he's a prolific user of AI in mathematics research. I don't think the scene serves a useful analogy.

Also Tao's reference to "feeling for" Salieri makes a lot more sense, the audience is clearly supposed to feel for him! That's what makes the scene effective.

And why would I want to see AI humiliate Tao?

I'm sorry if I misunderstood your comment. Thank you for the link, it is useful context.


> paint Tao as an example of some sort of gatekeeping luddite who would deny the world a post-abundance future in order to maintain the prestige of his particular career path

Because that is exactly what he is, and I for one want him nowhere near any decision making process whatsoever when it comes to AI.


I replied to a different comment with an explanation as to why I do not perceive Tao as a gatekeeper; in short that his current beat seems to be entirely about expanding understanding and access to math by improving the communication of opaque proofs, which we will shortly have a near infinite supply of due to AI.

I will also mention that he maintains a realistic, clear eyed attitude with respect to the inevitability of AI in math, while being sensitive to its disruptive nature in his field. Everything here strikes me as constructing a thoughtful, grounded way forward for his community.

I'm sure there will be missteps along the way, but I think Tao is overall an excellent example of maintaining a balanced position between the poles of absolutism that seem to capture so many.

I am curious where you interpret this as gatekeeping behavior.


I don’t really care whether Tao intends to gatekeep or not, outcome matters more than intent. I don’t consider preserving human mathematical labor or the prestige of its practitioners worthwhile goals in themselves. In fact, I consider the opposite to be the worthwhile goal, as I want an end to all human labor. Anyone who gets in the way of that goal is almost by definition a gatekeeper.


the ends justify the means, very classy /s


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: