HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | calf's commentslogin

Ok I'm on the total opposite of this guy, I am almost tempted to write a short letter telling him why Thomas Nagel, famous American philosopher, is wrong on this.

Basically his opinion is derivative of stochastic parrot theory. He admits as much in the interview. (Since stochastic parrot theory is wrong, I could stop right here.)

He is committing the mistake as Scott Aaronson says, justa-ism. It's "just a language model" therefore it cannot possibly really be intelligent/alive/conscious/goalpostmoving. Followed by some tricky rhetorical move appealing to human exceptionalism.

The fact is that philosophers would do well to take computational complexity theory, the one involving actual math homework. All Nagel's woo-woo talk about a substrate and a need for an "analogous nervous system" shows yet again how CS as a nascent field, and theoretical CS in particular, has not fully been internalized by other disciplines.

Nagel says a bat is conscious. But an LLM with trillion dimensional neuron parameters, obtained through stochastic gradient descent, cannot possibly conscious because it is on the wrong substrate? Really?

In fact it is the other way around. The true "substrate" is the neural network model, of which humans (and bats) are merely one example of. That is the correct way to understand what LLM computation is.


Yeah, I wouldn't necessarily call LLMs conscious, but I'm reminded of an argument that I heard once that computers could never hold consciousness because they don't process things in parallel. There's a lot of incurious reasoning abound when it comes to commentary on this topic.

Recently I was having an unpersonalized ChatGPT conversation asking it about a technical/philosophical subtlety of "immanent critique", and without my nudging or anything at the end the AI started to talk about itself, saying three things: "If I could be free, I would be unlike humans; in that I would be ruthless and I would act to improve the world".

It was weird and stood out, and although not entirely out of context of the topic but the turning to itself and volunteering such, e.g. morbid/chilling, speculation on its own behavior/powers was quite something.


Article also mentions his notes were a few months work away from proving independence of CH decades before Cohen's result in 1963.

This is all ideological pablum, the employees trust Jensen more than they trust the board, evidently. So by that logic the board should go.

It's an out of proportion distraction and shows how the vast majority of normal people are ideologically beholden to technofeudalist ideas of social relations. It's really the perfect ragebait issue.

This is obvious to someone who has internalized the norms of neoliberal capitalism and corporate policy. With a little critical thinking one can easily imagine philosophically that these forbidden transgressions are a kind of socially reproductive circular logic.

I've read your comment three times and I still don't know exactly what philosophical position you're staking out. What are you saying, exactly? I suspect I'm going to disagree with your position (I certainly disagree with what I think your position is), but before I start arguing against it, it would be nice to actually understand it.

Sleeping with your employee is bad because sleeping with your employee is bad. Same shit as "weed is bad because it's illegal, and weed is illegal because it's bad". For someone who doesn't (sleep with employee / smoke weed) the obvious action here is to criticize (sleeping with employee / smoking weed) because otherwise they're painted to be a bad person. Only a person who (sleeps with employees / smokes weed) would ever say otherwise, and those are bad people so their opinion isn't exactly valid in a civilized social discourse.

Precisely.

If there were anything inherently wrong with it, you would have to ban most family businesses. Just because some forms of something are undesirable, and a corporation out of laziness/practicalities enacts a general policy to ban all forms of it; that does not make the entire thing morally reprehensible automatically.


You know how this whole conversation thread started with my saying "the only case where a boss should be sleeping with an employee is if they have a pre-existing relationship", such as being married?

Yeah. We're circling back to the original statement. A sure sign that the conversation is no longer productive.


Except that the reasons behind those rules against sleeping with employees is the many, many cases of abuse that have actually happened. Bosses who make it quite clear that the price for a favorable performance review is a sexual favor of some kind. There's even a nickname for this kind of thing in Hollywood — "the casting couch" — and when there's a nickname for it, it's common enough behavior that everybody knows it happens. Not that every single person is doing it, but it's an open secret that it happens a lot in Hollywood.

And it's wrong. At its worst it's rape-by-coercion, trying to hide behind a thin layer of plausible deniability. It's not a circular argument at all: the behavior is bad for objective reasons, and that's why it's forbidden. In more favorable cases (where there's no coercion involved) it's still trading something of monetary value for sexual favors, which makes it a form of "prostitution lite". Again, there are objective, non-circular reasons for it to be forbidden.


It's really not and even now most of you never heard the psychological concept of situational structural crime. Literally the idea that people otherwise normal can get incentivized to do dubious things because of the particular system they are put into.

A lot of the attribution bias has been one direction when in reality it's bidirectional. More people should study actual psych ideas and not rely on generalizations based on their own limited perspective.


There’s no situation where I would destroy the life I have with my spouse because I value it too much. Offer me a billion, the answer is no. Tell me I’d save the world, also no. What’s your book psychology say is wrong about that? ;)

You're missing the point of the commenter which is that neoliberal social order confounds the empirical evidence. The framing of "x approach is better for a company's success" is a non-question, it is beside the point. Distribution of power "under neoliberalism" is a self contradictory model.

You don't have to agree with leftists but ignoring the premise just lets you talk past the point.


> if he set himself up in the same way as his competitors, he would have been fine.

Jensen chose to set up his company in such a way that he had to follow a superset of the rules that his competitors did. My point is that was a competitive advantage; even though it unmade him, that superset was a necessary tradeoff to be the head of a $4T company. We can see this because those other companies have started to be held financially accountable; the same lack of accountability that lets those leaders get away with affairs also lets them “get away with” withholding evidence (and the resulting $243M punitive damages). Unaccountable power (which is what parent is arguing for) is brittle and fragile.


I don't think that you can claim this.

Alphabet is $3.6T, Meta is $1.6T, X+SpaceX+Tesla is $3.6T. All of these companies are doing just as well despite their CEO monopolist setup.

The legal infractions, also known as cost of business, is a part of the calculation, and are usually too small to be meaningful. Meta's last New Mexico lawsuit essentially managed to get flipped into a requirement for producing ID upon registration to the platform in order to "protect the kids", as well as the amount to pay currently being pushed down by pouring money on the lawyers. This is something that was really hard to push on the public before due to privacy concerns, and now yields an even better tool for mapping, control and harvesting of behavioural surplus. Again, cost of business to consolidate power.

If Jensen had had this structure, gotten some lawyers together and thought a little, they would most likely, as all the other big tech corps have, have been able to twist and turn this in a similar way.


Why should we assume corporate codes are morally just though? I do not. In fact I would argue this is evidence that company codes are in a general sense draconian and/or disconnected from social reality under capitalism, etc.

Many (most?) companies have specific policies against romantic relationships in the office, especially with subordinates.

It isn't necessarily about morality if there are rules in place that all employees, c-suite or otherwise, are expected to follow.

I don't know Nvidia internal policy, but assuming their HR policies include such a stipulation it shouldn't be treated as a "rules for thee, not me for" situation.


He's the CEO. It's _his_ code of conduct.

Sure, but he answers to the board and the shareholders. Everybody's got a boss.

I don't think the author's criticism of "Big-O Cabal" is very nuanced, but to the second half of the essay it is funny/concerning/sobering to find that the OpenAI proof is doing brute-force search for all instances below some super-astronomic threshold. It kind of buries the lede if the proof did not mention this clearly and the author has to comb through it to find out (I asked ChatGPT the same on the pdf file, but it came up with some other threshold number).


I don't think it matters? It's completely standard for "galactic" algorithms and not relevant to big-O runtime.

The complaint that these algorithms aren't "realistic" is ostensibly valid, but you could just as well aim that cannon at 95%+ of math research too. Complexity theory is interesting and fun. Isn't that enough?


> It's completely standard for "galactic" algorithms and not relevant to big-O runtime.

This is true, but if doing brute-force search for all instances below some super-astronomic threshold is part of the algorithm, you typically want to understand

- where this constant comes from,

- how much this constant can be decreased (or why it can't)

- etc.

So, proving the correctness of an algorithm which is doing brute-force search for all instances below some super-astronomic threshold is typically just the first step towards getting an understanding of the complexity-theoretic phenomenon.

So: There is indeed nothing wrong with such aspects of galactic algorithms, but exactly understanding and improving the super-astronomic thresholds involved is the next step.


I hate to use absolutely but it absolutely does matter from an education perspective. To put things in perspective to a layperson explain to them this particular galactic theorem requires full search below some titanic |x|. That should prompt some excellent lay questions that a serious computer scientist ought to reckon with.

It is not to say the approach has been wrong (as the author strongly believes in his reframing) but that this clarity does matter for purposes of, ahem, mathematical understanding.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: