HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | caaqil's commentslogin

In other news, Gentoo has been working 24/7. Come to think of it, every distro has been working 24/7*. This will be The Year of LibreOffice! This time, finally, msft really shot themselves in the foot and the masses are gonna download and setup their own word processors and spreadsheets.

(*) Well, unless some dork decides to do xyz because of abc due to the shape of the stars in relation to the moon.


> The book is quite basic.

Perplexing how it's on the front page then given the background of the median HN user (presumably technical with some STEM background in general, some pure VC bros peppered in etc).

The Tao love conquers all, as it were.


I enjoy reading less technical books even on technical topics I know about. They serve a different purpose.

Eh, I just like reading new books on mathematics, even if they're covering well trod ground. I think a lot of people in math are like this. I'm not endlessly grinding through introductory textbooks, but there is something nice about seeing someone brilliant give their take on something fundamental. And the cultural differences you get in reading different texts from different periods or from different authors is really stimulating, for me at least.

1) Not everyone, and 2) some of us regularly find ourselves recommending books to others, or for kids.

Basic knowledge resources are very common in HN in front page. And such resource from someone known to write very well will be helpful for newbies even from lesser known personalities. Shared here all the time so why pretend its not common.

[flagged]

HN guidelines:

> Be kind. Don't be snarky.


I'm not talking to another member or referring to a particular comment, I'm making a brief comment by analogy regarding a pair of public figures who profit from their notoriety.

Moreover I was accurate, unless your idea of kindness is to imply that comparison to a success physicist is "unkind".


im not pro-ai-bro but i gotta say some of the maths involved is pretty cool

That math isn't being discussed here, it's barely even discussed in the book! Frankly how often do you open an HN thread on the front page and see any significant technical discussion of anything other than coding? I find the times I see someone writing out equations and discussing fundamentals so rare and welcome as to be memorable.

Most conversation here is profoundly non-technical and never touches anything like "the math".


What if I told you nothing new is happening? Except casuals are noticing what the industry knew and saw for decades?

Script kiddies aren't new. Metasploit has been around literally decades. vx-underground existed for years, not to mention older open source projects that collect all known malware dev tools. APTs have been pwning stuff, script kiddies have been doing their thing. Nothing significant has changed for anyone in the know.

Just because LLMs automated some offensive stuff doesn't mean there's gonna be new magic collapse of society.


Given that our knowing-and-seeing industry is also the thing which enabled and then desperately shepherded humanity out-of every IT deficiency that has ever existed, our inside perspective is still highly fallible too.


Aviation is different because their rent-seeking is enforced by the required legal hedging. I'm not sure the same incentive structure exists in the software side of things.

In other words, we might need to find some hobbies.


In what way is requiring someone holding the title pilot to know how to manually fly a plane in case of disaster “rent-seeking”?


Rent seeking has a specific definition and it fits here. When Autopilot does almost all the critical work needed (besides announcing frivolous stuff in carbon-based voice), and you have mandatory seats for humans to babysit the Autopilot mainly to satisfy some law, the term fits.

I am not convinced humans can do much better in "disasters" than Autopilot, despite the emotional stories to the contrary (survivorship bias is one hell of a drug).


This take is so ignorant and provably false. I can't tell if you're trying to ragebait or if you actually believe this.

The autopilot does not do "almost all critical work", not even close. It only does some of the routine work (definitely not all of it). But the real critical work is when stuff goes wrong, dealing with emergencies.

The inherent complexity of aviation means that there are so many different failure modes and combinations thereof that no traditional system could ever handle all possibilities and edge cases.

I'm not going to claim that an AI could never do it. But as of right now, with current technology, well-trained pilots are absolutely critical to safety in even the most advanced airliners.

Also, the survivorship bias argument runs against you. Most events where pilots save the day are completely invisible. Like catching an incorrect clearance, a misconfigured approach, dealing with a technical malfunction, etc.

And even when disasters happen, it is very rare that simply engaging the autopilot would have saved the day. In fact, there are plenty of examples where the opposite is the case, and dropping to a lower level of automation would, in hindsight, have been better.


Your first sentence would lead one to believe that you have some substantial evidence to demonstrate the ignorance and falsehood you identified. It's impressive that you are regurgitating the same formulaic-template set of cliches that boil down to "X is so complex bro, how can you even?".

Note that I never claimed aviation relies on AI right now, most of the Autopilot systems are deterministic automation systems, but the original point stands regardless.


Your claim was that "the autopilot does almost all the critical work", and that couldn't be further from the truth in any airliners you can buy today.

I didn't say that an autonomous airliner could never be built. With more technological progress it might become feasible at some point despite the immense complexity.


As someone studying for a pilot license, your take is literally ridiculous.

You should perhaps look at all the crashes where the autopilot stalled the aircraft on approach due to incorrect settings.


As an airline captain, your take is completely ridiculous. The autopilot takes care of the mechanical act of guiding the plane along the desired path, but it does nothing else. There are hundreds of other tasks we need to perform in order to effect a safe flight, and the autopilot does nothing to help us.


Really? Do autopilots diagnose threatening situations in the main cabin? Understand something unexpected happening on the ground? Visually diagnose situations? Properly identify threat levels?

It's genuinely worrying to me to see statements like this. As engineers, we of all people should know that there's 1 billion variables that could go wrong and another 1 billion we aren't even aware of yet...


You might want to fire up a flight sim or at least read up on what “autopilot” actually means. It’s pretty much 3D cruise control and that’s it.


Pilots are nothing near powerful enough to seek any rent on that situation.

Instead, they are the weakest part on that market.


It is a good industry to learn from. I'm not suggesting SW should become exactly like aviation.


It indeed is and I like this analogy a lot. A lot of critical systems can definitely learn from aviation. It's one of the finest balances of humans and automation.


But there is a lot of software in aviation. And it is slow to develop, and expensive. And it has defects.

In general, it is of high quality.


> I’m getting so many 1Password prompts for agents pulling env variables out of it and with very little context of what is being accessed by who

This is a one-sentence horror story. I almost can't believe someone would let this happen, unless the 1Password account is not important (highly unlikely).


Permission fatigue is real.


I know it sounds bad, but it’s the reality for most people, just like permission prompts at every corner and after each macOS / app update (“Your screenshot app is watching your screen”, no shit, that’s why I installed it).


> this model is dead, grab the cash and go.

[citations needed]


> It's like your highschool having a wall of notable graduates, and having your likeness taken down

So, basically inconsequential stuff only the juvenile should worry about? Agreed.


If caring about prestige is juvenile... Wikipedia as an institution cares ridiculously much what people think of it.


Wait til you hear about the rest of human psychology...


Appealing to complexity is always fun. Just throwing "a lot" in there for good measure and you won't have to think about practical security implications.


> did you not expect this conversation to go into training or at least review?

Use it for training/review (RLHF, whatever) and "we load the whole thread, not the specific response or surrounding few prompts, and store it for 5 years" seem completely different things. It's not obvious why being tech savvy would automatically make one aware that the 2nd version is happening.


> Unix and Linux solved all this even before Alexander III of Macedon started wearing his nappies

I mean, didn't Linux shells invent pop-up fatigue? I thought we (yes, we) all used to -y flag preemptively so the upgrades and installations/setups go through. Linux really did do it first, the agents are just more needy and their popups more verbose now, but not exactly new.

VM isn't a silver bullet.


Stuff like this is highly context dependent. It is a good thing that apt asks about each step. I voluntarily add more of this by opting for things like listbugs. If I then decide to override such protections with a -y for whatever reason that's a choice on my part to prioritize convenience.

Either way it's got nothing to do with security - I was never going to catch a vulnerability in the central debian repos by reading a list of dependent packages.


It's kind of the opposite. The more typical Unix nehavior is to just assume you knew what you were doing and meant it, and not ask for confirmation in the first place. -y is just the reversion of an abberation.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: